tant cas faire un film sil devrais faire avec les vrais evenement, a peine 500 mort des 2 coter, aucun contact entre les ligne d'infenterie, duel d,artillerie... general prussien ( duc de brunswick a ceux que ne le savais pas) a estimer que la position des francais ne permetais pas un assault et prometer des perte severe, dont decision de retraiter...... pas de victoire francaise juste de la propagande de la convention
Exactly. The Battle of Valmy was only an artillery duel between the French and Prussian with only 500 men out of action. The republic has recovered to make it a great victory.
There were 1500, not 500. Even if this battle was not strategic important (It will be the victory of Fleurus), this battle proved for the first time that a army of citizens can win over a army of mercenaries. In this time, it was totally new.
Apart from the uniforms, everything is wrong in this video. Pity, if they only had someone to teach the actors the right moves and exercise... Valmy wan't as bloody as it is suggested here.
Exactly. The Battle of Valmy was only an artillery duel between the French and Prussian with only 500 men out of action. The republic has recovered to make it a great victory.
Vive la nation, vive la République, non au retour de l'obscurantisme et des archaïsmes d'avant 1789!
valy1974 5 months ago
On a pas vu un seul moulin curieusement !
MrRegwis 6 months ago
2:30 la tête de brunswick lol
maxi3317 9 months ago
Vive Dieu Vive le Roy
shanfsgein007 1 year ago
Vive Dieu vive le Roy !!!
shanfsgein007 1 year ago
Bonjour est ce que quelqu'un sais de quel film est extrait c'est extrait s'il vous plait ? J'en ai besoin pour mon TPE ? Merci !
26hellomoto26 1 year ago
@26hellomoto26
"La révolution française"
maxi3317 9 months ago
Que l'éducation national parle aussi de notre belle histoire et non pas seulement cette flagellation incesente!!
Vive la france!
gomis751 1 year ago
Vive la République et Ses Défenseurs ! Pour que le Peuple Français aujourd'hui soit fier de Sa Nation et de Son Histoire !
Jio1557 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Vive le ROI!
Ordinaryguy89 1 year ago
Viva la Revolution!
Wastedgrunt 1 year ago
tant cas faire un film sil devrais faire avec les vrais evenement, a peine 500 mort des 2 coter, aucun contact entre les ligne d'infenterie, duel d,artillerie... general prussien ( duc de brunswick a ceux que ne le savais pas) a estimer que la position des francais ne permetais pas un assault et prometer des perte severe, dont decision de retraiter...... pas de victoire francaise juste de la propagande de la convention
ceberius 1 year ago
Exactly. The Battle of Valmy was only an artillery duel between the French and Prussian with only 500 men out of action. The republic has recovered to make it a great victory.
delta100 2 years ago
There were 1500, not 500. Even if this battle was not strategic important (It will be the victory of Fleurus), this battle proved for the first time that a army of citizens can win over a army of mercenaries. In this time, it was totally new.
sirupeuse 2 years ago
Like British have made Waterloo "their Victory" while more than 2/3 of the Coalition was dutch, belgian and Prussian
gipcambero 1 year ago
Apart from the uniforms, everything is wrong in this video. Pity, if they only had someone to teach the actors the right moves and exercise... Valmy wan't as bloody as it is suggested here.
Mohawkmarcje 2 years ago
many movies get it wrong,
just look at the Hollywood productions
:-)
want some history ?
then watch HistoryChannel ,
movies and novels are not history
this is for entertainment
ArseneLupin2009 2 years ago
Exactly. The Battle of Valmy was only an artillery duel between the French and Prussian with only 500 men out of action. The republic has recovered to make it a great victory.
delta100 2 years ago
Vive la République! Vive la France!
republicain85 2 years ago 3
vive la république ! vive la France ! Vive la Nation !
claire19850404 2 years ago 8
This has been flagged as spam show
Vive la liberté !
Refragatio 2 years ago 3
Vive la France!
darsh9999 3 years ago 21
Vive la Nation!
hommechauvesouris 3 years ago 17