Mama I'm a Big Girl Now (Broadway on Broadway '06)

[MUSiCiSMYS0UL1]

Dianna at 3:10 :)

[Elysia1979]

okkkk

?

[iskoGomez]

haylie duff! <3

[Reganniccole]

i wish the whole Broadway show was online.

[thederekone]

To the camera person - Amazing, I think you already saw this show because you moved to who was singing so quickly! :)

To the music - wow, I really love this song, I don't think I head this cast sing it before. I like it, but Diana DeGarmo IS THE BEST.

Ensemble, so nice. I wish you guys had a bigger part than just standing there. Without you guys the song wouldn't feel so full. :(

[demiselenafan1993]

Haha... Oh man... Diana was so funny as Penny. I am so glad I got to see her in this show.

[deemsandjeems]

haylie is the best !

[omgitsmichelle]

great performance!! and just for everyone's knowlege...the singers change their voices to a certain pitch's for their solo's in this performance as you can tell, that is not really how they sound when they sing for real including Haylie who has a fantastic voice.

[JBrox1234]

This is so awesome!!! Great Job

[elijahrocks101]

thanx 4 posting!!

[theflintstones16]

was michelle dowdy the understudy for shannon durig in 2006

[alexreview1234]

yes she was

[xxHEYitsKathyxx]

i love haylie and diana my fave ppl here

[lovelysngr]

is that diana degarmo playing penny?

[hairspraydude1]

Yes.

[CSkittlez291]

im sad it closed :(

[kadukoogecko]

every clip i see of Diana playing this part makes me sadder that i didn't see it live

[UniicasEstrellas]

Tara Macri is Amber in this video?

[paypay305]

No Haylie Duff is

[UniicasEstrellas]

who is amber?

[NEWMAN7689]

y isent there a video of haylie on broadway playing amber lol, when i herd she was doing it back then i was like really casue i never herd her sing, and her " watch me fly" that is my favorite part in the song and she sounded so childish and annoying but i bet her acting was good tho and she pulled it off it just wasent great

[iluvbrdwy771]

i. love. diana.

the end

[j3ss1grl]

i thought haylie did fine, and im not really a fan, but before i knew it was her i wasnt being critital and i thought it was good. i thought (dont shoot me) that diana was overacting in the beginning. whatever. good performance!

[j3ss1grl]

oh but on broadway i thought diana was awesome. i guess without the costumes its different =P

[prinstongirl08]

LOve haylie her voice is bet (:

[ShoGanlover]

Loved how Diana made penny her own!!

No offense, but Haylie...kinda...sucked. She is, in my opinion, no where near Broadway standards...

[MissAlainey1991]

i hear ya;)

[paypay305]

I totally agree with you all the way

[aasjb4ever]

haylie (happy?) sounds like shes trying to emulate her inner laura bell bundy

[MapleMardia]

Diana was amazing.

[rockxandxroll]

I love Penny! She is great!!! I like Haylie`s voice but it wasn`t good. I like Tracy too.

[brandonsmith14]

i agree i hated how Haley sings watch me fly it annoyed me lol

[Samantha1234perfect]

its spelt H-A-Y-L-I-E by the way

[elphielover247]

Haylie's voice isnt the best.

[punkysk8er522]

is it me or do the people that they choose to play tracy just keep getting thinner and thinner?

[elphielover247]

I know right?!

[brandonsmith14]

damn i hated how Haley sings watch me fly

[broadway160freak]

Who's tracy?

[MyLifeIsAMusical]

Please don't take this offensively, but that IS Haylie Duff's voice, right? I'm just wondering... I've never heard her sing before.

[Samantha1234perfect]

Yes, she's a very good singer really, some say she way better than her sister and that she deserves some credit, instead of people makeing fun of her like most do... but im not saying you personally

[BroadwayKaytay]

i saw haylie as amber and Diana as penny, and Diana is amazing. Haylie was pretty good, but not amazing.

[lobogirl]

quit bashing haylie i like her she's good not as good as lbb but she is good

[berube4life]

i HATE haley's voice it SUX

[brandonsmith14]

lol i wouldnt say suck but it isnt right for Amber

[Samantha1234perfect]

Stop it, her voice is very good and its spelt H-A-Y-L-I-E by the way

[brandonsmith14]

well excuse me HAYLIE'S VOICE STILL SUCKS

[sandorffer]

i saw diana as penny and she was KILLER!!

i cant stand haley duff though. she doesn't even really sing the part

[Samantha1234perfect]

Yes she does, she did awsome in the show, and they wouldnt have cast her if she wasnt good enough for the part, she has a very good voice

and its spelt H-A-Y-L-I-E by the way.

[buffymovies]

it is called stunt casting, every now and then they will cast someone famous or semi-famous to ensure ticket sales stay up. and no if you have heard other ambers you will see haylie is a definite downgrade

[Kjade5860]

laura bell bundy did soo much better.

=D

[tingobingo09]

i think i will have to agree with that. lol.

[buffymovies]

i really liked how diana did it. i however don't like hayley duff's. her voice isn't as good the past ambers, especially not lbb

[mrtattoo125]

You guys know that Diana DeGarmo was on American Idol, and she's just singing like that because she's trying to sound like a dork, right?

[epaves]

Penny is horrible!

[flowerpower70]

Penny's supposed to have sort of a squeaky, high-pitched voice. Diana DeGarmo is actually a really amazing singer; she's just playing the character.

[hairspraydude1]

The way Diana played Penny was very unique. You have to see the entire show in order to understand it and see how Penny evolves from the beginning to end.

[tingobingo09]

noway! penny rocks! she is suppose to sound like that!

[LoveABCsoaps]

Velma- Iasbel Keating

Amber-Haylie Duff

Tracy-Michelle Dowdy

Edna-Blake Hammond

Penny-Diana DeGarmo

Prudy-Lisa Jolley

This was September 2006....haylie left oct 2006, diana left feb 2007...and michelle dowdy (tracy understudy) left..like.a while ago. this is an old video. there have been 3 ambers and 2 pennys since then (counting currents)..LOL. i loved this performance though! Diana is HYSTERICAL.

[htycz]

Haylie Duff? Hilary Duff's sister?

[LoveABCsoaps]

yes.

[JeNNiiNATOR]

whoa... you mean Haylie actually has singing talents?!

[LoveABCsoaps]

LMAO. surprisingly, yes. well...sort of. hahaa. maybe. LOL

[LoveABCsoaps]

Velma- Iasbel Keating

Amber-Haylie Duff

Tracy-Michelle Dowdy

Edna-Blake Hammond

Penny-Diana DeGarmo

Prudy-Lisa Jolley

This was September 2006....haylie left oct 2006, diana left feb 2007...and michelle dowdy (tracy understudy) left..like.a while ago. this is an old video. there have been 3 ambers and 2 pennys since then (counting currents)..LOL. i loved this performance though! Diana is HYSTERICAL.

[madonnawhore]

This was fun. :)

[ABroadwaystar2534]

HAHAHAHAHAHA i like the guy who does Enda's voice so well when he says "don't even think about going to that audition" it's really funny

[ABroadwaystar2534]

HAHAHAHAHAHA i like the guy who does enda's voice so well when he says "don't even think about going to that audition" it's really funny

[ABroadwaystar2534]

HAHAHAHAHAHA i like the guy who does enda's voice so well when he says "don't even think about going to that audition" it's really funny

[FelineMimiDavis76]

Haley duff isn't that bad, I thought she would be but she's good here! Diana and the girl singing Tracy's part here are awesome too

[stephanieb88]

I knew that Diana was performing in Hairspray, but I had no idea that Haylie was! She's got a pretty good voice, I prefer her over Hilary Duff anyway!

[lolarayyy]

Oddly enough, Haley Duff isn't that bad...

Have to say though, I can't say I like the portrayal of Penny by Diana DeGarmo, too sterotypically nerdy in my point of view.

[Angelus51671]

You hold an extremely unpopular opinion haha I actually love Diana's portrayal of Penny; she's by far, my favorite Penny.

[kclrox11]

this isnt the real braodway cast is it? theyre like... well theyre not the real cast!!!!

[Angelus51671]

Umm...

[awesomeprods]

Yes, this is from 2006.

[lovepool2]

Diana DeGarmo is so great

[SilentPunk101]

who are the actresses playing teh daughters? I know Hayley Duff is 1 of them!

[allie8nk]

diana degarmo (from season 3 i think of american idol) is penny... i don't know who's playing tracy

[TweetyGirlz]

What is Alexa Vega role??

[laneneboricua]

alexa vega was formally Penny at the begin of year 2007

[Angelus51671]

Tracy is being played former Tracy stand-by Michelle Dowdy.

[CBA1990]

@allie8nk Sharon Durig is tracy

[hairspraydude1]

@CBA1990 Michelle Dowdy (Shannon's stand-by) is actually Tracy here.