Maulana Tariq Jamil Comments on Maududi

[truth3807]

KIA ISS CLIP MEI TARIK JAMEEL SB NE APNE WO BAYAN JIS MEI MOULANA MOUDOODI KI TAREEF KI THI KI TARDEED KI .YE EK ILMI BAHS HAI .GENERAL TOPIC HAI TUM LOG TOR MOR KAR APNE HAK MEI SABIT KARNE KI NA KAM KOSHISH KARTE HO.MASHALLAH WO ZINDA HAI APP JA KAR UNKO KAHEIN K JANAB WAZIH KAHO K MOUDOODI AALIM NAHI THIE .

[surotmiah1]

English please.

[auhq1990]

Molana sb nay bohat achay tareqay say aik Elmi masla biyan kia, main nay modoodi sb ko b parha hay, lakin is clip k half honay say tariq sb ki koi samjh nahi aa rahi, wah kia sabit karna chahtay hian kia mododi sb naozobillah min zalik gustakh e shaba thay ya phir yah sabat karna chahtay k un ka elm naqas hay? jin ko aalam e islam mian aik namayan mqam hasil hay? ya phir tariq sb apni ghalti drusat honay ki nishan dahi kar rahay k mododi sb nay un k concpets drust keay? plz load full clip, tanx

[sipraomer]

Jo log sahaba keh baare meh baatein karte hon woh pehle namaz parhne ka sahih tareeqa seekhen. Pehle Islam ki bunyadi baaton ko seekhen. Pehle deen ki implementation ke baare meh ilm hasil karein aur amal karein. jo hastian guzr gain aur history ban gain unke baare meh kion baatein karte ho. Sahaba ra keh baare meh tab baat karo jab khud sahaba keh maqaam pe puhncho jo keh ho nahin sakta. Lehaza khamosh raho aur apna girehbaan dekho keh khud kia ho.

[MyAzeem007]

mery khyal main hamain Modudi sab ko parhna chahiye jesy Molana Tariq sab ny parha or un ki galtfehmi dur hui

[maymar1]

جميل شيطان

[SJHUSSAINPK]

How are wort that jameel is shytan.Are you know about molana tariq jameel.? you confirmed somthing he don some work as same shytan.

[Zuibee]

Yeh upload kaene wala Fassadi aur Fitnaa hai..!!

[jazbaedil]

Moulana Moudoodi Alehe Rahma se aaj k baray baray scholars ka koi muqabila nahi hai, sab unn k samnay pani bhartay nazar aatay hain, agar moulana moudoodi AR sirf Tafseer e Quran hi par iktefa karte tou bhi buhut tha, lekin unhon ne islam ko jadeed andaz main samjhaya. Aap ki likhi hui kitabon se aaj tak log ilm k charagh roshan kartay hain. Tableeghi jamat k logon ko moulana Moudoodi RA k baray main bat kartaay huay ehtiyat baratna chahiye, warna hashar k roz Allah ko kiya jawab dain ge?

[MaleDecent]

Sawal sirf yeh hai ke ... kya Sahaba karam radhiy'Allahu anuhum Rasoolullah sallahu alihi wa sallam ki tarah masoom the, agar che duniya hee mein unhein(RA) jannat ki basharat dee gayee thi?

Doosri cheez jo ikhtelafat sahaba karam radhiy'Allahu anuhum kay darmiyan huay unhein kaisa suljaya jaa sakta hai?

Teesri cheez... Sheikh Tariq Jameel ko aise nazook masaayel par awwamun-naas mein guftagoo nahin karni chahiye... agar unhein eytaraz hai to ilmi kitab likh kar apne dalayal pesh karni chahiye

[rizwanwattoo86]

@MaleDecent my dear pehli baat ka jawab ye ha k sahabah r.a. nabi s.a.a.w. ki tarah masoom agarche nahi they lekin jab Allah ne razi hone ka ailan kar dia tou ab mujhe ya ap ko ya kisi aur ko koi ikhtiar nahi k unki un baton ko uchala jae jinhen hamari naqis aqlen negative samajhti hein, doosri baat ka jawab ye ha k Allah ne hamari zimmadari nahi lagai k un ikhtilafaat ko suljhaen halanke un hazraat mein ikhtilaaf k bawjood muhabbat thi, ikhtilaaf sirf ijtihadi tha

[MaleDecent]

@rizwanwattoo86 Inna lillahi wa inna ilaihi rajee'oon... kaon bad bakht musalman hoga jo sahaba (r.a.) jaisi azeem hasteeyon par kuch kahe. Yaqeenan woh jahannami hai. Laikin, aap khud mante hain ikhtelafat the sahaba(r.a) kay beech. Lazim hai shar'ee, tareekhi, ilmi haisiyat se unki tat beeq ki jaye. yeh sara sar Allah ki rahmat hai. continued

[MaleDecent]

contd... @rizwanwattoo86 Shutar murgh ki tarah unko sarf-e-nazar karna koi ma qool baath nahin... iss se to shukook aur bad jaate hain kum hone ke bajaye. Agar aap samjhein to unke muqaam se iska koi talloq nahin. yeh fitna-parwar maulwi unko awwam mein bah kahne iss tarah ka istemal kar te hain. Shaikh Tareq Jameel ko chahiye ek mudalil kitab likhe aur jo bhi eteraz ho uska jawab dein... unhein kaon rokta hai iss baath se.

[rizwanwattoo86]

@MaleDecent assalam o alaikum bhai, masha'allah achi soch ha apki, jahan tak tareekhi baton aur quran o hadees ki tatbeeq ki baat ha, tou is barey mein ye usool ha k jo tareekhi baat quran o sunnat k mutabiq ho usko lia jata ha aur jo khilaf ho usko chor dia jata ha. is mein tatbeeq ki zuroorat nahin. aur doosri baat mushhajraat e sahabah k unwaan par guftagoo karna nuqsan se khali nahin, kiunke is se ziada shukook o shubhaat paida hotey hein, (continued)

[rizwanwattoo86]

@MaleDecent (continued) aur jis ikhtilaaf ko rehmat kaha gaya ha wo ye nahin ha, is se tou logon k dilon mein unki kami aa rahi ha jis ka mushahida mein khud kar raha hun tou is cheez ka tazkira kesey rehmat ho sakta ha? hamein karney k kaam karne chahyen aur jo tareekhi baten hamen quran o sunnat k muaafiq milen unpar amal karna chahye,ap dekhen k unke ijtihaadi ikhtilaaf k bawujood un mein aapas mein kesi muhabbat thi, quran kehta ha k woh dushman par sakht they aur aapas mein naram(continued)

[rizwanwattoo86]

@MaleDecent (continued) ham aisi baton ko mauzoo e bahas banaen. 1 dafa 1 roomi badshah ne hazrat muawiah r a ko likha k ham donon mil kar hazrat ali r a par hamla karte hein, tou jawab mein unhon ne kaha k o roomi kutte agar toone ali r a ki taraf meli aankh se dekha tou unki taraf se pehla sipahi mein ban kar aon ga, ye tou mein ne aik misal paish ki ha warna bht saari misalen maujood hein. aik aur usool ki baat ha k jis barey mein tazabzub ho tou ahtiaat wala pehlu apnaya jata ha(continued)

[rizwanwattoo86]

@MaleDecent aur ahtiaat isi mein ha k ham jesy log un a'alaa hastion k barey mein aisi baton se guraiz karen jo zareeah banti hein un par tanqeed ka halaankeh pichli aasmani kitabon mein bhi unki khoobian bayan ki gae hein aur quran mein bhi, ya phir shayad iski ye wajah ha k ham apni tehqeeq ko Allah k ilm se ziada authentic samajhte hein!!! baqi rahi baat kitab likhne ki tou iski zuroorat nahin kiunke pehlw hi kaafi books likhi ja chuki hein jo muntazir hein k unhen study kia jae(continued)

[rizwanwattoo86]

@MaleDecent aur teesri baat ka jawab ye ha kunhon ne ye baat awamunnas mein nahin ki balke unhon ne kuch arsa pehle maudoodi sahib k barey mein aisey ta'areefi kalimaat kahey they jo kuch sahee they aur kuch nahi. jo sahee nahi they unki wajah se awamunnas pareshan hui aur maulana sahib ki is barey (sahabah r.a.) maulana ali sher haidri shaheed se baat hui tab maulana ne ye baat is andaz mein ki.pehli baat bhi madrase ke students ko ki thi aur doosri bhi, naakeh awamunnaas mein. jazakallah.tc

[StrictlyQrnANDsnna]

@jaguariiui no you are incorrect tens of thousands of people began to follow the sunnah and became practicing muslims because of maulana tariq jameel

[MaleDecent]

@Strictly Since when did it become criteria that because tens of thousands of people follow him, hence he should be ALWAYS right? Millions more follow Maududi alaihir rahma does not mean he is always right! The real criteria is balanced approach in understanding Islam based on the Qur'an and Sahih Sunnah of Rasoolullah sallahu alihi wa sallam. If someone says something, what is the source of that information, is that source correct and does not contradict with established tenets of Islam.

[zindaannaama]

kis se baat huee ? kin ke munh se nikli ?

[rizwanwattoo86]

@zindaannaama MAULANA ALI SHER HAIDRI SE BAAT HUI THI JANAB. OK?

[dawattabligh]

mashallah