uhhhh good try, for the guy, the girl did decent, but she should have kept the same tempo as the guy. they should have tried to match it better and should have worked on musicality some more, but then again, musicality only after the technicality has been perfected.
This is the closest I've seen to it been replicated half decent. It's far from perfect but it's the best there is on youtube apart from the original. Good work.
I have a converted solo version, but it's not open to public. And look, they the sheet music here like where many got Secret: 20 Years Time Travel, take out spaces, gangqinpu . com / html / 4215 . htm
Very good! This is the most accurate transcription of the song I've heard yet, except at 1:22 (where that one phrase "F-E-E flat" seems to have been repeated). Nicely done! Keep it up!
This is a piece composed by Jay and he doesnt publish the sheet i can say it with 99% of certainty.
All you can do to get the sheet is wandering the internet asking sbd who can play the piece and write the notes down.
Or go to Alfa Music, tell Jay you'll suicide if he doesnt give you the sheet =))
___
Anyway. You two are awesome. At 0:16 you should do better. But I understand, even Yu Hao cannot play any faster when playing live, check the performance in Singapore :(
Agreed, and very well said. I've tried many times to find the sheet music, and needless to say, I have failed spectacularly.
And I agree with your point on the scale/chords at 0:16, but ah well, Jay himself didn't do much better. In the movie it doesn't show Yuhao doing it, it just cuts to the two guys going "Oh gosh Jay's screwed". And Jay's one-handed bit is also obviously faked.
Hmm, well he isn't too bad with that other song for two pianos..."Dragon Heel", I think it's called. He plays octaves really quickly, and that's impressive considering how long the melody drags on.
I dunno, maybe I heard a different version, but the live version I heard was distinctly different from the movie version...for example, the ending chords (E-A) had some sort of...erm...glissando-sounding embellishment added on. A nice touch...
hey, its good. im so friggin excited! my friend just found this music and we're planning on doing it for the talent show.
I like what you did with the second part. For the separate part though, I did notice that while the girl played it cleaner, she only did a single note arpeggio for the double note part. You both did a good job though.
i would say this is pretty amazing, cauz ur not jay chou and yu hao themself playing this piece. very nicely done, just try working out the beginning chords :) good job
hat was greatttt!!! i was just wondering tho......what is this piece called? like....the actual name....so that maybe i can find the sheet music myself?
yes i'm jeslous too la... and to have 2 ppl playing such good pieces in one house is so rare. i wish i could do that too. where did you get the score?
thank you , you've inspired me to finish my song i started writing.... =D i got stuck... but INSPIRATION!
BixZsc 6 months ago
GUYS I NEED THE MUSIC SHEET OMG >< Please please please I'm so gonna do this with my friend.
MissLittleWhoopsie 8 months ago
I wish I could play this good -.-
DontHateShanaynay 9 months ago
i would say the girl won but she had sheet music so i cant decide
lexie84740 10 months ago
勁呀,youtube最強!!!
71648hk 1 year ago
to be fair, the guy seems to be playing it from memory, while the girl seems to have music in front of her, these are assumptions of course
12ui12ui 1 year ago
friggin awesome ;D
emaliciouz2 1 year ago
I gotta say... you where both awsome and the tune rocked =P
Archonful 1 year ago
5 stars for the Spongebob T-Shirt ;D !
ZeroXBreak 1 year ago
You both rocked my socks off! haha great job!!
calliejean09 1 year ago
at least he can do it :D good jobb..i cant even play this kind off fastt..:D
AAagentAA 1 year ago
azn FTW
hitosawa 1 year ago
haha this was so cool. awesome job.
laxattack1 1 year ago
nice jobs guys...probably the best video other than the original so far
touxay559 1 year ago
Excellent !!!
Exaltationitrique 1 year ago
Nahh the one on the right still has to read the music. You have to let the music flow
BeastlyINC 1 year ago
haha this was pretty impressive. but i must say the girl was better.lol but i read the comments below so i know jjianc didnt practice.lol
nice job though. keep making videos.
bipolarbear24721 1 year ago
YOU ROCK!!!
damonmaster999 1 year ago
the guy in the middle piano did the best lol jk jk
blkwing15 1 year ago 14
nice job :)
xEdwardPangx 1 year ago
don't worry dude, you did well, from a piano pro =P
Hubertroxyoursox 1 year ago
WAouuuuuu sooo GOOD !!!! jay chou is jealous now :)
bambounette29 1 year ago
what piano is that in the middle? I think I have the same one
BrokenBrilliance 1 year ago
LOL! These comments are so funny =)
I'm the guy from this video! And yeah I admit I really did suck, I didn't practice nearly enough bahahah! But thanks for watching though =D
jjianc 1 year ago 5
@jjianc we'll record another one...
julisaa 1 year ago 4
i didn't even the person on the very right! but amazing by the way!:)
kawaii4u2 1 year ago
hey !
why didn't you wait a bit longer before recording this? it s****s
tayumaru 1 year ago
the guy sucks at it!
Yael108 1 year ago
good job!! awesome playing with no sheets (:
megapig01 1 year ago
The black thing in the left side, isnt it fourth piano? :D
8rip8 1 year ago
uhhhh good try, for the guy, the girl did decent, but she should have kept the same tempo as the guy. they should have tried to match it better and should have worked on musicality some more, but then again, musicality only after the technicality has been perfected.
dankasan123 1 year ago
i just noticed that the guy uses no music.
Eleventytwoo 1 year ago
which one do you think is harder? primo or second? Pick a side and not middle =D
Arachnaphobian 1 year ago
can you help me please ? how do you play right hand on 0:17 to 0:21 , I mean finger position
Joint145 1 year ago
@Joint145 play an F -A- G chord. Then go whine about it.
jmevo 1 year ago
@jmevo ah, i played just FA-AD-DF thx .o))
Joint145 1 year ago
Either your illiterate or your a dumbass.
jmevo 1 year ago
it sounded sloppy
Chefodeath 1 year ago
i have the midi file
whoopsforgotmypiano 2 years ago
great job! really well done!
63362 2 years ago
i know where the sheet music can be found u can comment me and ill send u the link.
ColorMeVicious 2 years ago
@ColorMeVicious: lol i want that link... hahaha
TheJDLA 2 years ago
This is the closest I've seen to it been replicated half decent. It's far from perfect but it's the best there is on youtube apart from the original. Good work.
LoftyProduction 2 years ago
awsome, i wish i could do that... mabie i could have one of your pianos :) or do you need all 3 haha ?
kaine180 2 years ago
Where can I get the music sheet for the second part plz?? :(
Mizerablism 2 years ago
Good job and does anyone know the name of the damn song...cause I haven't seen one person that knows the name of it
twicksbar 2 years ago
secret battle 3. I found the sheets when i googled Piano battle 3.
123Shankar123 2 years ago
even though u dont hav the sheet music
would u mind telling me where u found it in the first place?
elephanttif 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
unclear and too slow
xiaoxiayu 2 years ago
stfu u can do better ?
AznSoldierx 2 years ago
i bet you i can, its not exactly difficult compared to them
xiaoxiayu 2 years ago
k so post a video of u playin it btch
AznSoldierx 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
go to my page and look at me playing violin and piano, better then these amateurs
xiaoxiayu 2 years ago
@AznSoldierx lol
LoftyProduction 2 years ago
The guy got OWNED lmfao!
Tybu2585 2 years ago 20
@Tybu2585 >=(
jjianc 1 year ago
Very nice!
darkeagle999 2 years ago
WOW....soo good lol
Animeextreme25 2 years ago
even though this way played a little slower, this was impressive. im truly amazed. you guys are awesome. keep up the good work
anh2013 2 years ago
you guys are good :D
me and my friend tried doing it but its too fast haha
ateedanda806 2 years ago
lol
chopinjierong 2 years ago 2
omg 3 pianos
haiz369 2 years ago
damn
mkem2 2 years ago
lol some friend played this in our school music concert
conzomonzo 2 years ago
danggg nice
chutpimp 2 years ago
What song is this?
ivoeicecream 2 years ago
obviously it's slower but then again they're not getting paid to play or anything.
Eleventytwoo 2 years ago
cool!
aaabbbccc5 2 years ago
FASTER
acatisfinetoowut 2 years ago
is there a proper name for the song, i really want the score, been looking for it for awhile now
kasonyaj1 2 years ago
lady wins ^^
IceShadowMeteora 2 years ago
I agree...
shinobikakashihatake 2 years ago
OMGEE I WANT TO PLAY IT ARGH!
erosennin4203 2 years ago
COOL!!! :D
rifqi7san 2 years ago
AWESOME! But you guys played it a little slower.
flubby123456 2 years ago 3
name please
zhzhzh5 2 years ago
Waw that was amazing 0.0"
SmilingOnigiri 2 years ago
omg pro
fannyboy1 2 years ago
WOW!
i forgive your mistakes plain yellow T's HAHA
sanggong 2 years ago
He was actually better considering he has no sheet music.
Keyboardbeatz 2 years ago 4
wow :O 3 piano's
granturismo4fan 2 years ago 2
OMFG U HAVE 3 PIANOS
timfey 2 years ago 35
@timfey correction, its 2 pianos and 1 keyboard.....haha
dcninga 1 year ago
@timfey He's also got the chair of a possible fourth in the edge of the screen..
bnbmaster3 1 year ago 2
Thats cool~~~ :) Great job~~~!!!!
AsH3sANn3 2 years ago
great job!!
blackness1747 2 years ago
It's awesome, but there are some wrong notes at the beginning...juz watch out for those.
jeff151292 2 years ago
WOW!!! AWESOME!! like it^^
lxCHerRYxl 2 years ago
Great job.
Dien239 2 years ago
Very cool.
ezeella 2 years ago
yay! :] hi sean
vvv
mikestahhh 2 years ago
you guys are so amazing. best cover i've seen so far! good job!
Mus1calMayhem 2 years ago
What is this piece called,
and the composer of this piece???
BreathtakingSadness 2 years ago
Ofcourse IT IS a great Job, Did anyone try to play THIS on Two?
habt ihr es jemals versucht zu Zweit zu spielen? Hard. Schwer. TRUDNO !
wallhalla64 2 years ago
Awesome D:
carrieebear 2 years ago
XD that was very good !!!!!!! COOL
Shanewilliams12 2 years ago
Wow. amazing! keep up the good job.
liloaznboi 2 years ago
you guys rock!!!!
Babyfacenatz 2 years ago
amazing :D :D :D
UnspokenWordsx3 2 years ago
Wow, this is absolutely stunning! Excellent work!!
EdwardChibisan 3 years ago
hmm just noticed.... 3 pianos 2 real and 1 electric lucky :P
plx7 3 years ago 2
nice! :DDD
where did you find the sheet?
hanadhyas 3 years ago
I have a converted solo version, but it's not open to public. And look, they the sheet music here like where many got Secret: 20 Years Time Travel, take out spaces, gangqinpu . com / html / 4215 . htm
pokemonaruto123 3 years ago
What's this song called?
ctrainyu 2 years ago
Piano Battle 3
pokemonaruto123 2 years ago
lol, i guess it could be called "piano battle 3" but isn't this like jay chou's version of flight of the bumble bee?
superpnoyboy 2 years ago
nice!!!!!!!!!!!!!9/5
plx7 3 years ago
Very good! This is the most accurate transcription of the song I've heard yet, except at 1:22 (where that one phrase "F-E-E flat" seems to have been repeated). Nicely done! Keep it up!
starwarsfanboy 3 years ago
wow, this is amazing!
i like it when u both started playing together, good synchronization.
EChis33 3 years ago 2
This is a piece composed by Jay and he doesnt publish the sheet i can say it with 99% of certainty.
All you can do to get the sheet is wandering the internet asking sbd who can play the piece and write the notes down.
Or go to Alfa Music, tell Jay you'll suicide if he doesnt give you the sheet =))
___
Anyway. You two are awesome. At 0:16 you should do better. But I understand, even Yu Hao cannot play any faster when playing live, check the performance in Singapore :(
bunnyoneedge 3 years ago
Agreed, and very well said. I've tried many times to find the sheet music, and needless to say, I have failed spectacularly.
And I agree with your point on the scale/chords at 0:16, but ah well, Jay himself didn't do much better. In the movie it doesn't show Yuhao doing it, it just cuts to the two guys going "Oh gosh Jay's screwed". And Jay's one-handed bit is also obviously faked.
starwarsfanboy 3 years ago
Yu really doesnt play the piece well T__T. I checked the live show, he disappointed me T__T.
About Jay I think he's somehow able to handle his own piece. Jay is probably pretty good at speeding all pieces up :)).
bunnyoneedge 3 years ago
Hmm, well he isn't too bad with that other song for two pianos..."Dragon Heel", I think it's called. He plays octaves really quickly, and that's impressive considering how long the melody drags on.
I dunno, maybe I heard a different version, but the live version I heard was distinctly different from the movie version...for example, the ending chords (E-A) had some sort of...erm...glissando-sounding embellishment added on. A nice touch...
starwarsfanboy 3 years ago
Impressive and stunnning!
But not without room for improvement!
Congrats and nice effort!
hong87k 3 years ago
awesomee!!! but there's a few noticible mistakes here and there haha. keep the good work up!!!
LausaiCow 3 years ago
wow!! i wanna play like you guys
munkah987654321 3 years ago
Nice going guys! :) 5 stars!
Your piano friend
Karl ;)
karlng888 3 years ago
are u chinese
veng98 3 years ago
wooooooooooooo so good. u guys are fast! upload more vids please!!!!
purple3gem 3 years ago
anyone got this music? send me a message on youtube with the link if you do please
MikeyCanDoIt 3 years ago
damnnnnnnnnnnnnnnn good job lol
scitri 3 years ago
holy shyt!
u guyz r friggin awesome!!!!.....almost sounds lyk itz ryt outta the movie.....luv that u guyz were really battling it out ^-^
r u siblings???
Krazee5 3 years ago
wats the name for this song??
alyychann313 3 years ago
holii crappp i couldn't breath while watchin this!!!!
uhmazin
nlee92 3 years ago
hey, its good. im so friggin excited! my friend just found this music and we're planning on doing it for the talent show.
I like what you did with the second part. For the separate part though, I did notice that while the girl played it cleaner, she only did a single note arpeggio for the double note part. You both did a good job though.
topspin525 3 years ago
omg... ive been looking for the score for this song!!! :'( where can i get it?
RoGuEclaud 3 years ago
so cool!,because they look somewhat similar to the original one =]..oh yeah the girl was playing like jay chou =]..the guy was pretty good too!^_^
kimielle13 3 years ago
i have the sheets for this song
work out the two note chords
kakashi321naruto321 3 years ago
hey hey!can i have a copy?!please!^_^,
kimielle13 3 years ago
can i have a copy plz too!! thanks
nightslayer 3 years ago
could you please post them somewhere and give a link?!?
wayzhack69 3 years ago
Can I have a copy, too ?
I'm dying searching for this.
Thank you very much
bunnyoneedge 3 years ago
marvelous!!!!!!!!!! im dying for the score!! so sad that you do not have it anymore..-_-
rifqi7san 3 years ago
i would say this is pretty amazing, cauz ur not jay chou and yu hao themself playing this piece. very nicely done, just try working out the beginning chords :) good job
qqqqaaaawwwwssss 3 years ago
nah he makes more mistakes...rofl
lomeinaddict 3 years ago
horrible...dude...
the girl wins by a landslide.....
lomeinaddict 3 years ago
They're both the same....he goes to fast for his paste, she goes to slow for her paste...
coolboi08 3 years ago
lol btw its pace not paste XD
but oh em gee very good playing on piano! awesommeee
hannerdino 3 years ago
Very nicely done. Though the guy playing was rather inconsistent in the piece as compared to the lady.
By the way, this piece was composed by Jay Chou himself just for the movie "Secret", so the score shouldn't be existent, or at least to the public.
LiewII 3 years ago
oh it was available before =], it was in a chinese website =] but i think it's deleted now because of some reason =[
kimielle13 3 years ago
pro
teddykute255 3 years ago
a little off tune, don'tcha think?
nooblaggers 3 years ago
wow. my dreams are shattered. o_O;
chinesewolfofmibu 3 years ago 4
that was awesomeeee
NaiBara28 3 years ago 2
WOWOWOWOWOWOWOWOW I think this is the best piano battle 3 I have ever seen!
kptib88 3 years ago 2
this is great ! good job !
melissa5578 3 years ago 2
wowowwo !!!! nice ~~~~
jason11Zero 3 years ago
hat was greatttt!!! i was just wondering tho......what is this piece called? like....the actual name....so that maybe i can find the sheet music myself?
bobble138 3 years ago
that was AWESOMEEE!!!
Animeluver750 3 years ago
P.E.R.F.E.C.T
laughya 3 years ago
wow, amazing perfomance.....
send me the music sheet please...^.^
nifengerl 3 years ago
You guys are PRO
Qupos 3 years ago
awesome :D
septemberxv 3 years ago
damn!!! good stuff can u send me the sheet music please?????
Kbdrive21 3 years ago
AWESOME i want the sheet music so me and my friend can play that its soo wicked
TehLilAzn47 3 years ago
wow im shocked that was soo good xD man i hope i can play liek that one day :]
YummiPoPTart 3 years ago
Can I get the score for this? My email is fartyjack007[at] hotmail. com
dbskiluvu 3 years ago
wow...you got three pianos o_0
I am very jeaous
and both of you play very very well :)
mistmv12 3 years ago
yes i'm jeslous too la... and to have 2 ppl playing such good pieces in one house is so rare. i wish i could do that too. where did you get the score?
mileycyrus2204 3 years ago
could you guys send me the score for this... that was awesome
wordup666 3 years ago
Hey guys, this is pretty much repeating everyone...but WHERE DO YOU GET THE SHEET MUSIC? XD
And AWESOME performance by the way, really good sound quality.
narutoinuyasha 3 years ago
awesomeness!
swimmingviolinist 3 years ago
oh man.. where can i get the sheets for this! puhleaseeee... =)
madmarycash 3 years ago
can you send me the sheet music for this pleaseeee? =]]
dArKnEkO13 3 years ago
this is so good guys, keep it up, its like better than the real one!!! nice work
abzo 3 years ago
omg this is almost like the real thing!
awesome
5 starsss
jayja934 3 years ago
u guys are good =D
amababies 3 years ago
Very nice, but I think you played a note wrong in the fast arpeggio section... not entirely sure though, so sorry if it's wrong... but nice playing^^
FeiLunHairox112 3 years ago
u have 3 piaos at ur house?
arielgal 3 years ago 2
yeah..i wonder too..they have 3 pianos in this vid..i'm jalous..hhaha
karasashanna 3 years ago
wicked!!!!
arielgal 3 years ago
whoa we have 1800 views??? hahah sweet!!
BTW i'm the guy playing in the video... bahahaha
jjianc 3 years ago
Waaaaaaaaaaa!!!!
Sooooo goooood!!!
You both play soo amazingly!! LOL
i've watched this for the like 5th time HAHA XD
yaingy 3 years ago
can you please send me the piano sheet? please...
solventlind 3 years ago
awesome. do you have the name of the piece or the piano sheets you could send me?
brittaaanyl0ve 3 years ago
best
philochampion 3 years ago
Very nicely done! Do you happen to have the sheet music of this, or the name of the piece?
fqwu 3 years ago
can i get the sheet
ssyang911 3 years ago
what is this song called?
EMMiiSHERE 3 years ago
my gosh. =.= so nice. do you have the score?
kevinashi 3 years ago
very very nice
iamthepro 3 years ago
yo man where can i get the sheet music for this song?! plz plz plz =]
cowcloud927 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
what is the song called?
MagicPiano22 3 years ago
nice job guys keep going!
DrFrakenstein 3 years ago 2