Doctor Who 2009 - Fire and Ice (2 of 8) Fan Film

[1917redstar]

No worse than "real" Doctor Who, but then that's crap to.

[jedr1989]

@1917redstar If you don't like Doctor Who, may I ask why you're watching a Doctor Who fan film? Seems a bit illogical.

[boybob2]

its great but the only thing that bugs me is the audio levels

[NateSean]

I think that was one of the best "Doctor Meets Companion" scenes in a while.

Alice kind of loosely reminds me of Sarah in the beginning of Labyrinth.

[NateSean]

Nothing can go wrong when you go wandering through the woods of Maryland. Right Blair Witch Project?

[Vestamusic]

wouldn't you be screaming if you were attacked by a veloceraptor?

[auro1001]

"You're trespassing"

"Why, do you live here?"

"No"

"Then you're trespassing"

So something Tom Baker would say. Brilliant!

[auro1001]

"You're trespassing"

"Why, do you live here?"

"Then, you're trespassing"

So Tom Baker!

[MurrayTheMac]

Great cinematography work, really impressed. But I'm afraid halfway through this part I stopped watching ...

As a piece of drama, it's just too slow, sorry. 15 minutes in and I know nothing of significance about any of the characters, and there's no real mystery yet to wonder about. Pacing problems.

[PapercutTwilight]

@MurrayTheMac Like, 3 minutes further in there's a dinosaur

[marthavell]

Enjoying it,my only criticism and I do mean, my only criticism, the Doctor's English accent is a bit dodgy, but so was David Tennant's lol.

Keep at it guy's, I'd love to see more

[djfreebey]

any know when next 1 comeing out

[LaraDarkwood]

I love how he totally read what she was thinking, from, like, a grunt

[Jez32uk]

seems pretty good, far better portrayal of a new Doctor than most fan films, however calling Alice's friend Young Lady jarred a bit. Plus the dialogue was hard to hear after Alice got attacked by the dinosaur.

[TurtleIndustries]

So much grading! Other than that it was rather good, actually.

[CampRockfan40]

love it love it love it

[kylephantom4]

the doctor looks like my pe teacher, lol

[HTprods]

(Please Don't Comment On The Capital Letter Thing,It's An Annoying Habit) Liking It,Though It Lacks Realism. What's The Point Of So Much Grading? Doctor Who Is About Taking An Ordinary Person From Earth On The Trip Of Their Lifetime. The Whole Idea Is Too Relate To That Person,And You Can't Really Relate To Alice If Everything Around Her Is Graded,Looking Surreal. Also I Think The Script Made Things Over Dramatic At Times. Maybe You Should Tone Down All This,Making It All More Realistic.

[snapecharmer]

I hope Alice steps up the acting!

[SPASMSthePENGUIN]

@snapecharmer the dr needs 2 step us the acting

[snapecharmer]

Love it so far, but cribbing the music from the show is kind of a cop out! Not that it doesn't fit perfectly..... I'm conflicted!

[Murdock129]

It's DW, so it uses DW music, I don't see the problem

This si the best fan episode you could get, don't nitpick it too badly

[snapecharmer]

Not nitpicking. Think it's great, but if you use all your own stuff, use your own music too. I think it's a chance to get an up and coming musician/composer some recognition. I just don't want the BBC to go all crazy and demand they remove it, being copyrighted and all.

[GeordieDan89]

lol not bad at all!

Nice to see they're taking to DW over the pond ;)

ΘΣ

[dancergirl]

I'm liking this fan film. it's really cool!

[Sanchara]

I <3 Alice <3 <3

[crdbrdconstructor]

AWESOMENESS

[crmfghtr]

Everybody's a critic lol. Well done.

[weemcghee100]

I like how you still use the series music.

[dragounsleer]

Definitely one of the better fan films I've seen. Writing and acting are a little dodgy, but even RTD gets there sometimes...

[Murdock129]

Hello Russell T Davis screws up in nearly every script he writes

The only one of his episodes I really think is good and can remember as his is Utopia

And even then he made Martha and Jack spend a scene bitching about Rose

[WorldVideophone]

We wouldn't be talking about Who now if it weren't for him.

[akiugn]

@WorldVideophone It doesn't mean we can't criticise.

[WorldVideophone]

@akiugn As far as I'm aware I made no attempt to deter you fom criticism.

[TheKingofthemods1995]

The Doctor sounds like he's got a cold. Honestly America, you can't do good brit impressions!!! LOL.

[Disneyewok]

"Must you do that - make that annoying sound with that hole in your face?"

That's typical Doctor - and I love the fact that the Doctor with a sentence can make Alice's best friend speechless

For a fan made film - very good (so far) LOL

[JakeCanner]

Hmmm, WOW! ABSOLUTLY FANTASTIC! :O:O:O:O

[PrincessOfAvalon]

slightly dodgy writing and acting, but very impressive for a fan film!

[heyarnoldsknee]

Spot on mate...a little lacking in confidence, and it also aped some of RTD's stuff like a lot of fanfilms do, rather than do something a little original.

[Grantwebb13]

"I'm listening to the ground"

Brilliant!

[drwhoinsidethebox]

Wow, cheesy smile, but i'm very impressed :)