singer needs a better shirt....and the curse of "The cage" continues, unblemished. Outside of the album, i have never heard a keyboard player get all the way through the song with blowing it to some extent. Heck, I even saw Tony Banks clam it 2 nights in a row back on Dec. 17th-18th 1974 in Rochester and Buffalo NY during the original Genesis "Lamb" tour with Gabriel. I blew it myself whenever i knew the red "Record" light was on, with Rapid Eye, a cover band in NY, so I pay close attention :)
@markboccaccio Tony Banks also completely blows it on the MAMA tour on the video and on the bootleg cd I have of that tour. Outside of the 3 sides live version and the actual album I think the guy in this band is the best that I've seen =)
I've seen some really awful versions here on youtube also.
@just4thelolz They are doing an exact rendition of side 3 from three sides live and the singer is singing in English when he speaks German, so they are literally copying that version.
Amazing to hear. If I hear this is in a club I would be all over it. Just because they are not Genesis does not take anything away from these guys. Enjoyed, deep enjoyment. Please do more!
I tell you what, if there was ever a singer who could mimic Gabriel and Collins at the same time, it's this guy.....he sometimes has a gabrielesque voice with Collins' range.
Yeah great cover, and I've been listening to the original for 30 years! Sounds a lot like "3 sides live" version with Phil Collins intonation and mannerisms. Fair enough if that's what you prefer, sounds good. Vocals and bass stood out as good for me. Keyboards good, but too fast at times - I know Genesis did that in concert in the 80s/90s but for me it was not an improvement! Cheers, good job guys, I'd pay to see you here in California.
Absolutely stunning! Holy $hit. Any US dates coming up?
And enough with the "hands" comments. This band blows the roof off the joint and people are focused on what the singer's HANDS are doing? Unreal. The guy just took 99% of all singers to SCHOOL.
We'll be playing a new show on march 13th at the studio theatre in Hanover, Germany. This time, we focus on songs of Genesis and Phil Collins... featuring a larger lineup with two drum sets + percussion, live horn section and background singers!
So you'll see a brand new set list with some of the hottest Collins stuff as well as some rarely performed bold and glorious Genesis tunes.
Again, you don't have to buy any tickets, since entrance is free. We do ask for donations, though... :-)
The lead singer is trying to act like Phil to much. Voice is decent by his attempt at acting like Phil makes him look retarded. Hand movements need stop. LOL. Excellent instrumentally though!
Wow, impressive voice! Wish I could do that. You don't need the wierd hand things going. The whole band is great - love the girl playing the wicked bass parts.
The singer is good, flubs some words, my only advice is that he should make the song his own, it would seem like there is more conviction there. overall though thumbs up!
He sounds a bit like Phil & Peter. I look away from the screen to feel the sound. The band is right on!... I would give my left one to play drums along with these guys...
To me is really frightening listen to this, believing that is the real Genesis and suddenly watch other people making it. It seems like a possession or something like that. Very strange, just like the many "Beatles cover" bands around the world.
Sorry if my comment seems agressive. I'm only a sincere person. Yes, I'm a musician, but above all a great Genesis fan. Initially I was really glad to know that someone make a show in homage to Genesis. But, sincerely, search for Colin Smith on YouTube and you'll see a much more creative version of some of the Genesis songs. Really profound, not imitation.
Good intentions, bad results. Today musicians believe that only the ability to play difficult things is equal to musicianship. This band have no personality at all. Phil Collins trying to sing Peter Gabriel's repertoire is pathetic, but someone trying TO BE Phil Collins is too much unconvincing.
Replies such as this really test my "no flaming" montra. Suffice to say that vpdigital's band are exception musicians and I REALLY enjoyed their work. Thank you vpdigital, you guys are all fantastic!
Perhaps pilhadenervos can show us some of his
musical performances??? He obviosuly is a musical expert and seasoned professional critic.
Peter Gabriel's repertoire? Did you just ate something, or smoked something that's bad for you?
It's Genesis' repertoire, they wrote that stuff together, Phil happened to be in the band as well, and had to sing when Peter left. He's singing songs he helped writing, not Peter's repertoire, so why blame him him for sucking at it, he gives it his own thing, at a high level, pretty damn good, just not the original way.
Than for this band, great cover, but singer, stop being weird with the hands
Don't know why I've only just come across these performances, but they're fantastic. I look forward to more. Jochen Pietsch's keyboard sounds are very tasty.
Sehr gelungene Cover-Version! Ihr habt den Drive und die Aggressivität von ITC (vor allem die Collins-Versionen!) sehr gut eingefangen. Der etwas unpassende Lead-Sound wurde ja schon angesprochen, aber ich denke es ist nicht so leicht Tonys Sounds 1:1 zu treffen.
Auch Cinema Show macht ihr sehr sehr gut, klasse Version. Aber ihr solltet euch mal ne 12-saitige Gitarre UND(!!) ganz wichtig ein Moog Taurus Basspedal zulegen. Das fehlt schon etwas...
Ich war total Baff. Wenn das Video nicht gewesen wär hätte ich an eine Orginal Genesis Live Aufnahme geglaubt!!!! Fantastisch, perfekt, geil! Ich liebe es!
Minimaler Abzug wegen Ungenauigkeiten im Cinema Show-Part und des harschen, trockenen Leadsounds. Trotzdem 5 Sterne: Sehr tighte und energetische Vorstellung, außer dem Synth-Lead authentischer Sound, und der Sänger klingt wie Phil. Gruß aus Bielefeld, Genesis-Tribut-Brachland :-(
My favourite Genesis "rock" song and you hit it ON THE MONEY !!! Seriously impressive - subscribed ... now I just have to listen to the rest of your stuff ... please tell me that a UK tour is planned because I am SO coming.
You mean cage not cave.
codematrix 1 year ago
Comment removed
mirobaldo 5 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@codematrix: The original text at the first time you have "in the CAVE, get me out of this CAVE", then "in the CAGE, get me out of this CAGE"
mirobaldo 5 months ago
Like Phil Collins sings this!
lesclaypool0727 1 year ago
the vocal is great!! sound very very nice!!!!
agustobba 1 year ago
Best cover ever!
lesclaypool0727 1 year ago
singer needs a better shirt....and the curse of "The cage" continues, unblemished. Outside of the album, i have never heard a keyboard player get all the way through the song with blowing it to some extent. Heck, I even saw Tony Banks clam it 2 nights in a row back on Dec. 17th-18th 1974 in Rochester and Buffalo NY during the original Genesis "Lamb" tour with Gabriel. I blew it myself whenever i knew the red "Record" light was on, with Rapid Eye, a cover band in NY, so I pay close attention :)
markboccaccio 1 year ago
@markboccaccio Tony Banks also completely blows it on the MAMA tour on the video and on the bootleg cd I have of that tour. Outside of the 3 sides live version and the actual album I think the guy in this band is the best that I've seen =)
I've seen some really awful versions here on youtube also.
zierkly 1 year ago
Excellent! Some pretty much like the band.
Delgift 1 year ago
don't try to be phil, do it the peter's way ;)
just4thelolz 1 year ago
@just4thelolz They are doing an exact rendition of side 3 from three sides live and the singer is singing in English when he speaks German, so they are literally copying that version.
zierkly 1 year ago
@just4thelolz I think they're trying to capture the 3 Sides Live vibe.... but I agree.
funkster007 1 year ago
WOW!!!!!!!! This is amazing. Other than a few wrong words this would be GENESIS. Nice Job!!!!!!
zierkly 1 year ago
HOLY CRAP!!!!!!!! This is amazing. Other than a few wrong words this would be GENESIS. Nice Job!!!!!!
zierkly 1 year ago
Superb.
davidmochen 1 year ago
Very, very good cover! So accurate.
JeauxBand 1 year ago
this is great, musically its awesome to listen to, solid bass, drumming is awesome, keyboard player is great, sounds good guys! keep it up!
TheTayMan 1 year ago
come to America!
sean3415 1 year ago
Good Work to the Singer !!
matstar19 1 year ago
Amazing to hear. If I hear this is in a club I would be all over it. Just because they are not Genesis does not take anything away from these guys. Enjoyed, deep enjoyment. Please do more!
praestigium 1 year ago
The best Genesis cover i have ever heard..Nice 1 lid..!
raeljjd1966 2 years ago 2
Excellent cover this! Seriously, very very good
georgeman2468 2 years ago
I tell you what, if there was ever a singer who could mimic Gabriel and Collins at the same time, it's this guy.....he sometimes has a gabrielesque voice with Collins' range.
semajttam 2 years ago
Incredible. This is the best cover that I saw in my life. Amazing!!
InrollRadio 2 years ago
Blimey! Its like watching genesis in conert with phil on vocals. I agree about the mannerisms etc. Super stuff
georgeman2468 2 years ago
Just Beautiful
ricardolimatrucco 2 years ago
you guys are amazing!! Please come and play in Berlin!! Truly excellent!!
yothdagor 2 years ago
Yeah great cover, and I've been listening to the original for 30 years! Sounds a lot like "3 sides live" version with Phil Collins intonation and mannerisms. Fair enough if that's what you prefer, sounds good. Vocals and bass stood out as good for me. Keyboards good, but too fast at times - I know Genesis did that in concert in the 80s/90s but for me it was not an improvement! Cheers, good job guys, I'd pay to see you here in California.
ntrlmass 2 years ago
This is a pretty damn good cover, actually.
blake46long 2 years ago
bravo ..... bravo ..... j'ai fermé les yeux pour vous écouter, c'est admirable .......... à bientôt
tof
christophemocquet 2 years ago
Freakin' good, fellas. From one tribute artist to another! It would be a dream come true to play in a Genesis tribute.
MikeyRB77 2 years ago
This is absolutely amazing stuff. Perfect.
fooger12345 2 years ago
Absolutely stunning! Holy $hit. Any US dates coming up?
And enough with the "hands" comments. This band blows the roof off the joint and people are focused on what the singer's HANDS are doing? Unreal. The guy just took 99% of all singers to SCHOOL.
ninedeep 2 years ago
What is the last part?
goethean 2 years ago
Stunning performance!
Who are you, where do you perform next?
Bernard
lekezenman 2 years ago
We'll be playing a new show on march 13th at the studio theatre in Hanover, Germany. This time, we focus on songs of Genesis and Phil Collins... featuring a larger lineup with two drum sets + percussion, live horn section and background singers!
So you'll see a brand new set list with some of the hottest Collins stuff as well as some rarely performed bold and glorious Genesis tunes.
Again, you don't have to buy any tickets, since entrance is free. We do ask for donations, though... :-)
vpdigital 2 years ago
@vpdigital You and your band play strictly a Phil Collins, Genesis?
Dannymusic1999 1 year ago
Musicians are brill,lead singer is too but might be better if he tried not to copy Phil quite so much..specially the hand movements..
mxpixx 3 years ago
The lead singer is trying to act like Phil to much. Voice is decent by his attempt at acting like Phil makes him look retarded. Hand movements need stop. LOL. Excellent instrumentally though!
TheTayMan 3 years ago 2
Wow, impressive voice! Wish I could do that. You don't need the wierd hand things going. The whole band is great - love the girl playing the wicked bass parts.
audiotrax2000 3 years ago
Altho, the proper way to sing this is shirtless.. Rael, you know ;-)
JackBlair2 3 years ago
great job
JackBlair2 3 years ago 3
this is like 1/3 Peter 1/3 Phil and 1/3 Michael Stipe.
ceazea 3 years ago
This is awesome! I want to be the singer! =D
Dafter88 3 years ago
Great job!!!
schizoidmannello 3 years ago
The singer is good, flubs some words, my only advice is that he should make the song his own, it would seem like there is more conviction there. overall though thumbs up!
tindrum 3 years ago
You are absolutely talented...
Are you coming to Italy for a tour?
PoetaDiLilith 3 years ago
Fan de genesis depuis presque 30 ans...
incontestablement le meilleur tribute band jamais entendu.
Again, again...
MUCVEGA 3 years ago
although i miss the double bass drums at the change.
tommycottreau 3 years ago
im critical when it comes to covers but man outstanding job. Well done. Well, well done.
tommycottreau 3 years ago 2
very gooooood job!
asmodeo1984 3 years ago
Excellent!
miloudyt 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I'm sorry but this guy can not be compared to Phil. Not even close. I mean he is on Pluto. Please don't waste ur money going to watch this guy.
buckeyesrule10 3 years ago
Easy man, the guy is good. The whole band is very talented, criticism is fine but come on...
erikinhawaii 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Just get a new singer. Ba
buckeyesrule10 3 years ago
WHO CARES ABOUT PHIL????
This is a Peter song.
And this lead singer is doing a great job.
The band is incredibly talented.
PaulHartXYZ 3 years ago
If anything, this guy sounds more like Peter....a little less dynamic though, & I dont know about his wardrobe....ironic, once I think about it
Laminateddeffect 3 years ago
Nice job to all there!! Great stuff!
Any idea where we can see the full version?
vision19701004 3 years ago
This is a great job on a awesome song!
He sounds a bit like Phil & Peter. I look away from the screen to feel the sound. The band is right on!... I would give my left one to play drums along with these guys...
sgvrr2003 3 years ago
Very good boys very good. Great vocals and playing by you all on what is a very complex song, nice one! (sounds like pete)
corlackis 3 years ago
Excellent Job ! Such a difficult song mastered by you guys great work!
mwolve64 3 years ago
Superrrrrrrrr
bennyGenesis 3 years ago
Ach was, phantastisch!!!! :-D
aqwaya 3 years ago
Fabulous! Nice work boys.
mattlth 3 years ago
Pretty dam good, actually perfect ! Great job on a classic Genesis tune...
erikinhawaii 3 years ago
Fantastic Phil Collins voice...it's a hard one to emulate well!
mooghammondb3 3 years ago
I think it sounds more like Peter Gabriel actually... But he does all the stuff Phil does,, so that's pretty damn good!!
emiel4sma 3 years ago
vpdigital: You guys are GREAT!
I loved the videos! Play more and come to North Carolina! Keep up the fabulous work!
DippysFinest 3 years ago
To me is really frightening listen to this, believing that is the real Genesis and suddenly watch other people making it. It seems like a possession or something like that. Very strange, just like the many "Beatles cover" bands around the world.
pilhadenervos 3 years ago
Sorry if my comment seems agressive. I'm only a sincere person. Yes, I'm a musician, but above all a great Genesis fan. Initially I was really glad to know that someone make a show in homage to Genesis. But, sincerely, search for Colin Smith on YouTube and you'll see a much more creative version of some of the Genesis songs. Really profound, not imitation.
pilhadenervos 3 years ago
Good intentions, bad results. Today musicians believe that only the ability to play difficult things is equal to musicianship. This band have no personality at all. Phil Collins trying to sing Peter Gabriel's repertoire is pathetic, but someone trying TO BE Phil Collins is too much unconvincing.
pilhadenervos 3 years ago
very sad.
i am sure you are a musician.
the only time i see one musician putting down another is when the one talking is talentless.
sorry.
shoans 3 years ago
Replies such as this really test my "no flaming" montra. Suffice to say that vpdigital's band are exception musicians and I REALLY enjoyed their work. Thank you vpdigital, you guys are all fantastic!
Perhaps pilhadenervos can show us some of his
musical performances??? He obviosuly is a musical expert and seasoned professional critic.
DippysFinest 3 years ago
Peter Gabriel's repertoire? Did you just ate something, or smoked something that's bad for you?
It's Genesis' repertoire, they wrote that stuff together, Phil happened to be in the band as well, and had to sing when Peter left. He's singing songs he helped writing, not Peter's repertoire, so why blame him him for sucking at it, he gives it his own thing, at a high level, pretty damn good, just not the original way.
Than for this band, great cover, but singer, stop being weird with the hands
emiel4sma 3 years ago
My God, you guys are incredible. Very tight and great. The music is impeccable....although I do find you sound like Phil on this one....
Jeuwseph 3 years ago
I disagree he sounds more like Pete on this song.
smadurski 3 years ago
Bravo!! Excellent musicians doing an excellent cover of the best music ever. Keep it up!!
strykertube 3 years ago
Don't know why I've only just come across these performances, but they're fantastic. I look forward to more. Jochen Pietsch's keyboard sounds are very tasty.
fernald10 3 years ago
You are great!!!
89DrAcoNiAn89 4 years ago
Nur Martin Levac (Ex.TMB) covert Phil in dem Song besser!
Mama, Fading Lights & Afterglow haben mir von Euch gesnaglich nicht so gefallen, aber Euer Käfig ist richtig klasse!
BloodOnTheRooftops 4 years ago
Hallöchen!
Sehr gelungene Cover-Version! Ihr habt den Drive und die Aggressivität von ITC (vor allem die Collins-Versionen!) sehr gut eingefangen. Der etwas unpassende Lead-Sound wurde ja schon angesprochen, aber ich denke es ist nicht so leicht Tonys Sounds 1:1 zu treffen.
Auch Cinema Show macht ihr sehr sehr gut, klasse Version. Aber ihr solltet euch mal ne 12-saitige Gitarre UND(!!) ganz wichtig ein Moog Taurus Basspedal zulegen. Das fehlt schon etwas...
sebawilken 4 years ago
Ich war total Baff. Wenn das Video nicht gewesen wär hätte ich an eine Orginal Genesis Live Aufnahme geglaubt!!!! Fantastisch, perfekt, geil! Ich liebe es!
flohdaniel 4 years ago
absolutely fantasic
volendos2 4 years ago
Minimaler Abzug wegen Ungenauigkeiten im Cinema Show-Part und des harschen, trockenen Leadsounds. Trotzdem 5 Sterne: Sehr tighte und energetische Vorstellung, außer dem Synth-Lead authentischer Sound, und der Sänger klingt wie Phil. Gruß aus Bielefeld, Genesis-Tribut-Brachland :-(
Capacitor76 4 years ago
Another flawless cover.
DavieMarshall 4 years ago
My favourite Genesis "rock" song and you hit it ON THE MONEY !!! Seriously impressive - subscribed ... now I just have to listen to the rest of your stuff ... please tell me that a UK tour is planned because I am SO coming.
CaptainFrantic 4 years ago 2
Who are these guys ?
Fantastic sound
arturfilipe98 4 years ago
Good job guys!!! congratulations!!!
Marcusvdgg71 4 years ago 4