its a stupid comparison between roses and oasis, oasis wrote great crunchy rock and roll tunes where as stone roses wrote spontaniously ridculously individual indie tunes with diverse drumming, bass lines and guitar fills.
@rosiemckay i'm a big fan of both....the roses are awsome....but were never a live band, the best work was done in the studio, oasis on the other hand could do both to be honest, there is no point worrying who was better,cause everyone will see it differently....2 top bands...thats about the size of it? :)
@saracen09767 no one knows the roses outside of the uk?? u are a fuckn idiot, for one im not from the uk. just because it has more sales does not make it any better, I could argue that justin bieber is better based on sales u faggot
@maxxxaids and rehash the same chord progression ? for one they dont and 2 how is that even a legitimate criticism hahaha if something sounds good it sounds good, so you have to change everything and make it sound a load of shite pyscadellic bollocks to make it sound good? what the fuck get a grip of yourself mate, oasis are ten times better than the roses, you dont judge a band on one album, and to say the 2nd album is good when it flopped like a jelly and barely sold a million copies is stupid
@maxxxaids well if youve seen it what the fuck you talking about then when even the ones who wrote the music say oasis are better, and no they dont, the roses did one good album the 2nd was wank and if you say otherwise u make urself look a fool cos even they admitted it was pure shite, nobody even bought it, if they were so good how come when they released there 2nd album and were competeing with the likes of oasis were they blown out of the water?, oasis are in another league altogether
@maxxaids you have bad taste if you think thats a good album mate im sorry lol they made an amazing first album but its still not better than definetly maybe, so your saying the second coming blows anything oasis has ever done out of the water HAHAHAHAHAHA
@tripoticsoundscapes yeah i can see ur point and thanks dude you too, there seems to be alot of people insulting other people for having a different opinion like maxxaids calling me a fucking idiot just for disagreeing with him, but i do think oasis were ten times better the roses couldnt follow up the good songs on there first album with a good second album but oasis could, and that to me makes them a better band
@tripoticsoundscapes anyone can copy a chord but not be able to incorperate it into a new song, oasis take everything youve ever heard before and turn it into something youve never heard before, the beatles did the same they were only playing what was in there record collection too, they used the same 2 part melodies the everly brothers did? john lennon was even sued by chuck berry for copying lyrics, in the words of noel if its so easy "lets see you do it"
@maxxxaids im an idiot? how can you be an idiot cos you have a different opinion on music you stupid cunt, music is a matter of opinion nothing else their is no written word that says this band is better than that band, and thats all stone roses are, waterfall, she bangs the drums, i am the ressurection all catchy coruses, ur the idiot live forever cuts you write to the bone as does wonderwall they are deep songs,
@maxxaids reni also says in the documentary oasis were the biggest band of the past 20 years, you cant compare a band who had the potential to do it but didnt to a band which had the potential and went on and did it, shoulda woulda coulda im afraid, the second coming sold 1 million copies you idiotic fool morning glory sold 20 million worldwide and went 4 times platinum not only in the UK but in the USA, the roses couldnt even crack america, shut the fuck up and give urself a slap
@maxxaids and talentless? oasis talentless? are you for real? the La's made a great first album too then split were they bigger and better than oasis too then? shut up and go home haha youve made yourself look a fool enough, you dont judge a band on one album,
@rosiemckay *slowly claps* . There would'nt have been Oasis without the Roses. (No disrespect to Oasis,they say it themselves)......Thats the fuckin beauty and evolution of working class people makin music...Cherish the lot x
Career wise really the main difference was that the Roses didnt stick around for years when the magic had clearly gone the way Oasis did. I preffer the Roses myself but both produced a couple of great albums and another albums workd of B-sides/singles. Since Whats the Story though has Oasis's output been any better than Squire of Browns post Roses work? not really and actually alot worse than Mai's with Primal Scream.
I am from Manchester and have adored the roses since those halcyon days of the late eightys timeless classic tunes the music thoses boys produced will last forever!!
my all time fav roses track, no one has to replace anyone they all have their own place in musical history....may all the ghosts come back to haunt you tell u how they died!!! f*****g tune!
The Stone Roses only managed 2 albums in 6 years with a huge gap inbetween. Oasis have continually pumped out quality music and huge tours over the past fifteen years. I'm not saying Oasis are better, I'm just saying they are famous throughout the world for their hard work, where as the Roses always dropped the ball when it mattered most.
obviously your taste is in your arse as well as your head roses got sold out by there manager,and could not make another album,get your facts right before making a pathetic argument bout the most over rated band ever. oasis r average at best,
Fair enough but the Roses did have a two and a half year court battle to deal with. Not allowed to record, play live etc, and this is at their peak! Oasis didn't have to deal with that. This is why there's a large gap between albums.
Also, the Roses technically have 4 albums in Garage Flower and the Complete Stone Roses. Not to mention dozens of songs they never released (such as the stunning Pearl Bastard only just heard!). I wouldn't say Oasis have "pumped out quality music" at all.
Man, Squire had some genius lyrics not even to mention the guitar riffs! I grew up with Oasis and was only introduced to the Roses around 2000 but I can't stop listening to them
no one else can sing these type of bitter dark lyrics better than ian brown.
second coming was browns best vocal performance, he really perfected that northern grit/soul/shaman quality. shame his voice since then has been destroyed.
squire in my opinion is better than anybody. a true cool genius.
this album is one of the best albums ever made cant believe it got slagged off when it was released,and this track is my favorite ! say no more! this band leads the way for every other band out there and they know it !
I forget how friggin great this band was. How the us market picked up oasis and blur and misssed these guys I will never understand. John squire wrote the riffs Oasis only dreamed of
Love it always did even back then,wasnt the roses we all knew but a class album all the same,and I could of listened to 100 more albums like this 1 from them
Probably my favourte Stone Roses song.
Dickyhardman 2 hours ago
with my eyes closed ;)
GamingXSportXClub 3 months ago
Oasis are bland mediocrity, Roses are seminal art.
Darrenov 4 months ago
Who gives a fuck what football team they support..Its not about that, Its all about the music...Anyway, Reni is a City fan
Great to have them back
Super5000G 4 months ago
Tune. Fact
MrHaggis03 5 months ago
are my dreams your nightmares i hope they all come true
spaced377 5 months ago
@rosiemckay No they are not.
BLAGASPANTS 5 months ago
its whatever you prefer, like all music to befair. so stop wasting your time. they were both great for different reasons.
crinkfloyd 7 months ago
its a stupid comparison between roses and oasis, oasis wrote great crunchy rock and roll tunes where as stone roses wrote spontaniously ridculously individual indie tunes with diverse drumming, bass lines and guitar fills.
crinkfloyd 7 months ago
Hahaha i prefer Roses to be fair, but wud prefer it if they were the the City fans and Oasis were the Utd
stressy192 7 months ago
The Roses were better because they supported United while oasis were City fans.
dukedodgington 8 months ago
@rosiemckay i'm a big fan of both....the roses are awsome....but were never a live band, the best work was done in the studio, oasis on the other hand could do both to be honest, there is no point worrying who was better,cause everyone will see it differently....2 top bands...thats about the size of it? :)
lavyheed 9 months ago
not long til the worms Maggie..
baldio67 10 months ago
Comment removed
everton0633668495 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
great song from the finest purveyor of music the world has ever heard
everton0633668495 10 months ago
@saracen09767 OASIS wunt have been half the band they were if it wasn't for the stone roses you sigh
MosboroughBlade 10 months ago
@saracen09767 no one knows the roses outside of the uk?? u are a fuckn idiot, for one im not from the uk. just because it has more sales does not make it any better, I could argue that justin bieber is better based on sales u faggot
campbelllovescock 11 months ago
@maxxxaids and rehash the same chord progression ? for one they dont and 2 how is that even a legitimate criticism hahaha if something sounds good it sounds good, so you have to change everything and make it sound a load of shite pyscadellic bollocks to make it sound good? what the fuck get a grip of yourself mate, oasis are ten times better than the roses, you dont judge a band on one album, and to say the 2nd album is good when it flopped like a jelly and barely sold a million copies is stupid
dazza2610 11 months ago
@maxxxaids well if youve seen it what the fuck you talking about then when even the ones who wrote the music say oasis are better, and no they dont, the roses did one good album the 2nd was wank and if you say otherwise u make urself look a fool cos even they admitted it was pure shite, nobody even bought it, if they were so good how come when they released there 2nd album and were competeing with the likes of oasis were they blown out of the water?, oasis are in another league altogether
dazza2610 11 months ago
@maxxaids you have bad taste if you think thats a good album mate im sorry lol they made an amazing first album but its still not better than definetly maybe, so your saying the second coming blows anything oasis has ever done out of the water HAHAHAHAHAHA
dazza2610 11 months ago
@tripoticsoundscapes yeah i can see ur point and thanks dude you too, there seems to be alot of people insulting other people for having a different opinion like maxxaids calling me a fucking idiot just for disagreeing with him, but i do think oasis were ten times better the roses couldnt follow up the good songs on there first album with a good second album but oasis could, and that to me makes them a better band
dazza2610 11 months ago
@tripoticsoundscapes exactly so is rearranging something youve heard before into something you havent heard before not original in itself?
dazza2610 11 months ago
@tripoticsoundscapes anyone can copy a chord but not be able to incorperate it into a new song, oasis take everything youve ever heard before and turn it into something youve never heard before, the beatles did the same they were only playing what was in there record collection too, they used the same 2 part melodies the everly brothers did? john lennon was even sued by chuck berry for copying lyrics, in the words of noel if its so easy "lets see you do it"
dazza2610 11 months ago
@maxxxaids im an idiot? how can you be an idiot cos you have a different opinion on music you stupid cunt, music is a matter of opinion nothing else their is no written word that says this band is better than that band, and thats all stone roses are, waterfall, she bangs the drums, i am the ressurection all catchy coruses, ur the idiot live forever cuts you write to the bone as does wonderwall they are deep songs,
dazza2610 11 months ago
@maxxaids reni also says in the documentary oasis were the biggest band of the past 20 years, you cant compare a band who had the potential to do it but didnt to a band which had the potential and went on and did it, shoulda woulda coulda im afraid, the second coming sold 1 million copies you idiotic fool morning glory sold 20 million worldwide and went 4 times platinum not only in the UK but in the USA, the roses couldnt even crack america, shut the fuck up and give urself a slap
dazza2610 11 months ago
@maxxaids and talentless? oasis talentless? are you for real? the La's made a great first album too then split were they bigger and better than oasis too then? shut up and go home haha youve made yourself look a fool enough, you dont judge a band on one album,
dazza2610 11 months ago
"SO RAISE YOUR GLASSES, HERE'S A TOAST TO WASTED LIFE"
Kaknose 1 year ago
@rosiemckay *slowly claps* . There would'nt have been Oasis without the Roses. (No disrespect to Oasis,they say it themselves)......Thats the fuckin beauty and evolution of working class people makin music...Cherish the lot x
funk67 1 year ago
I play this for my child put to sleep forevermore by the dogs of death who fed her the drugs.
annysvan 1 year ago
Career wise really the main difference was that the Roses didnt stick around for years when the magic had clearly gone the way Oasis did. I preffer the Roses myself but both produced a couple of great albums and another albums workd of B-sides/singles. Since Whats the Story though has Oasis's output been any better than Squire of Browns post Roses work? not really and actually alot worse than Mai's with Primal Scream.
moreorless87 1 year ago
stop comparing Stone Roses to Oasis and fuckin' enjoy both bands
britdemmen 1 year ago 3
the beatles > the velvet underground > the smiths > the stone roses > Radiohead > ?
my favourite so far to fill the interrogation mark is the libertines but thats just me :)
soprano004 1 year ago
@soprano004 Arcade Fire for me.
MrThreshold2009 1 year ago
I am from Manchester and have adored the roses since those halcyon days of the late eightys timeless classic tunes the music thoses boys produced will last forever!!
mrhoppy17 1 year ago
my all time fav roses track, no one has to replace anyone they all have their own place in musical history....may all the ghosts come back to haunt you tell u how they died!!! f*****g tune!
missmanc82 1 year ago 2
great, the stone roses are just great
oasis111111111111111 1 year ago
greatest lyrics ive ever heard....just amazing.
mallafets 1 year ago
the beatles>the smiths>the stone roses>oasis>???
who will fill oasis hole?
dort926 2 years ago 2
@dort926 arctic monkeys
madeofstone95 1 year ago
1:10 - i have that poster in my room :D
georgelikespie 2 years ago
whered ya get the pics from?
joshie3212 2 years ago
who is who at 2;23?
Melkisedech 2 years ago
me and a girl i used to get pissed together on a friday and sing this lol
good days
EvilRage1 2 years ago
well good song, only just heard it
JackStratton32 2 years ago
the most underated roses song!
joshie3212 2 years ago 12
The Stone Roses only managed 2 albums in 6 years with a huge gap inbetween. Oasis have continually pumped out quality music and huge tours over the past fifteen years. I'm not saying Oasis are better, I'm just saying they are famous throughout the world for their hard work, where as the Roses always dropped the ball when it mattered most.
Aggiechilds 2 years ago
obviously your taste is in your arse as well as your head roses got sold out by there manager,and could not make another album,get your facts right before making a pathetic argument bout the most over rated band ever. oasis r average at best,
35nstlgtnhigh 2 years ago
Ahahahaha. You're so silly.
Aggiechilds 2 years ago
Fair enough but the Roses did have a two and a half year court battle to deal with. Not allowed to record, play live etc, and this is at their peak! Oasis didn't have to deal with that. This is why there's a large gap between albums.
Also, the Roses technically have 4 albums in Garage Flower and the Complete Stone Roses. Not to mention dozens of songs they never released (such as the stunning Pearl Bastard only just heard!). I wouldn't say Oasis have "pumped out quality music" at all.
Waterfall64 2 years ago
Man, Squire had some genius lyrics not even to mention the guitar riffs! I grew up with Oasis and was only introduced to the Roses around 2000 but I can't stop listening to them
morningcrow00 2 years ago
was there. the dogs]
holl2002 2 years ago
ian brown is the best front man of all time
hipshakejunkie 2 years ago 5
No. Andrew W.K. is #1.
Aggiechilds 2 years ago
no one else can sing these type of bitter dark lyrics better than ian brown.
second coming was browns best vocal performance, he really perfected that northern grit/soul/shaman quality. shame his voice since then has been destroyed.
squire in my opinion is better than anybody. a true cool genius.
squirehorse 3 years ago 4
definitely, these lyrics are brilliant
morningcrow00 2 years ago
this album is one of the best albums ever made cant believe it got slagged off when it was released,and this track is my favorite ! say no more! this band leads the way for every other band out there and they know it !
johnty64 3 years ago
its good but not legendary
crippleslayer 3 years ago 2
I forget how friggin great this band was. How the us market picked up oasis and blur and misssed these guys I will never understand. John squire wrote the riffs Oasis only dreamed of
ahoneyman 3 years ago
can only agree with there fella...
I still can't tire of them and I've listened to them for about 15 years now!
Great band
gazzamaccaknacker80 3 years ago
how could u forget??? :)
brodel77 3 years ago
it's cuz they had the power to truly inspire...somethin' in the air so to speak....innocence is dangerous.....
Portis1Luv 2 years ago
Gives me shivers the way the chorus kicks in man... fuckin quality... the roses were the boys.
toothchipbeebop1986 3 years ago 2
took the words right out my fucking mouth!
ibmonkeyman 3 years ago
man this track is amazing!
theview089 3 years ago
Man, despite popular pinion,
I love 2nd. Coming.
As I listen to each track, I still can't believe how good this album is.
themightycelestial 3 years ago
Still think this was the best LP of the 90's
Ordsall66 3 years ago
Fuckin magical ...this was evolution!
weecoby3 3 years ago
Almost as epic as I am the resurrection
bolivianex 3 years ago
for any group...It's so hard to follow a masterpiece like the 1st album ....well yeah JD did it...BUT this is still a good album
donnybrooklads 3 years ago
iv seen ur severed head at a banquat for the dead all dressed up for dinner looks so fine :)
cowdensno1 4 years ago
stone roses r class
jamiehughes14 4 years ago
Love it always did even back then,wasnt the roses we all knew but a class album all the same,and I could of listened to 100 more albums like this 1 from them
dugsie 4 years ago