張清芳 戀戀金曲 聽海

[loveinsoul]

張清芳一定常常在KTV點唱這首歌～唱得太好聽了啦～芳式風格，­一點都沒有阿妹的影子。

[hpan0721]

好迷人

[wubrianMetal]

真是棒，用她自己的風格在唱。

[ak36hk]

太捧了 !!

[georgeamingo]

把自己高音特色唱出來不造作不模仿，這才是真正實力派。

[jansenchu0477]

謝謝你！張姐的聽海

[s8564058]

超好聽的！最愛阿芳完美漂亮的高音了！

[davidchubo]

not as good as amei

her voice is a bit too pitch and shallow.

[ahzai1988]

Damn powerful...

[nicemanpower]

真的唱得很好!!!

[iamlonely]

太完美了/

[shingolkw]

聽哂youtube十幾個歌星唱聽海

都是阿芳,阿妹的最聽

阿芳超棒~!

[german324]

Agree

[78789424]

讚啦!讚啦!讚啦!讚啦!讚啦!讚啦!讚啦!讚啦!讚啦!讚啦!­讚啦!讚啦!讚啦!讚啦!讚啦!讚啦!讚啦!讚啦!讚啦!讚啦!­讚啦!讚啦!讚啦!讚啦!讚啦!讚啦!讚啦!讚啦!讚啦!讚啦!­讚啦!讚啦!讚啦!讚啦!讚啦!讚啦!讚啦!讚啦!讚啦!讚啦!­

[teresafan]

阿芳唱得很好，不輸阿妹

=======================

阿芳跟阿妹不一樣

阿芳都是真音直接拉上去....

[teresafan]

阿芳現場都是不降key, 不用假音, 真音直接拉上去

[falaing]

@teresafan 阿芳另一味道, 遊刃有餘

[jnt1230]

太好聽拉 !

[jangchub]

her pitching is perfect which made this song so much wonderful

[teresafan]

@jangchub 阿芳是東方不敗，除了唱片銷售不敗，她的高音也是不敗 ^^

[ruje1748]

媽呀!

唱超好的!

最後一句真的很棒!

[daiwangemail]

哈 你說ㄉ也是有理

版主

[Lonnie0825]

有些人會把阿妹的嗓音特色，組成一個模子，套在別人身上，不一樣­的就說不好。萬一哪天出現一位完全符合那模子的歌手，怕又要被說­成模仿阿妹、毫無個人特色了。

[Lonnie0825]

雖然我早已聽慣阿妹的唱法，但我還是覺得阿芳唱得很好，不輸阿妹­！

[daiwangemail]

感激喔

版主

[Qian0108]

很好听

[anday520]

還是阿妹比較好聽!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Lonnie0825]

單就最後一句尾音的處理來比較，個人偏愛阿芳多一些!!!!!!­!!!!!!!

[daiwangemail]

當然

[daiwangemail]

恩了解

[b24374006]

聲音很尖 跟阿妹比起來的 張清芳高音沒有厚度 和力度

[daiwangemail]

鐘鼎山林

[Lonnie0825]

你怎不說阿妹沒有阿芳的亮度？另外，我完全無法認同你說阿芳的高­音沒有力度！！

[wonbin3699]

Dont be so sensitive ok. Amei version is always the best becos that is her song. But we do love Ah Fang too,becos of her crying voice is so touching when she sing love song. if Amei sing Ah Fang's song, Ah Fang could be better too.. For this song, if you went to Amei concert in early year 98, you will cry like non stop, Amei is always the best we love in Malaysia, we have already bought tickets for her 20 March 09 concert in Malaysia, even my friends from Singapore coming over to watch her too.

[scrol1m]

最後一句唱的真好聽耶!!