SHACK - Comedy

[dalek1952]

nice all around

[paulpellicci]

...great sound....

[drstevie]

one of the best bands ever !!!

[bid84]

just discovered this quality band, thanks to a helpful HMV employee, overlooked for sure.

[gram2358]

Such a tight band, H.m.s. Fable one of my favourite albums. Why didnt Shack make the big time, theres no frigging justice!

[SelflessWill]

'The' Love Song! X

[elgaed69]

seriously, the fact alone that this particular band has not become generally famous is an ill omen that humankind on the whole has abandoned the Muses....

[scottydog48]

absolutely brilliant,what more can i say.

[JamesonPR]

This song brings back so many happy memories. Beautiful songwriting, and such an understated performance.

[Sexpistols100]

amazing band thanks



[TheMerseyBoy]

noel's sound ya weirdos - shack are boss too - grow up!

[BruisedArcade09]

Oasis are the most over rated band ever! every song is just a rip off, Shack deserve to be more famous than Oasis but in my own selfish way i like them the way they are..all to myself!

[ianbrownshairdo]

back to view again, someone show this to Mumford and Son for fucks sake.

[ianbrownshairdo]

great track but calm down calm down, not exactly feeling sorry for noel eh?

[robjbray]

Do you really think Shack want comments like " this shits on Oasis"

for all you know they may be freinds, comments like that are just negative and help no one

[dermot51]

@robjbray i said " pisses" and Noel produced their last LP and their mates too but i still stand by my comment sorry

[KennyZilch2009]

Awesome song by Shack which goes as far back as 86' as the Palies. Sounds not much different either. Truely a song deserving the same recognition as Wonderwall and pisses all over it. Mick Head = LEGEND : )

[cam101room]

Better than Oasis, all fucking day!

[buffmanilla]

is rite lid

[buffmanilla]

is rite lid.

[aloneagainor1]

love this band. seen em about 8 times. never disappoint. h.m.s. fable has to be one of the best albums ever made.

[bartonim]

@aloneagainor1 So right! It makes the hair stand on my neck! I envy you, mate. Would love to see 'em!

[dermot51]

@aloneagainor1 A " fuckin" greed its perfect

[jonnyjonny84]

I met Noel Gallagher once and all i did was talk to him about Shack. One of the greatest hidden talents of all time!

[dermot51]

@jonnyjonny84 Thats funny i met him twice and all he did was talk to ME about Shack he knows a class pop group does Noel

[krank027]

"H.M.S Fable" is my album of the year 1999... Love from Athens, GR

[typhoon10]

Trying to come to terms with Shack supporting that second rate pub band Oasis..... Good god.......

[bartonim]

@typhoon10 While I like Oasis, you're absolutely right. Mick and John are two of the best, and Shack are brilliant!

[scouselid1]

Brilliant ! This one of my favourite tracks of all time. Oasis ? Totally overrated - They've never written as good a tune as this.

[dermot51]

@scouselid1 this tune pisses all over live forever and Noel knows it

[jimcup78]

i saw them live supporting oasis his voice is amazing

[longlostcomedy]

What do they say .... wasted talent.

Should have been huge.

Great Song

[jockpaisley79]

These guys should have got all the riches that Oasis ever made - not sure what they would gave been spent on...... oh wait !!!! Top band - top song !!!!!

[liam4ragdoll]

Comedy, no Its a Tragedy, Michael head hasnt been amply rewarded for his crafted melodies and role as scouse songsmith. Just makes you feel sorry for Noel and his millions of followers.......Go on keep Noel in luxury while you do the real donkey work for a pittance

[bartonim]

@liam4ragdoll Agreed. I've liked Oasis, but these guys are the real deal. This song still sends chill up my back, it's so poignant and beautiful!

[ianbrownshairdo]

gotta love 'sma...shack' x

[transonicbuoy1]

A rare example of a support act with more talent and charisma than the main act.

[dermot51]

@transonicbuoy1 goes without saying mate they piss all over Oasis and surely "Comedy" has to be as close to the best pop song ever written ...period

[dermot51]

@transonicbuoy1 well your right obviously but this song you got to remember is up there with even the Beatles best stuff even better

[Prsono1]

Tuuuuuuuunneeee

[thommo988]

Lovely song, that scouse accent ruins it though.

[2008nighty]

moron

[thommo988]

Maybe, I'm right though

[khiltscher]

This Should Be The Follow Up Hit fot THE BYRDS

after "I Wasn't Born To Follow" !

[aketzer]

gorgeous !

[herbertbertbert]

i love this song so much

[ruth1488]

dont know wot to say..amazin!got all their albums...apart from the one with all the chinese writin over it..that cost 27 notes!available in all expensive record stores!

[clift1967]

You must be a real fan.

Good Idea, to make beautiful pictures even worthier.

Thank You!!!!

[xXlonemilkmanXx]

i love this song absalutely amazing

[hypanova116]

woo man i got a personal performance of this by john pyaa amazin

[slideshowrod]

Fantastic tune - 1st time I've heard it since '99 when it came out. I live in France and found an original copy of Waterpistol in the local library (!!!), and it's brillant. I've got some serious catching up to do!

[rusure2398]

nice song and video - there best is water pistol - but all of there alums have great songs - i wish there were a dvd of them. listen to railway children they also are good.

[nozwad2]

mate get down 2 hmv its jst been repackaged if nt jst 4 stranger -there best song inmy opinion

[rkidkarl]

in response to Supasap, i think hms fable is their best album to date, certainly better than the 2 follow ups... i never got to hear waterpistol... hard to find, some said that was their best. im happy with hms fable, great harmonies, top guitar...

[supasap]

OK love this song love it...... best on HMS Fable in my view (which is only thing I have heard)...... if you think this too, what other songs should I get from Shack

[rossflemington]

cup of tea, tie me down, lizzie mullaly are all on The corner of Miles and Gil

Street of Kenny and this are the standout tracks on HMS Fable, but the whole album is great.

Also worth tacking down Mick's earlier band the pale fountains. Palm of my hand, jean's not happening, Reach, Thank You, Southbound excursions.

The reformed Pale Fountains are playing for 2nights only in Liverpool and London this weekend

[hypanova116]

and pull together on hms fable

[AndyW001]

Simple answer-All Shack LPs and The Magical World of The Strands, you're missing out if you don't :o)

[uksclavain]

This is sooo good...HMS Fable for me is one of the greatest albums of all time ...ty :D

[ckbefc]

Truly amazing band. Shack forever

ONWARD EVERTONIANS

Scouse Chris

[hypanova116]

if they wenrt both liverpool fans i would agree with that

[stefan1912uvf]

wow....what can i say???? why are they not the biggest band in the world???

[OdedFriedGaon]

i love this song. great harmonies. sound like other bands i like: The Lilac Time, R.E.M., The Yardbirds. NICE!

[leespj]

Class

Shack are the best ever Liverpool Band

Actually Fuckin Britain !!!!

From Scouser John

[nemeth2009]

Your right way better than the Beatles PMSL go play with the traffic mate