I love both versions, right now i'm digging on this one since it's very upbeat but you can still feel the raw and at times dark emotions, goddamn lou reed how do you do it
The drumming by Steve Yule (Doug's bro, filling up for a pregnant Moe) gives a real rock'n roll feel to the song and in fairness to the all Loaded album.
yeah fool,look atthe name "Velevet Underground" was long before Lou babe went solo with the help of a one Mr bowie.....who happen to write allhis songs :)
LOL, you got so mad that you resorted to profanity and made a further fool of yourself. And you think I was picking on your grammar? HA! Google misnomer you foul mouthed wretch.
You're entitled to your "opinions" but don't go confusing them for facts, to correct you would of used up too much space, but you are but a simple philistine and I forgive you for your puerile outburst. As I said in my original post 'Lrn2 Rock n' Roll history my friend'.
"but by the mid seventies reed, bowie, and iggy were in a sort of musical affair"
You aren't even sure of the bullshit you spew forth from your own keyboard, but here, I'll fix it for you. This musical threesome you envision never actually existed OK? Yes Lou and Iggy share a connection in that Bowie worked with them both in varying degrees. But that's where the connection ends. They never worked together or shared a 'musical affair' as a threesome. Do some research, moron. Kthxbai.
"but the fact is since day one lou reed wanted the band to hit it big".
That is bullshit as well but you attempt to state it as 'fact'. Reed was not chasing fame from day one, if he was why did he walk out on the Velvets when they were at the precipice of being commercially successful in 1970 to work as a typist for an entire year? He even stated years later that he saw the commercial direction they were headed in and did not like it. Keep your erroneous comments to yourself.
In September of '68 Cale was pushed out of the group by Lou Reed in collusion with new manager, Steve Sesnick.
Sesnick was the one who pushed for commercial success in the later years and for Reed to write more accessible material. If Reed was so obsessed with fame he would've been writing bubblegum from day one. Not recording songs about drugs and sadomasochism. Seriously. Even in his solo years he attempted to sabotage his own career in response to the fame he was garnering.
if reed had wanted to he would have been in the position to turn straight to mainstream after "transformer". but he recorded "berlin". and later on "metal machine music". but that was not his aim. he wanted do do the records he wanted do create.
to me: a lot of good stuff, a lot of bad stuff. but never focused on commerzial aspects after transformer. same with cale (who i prefere more). the velvets changed my life in 1974 when i was sixteen.
OK, you are backing my original argument. Reed in fact was more consumed by his drive for making an artistic statement, than seeking fame and adulation. In the beginning of the velvets anyway. After his masterpiece Berlin had tanked, he released an album (Sally Can't dance) that he gave the barest of effort to. It did well commercially and in disgust he backed it by releasing one of the most perverse albums ever released in Metal Machine Music.
Lol, I proved you wrong and exposed you for the foul mouthed ignoramus that you truly are. Keep getting mad and spitting profanity at me, don't faze me sugar.
You still stand by your imaginary musical trinity. But here, give me a single example of Iggy Pop working with Reed in the 70's. It never happened. Not then or ever.
I initially thought you were being facetious, but if you are serious then LOL. Serious Business.
In a way I'm so happy that the Velvets were never able to break into the mainstream, because their charm has to do with the fact that they never did, and makes their already top notch recordings just a little more memorable, and, much like Lou himself, would have probably fallen into the pop music scene, being more concerned with selling records than making kickass music, even though LOADED was kind of a sell out album, it's great because in a way it never sold out. VU forever
@CAR18MEN prefer the lou solo one seen him do it 3 years ago with a big choir and band when he toured the berlin album and done this as an oncour still good this one i heard this one first but with bowie on productoin and backing vocals on transformer just shades it for me
Sorry to be a nitpicker but why is Nico on the picture? She has never been part of the V.U., just a guest on the first album and this cover is an outtake of the Loaded session long after the banana album.
i like the transformer version better. it seems more evocative of a mysterious space voi d. its calmer and lounge singer. this version is cool too i just prefer the transformer one.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
The transformer version sucks compared to this one. Why Lou always had to sing stuff so weird when he went solo I'll never know. Don't even get me started on the stupid production too
I don't think the Transformer version sucks, I think Transformer is a pretty classic album. And while I do think Lou has made some odd career choices in order to purposefully avoid public and critical recognition, I think he's had a pretty great career when you look at it as a whole.
BUT, that being said, I do think this version is superior to the Transformer one. The simpler production and the guitar riff is too good.
i think the best songs written are ones that make me want to cry and dance at the same time, so i completely agree. its a lot harder to capture such varying emotions in one sound
Joder!! Qué gozada descubrir este anillo de oro, dormido y olvidado dentro de un vaso de deliciosa cerveza negra. No me voy del bar, qué siga la música :-D Amazing discovery!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
this version is a great discovery for me. I think Lou improved this version and the lyrics when he did it on transformer.. but the youthfulness and rawness of this version bears a close listen.
i honestly believe that had this song been released on loaded velvet underground would still be a band today one of my favorite songs of all time...it's insane how catchy and pretty this song is way better than lous version
Man!!!! This versions sounds nice!! made me feel dancing!!! If i talked to Lou Reed or any member from the VU!! why they couldn't realese this song!!! I'll think this song will impact the rock momment!! including to the beatles!!! in my vision!! this sounds like "DA Shiznit!!! man" Love This song and VU!!!
manic!
bobbycormier 1 day ago
I like the feeling of velvet.
browneydgirl4924 1 week ago
I love both versions, right now i'm digging on this one since it's very upbeat but you can still feel the raw and at times dark emotions, goddamn lou reed how do you do it
enthnd03 2 months ago
Comment removed
123jsbach 2 months ago
After hearing this, I've always switched out "Harry, Mark and John" with "Winkin, Blinkin and Nod."
SonofMrPeanut 2 months ago 4
i'll take reed's version
drthess 2 months ago
Loaded session.
The drumming by Steve Yule (Doug's bro, filling up for a pregnant Moe) gives a real rock'n roll feel to the song and in fairness to the all Loaded album.
Doo-wop Lou is playing along.
Pure enjoyment!
nicorigo 3 months ago
yay much livelier, much better!!! :) in my opinion :)
fuckamericanidiot 4 months ago
I wish Lou reed and the band never broke up they could've gotten legendary
bibimyunn 4 months ago
@bibimyunn they are legendary
connorbrowne 2 months ago
Doesn't Mo Tucker look so out of place?
angryhandjob 4 months ago
@angryhandjob He looks baked..
harmike17 4 months ago
@harmike17 Lol, Moe is a girl.
BasementBeginnings 4 months ago
tuning your guitar was so not done back then ;-)
rectorsulk 5 months ago
this is better than the transformer version and if you think otherwise well i dont fucking care
siarung 5 months ago 3
What's the name of the guy on the top left?
Lauraloli1 5 months ago
@Lauraloli1 It's John Cale.
TenWhoWereTaken 4 months ago
new york > berlin
freudastaire 7 months ago
I hate to say this but I never used to like T.V.U or this song. It really grows on you though. I know it's a classic!
I really like this version of it............it's great.
pixelmike 7 months ago
In the Box Set booklet Reed says he regrets the "Winkin, Blink, and Nod" lyrics. Thought that was funny
TheIsay21 8 months ago
i prefere this to the Lou version couse this is more enthralling,great rock n roll..Nico is astonishing......
mymindourdream 8 months ago
Makes me want to run naked when I hear this song.
TheRaphaelmc 8 months ago
@TheRaphaelmc So says a balding, beer-bellied 45 year old man...
laser325 7 months ago
I feel better knowing that even Lou Reed changes his lyrics to his songs. I always feel like a hack when i change lyrics to song ive written.
TheBalloonHoax 9 months ago
this one is better than lou's in my opinion. but it would have been even better if Bowie had done backing vocals on it.
elephantstone222 9 months ago 2
yeah fool,look atthe name "Velevet Underground" was long before Lou babe went solo with the help of a one Mr bowie.....who happen to write allhis songs :)
MrPlayfulxxx 9 months ago
1 faggot. JUST 1 FAGGOT FUCKED THIS UP.
ublec15 10 months ago
@ublec15 make that two for annoying me (but this song rocks anyways so who cares)
sulmagnificent 10 months ago
@sulmagnificent ok?..
ublec15 10 months ago
I'm gonna play that again
pablosonfire 10 months ago
Was anyone aware Porno for Pyros did a version?
jmorris724 11 months ago
EFFING HELL this beats the sh it outta the transformer version
ganjavulture 11 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Reed's version is better but this is fantastic
passiveMenis 1 year ago
Comment removed
passiveMenis 1 year ago
Great bass-playing in this version. Walter Powers, right?
mussman717word 1 year ago
@mussman717word I think its Doung Yule
nicorigo 10 months ago
geez theres just something about 60s music that gets me. no decade will ever beat the 60s .
CrapLode66 1 year ago 17
@CrapLode66 lol this song was recorded in 1970.
aaasamaaa 2 months ago
Comment removed
dirtynuke 1 year ago
@dirtynuke
Your argument is invalid. Lrn2 Rock n' Roll history my friend.
But wait, you were trying to be funny right?
Sorry but you failed. Failed good and hard.
Enjoy your fail, bro.
ConnieLynchitz 10 months ago
Comment removed
dirtynuke 10 months ago
@dirtynuke
You're an idiot.
So many misnomers in your post it's laughable.
ConnieLynchitz 10 months ago
Comment removed
dirtynuke 10 months ago
@dirtynuke
LOL, you got so mad that you resorted to profanity and made a further fool of yourself. And you think I was picking on your grammar? HA! Google misnomer you foul mouthed wretch.
You're entitled to your "opinions" but don't go confusing them for facts, to correct you would of used up too much space, but you are but a simple philistine and I forgive you for your puerile outburst. As I said in my original post 'Lrn2 Rock n' Roll history my friend'.
ConnieLynchitz 10 months ago
Comment removed
dirtynuke 10 months ago
@dirtynuke
"but by the mid seventies reed, bowie, and iggy were in a sort of musical affair"
You aren't even sure of the bullshit you spew forth from your own keyboard, but here, I'll fix it for you. This musical threesome you envision never actually existed OK? Yes Lou and Iggy share a connection in that Bowie worked with them both in varying degrees. But that's where the connection ends. They never worked together or shared a 'musical affair' as a threesome. Do some research, moron. Kthxbai.
ConnieLynchitz 10 months ago
Comment removed
dirtynuke 10 months ago
@dirtynuke
"but the fact is since day one lou reed wanted the band to hit it big".
That is bullshit as well but you attempt to state it as 'fact'. Reed was not chasing fame from day one, if he was why did he walk out on the Velvets when they were at the precipice of being commercially successful in 1970 to work as a typist for an entire year? He even stated years later that he saw the commercial direction they were headed in and did not like it. Keep your erroneous comments to yourself.
ConnieLynchitz 10 months ago
Comment removed
dirtynuke 10 months ago
@dirtynuke
In September of '68 Cale was pushed out of the group by Lou Reed in collusion with new manager, Steve Sesnick.
Sesnick was the one who pushed for commercial success in the later years and for Reed to write more accessible material. If Reed was so obsessed with fame he would've been writing bubblegum from day one. Not recording songs about drugs and sadomasochism. Seriously. Even in his solo years he attempted to sabotage his own career in response to the fame he was garnering.
ConnieLynchitz 10 months ago
Comment removed
dirtynuke 9 months ago
@dirtynuke
Keep changing your argument sweetie. It makes your original post oh so insignificant.
ConnieLynchitz 9 months ago
Comment removed
dirtynuke 9 months ago
Comment removed
dirtynuke 9 months ago
Comment removed
dirtynuke 9 months ago
@dirtynuke
I don't phase you, yet you just made three long winded posts directed at me with a whole lot of words that mean absolutely nothing.
You seem vexed, are you mad bro?
ConnieLynchitz 9 months ago
Comment removed
dirtynuke 9 months ago
@dirtynuke dude its pretty obvious that he does phase you lmfao 3 long posts that mean nothing
watever4201 8 months ago
@watever4201 @dirtynuke @ConnieLynchitz Please please please! FAZED, dammit, not "phased".
Okay, carry on.
liberal2nSF 8 months ago
@liberal2nSF lmfao!
watever4201 8 months ago
@ConnieLynchitz
if reed had wanted to he would have been in the position to turn straight to mainstream after "transformer". but he recorded "berlin". and later on "metal machine music". but that was not his aim. he wanted do do the records he wanted do create.
to me: a lot of good stuff, a lot of bad stuff. but never focused on commerzial aspects after transformer. same with cale (who i prefere more). the velvets changed my life in 1974 when i was sixteen.
kuechenuschi 9 months ago
@kuechenuschi
OK, you are backing my original argument. Reed in fact was more consumed by his drive for making an artistic statement, than seeking fame and adulation. In the beginning of the velvets anyway. After his masterpiece Berlin had tanked, he released an album (Sally Can't dance) that he gave the barest of effort to. It did well commercially and in disgust he backed it by releasing one of the most perverse albums ever released in Metal Machine Music.
ConnieLynchitz 9 months ago
Comment removed
dirtynuke 10 months ago
Comment removed
dirtynuke 10 months ago
Comment removed
dirtynuke 10 months ago
Comment removed
dirtynuke 10 months ago
@dirtynuke
Lol, I proved you wrong and exposed you for the foul mouthed ignoramus that you truly are. Keep getting mad and spitting profanity at me, don't faze me sugar.
You still stand by your imaginary musical trinity. But here, give me a single example of Iggy Pop working with Reed in the 70's. It never happened. Not then or ever.
I initially thought you were being facetious, but if you are serious then LOL. Serious Business.
ConnieLynchitz 10 months ago
This idea of slagging Lou Reed's solo stuff because it's not 'The Velvet Undergound' is completely asinine.
lundehund44 1 year ago 19
this is gay
proudfoot25 1 year ago
a night with lou reed live version is nice too
Locust1313 1 year ago
this song is perfect.
tacStar253 1 year ago
The 'Transformer' song is much worse than this. That is, unless you like commercial crap.
louiseduvee 1 year ago
@louiseduvee Which might be a valid argument if the transformer version didn't have a certain man named David Bowie making adorable "Bom bom bom"s.
justnicknet 1 year ago
@justnicknet Well, Mr. Bowie's influence was certainly one of the things I hate about Transformer, although I love Mr. Bowie's own music.
louiseduvee 1 year ago
This is way better than the one on Transformer
michigangirl1994 1 year ago
Bong Bong Bong
Sate-lliiiiite, Ah Aaah, Oh o o o
sorry just filling in for Bowie
mimesis6mime 1 year ago 3
This version is sooo great. I love the Solo version of Reed's but the more I listen to this version the more I start to favour it.
Beatmyguest001 1 year ago
I love both versions so much.. :O <3
PeachyLovesYou 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
what a terrible voice
purple2275 1 year ago
In a way I'm so happy that the Velvets were never able to break into the mainstream, because their charm has to do with the fact that they never did, and makes their already top notch recordings just a little more memorable, and, much like Lou himself, would have probably fallen into the pop music scene, being more concerned with selling records than making kickass music, even though LOADED was kind of a sell out album, it's great because in a way it never sold out. VU forever
DaRandom90 1 year ago
Awesome song.
stoprejectingmynames 1 year ago
not as good as transformer's version in my opinion, but still great
howard22 1 year ago
Who is this strange garage band stealing songs from Reed?
just kidding
NicoDraak74 1 year ago
better than reed's solo
DaRandom90 1 year ago
I love both. <3 Lou is a genius either way.
BribaLovesClassics 1 year ago
This is superb, but the Transformer version is sublime.
gercasty 1 year ago
Bowie helped make Lou's solo version more pop-friendly and modern but it can't beat that old 60's charm.
lemonlorry 1 year ago 30
@lemonlorry i find lou's version a bit of a drag, i love this! seriously a revelation for me :)
fuckamericanidiot 4 months ago
@lemonlorry Exactly what I wanted to say only not about the Bowie part didn't know that, fun to know
lunasco23 4 months ago
@lemonlorry Yeah, "modern" as in 1972. Haha.
FetaCheese222 3 months ago
i think i like this version more than Reed's original.
CAR18MEN 2 years ago 25
Actually this one was recorded earlier than Reed's version!
WaldoJeffers25 2 years ago 43
@WaldoJeffers25 nice name
a1stooge 1 year ago
@CAR18MEN It is still a lou reed song. He Wrote it and sang it. This is just the first version. I like the 2nd better though.
bkalms1 1 year ago
@CAR18MEN prefer the lou solo one seen him do it 3 years ago with a big choir and band when he toured the berlin album and done this as an oncour still good this one i heard this one first but with bowie on productoin and backing vocals on transformer just shades it for me
GAREMPOTS 8 months ago
@CAR18MEN i agree. i also like the vu version of andy's chest.
soulthrasher9 5 months ago
I got the record 'Peel slowly and see' and this isn't the version i got! Will post it tho..
dergan1471471 2 years ago
I can say which version I like better. They're both great!
allycatten 2 years ago
I prefer this version over the one off Transformer.
askl23 2 years ago 2
Sorry to be a nitpicker but why is Nico on the picture? She has never been part of the V.U., just a guest on the first album and this cover is an outtake of the Loaded session long after the banana album.
That's said I really like this version.
nicorigo 2 years ago
A lot of people just lump her in as member of the band because her name is in the title of their debut album.
beepmotherfuckerbeep 2 years ago
Exactly.
sandyjimenez1 2 years ago
Anyone know where I can download an mp3 of this?
WILLOW5033 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This isn't a VU song. It's just a Lou Reed song.
subsamadhi 2 years ago
it was recorded with VU originally
frankc91 2 years ago 4
It wasn't released by VU in an album, but they recorded it and it appears on Peel Slowly and See.
Lou later recorded his own solo version, in Transformer
WaldoJeffers25 2 years ago 11
wouldn't that make it a Lou Reed song nonetheless? If they never released it as their own single? Just a thought.
subsamadhi 2 years ago
That would make 90% of VU released songs, Lou's songs, cause he wrote most of it.
WaldoJeffers25 2 years ago 12
@subsamadhi Uh, no.
casualinsomniac 5 months ago
@subsamadhi WHAAAAAT!?!?!? Can't you hear the twisty guitar and Lou's false but true voice? Of course this is the blooming Velvet Underground.
TheAloich 1 year ago
One of the best songs of all time.....but,,,,V.U. did too many 'best songs' to even remember. Hehe. Thanks for posting. 5 ***** and faved.
NoRosesForMe 2 years ago
soooooooooo good
makes me so happy :)))
Heronjim 2 years ago 4
this version kicks ass.
Sigmundfraud 2 years ago 4
this is a great VU song. Transformer version is a classic, Bowie's vocals, but it is sad nobody mention Mick Ronson piano, it's awesome!
h34th3n 2 years ago 9
transformer version is better produced,very nice and perfect david's vocals after break.... BUT i prefer this one, its pure and solid emotion! ;)
sarwae88 2 years ago 2
I totally agree with you...Bowie's vocals really make the Transformer version great though
cubyman23 2 years ago 4
i like the transformer version better. it seems more evocative of a mysterious space voi d. its calmer and lounge singer. this version is cool too i just prefer the transformer one.
JonathanHancock 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
This song is just great
OzzieFreedom1 2 years ago 3
Gypsy, Cambot, Crow and Tom Servo like the solo version better.
pinworms70 2 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
The transformer version sucks compared to this one. Why Lou always had to sing stuff so weird when he went solo I'll never know. Don't even get me started on the stupid production too
JustinV84 2 years ago
I don't think the Transformer version sucks, I think Transformer is a pretty classic album. And while I do think Lou has made some odd career choices in order to purposefully avoid public and critical recognition, I think he's had a pretty great career when you look at it as a whole.
BUT, that being said, I do think this version is superior to the Transformer one. The simpler production and the guitar riff is too good.
ZombieHipHop2345 2 years ago
balls, classic
priceuponreturn 2 years ago
I prefer this version, its just so happy and energetic :D
lageregal 2 years ago 5
This version is cool mostly because of the fact that it is basically a beta version of the vastly superior final product on Transformer.
Blackson187 2 years ago 4
im addicted to this version
h0tpoop 2 years ago
I like the raw sound of this one but I love the transformer version too!
j1mcr0w 2 years ago
I don't like it as much as the Transformer version. I like how... down the other version is. Makes me sad, and kinda happy at the same time.
Still a great song in all forms. >_>
Ikzai 2 years ago
i think the best songs written are ones that make me want to cry and dance at the same time, so i completely agree. its a lot harder to capture such varying emotions in one sound
nickypeeps 2 years ago
Joder!! Qué gozada descubrir este anillo de oro, dormido y olvidado dentro de un vaso de deliciosa cerveza negra. No me voy del bar, qué siga la música :-D Amazing discovery!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Virginiaotis 2 years ago
this version is a great discovery for me. I think Lou improved this version and the lyrics when he did it on transformer.. but the youthfulness and rawness of this version bears a close listen.
hopturtle 3 years ago
cam eats monkey poo all day and night yeaaaah
gentleman118 3 years ago
I never lisened this version. It´s good, but the other one (the one with bowie in the backround vocals) is much better.
crolesco 3 years ago
nico just butchered half of the velvet underground ablum
hisuperman 3 years ago
I like this version better but I like the line "Harry, Mark, and John" better than "To winkin, blinkin and nod".
EMinorRant 3 years ago 2
this is the best version of this song, and now i feel good :)
bennunez73 3 years ago 2
this version is the best
pikapoka17 3 years ago 3
I don't think it's the best version; but what a find, I never knew that Lou did it first with the Velvet Underground. Cool!
wolverine37x 3 years ago
This isn't the exact version from 'Fully Loaded', is it? Oh well, makes little difference.
PhiloCentinel 3 years ago 2
i honestly believe that had this song been released on loaded velvet underground would still be a band today one of my favorite songs of all time...it's insane how catchy and pretty this song is way better than lous version
vlietvandon 3 years ago
Man!!!! This versions sounds nice!! made me feel dancing!!! If i talked to Lou Reed or any member from the VU!! why they couldn't realese this song!!! I'll think this song will impact the rock momment!! including to the beatles!!! in my vision!! this sounds like "DA Shiznit!!! man" Love This song and VU!!!
FernyBass007 3 years ago
its gold,Waldo/jerry, GOLD !!!
schaefersmann 3 years ago
It's awesome, but the lyrics are fairly unpolished. Lou admits this himself.
Blackson187 3 years ago
Agreed - not just the lyrics though - the version from Lou Reed is much crisper and more disciplined.
nblumer 3 years ago
great version......... thanks for sharing
bxnyc99 3 years ago
wow, id heard they did a version b4 lou did it on his one. its great!!
gentleman118 3 years ago
favorite vu song...you don't know how many times i've listend to this
vlietvandon 3 years ago
Amazing. i think I like this version better than the Lou version. Thank you.
Nawap24 3 years ago
version très fun super!
gombertabcdefg 3 years ago
Thanks! I've been looking for this, better than the Lou Reed solo version.
Fastmedic 3 years ago