No one seems to ever be able to nail this Choir'ed theme exect Williams himself. There's something about it that no other Conducted and choir can get right. It's just a tribute to Mr. Johnny Williams I suppose.
'Duel of the Fates' is just one of those hard tracks and recording's that only John Williams himself seems to get right. Noone else seems to be able to pull it off properly.
This can't be John Williams, he puts passion into his music. This symphonic band does not have the passion John Williams put into his fellow musicians.
@DevonHartsalla The irony is that John Williams stole most of his ideas from classical pieces of music, true that Mr. Williams film scores are some of the most epic, but still classical pieces in a different key.
I don't think it was bad. Just at the beginning the chorus sounds as if they were uncomfortable with the song. The rest of the song is good in my opinion.
WTF was that....my high school chorus did this song and it was definately ten times better than that...and in tune! OMG this people should never sing again!
WHOA! This video is an optical illusion! At the start it looked like I was watching from the left side of the audience, then realized halfway through it was filmed from the right side!
Please go to watch, rate and comment the 4 rearrangements for 3 violines of Star Wars themes (Main Title, Flag Parade, Duel of Fates and Imperial March) by searching :
instrumentally perfect but the vocals were a bit iffy, one guy had a really powerfull voice that he wasnt controlling and just overpowerin the rest... not in time as well :\
I think that it´s good, never like the original version cause the tempo it´s quite slow but it´s nice to heard tha live... If the tempo thing it fix the song will be better...
the choir position is all wrong always put the choir behind the orchestra never ever in front,.. the choire is only in the song to build it not star in it
Errr... That's what happen when the classical music world deals with film music. It's not punchy anymore... Not that bad, just pretty inunteresting once you've heard the original.
I agree woth the critic of Famicom4.. but limiting to the a cappella opening. In the rest of piece the choir was ok and gave a great energy: I attended the concert live and the audience was enthusiastic especially on this piece. Sure the Orchestra can work to make the concert better but this was the 1st such event in Italy and such events need to be encouraged. See this HQ official video of Imperial March from same concert on channel OrchFilarmonicaRoma
WTF? Horrible! Giving it such a lyric feel was a terrible mistake. It must be everything but operistic. Besides, the chorus is not very accurate in terms of pitch.
this is slightly too slow
Zippyd00da132 1 week ago
if orchestras played stuff like this instead off bach etc, i would actually pay to listen.
Troforso 3 months ago
What a fantastic job by the conductor! I loved this. Great energy off of the orchstra.
mrJinsudbury 5 months ago
PRACTICE!
Briksil 8 months ago
59 people didnt get chills from such epic orchestry
oakster777 10 months ago
ma che figata cazzo, com'è che a milano non ne fanno?
NaClO3 11 months ago
lyris is sanskrit hinduism and budist langued
iceburg008 11 months ago
JediOutcasts FanClub? HAHAHAHA!!!!! I love that!
Ampersandra 1 year ago
lol its not live right now XD
90Blakey 1 year ago
the choir is way too slow.... and this score is supposed to sound terrifying... this sounds just as terrifying as a cute little bunny...
bananaficator 1 year ago
dope
askerkaca 1 year ago
великолепно!
Jarekyandexru 1 year ago
0:04 NIIIIIICE engine sound you have here @_@
URIZHEY 1 year ago
'Duel of the Fates' seems to be a theme that really no one can truley perform but Williams himself.
jayce79 1 year ago
baaaaaddd choir
Droideka133 1 year ago
@Droideka133
No one seems to ever be able to nail this Choir'ed theme exect Williams himself. There's something about it that no other Conducted and choir can get right. It's just a tribute to Mr. Johnny Williams I suppose.
jayce79 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
'Duel of the Fates' is just one of those hard tracks and recording's that only John Williams himself seems to get right. Noone else seems to be able to pull it off properly.
jayce79 2 years ago
corn oooooonnn the cooooob!!!
superjam18 2 years ago
@superjam18 I always say "Put oooonnn DARTH MAUUUULLL!" I really dont know what that's supposed to mean though
TelenStar 1 year ago
Comment removed
jayce79 2 years ago
i think john wilems is a gensies
sholomcitrin 2 years ago 3
Yes . . . Yes he is.
jayce79 2 years ago
it's just a poor recordin
chefkhalipha 2 years ago
dont u just love muusic
1122smc 2 years ago
it's obviously not the same as the originial.. but it's still good!
Sillygoose241 2 years ago
I see that the conductor is the guy from Assassin's Creed 2. =P
atomiceraser 2 years ago
This just wasn't up to par.
Don't know if the recording was bad or the orchestra's tempo was off
tsoe2001 2 years ago
both
DeltaSquad451 2 years ago
This is a lot slower than the original.
AceOfSpades066 2 years ago 3
Sound quality is terrible.
3y3raven 2 years ago
This can't be John Williams, he puts passion into his music. This symphonic band does not have the passion John Williams put into his fellow musicians.
JL121296 2 years ago 9
this isn't like john williams
marcohotmai 2 years ago 5
No one should copy George Lucas or John Williams.
All the millions of dollars invested into the Star Wars franchise, it is a disgrace to Star Wars cinema!
DevonHartsalla 2 years ago 32
Not just because of the millions of dollars, but because there's a lot of work and passion put into this franchise.
BeatPeet 2 years ago
@DevonHartsalla The irony is that John Williams stole most of his ideas from classical pieces of music, true that Mr. Williams film scores are some of the most epic, but still classical pieces in a different key.
ItachiUchiha2010 1 year ago
@DevonHartsalla
This is kinda dumb, THIS IS John Williams Orchestra, they worked with him.
Sponsored by Lucas.
thedarkflowkiller 1 year ago
@DevonHartsalla george lucas isn't a composer =P
TheRollerhockeypro 1 year ago
what was this a middle school?
maxpower978 2 years ago 3
chorus is to slow and so is the beat..i give a thumbs down
babygal2lovu 2 years ago 25
The chorus sounds horrable!! >:O
SuperQuack123 2 years ago 7
that concludes siths don't eat pastas :)
X2T2X 2 years ago
wtH! the conductor is like holding the lightsabre! swing around like that!
gunz4show 2 years ago 5
haha lol funny
LaughingChinchilla 2 years ago 2
The chorus lyrics are supposed to be pronounced with HARD, accentuated consonants. it's been pronounced too soft here. But the orchestra is good.
zoltan902 2 years ago 5
It's like they're singing the funeral of Darth Maul or something
dunvirzelani 2 years ago 9
Darth Maul had no funeral. That was Qui-Gon's.
seamuscleary 2 years ago
I KNOW. That's the POINT.
dunvirzelani 2 years ago 5
I agree, the chior is off, but the instruments sound awsome!
dakoata121212 2 years ago 6
WAY of they sag as if they were doing opera.
SGC1fan 2 years ago
sonds sooo real
mariotttttttt 2 years ago
I think it was pretty good.
MusicalReview86 2 years ago
I don't think it was bad. Just at the beginning the chorus sounds as if they were uncomfortable with the song. The rest of the song is good in my opinion.
TheodenN 2 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
ITALY SUCKS !!!
schinkenmantheo 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
italy sucks
mattstaropoli 2 years ago
out of tune chorus and the tempo wasnt energetic enough!
zekew32394 2 years ago 2
too sloow.
nuttysolos 2 years ago 5
i had to play this song last year in band. its a fun piece to play.=]
jfleming14 2 years ago
Sorry, i have to agree. its out of tune.
JBaxley08 2 years ago 2
WTF was that....my high school chorus did this song and it was definately ten times better than that...and in tune! OMG this people should never sing again!
Squirtmcg 2 years ago
Tone deaf people D:
Astrosimi 2 years ago
jango 6 italiano?
VainerHydra 3 years ago
Esatto.
JANGO82 3 years ago
bella sai se in giro su youtube ci sono i video dell'orchestra dove suonano "across the star"? intendo la colonna sonora di anakin e padme
VainerHydra 3 years ago
Certo, anche quella era presente al concerto, purtroppo il mio Nokia non aveva grande memoria e non sono riuscita a registrarla.
JANGO82 3 years ago
grande ma dove li fanno ste orchestrate?
VainerHydra 3 years ago
Questa era a Roma.
JANGO82 2 years ago
either the camera's sound sucks or the hall had vary bad acoustics!!!!
the song was ruined!
6changoman6 3 years ago
Yeah, I couldn't agree more. The choir sounds like it was out of tune.
TommyIrianto 2 years ago
wth?
ElBarto1347 3 years ago
Nice effort. What's with the tempo?
yoshtamz 3 years ago
WHOA! This video is an optical illusion! At the start it looked like I was watching from the left side of the audience, then realized halfway through it was filmed from the right side!
Chumbukkit 3 years ago 3
Or it's possible he filmed from the middle and looks like he's filming from the sides because of the conductor's position...just a thought.
lifesaver011 3 years ago 3
thats cool, i can see that
MichiganWolvs 3 years ago
my favorite star wars songs:
this song and battle of the heros both together my favorite equally. then the theme.
legorocks3 3 years ago 2
This has been flagged as spam show
Hello...
Please go to watch, rate and comment the 4 rearrangements for 3 violines of Star Wars themes (Main Title, Flag Parade, Duel of Fates and Imperial March) by searching :
star wars 3 violines
It's quite interesting =p
TheMercadian 3 years ago
3:52 is my farvorite part
Iowa789101112 3 years ago
defintely. it's used in the movies as the most dramatic scene :- ))
xstingrayx 3 years ago
REPLICA QUESTA DOMENICA (26 OTTOBRE) a CITTA' DI CASTELLO (PG) con due NUOVI cori, ancora musica dai 6 episodi (con nuovi brani) e fans in costume.
Ero l'altr'anno al concerto di Roma da cui è stato tratto questo video, e vado alla replica, ne vale la pena anche se vengo da un'altra città.
Info sul sito dell'orchestra, raggiungibile dal channel OrchFilarmonicaRoma. I posti vanno a ruba.
Sul mio channel, playlist con tutti i video del concerto di Roma.
urbania70 3 years ago
lol, corn on the cob
NOSYPOWER 3 years ago
cyborg jesus, TOTAL CEREAL
dangeurs 3 years ago
hazlo bien... o no lo hagas ¬¬
Berekberek 3 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Corn on the Cob!!!
Greggorion 3 years ago
how terrible is that singing?
dan93iel92 3 years ago 4
instrumentally perfect but the vocals were a bit iffy, one guy had a really powerfull voice that he wasnt controlling and just overpowerin the rest... not in time as well :\
mepwnu 3 years ago 3
omfg! i love plaing the baritone b.c. part on this song!!!!
Phamsterz 3 years ago
Questa canzone mi mette i brividi... favolosa!
TRamp94 3 years ago
love the chorus and nice very nicely played
Kahn619 3 years ago
lol the song XD
tubiste11 3 years ago
aaaa. it don't sound bery good, but nice try
gladiussecus 3 years ago
Listen closly to the lyrics..."Corn onnnnn, the cob!!"
ChristianDavis629 3 years ago
rofl c o n t c
ro332 3 years ago
ci,ci,ci!beautiful!
nutterbudder3000 3 years ago
all bueno
Sebcarr21 3 years ago
not a good recording :(
not good sound i mean!
nice job anyway!
p4n0sgr 3 years ago
the voices at the begining do not match ok, men's with women's i mean, and also ,they go too slow.
25500 3 years ago 4
ur making it sound like its his fault the voices aren't rite..
gooood one buddyy
Chippychops7 3 years ago
nice!
miramesolo 3 years ago
Ciò è grande! Desidero che la fascia alla nostra scuola potrebbe giocare buon quanto questa fascia.
Starwors123456 3 years ago
I love the song, but is it just me or does the angelic vocalizing sound like gibberish?
simpsonman956 3 years ago 5
a bit ya maybe this was a pre-production
philabb 3 years ago
¿con que programa haces esa animaciones?
Orellanascout15 3 years ago
This is powerful.
Jowgen 3 years ago
la vinotinto futbol bueno
vascovem 3 years ago
esta muy bueno vinotinto futbol vamos
vascovem 3 years ago
me gusta
lordangel10 3 years ago
Sencillamente espectacular
Inmorula 3 years ago
What a horrible recording...
knightablaze 3 years ago
It wasnt bad, I would have loved to see it live. But at the same time I agree that the tempo is a bit slow in the beginning.
fvidvandre 4 years ago
I think that it´s good, never like the original version cause the tempo it´s quite slow but it´s nice to heard tha live... If the tempo thing it fix the song will be better...
pedroafontanive 4 years ago
well don't the orignal in the movie went though tons of editting and screening before it went into the movie
BECKDADDY 4 years ago
the choir position is all wrong always put the choir behind the orchestra never ever in front,.. the choire is only in the song to build it not star in it
filathor 4 years ago 6
me and my fello martial artists did a demo timed to this song it was epic!!
halfdogderek 4 years ago
Errr... That's what happen when the classical music world deals with film music. It's not punchy anymore... Not that bad, just pretty inunteresting once you've heard the original.
Eldween 4 years ago
I agree woth the critic of Famicom4.. but limiting to the a cappella opening. In the rest of piece the choir was ok and gave a great energy: I attended the concert live and the audience was enthusiastic especially on this piece. Sure the Orchestra can work to make the concert better but this was the 1st such event in Italy and such events need to be encouraged. See this HQ official video of Imperial March from same concert on channel OrchFilarmonicaRoma
urbania70 4 years ago
is that george lucas to your right xDDDDDD
Otty2Hotty 4 years ago
He really looks like George Lucas. huahuahauhauhuauahauhsuha
BrunoM321 4 years ago
I forgot: too much vibrato in their voices. I guess they cannot distinguish between Aida and Star Wars
Famicom4 4 years ago 2
WTF? Horrible! Giving it such a lyric feel was a terrible mistake. It must be everything but operistic. Besides, the chorus is not very accurate in terms of pitch.
Famicom4 4 years ago
true. the chords are a little off. the instrumentals are good, though. i've probably heard this song over 200 times. mistakes are easy to find.
evilottojr 4 years ago
Great video.
thelostduck 4 years ago
Io c'ero! I was there!
This is the best track of the concert: the live choir let the midichlorian feel inside me!
urbania70 4 years ago