Should The Eagles Trade Donovan McNabb?

[lakerstrufan24]

i'm glad he's gone. inaccurate. he can't throw.

[DJAPK]

im not only mad they traded him, but they traded him for ABSOLUTE SHIT!

[bertmarx]

Fuck Kevin Kolb Are You Serious

[D7a7v9e7]

definetly

[tippytheman667]

I think the eagles should trade mcnabb to whom you ask to the raiders look at the offer the raiders have made nhamdi asmougha AND a first round draft pick thatd be a good trade right? well yeah but part of the whole the reason why there hesitating is the line kevin colb is a pocket passer the line of the eagles is terrile part of the whooole reason why the eagles were so successul in the passing game is cause of mcnabbs rushing abilities if im andy ried i trade mcnabb but for a LINEMAN

[oOoShadowZoneoOo]

Exactly, so why the fuck isn't Vick starting?

[jeoskyz]

Donovan was a great Qb For sum odd reason he lacked in passing after the super bowl lost to THE GREAT TOM BRADY AND THE DYNASTY PATRIOTS. who dat?! said they gonna win them PATS!!!! WHO DAT WHO DAT!!!!!

[gfscarface13]

WOW!!!

Look at this people, this video is from 2 Years ago. They've been wanting to trade McNabb since 2 years ago.

LOL

[Chappine05]

McNabb does not get enough credit at all for all he's done. He's carried this team with no run game at all. And some of you guys are saying Vick? No comment on that. You're obviously little kids and had Vick's jersey when he was on the Falcons or something if you think Vick should be our QB.

[PHILLYfan1518]

Couldn't agree with you more about that. Some people just seem to have an infatuation with Vick and throw out logic when talking about him. Why would we get rid of McNabb and replace him with a QB that was never as good as him and is only a few years younger? I think it's time for Kolb, but that only because the Eagles are a team that needs to be thinking about a few years down the road given the number of holes they currently have. Because of this it's time to see if Kolb is a franchise QB.

[mcsuchnsuch]

Just read on a rumor blog that the Browns are fishing for a savvy QB and that McNabb and Kolbs names were both mentioned. Hasselbeck, Vick, and Trent Edwards were also mentioned. If we give D-Nabb who can we get from Cleveland? I dont want Quinn or Anderson. Maybe Wimbley and a draft pick or just Joe Thomas. Again, this is only rumors, i strongly believe that Coach Reid wants him back.

[Chappine05]

OK you have no idea what you're talking about. Why would we trade straight up for Joe Thomas when we just traded for Jason Peters last offseason?

[mcsuchnsuch]

Winston Justice buddy!! Is Winston better then Thomas??Stacy was no where to be found. Our O-line got banged up pretty bad last year. Besides its only RUMORS and 3 weeks ago. Relax Chris McPherson.

[Chappine05]

LOL are you an idiot? Did you read what I said?  Jason Peters is our LT. WHY WOULD WE TRADE FOR JOE THOMAS? Wow I can't believe I'm arguing with someone with this much lack of knowledge.

[mcsuchnsuch]

Stupid fuck, they are pros. They can play anywhere on the line. Look at Herremans. Andy was thinking about putting Shawn at OT when we got Stacy bro. I said trade for Thomas because thats the only player from the Browns who is worth dealing for. So your saying is that if you got two QUALITY OTs you would only start one of them and leave the other riding the bench? You wouldnt put him at the other side.......and you say i have a lack of knowledge!?!??! Your pretty much a used douche bag bro.

[Chappine05]

You dont understand. The Browns aren't going to trade their franchise LT for McNabb. And that kind of name calling isn't going to do anything. Your obviously like a 12 year old punk with no respect at all. And are you serious you don't think Shaun Rogers is good? And Andrews used to play RT so it's not that big of a deal to move him back to it. What's wrong with Andrews? If it really is just an injury and not him still in depression than he can play RT as long as he's in good enough shape

[mcsuchnsuch]

I lost faith in Shawn last year, i believed the hype with him and his brother on the same side doing damage but seems Shawns back problem is too serious. Shaun Rogers is good but he is a key component on CLEs. 3-4 Def.. I dont think they would give him away. The Thomas trade was only about the rumors i read and if there was a trade happening in CLE. i hoped that the trade only involved Thomas. Not that its gonna happen or anything but thats the only trade i would like to have.

[Chappine05]

Yeah they'd be really dumb to trade Thomas... and the reason I think they might trade Rogers is because he's pretty old. It would be sweet if we traded Kolb for Rogers straight up and than signed Julius Peppers. It'd be dominant and not to get ahead of myself but maybe make them the best team in the NFL as long as they all stay healthy unlike last year.

[TheTopdawg14]

YES, Trade Mcnabb and I will honestly tell you why:

Mcnabb has had a great career for the Eagles. Although Mcnabb is 32 years old and he "IS NOT" the future of the Eagles, Trade Mcnabb for some good draft picks to help "rebuild" the Eagles for the future. Farve was traded to start the new Era for Green Bay, Even Joe Montana was traded to Start the Steve Young Era. Trade Mcnabb and let Kolb and Vick compete for the starting QB. position next year.

[ace8842]

Mcnabb needs to go. GCobb has been a Mcnabb defender for years. Mcnabb has a zero percent chance of winning a Super Bowl here. I don't know Kolb's chance, but I know Mcnabb will not win here. We need two safeties, two linebackers, a defensive end, a pass rushing defensive tackle, and a couple offensive lineman...now is the perfect time to trade Mcnabb for picks and turn the keys over to Kolb. GCobb foolishly thinks we can win next year with Mcnabb...fool's gold.

[Tzler]

heres a thought...maybe mcnabb would make it to the superbowl AGAIN and actually win if they GAVE HIM SOME REAL RECEIVERS!

[Tzler]

i thought this was a very stupid topic. donovan mcnabb really is the philly superhero. seriously folks without mcnabb you guys wouldn't even be a playoff team let alone making the nfc championship every other year.

[dnabbsfan]

were not retarted will be the next lions dumb ass

[clopz33]

how bout trading kolb mcnabb is a philly super hero

[EastCoastDude99]

LOL Super hero? No that would be the Phillies, not Mcpuke.

[byvacantskies]

kolb sucks

[eaglefan64]

I believe the question should be asked like this. "Should the Eagles trade Kevin Kolb? Duh, Yea! Kolb couldn't do one simple thing even up the score vs Ravens. Instead of running it in himself he throws an interception and the Ravens kicked our asses. Worst defeat we ever suffered...EMBARRESSING!

[dcxdcdcdcdxdcdcdc]

Mcnabb is a hall of fame qb and the best eagles qb ever

[EastCoastDude99]

Better then Van Brocklin? A hall of famer who HAS A RING, unlike Mcnabb.

[godanselmo]

trading McNabb = Kolb = No playoffs = Superbowl.

[godanselmo]

*No Superbowl

[Thekev8134]

KEVIN KOLB BLOWS...there are so many idiots out there that don't know JACK SHIT

[LadyHolmon]

trade his ass never plays well when we need him to superbowl 3 ints

cards game missed 2 to 3 tds f em

still e-a-g-l-e-s all day

[tightmadnessss]

KEVIN KOLB SHOULD BE THE STARTER!!!

[skysummers71]

Your fucking stupid...

[KnightFirePhoenix]

you're retarted i rather play chris wienke

[EchDev]

id rather have Desean jackson as a QB over Kolb lol

[ohiostatesnumba1fan]

HELL NO HE IS MCNABULOUS!!!!!!!!!!

[ThunderChunky1303]

I think the white guy is rigth they need a transition

[molonlave2010]

If you trade McNabb, who would you have as a number one starter? Kolb? Feeley?

Not a good idea, he's the franchise player.

[eagles1cowboyssuck]

should the eagles trade mcnabb?

hell no

[Portiz26]

Ummm yes hes 33. When will you learn that sooner or later he'll be done. That tank is going downm

[DX231]

33's not old

[dwid1984]

McNabb and the Eagles began the 2006 season at 5-4 heading into a week 11.His weekly passing ratings ranged from a lofty 113 all the way down to 65. mcnabb got hurt and garcia comes and leads the Eagles to five consecutive victories and the NFC East division championship. 10 touchdowns and only 2 interceptions,a QB rating of 95.8 in eight total games played, so was it the team or was it mcnabb? from 5-5 after the Tennessee game to 10-6 and winners of the NFC East

[broncosnuggetsphilly]

remember though that when Garcia came in they were more balanced on offense....all he had to do was manage the game....they expected mcnabb to put the team on his shoulders and win, by being a pass happy team

[dwid1984]

well that right there tells you mcnabb cant handle being a top tier qb, if you have the same exact team, and another qb comes in and you are able to balance the offense more and win games, then its the coach's fault, he should have had mcnabb managing games instead of putting it all on his shoulders and being pass happy if he cant handle it, you have to do whats best for the team

[mjpd345]

D MacNabb is a great QB. The problem is with the system he plays in. They are pass compulsive to the extreme. You can't win in the NFL without a Power Running Game to balance things out and take pressure off the QB

[dwid1984]

drew brees is on pace to break marino's record. the saints running game is worst than the eagles yet brees still puts up great numbers.they are barely winning at 6-5 but if they had a defense they wouldve won more. brees is doing well with everything on his shoulders, the only reason they have won at all, its just he cant play D also. mcnabb couldnt even drive the team down the field last game,brees is able to, i know its hard but GREAT qbs rise above. mcnabb is simply just a GOOD quarterback

[RafaelCelticsFan1]

But atleast he has a decent reciever that hardly drops the ball

[CDawgDoubleA]

Mcnabb is one of the best QB's in the league, and he is highly underated in my oppinion. the fans should be glad that he plays for the phillidelphia eagles or this last season would of gone 4-12. he just needs an athletic, mature reciever that he can work with and get himself a superbowl ring that he diserves

[baldwinjackson41]

@CDawgDoubleA mnnabb sucks he cant do crap but dont trade him cut his butt he dont deserve to play NFL

[dingdongJTLD]

mcnabb is the shit man he is amazing he wont be gone

[molonlave2010]

He's not going anywhere, he is under contract until 2010. The Eagles owner insist he's staying put.

[samek25]

oh, and giving up mcnabb would hurt the team soooo bad.

[samek25]

i want chad johnson on the team. he's unhappy where he is, he wants a winning team--the eagles should atleast ATTEMPT to pick a player of his caliber up.

[gonnaproveuwrong]

u really want anotehr t.o?

[samek25]

no, i want to sign an awesome wr like him for a one year deal (like the pats did with moss) and see where that takes us. but that doesn't really matter with chad anymore because it seems like he's stayin in cin

[babies5560]

anyone who wants to get rid of donovan mcnabb is a ingorat faggot.. he turned our team around.. just cuz he cant win the superbowl without any wr's doesnt mean he sucks

[kevin514]

it just means they need a #1 WR

[jimmytwotimez]

Thank you Babies. And ppl whine and complain about McNabb but is there a better choice out there? The only reason Jeff Garcia was successful when he stepped in was because we ran the ball more and Andy Reid simplified the playcalling. When McNabb is in the game then Andy Reid goes Pass crazy like theres no tomorrow.

[renomahe34]

mcnabb is the best qb in the nfl so y trade him????

[shrador]

mcnabb isnt the best yes i am an eagles fan but mcnabb is not the best but i dont want to trade him for ed reed and i agree we need mcnabb and we need star recivers. give us that well go to the super bowl.

[renomahe34]

well brady obviously isnt and peyton obviously isnt so, who is?

[shrador]

payton manning is the best

[renomahe34]

how? hahahahaha. manning had a terrible winning percentage as a young player even with the help of marvin harrison and a coach that is actually good at play calling. mcnabb got stuck with pinkston and thrash and a coach that called for a pass every ply. mannings line was also much better. if manning were on the eagles he would be sacked time and time again just like mcnabb was when he was immobile. then pplcriticize mcnabb for choking when manning had harrison and wayne and still did horrible

[shrador]

yeah your right he did have a bad season but he still the best because he got better awareness and he can get the ball off faster. but your right payton does have good recievers to catch the ball for him. but the last time when the eagles went to the super bowl mcnabb throw a pick and we lost the game. manning when the colts went to the championship lead his team to a win. so whose better right now? manning.

[renomahe34]

mcnabb

[samek25]

tough to say. manning has a better offensive line protecting him; let's be honest. manning could defiitely not scramble under pressure and get out of the pocket like mcnabb, but overall, manning might have him beat; by just a little bit. and i'm saying this a 100% supporter of don mc. if we shaped up our o-line and got a wide receiver like chad johnson; we'd be the number one team in the nfl. it;s true. we need that go-to, threatening WR. the only problem is, would cj give trouble like TO?

[renomahe34]

i can agree with u there. there is no real way of knowing who would be better if both were given the same conditions but i would have to say mcnabb is better. if u put manning on the eagles he would have sucked. we all know that. if u put mcnabb on the colts he would have been really close or betteer than manning so thats why ill go for mcnabb

[molonlave2010]

McNabb is far better than Randall Cunningham

Cunningham never took the Eagles to the Super Bowl, while McNabb has and could lead them to another one this season.

[mikejd12]

Ok this guy on the left in the suite coat is an idiot!!! Once the eagles brought in a number one for donovan we went to the superbowl. Since then we have had problems all around not just Donovan. Donovan should not be traded! But he needs to be in good health! If anyone is gonna take us there it is him with a number one reciver! Every team in our division has one except for us!!!

[eaglesroks7789]

no they shouldnt trade him