I think this lesson should of been longer, it seems like as it gets harder the videos get shorter and I think it should be the other way around. I really like how in the first video you really took your time with each letter.
hey Dr. you said that the c backward without a dot is cah. and the c back ward with the dot is kah pronounce hah.. in this lesson on the second row you pronoune hah for the first letter. is it hah or cah?
@GatoFrmCuba1 hey, I'm not the video guy but I speak a bit of Hebrew and came here out of curiosity. It looks like you learned the pronunciations the wrong way round. The "c backward" with a dot (kah) is pronounced as a hard "k" as in "kilo".
Without the dot it's pronounced as a gutteral -- that's the sound you're describing as "hah". (It's actually more of a throaty sound, a bit like the German "ch" in "ich" but harder.)
@truthseeker911david That's the difficulty with "teaching" a language deductively & using grammar-translation methods instead of helping one "acquire" the language thru inductive means. These lessons r useful to a point, but they do not build toward fluency. Look for videos that have picture association, using pictures w/ Hebrew words & phrases. U will immediately begin to associate the Hebrew form w/ the picture itself, & ur brain will not be working thru a filter ("sho MO, sho MAH...," etc).
@xxpowwowbluexx if the best way to teach the language is with picture association then why dont you make your videos accordingly? We simply want to learn and you present yourself as a teacher. We as students cannot control the methods you as the teacher employ to share your knowledge.
@truthseeker911david B/c I don't know Hebrew & I don't make videos. :) I'm still a beginner at this language myself. I just know how language acquisition works since I have reached a high level of fluency in American Sign Language this way (w/ real-life interaction) & I used this type of methodology to pass that language on to many others. I am also familiar with Randall Buth's 'Living Koiné Greek' materials & w/ the communicative approach of his Ulpans. & I'm using Rosetta Stone Hebrew now שלום
@truthseeker911david Check out the products & courses offered by the Biblical Language Center for acquiring real fluency in biblical Hebrew, not just learning about the language & how to analyze it, but actual internalization of the language which results in it living inside of you. You will be able to communicate in biblical Hebrew through speaking, listening, reading, & writing. Conversing over lunch in biblical Hebrew. Nowhere else that I know of can you get this. biblicallanguagecenter . com
@KerstinTschernigg It's hard to build confidence in using a language when you aren't using it. Grammar-translation methodology for languages does not build fluency. SLA (Second Language Acquisition) takes place (& builds confidence) in environments where u r exposed to the language itself directly (not thru another language) in understandable contexts. Look for videos with picture association: pictures w/ spoken & written Hebrew. (U see a picture of a dog; beside it is כלב & u hear "kelev.")
I have very much enjoyed your instruction. This lesson has become very confusing. If there can be more explaination and going thru the correct pronunciation as you have done in the past videos would be very helpful. Thank you for taking the time to do all of this for us!
There seems to be things we have not covered. Third line, first letter...the vowel points under the Alef, and then in the fourth line under the first highlighted Alef. Thirdly, there is a vertical dash between vav and yud in three of the highlighted boxes.
Is there anyway, teacher, that you could do more explanation here. I have really tried to figure out, but can't. Please restructure this and pronounce these at the end for us so that we can know if we are right or wrong in what we are pronouncing. Please. Please. Please. All was going OK til now. I am stumped. Please.
what does it mean when there is just one dot under the letter, is that another vowel point, and if, which? also the short vertical line in the uppen end of a written line - I suppose it is another letter? but which?=P
I'd be very grateful if someone could explain this to me.
@TheyDontSee Chaf is another way of pronuncing kaf. This happens in the middle of a word or at the end. Chaf sofit (final chaf) is the form that kaf always takes at the end of a word. While in the beginning of a word it is always kaf.
@roundbunny@roundbunny The only difference between chet and kaf is that kaf in the beginning of a word is always pronunced k. In the middle kaf is either pronunced k or ch (in bach), while in the end always ch and is called chaf sofit (final chaf). But chet and chaf sound exactly the same in modern hebrew. If you want to listen to the difference between these two, you have to listen to a jew from arabic countries.
Thank you so much, I know it is getting alittle bit difficult but I am learning and ance again I thank you for taking your time and help us to learn Hebrew.
@imrichyournot lol. That's the difficulty with "learning"/"teaching" a language deductively instead of helping one to "acquire" the language through inductive means.
dear teacher! Am mohamed from Morocco! before i get to anything, i'd like to thank so much for those lessons, they're really helping me. And am just suggesting that you give the meaning of the words you give us from a time to another as examples, that will be better!
With the Vav, it becomes silent when the vowel is used in it; either in the middle or on top. I always remembered it by ooooo my tummy... Ohhhhh my head.
Wow. 1:33 is where I start to get lost! Yikes! So the "Chaf Sofit" is just the special way of writing this 11th letter of the Alephbeyt when it comes at the end of a word. I gather that it is usually (if not always) pronounced with the gutteral sound - not with the hard |k|. Is this right?
Then I get lost with the three forms on the bottom containing vowel markings. How are each of these pronounced? Is it like the "vav" which sort of turns into a vowel, or is it totally different? Thanx
So usually when there is a vowel in the chaf sofit, it's the qamatz [ךׇ] which is pronounced as /-kha/. As you can see in the last given example the chat sofit exceptionally takes a dagesh: ךָּ (the small dote inside it) and the resulting pronunciation must be [because of this dagesh] /-ka/.
Well I have to admit I have misbehaved and I have gone through the first five lessons in the last two hours. I am making notes to read and reread on the train tomorrow along with my cheat sheets/ cards. But... this is where I stop. This is a bit intense. I will continue from here next time. THANK YOU FOR THESE! So much.
This is a fantastic series of lessons. Thank you so much. You are an absolute star.
bgreenb4u 2 weeks ago
I think you should of done the last part with us first then let us do it on our own so that we would know that we are doing it right
MALIBUSTACEY08 1 month ago in playlist Hebrew
I think this lesson should of been longer, it seems like as it gets harder the videos get shorter and I think it should be the other way around. I really like how in the first video you really took your time with each letter.
MALIBUSTACEY08 1 month ago in playlist Hebrew
hey Dr. you said that the c backward without a dot is cah. and the c back ward with the dot is kah pronounce hah.. in this lesson on the second row you pronoune hah for the first letter. is it hah or cah?
GatoFrmCuba1 6 months ago
@GatoFrmCuba1 hey, I'm not the video guy but I speak a bit of Hebrew and came here out of curiosity. It looks like you learned the pronunciations the wrong way round. The "c backward" with a dot (kah) is pronounced as a hard "k" as in "kilo".
Without the dot it's pronounced as a gutteral -- that's the sound you're describing as "hah". (It's actually more of a throaty sound, a bit like the German "ch" in "ich" but harder.)
Rev1913Rev1916 5 months ago
hebrew is beautiful
samanthajessica111 8 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
This lesson is harder but it's worth it... Hebrew is so beautiful
samanthajessica111 8 months ago
This lesson is harder but it's worth it... Hebrew is so beautiful
samanthajessica111 8 months ago
Honestly it's not that bad. Watch it a couple times and study the past letters and vowel points. You guys make it seem like the end of the world...
FenrirIceKing 9 months ago
Look at all the coments on this video. PLEASE we are begging for help here, can you remake this lesson better?? Thank you so very much in advance.
truthseeker911david 9 months ago in playlist Learning Hebrew
@truthseeker911david That's the difficulty with "teaching" a language deductively & using grammar-translation methods instead of helping one "acquire" the language thru inductive means. These lessons r useful to a point, but they do not build toward fluency. Look for videos that have picture association, using pictures w/ Hebrew words & phrases. U will immediately begin to associate the Hebrew form w/ the picture itself, & ur brain will not be working thru a filter ("sho MO, sho MAH...," etc).
xxpowwowbluexx 8 months ago
@xxpowwowbluexx if the best way to teach the language is with picture association then why dont you make your videos accordingly? We simply want to learn and you present yourself as a teacher. We as students cannot control the methods you as the teacher employ to share your knowledge.
truthseeker911david 8 months ago
@truthseeker911david B/c I don't know Hebrew & I don't make videos. :) I'm still a beginner at this language myself. I just know how language acquisition works since I have reached a high level of fluency in American Sign Language this way (w/ real-life interaction) & I used this type of methodology to pass that language on to many others. I am also familiar with Randall Buth's 'Living Koiné Greek' materials & w/ the communicative approach of his Ulpans. & I'm using Rosetta Stone Hebrew now שלום
xxpowwowbluexx 8 months ago
@xxpowwowbluexx my bad, I thought you were the video poster finally responding to my comment. I should have looked at the names.
truthseeker911david 8 months ago
@truthseeker911david Check out the products & courses offered by the Biblical Language Center for acquiring real fluency in biblical Hebrew, not just learning about the language & how to analyze it, but actual internalization of the language which results in it living inside of you. You will be able to communicate in biblical Hebrew through speaking, listening, reading, & writing. Conversing over lunch in biblical Hebrew. Nowhere else that I know of can you get this. biblicallanguagecenter . com
xxpowwowbluexx 8 months ago
Same, I don't feel confident at all in this lesson.
KerstinTschernigg 10 months ago
@KerstinTschernigg It's hard to build confidence in using a language when you aren't using it. Grammar-translation methodology for languages does not build fluency. SLA (Second Language Acquisition) takes place (& builds confidence) in environments where u r exposed to the language itself directly (not thru another language) in understandable contexts. Look for videos with picture association: pictures w/ spoken & written Hebrew. (U see a picture of a dog; beside it is כלב & u hear "kelev.")
xxpowwowbluexx 8 months ago
1:31 Disaster.
I'm trying to keep telling myself Hebrew can't possibly be as hard as Mandarin... at least it has an alphabet, right?
phoenixfire723 1 year ago
I am not seeing the difference between the dalet and the khaf
N8zerDude 1 year ago
The first couple episodes I thought I was pretty smart learning Hebrew. Then I got to this one and...O.O
ChristianPainter 1 year ago 3
thank you , u are very helful , but i got confused in this videos , i didnt know how to pronounce all the letters in the yellow boxes
jasminepwincess666 1 year ago
I have very much enjoyed your instruction. This lesson has become very confusing. If there can be more explaination and going thru the correct pronunciation as you have done in the past videos would be very helpful. Thank you for taking the time to do all of this for us!
phishmoto 1 year ago 3
There seems to be things we have not covered. Third line, first letter...the vowel points under the Alef, and then in the fourth line under the first highlighted Alef. Thirdly, there is a vertical dash between vav and yud in three of the highlighted boxes.
ElectraglideMac 1 year ago
Is there anyway, teacher, that you could do more explanation here. I have really tried to figure out, but can't. Please restructure this and pronounce these at the end for us so that we can know if we are right or wrong in what we are pronouncing. Please. Please. Please. All was going OK til now. I am stumped. Please.
SuperDeut4 1 year ago
what does it mean when there is just one dot under the letter, is that another vowel point, and if, which? also the short vertical line in the uppen end of a written line - I suppose it is another letter? but which?=P
I'd be very grateful if someone could explain this to me.
gosesnuff 1 year ago
@gosesnuff Just one dot under is a long "E" sound.
mjmckool 6 months ago
thank you very much again dear professor; it was a pretty long lesson but with your patience gods language can be learnt may He wishes so! thank you!
mahvachcheidani 1 year ago
This is a hard one - do not understand the combining of letters you need to read full through
wcroach1 1 year ago
So is Chaf what caf turns into at the end of the word? Or is it a separate letter? This part is very confusing..
TheyDontSee 1 year ago
@TheyDontSee Chaf is another way of pronuncing kaf. This happens in the middle of a word or at the end. Chaf sofit (final chaf) is the form that kaf always takes at the end of a word. While in the beginning of a word it is always kaf.
Etyaldaron 1 year ago
shalom shimi savannah. slicha ha ivrit sheli garua eod. ;/
nalls96 1 year ago
this video sucked compared to the others
pianoandtrombone123 1 year ago
whats the difference between caf and chet?
omoshiroidayo 1 year ago
can someone explain the difference betwen chet and kaf? to me they sound really similar (sound coming from the throat...)
thanks!
roundbunny 1 year ago
@roundbunny @roundbunny The only difference between chet and kaf is that kaf in the beginning of a word is always pronunced k. In the middle kaf is either pronunced k or ch (in bach), while in the end always ch and is called chaf sofit (final chaf). But chet and chaf sound exactly the same in modern hebrew. If you want to listen to the difference between these two, you have to listen to a jew from arabic countries.
Etyaldaron 1 year ago 2
むずかしいね!
kinotori 1 year ago
@kinotori そですね。。。
KnownHiro 1 year ago
With the Aleph there seems to be more dots below it that I've learned yet, or maybe those are two vowel sounds together. Could you explain?
bagelsscareme 1 year ago
Thank you so much, I know it is getting alittle bit difficult but I am learning and ance again I thank you for taking your time and help us to learn Hebrew.
ramboIII3 1 year ago
is that a new letter or is it the letter dallet? bc it looks like it.
SexieLatinMami 1 year ago 2
shalom. everything was going fine until this lesson.
imrichyournot 1 year ago 36
@imrichyournot lol. That's the difficulty with "learning"/"teaching" a language deductively instead of helping one to "acquire" the language through inductive means.
xxpowwowbluexx 8 months ago
dear teacher! Am mohamed from Morocco! before i get to anything, i'd like to thank so much for those lessons, they're really helping me. And am just suggesting that you give the meaning of the words you give us from a time to another as examples, that will be better!
064066030 2 years ago
Dear Teacher: Shalom!!! It is sooooooo hard. Why so many dots? English is a whole lot easier... I will still trying....
lakeoffire77 2 years ago
its harder than the arabic :((((((((
Imad9494 2 years ago
You are right IT IS HARD.
lakeoffire77 2 years ago
cool XD
beaverdctor 2 years ago
thank you bnaior this is great for me even though I'm now into my Haftorah whatever. Phyl now onto lesson 7
FOAMANTE2 2 years ago
With the Vav, it becomes silent when the vowel is used in it; either in the middle or on top. I always remembered it by ooooo my tummy... Ohhhhh my head.
nissanaltima17 2 years ago 5
i can't get the chaf sofit
jahlove111 2 years ago
How do you say the yod with the dot and vowel point under it on the first reading?
ratlover100 2 years ago
Wow, my brain is exploding!
ilikeapplanas 2 years ago 2
it is alike Arabic Langauge : ) so it's not hard for me lol
Saudi7Girl 2 years ago
oh boy the chef looks like dalet
mohamadsaif 2 years ago
u must see the resh lol
Imad9494 2 years ago
this lesson isnt as good as the others, the example needs a LOT of explaining
cgullcharlie 2 years ago 15
Wow. 1:33 is where I start to get lost! Yikes! So the "Chaf Sofit" is just the special way of writing this 11th letter of the Alephbeyt when it comes at the end of a word. I gather that it is usually (if not always) pronounced with the gutteral sound - not with the hard |k|. Is this right?
Then I get lost with the three forms on the bottom containing vowel markings. How are each of these pronounced? Is it like the "vav" which sort of turns into a vowel, or is it totally different? Thanx
KimmyandTony17 2 years ago
I love this language.
Ririjackson 3 years ago
haha im from israel i know hebrew that's so easy.. write to me if you want help ;)
sziv1 3 years ago
Thanks, but I got it now.
hr412 3 years ago
I'm confused with the final form of the kaf.
And just out of curiousity, how do type Hebrew figures on the computer? Do you have to press some special button?
hr412 3 years ago
i have a keyboard that has both english and hebrew letters... so no you don't type special buttons you buy the keyboard .
Katamapatcha 3 years ago
OK.
hr412 3 years ago
in word
landomagicus25 3 years ago
In word? Word has it?
hr412 3 years ago
sure
on the icon of the simbols
landomagicus25 3 years ago
Great! Todah rabah! :)
hr412 3 years ago
mmmm , you are welcome?
שלום
landomagicus25 3 years ago
Shalom.
hr412 3 years ago
ohh alelloya it worked now xD
mrmorocco18 3 years ago 2
ohhh .. where is the Lesson 6 =(
mrmorocco18 3 years ago
yeah.. it is really helpful.
my boyfriend will must be happy, when he
noticed that I'm learning hebrew.
thank you, bnaiorpueblo :-)
ANDYatWO 3 years ago
On the third box I noticed that you didn't pronounce the vowel sound on the vav. Can you tell us why? Is there some rule?
mrsbriandear 3 years ago
It's so exciting to sound out scripture in the original language! I am faithfully following along! Thank You for the lessons.
mrsbriandear 3 years ago 2
I learned more here in 45 min than I did in 4 hours of Hebrew class. THANKS!
colstonac 3 years ago 2
II]
So usually when there is a vowel in the chaf sofit, it's the qamatz [ךׇ] which is pronounced as /-kha/. As you can see in the last given example the chat sofit exceptionally takes a dagesh: ךָּ (the small dote inside it) and the resulting pronunciation must be [because of this dagesh] /-ka/.
KlaasAlexander 3 years ago
I]
@ keighj: yes, you're right and that's because he passes a step in explaining.
- the chaf sofit [ך] is usually pronounced 'kh' very very seldom like 'k'.
- examples: חֹשֶׁךְ chôshekh, רֵעֶךָ re'ekha, מַלְכֵּךְ malkêkh, לָךְ lakh
- example of the very rare chaf sofit pronounced as [k]: וִיחֻנֶּךָּ wichunnêkka
KlaasAlexander 3 years ago
Well I have to admit I have misbehaved and I have gone through the first five lessons in the last two hours. I am making notes to read and reread on the train tomorrow along with my cheat sheets/ cards. But... this is where I stop. This is a bit intense. I will continue from here next time. THANK YOU FOR THESE! So much.
liam4mail 3 years ago
1:52 = confusing :S
keighj 3 years ago
thank you
profeale1 4 years ago 3