Added: 4 years ago
From: trexnton
Views: 51,125
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (197)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Who puts thumbs for this quality??

  • The wedding veil came from a dude in the crowd who was wearing foot high platform shoes and a bridal dress lol. This was a pretty good show!

  • The niggers must feel good for this song

  • @MAPURITE27 We love this song!!!

  • @MAPURITE27 The word nigger is used in the song as everyone who is different and it is a complement to all those "strange" like Marylin himself : )

  • My mom was a rock and roll nagger. All the time, "turn that music down". Those people annoy me.

  • his is neonazi idioits is friend of cxharles manson\]

    

  • @killuminati614 what?

  • NIGGER NIGGER NIGGER HANG NIGGERS..KILL NIGGERS HAILL THE KKK THE SOUTH WILL RISE AGAIN WITH A NIGGER HANGING FROM THE BIGGEST TREE IN EVERY FRONT YARD.......HAHA IM JUST PLAYIN...KILL WHITEY

  • omfg hes not racist u fucking idoit

  • He said nigger. Get over it. Nigger.

  • patti smith does it better

  • his only problem was, his parents named him ' Brian' can you imagine being MM in the body of a suburban Briam. ooh gives me shivers

  • What does he say instead of Jackson Pollack? He should've said Patti Smith.

  • I am your shit - you should be ashamed of what you have eaten. i think i know wat that means

  • i heard he's hella weird because he got th eshit kicked out of him when he was a kid

  • Man, I love Manson but he is getting old... not the same energy he had ten years ago :(

  • <3

    

  • nices clothes (srsly)

  • Is this song saying that rock is for white people?

  • @peter8099 this song isn't saying anything about race. my interpretation of this song is: we don't have to be a sheep of everyone else in society, we can be outcasts and be proud of it. it uses the word "nigger" to describe not black people, but anyone who is viewed with negativity just because they are different.

    Damn i wish Manson was still young. I was born a decade too late.

  • i know that this was originally a patti smith song but i like the manson version way more

  • I think if you put Rock and roll in front of the word nigger- well I could just about forgive all white people for slavery. It's about time people associated the word nigger with something as beautiful as ROCK AND ROLL.Cause we all know sweet niggers created ROCK anyways- these guys just were grinding it out in celebration- lets face it every body wants some part of them to black.Be it our hair our crotch size our ROCK AND ROLL- duh!--own it!

  • @mymymy39 Your right! It's much better to use the word fifty times in any given rap song. Makes it beautiful, I guess.

  • @mymymy39 count me in for the crotch size... and the deep voice... :)

  • patti smith said it first so hes not the first no need to get all worked up people

  • Well, it was kinda different when Patti Smith did it. I get the feeling Marilyn just did it to be controversial and attention-grabbing, and kinda feel good about himself adding to his rebellious image, not to make the same point Smith made with the song. It's not really one of those kind of songs you do a cover on. Smith barely made it work with her activist flair, head-strong attitude, and songwriter/poetic style. It just comes off kinda trashy when he covers it.

  • He was always a piece of shit. Now he's a fat piece of shit.

  • obama sucks

  • HE IS FAIIIIIIIIL PATTI SMITH 4EVER

  • @gwgw1995 Brian Warner was born FAIL.

  • @RManFlint  SURE!!!

  • I was there front row. FUCKING AWESOME!!!!

  • One more thing...NIGGAS NEED TO LIGHTEN THE FUCK UP!

  • Peace

    This song is far from being racist. What peoples need to do is listen to the lyrics, get the meaning of the fuckin' song, enjoy it 'n shut the hell up! I hate the word myself, and have been called it MANY times. I'm part black 'n wasn't the least bit offended by this song. I fuckin' love it! Marilyn Manson's my shit! Dude comes with some of the tightest music I've EVER heard. With that being said, Don't look at the word, and listen to the song. Peace.

  • Can he say nigger?

  • i cant post? lame

  • @mclaren450 he is not calling you a niger. he has no problem with black people. the song is not even aboit black people. its about being singled out for being different. the song he is singing is 30+ years old and written by patti smithe.

  • Coming from a black guy who isn't offended by the word nigger anymore i wouldn't care if he called me a nigger but i definitely wouldn't want to buy albums and go to a concert of an artists that hates my existence. just common sense. this day and age. there are too many things that are going on to be so caught up on politically correctness.

  • I wasn't aware that MM was a racist... that's disappoint to know.

  • @upinarms79 oh, my god. He's not a racist. look at the other comments before you comment, it's only common sense.

  • @spookymax18 no! he said nigger that means he is a racist. u cant call someone a nigger and not be a racists.

  • @upinarms79 Dude, I know what the word means. But this is a song, and thus it doesn't mean he's racist.

  • @spookymax18 mabe u r a racis 2. i wouldnt defend somene who said nigger.

  • @upinarms79 I'm not a racist, I voted for Obama. Clearly, you're racist.

  • @spookymax18 "I voted Obama"

    My apologies, sir. Clearly, in light of your voting record, you are not a racist. I'm sure black people everywhere must be proud of you. Carry on then.

  • @upinarms79 God you're a fucking moron. The song isn't saying nigger as an insult to black people. It's saying how people used to blame society's problems on black people, but now they blame everything on rock 'n' roll. God, the word nigger isn't always associated with being a racist, you ignorant bigot. Actually listen to the lyrics instead of blocking out every word just because you hear "nigger"

  • @Pr3dictableCl0wn Wow, you're obviously very smart. I'm a "racist bigot" because I'm denouncing racism in a song that clearly does not send a racist message? Wouldn't that just make me an ignorant anti-racist?

    Also, you're being trolled.

  • @upinarms79 When did i say "racist bigot"? I said ignorant bigot. Actually make an effort to comprehend my comment you moron. And of course i know you're a fucking troll. I'm wasn't born yesterday.

  • @Pr3dictableCl0wn That's a very adequate user name you have there.

  • @upinarms79 It's a Korn reference because Clown and Predictable are 2 songs off of their self titled album. And of course, you make a comment about my user name. I proved you wrong in my last comment but you didn't want to admit it so you try to change the subject by insulting my user name. Way to go, buddy.

  • @upinarms79 REMEMBER, OBAMA IS ONLY 'HALF' BLACK (AFRICAN-AMERICAN)

  • @BMANSON6 So being African American means you must be half-black, or of some non-negroid racial mix, huh? I wasn't aware of that.  Thank you for your insightful information, good sir. I have seen the errors of my ways.

  • @upinarms79 YOU ARE VERY MISINFORMED!!!!

  • @BMANSON6 NO, U!!!!!!!1111

  • @upinarms79 WHAT ???????????????????????

  • When Patti Smith sings this song its cool

    When Manson sings it its just fucking stupid

  • Marilyn Manson IS THE FUKING BEST!!!!

  • Gee he looks so tired. . .

  • I'm so glad he still does this song.

    I'm also surprised they allow this on youtube... pleasantly surprised. Love this song.

  • @Erilis666 why woudl they not let it on youtube?

  • i love patti smith!!

  • well, he looks like a crack whore

  • i like yor video what you recoded

  • he turns 41 on the 5th of january

  • Brian just isn't even trying anymore what a lousy performance

  • Oh no he said Nigger. Lets all bitch and moan about it

  • i watched the original patti smith version before i came across this one, and the comments are damn near the same. thats all i have to say about that

  • Just Excellent! Rock and Roll down at the elemental Source! Thank You!

  • Manson kicks ass noone can lie about that...

    The term "Nigger" if anyone has any knowledge...Does NOT mean black,brown people...It means "Bad Person"in general...Wich is any and ALL colors...Just dumb ass white people (yes I am "white"..) gave the name to others who are not..

  • in his book, he explains. The song is about being prosecuted, for being who you are. It isnt a hate song, its to defend those, who experiencing hate for being who they are. Much like marilyn himself

  • excellent

  • he seems kinda down singing this, isnt it? whats wrong with him?

  • No, I can assure you, that that is not what it is about.

  • Anyone you compare to Patti Smith is going to come up short.

  • Pity the KIDS who have no clue WHO or what you're talking about...

  • Both versions are great! MM and PS!

  • well i hope the same 4 u and ur family u jackass

  • get laid, that way u will be a man and start sayin manson rocks

  • MM is too intelligent to be racist

  • nigger isn't a racist word, it was turned racist by the bastards in the u.s a few hundred years ago. Nigger is another word for anorchist, google it if you dont believe me.

  • Funny, every reference I see on Wiki = a corruption of the word Negro, a spanish/latin word for "black". I always felt that was wrong anyway, since the people hailing from Africa are brown, not black anyway...

    BTW, it's ANARCHIST.

  • You're so fucking right,celty234!

  • I enjoyed it... but no one will ever beat Patti Smith's version

  • 1 you should really learn to spell. i think you are the one who is a stupid mother fucker faggot. and by that i mean get an education and learn to be grammatically correct. also, don't speak upon things in which you are ignorant, like manson. if you knew a thing or two, for one, he isn't racist, just because he does a COVER that happens to say NIGGER doesn't make him a racist.

    faggot.

    oh, and P.S. get a FUCKING SPELL CHECK... or grow up and grow a pair... give me a thumbs up if you agree...

  • But how do you know he isn't racist

  • i don't KNOW if he is or isn't. the only way i could truely know that is if i were him, although i highly doubt that he is racist. he is probably like me, and thinks of racism as a joke. not saying that being racist its self is funny, but the idea that someone will hate someone else because of the color of their skin is so ignorant and stupid, i find it appropriate to joke about it, and say racist things myself, but i love all colors. when it comes down to it, we all bleed red. :)

  • True Manson seems too self aware and smart to be racist :)

  • @furvert101 1. You should really learn to spell. I think you are the one who's a stupid mother-fucking faggot, and by that I mean get an education and learn to be grammatically correct. Also, don't speak upon things in which you are ignorant, like Manson. If you knew a thing or two, for one, he isn't a racist, just because he does a COVER that has the word NIGGER does not make him a racist. Faggot.

    P.S: Get a fucking spell check! Or grow up an grow a pair. Give me a thumbs up if you agree!

  • @AntiChristTeenager looks like im the one with the top thumbs up comment... sorry, man. fail.

  • @furvert101 Wasn't looking for up thumbs, just being an arsehole. :)

  • @AntiChristTeenager lol me too! lets be arseholes together :D:D:D:D

  • @furvert101 I agree that, under the circumstances, Manson's use of the word "nigger" is not in the least bit racist. However, I find it slightly ironic that you are telling someone to get an education, and to be more grammatically correct, when you yourself, have made numerous grammatical errors. Also, as a member of the LGBTQ community, I would prefer that you would not use the word "faggot" in such a derogatory manner. Manson may not be racist, but you are certainly acting homophobic.

  • @HTROXURSOX and i certainly have a bf who is 53 and we've been together for 4 years now. i have also performed in gay porn. if you read what i was replying to (which btw i accidently didnt hit the reply button) but i was actually replying to someone who called manson a 'stupid mother fucker faget' which i found to be quite humorous, so i tossed that back in return cause i found it stupid what he said, so i was just throwing his own stupidity back at him.

  • @furvert101 My apologies. I do not generally read the majority of YouTube comments, and only happened upon yours because it had been given so many positive votes that it was featured at the top of the page. Congratulations on your relationship. I hope that one day I may be as lucky as you.

  • @HTROXURSOX read the 'hidden comment' directly above mine... 

  • @furvert101 he may not be racist but you certainly sound homophobic and no you weren't redifing the word like the song does you where saying it as an insult. thumbs down breeder.

  • good cover.

  • can you hear those drumming skills? Gingerfish must've been taking lessons from Joey Jordison

  • eheh my ex-boyfriend always told me ginger was underestimated.........he's always been great in this song, it's not his fault the band he plays in (or is it....uhm.)

  • Go Ginger yeeaah!

    He got better alright!But I'd really like to see him beat the crap out of his drums (musically of course)

  • its not racist, stop being a bunch of cunts to be honest.

  • This is my all time favoite song by MM, right next to Kiddy Grinder!

  • cool performance man!!

    manson still rocks!!

  • Hmm, not that much different from the Patti Smith version. I thought he's make it way different er sumthing.

    Oh well, good performance.

  • he isnt racist dumbass im mixed with black and white and i fukn love metal like the bands HIM and Marilin manson!

  • indeed its about being a slave to rock n roll. having nothing at all to do with racism.

    Manson fucking rocks and always will.

  • This is actually a cover of Patti Smith song, and it's not racist, quite the contrary: it refers to the fact that in the 70s, being black meant being cool, so everybody wanted to be a nigger, ie be cool.

  • I thought it was more like, how bigotry extended over to kids and their Rock-And-Roll lifestyle. It's about punk-rock really. Wanting to be outside of society. How we're all rockNroll niggers. Victims of bigotry.

  • That's also a good interpretation; hadn't thought of it that way.

  • Yeah that's what I think too. I can't elaborate because I can't think of the right words, so I'll just have to say I agree.

    The song is clever though, I can say that much. xP

  • indeed

  • lol, dont know why but i really like the way hes dressed and makeuped here.

    I normaly love his crazy outfits but i personaly HATED the overalls that went up to his belly button, guck!

    Hes beautiful here. bahaha

  • need a momet when the klans hangin you'r ass grab a sniggers bar made for niggere like you

    marlyn manson rules an he was'nt trying to be raceist i was how ever this to piss you off

    peace 666

  • haha fuck yo couch nigger!!! i hope you die you fuckin dirty black cunt jump into a pool of bleach and maybe you'll be accepted upon society:D oh and get a nose job to get rid of that fuckin foot long wide of a sniffer you got there haha:D

  • dont hate cuz yall suck at shit and we fuck your women

  • why are you even watching the video? cause it had OUR word in it? lol, a bunch of brown people like manson.

  • ure a dumass. Stupid black ppl that say the word is racist and then call each other niggers. Truly u r a hypocrite and a dumass... and yes i know i spelled it wrong. Im lazy

  • she is a bitch

  • ok first of all hes not being racist...

    he is saying that is the type of person in his genre of music

    he remade the song becuase he feels he has the same thing too say,but obviously with diffrent meaning

    and we can be called cracker white boy wtf ever....i am racist cuz of that bitches and id never claim to be a rock and roll nigger....

  • @ sad is that he has already lose his angry voice, somehow, I really hope he´ll get his power back..

    I love the old songs, where he had really fire in his voice...

    until holy wood [included] his voice was just fantastic..

  • its sad knowing that one day hes just gonna be too old for this

  • no^^

    look at alive cooper...

    he is still making music, too, lol^^

    M. Manson will never die xDD

  • good drums

  • MM the best 4 ever

  • oh my fucking god, this is one of my absolute favorite Marilyn songs, fuck yes!!!!

  • it was originaly done by patti smith in the 70's but iv seen bolth ;ive and he is much beeter

  • you know its really funny how manson said that rob is an official member and still is yet wes borland is touring with them in support of there new album haha I like it a lot

  • yep white boyz

  • what are they doing in 2.42

  • Looks like the guitarist needed an extra hand to make that sound on the guitar, so manson went over and did it

  • Well, this reply comes a few months late, but Marilyn is strumming out some notes himself, though it's kinda hard to see.

  • Its rock n roll african american. Im just kidding.

  • jajajajaja,I'm gonna stole your joke. jaja

  • I was at this show. It was the best night of my life! I believe I was the only Black guy there(In a kilt none the less!)... besides security! LOL! MARILYN MANSON RULEZ!

  • haha i remember thinkin about the security guy right when this song came on haha

  • Manson's still got it. . I dont know why people say he sounds so bad live? Mansons never been a singer, but he does have good pitch. For a man being 40 years old and still putting on shows like that, and touring and BTW 2008 shows got better n better as it went on. STILL tho, for being that age and screaming and stuff and twiggy back. I expect great things from the manson camp next LP. Rock on manson! Good performance!

  • He needs to turn up his PA I can barely hear him xD. Actually they need to turn up everything. He probably doesn't do anything when he's not on tour that's why he sucks at the beginning and gets better towards the end.

  • well, if you canthear him, you must be going deaf you retard

  • i agree 100 percent!

  • a música mais louca de todas

  • They didint play Rock 'N' Roll Nigger in Finland :(((

  • it was a shame, they didnt play Coma White either.

    Why you guys giving thumbs down?

  • wow, now I can actually see what I didn't get to see when I was at this show. Due to the fact that I was stuck behind 50 people.

  • I was there its was good- it was too small for manson though. packed as fuck.

  • I was at this performance. I had fun and all but this was my least favorite concert of his that i have seen. Venue was too small for someone like Manson.

  • I was here at this show. Actually, this was my favorite live performance I've been to of his. I think, back in 1997 (the Antichrist Superstar era), his shows were largely more energetic and provacative, and I haven't been to any of those. But regardless, I think he put on an awesome show here. The crowd was just feeding it back to him, too. You could tell he was having a great time.

  • pfffft

  • pfffft

  • yeaaaah so fucking hight !

  • Manson ROCKS! I know this. I saw him in concert last year.

  • are you kidding me? I love manson, but he fucking sucks live.

  • if u think manson sucks live u should check out the guns god and government dvd, it has all the cool shit he took out of his show like fire, bitches, and bringing people on stage and molesting them in nothing but his pantyhose and thong

  • TO giovannim- actually I went to the ggg tour- cought it in Indianapolis while I was out there to visit my sister. Maybee he was just off that night, but it sucked horribly. I was so dissapointed.

  • This was one of the best concerts I have ever been too.

  • i think that guy was talking about mansons live quality but i think its not all on him. a shitty guy behind the mixer can make or break how good he sounds. but the studio is gaurenteed because theres as many tries as he needs to get it right. thats the difference you hear

  • the mixer can only make you sound better bro

    your voice is your voice period.

  • the mixer can only make you sound better bro

    your voice is your voice period.

  • from my live playing expirence i know thats not true. many crappy PA systems will make things sound bad that with no pa would be great. like feedback, static, and bad natural overdrive. i have owned some cheap berhinger mixers that would not make things sound better. i think its pretty ignorat of you to think a mixer cant make you sound bad. when i saw zakk wylde and kerry king playing live their guitars sounded like pure shit, and i know it wasnt their $10,000 dollars of marsharl sounding bad

  • has he been lifting he loks bigger its good he has energy again

  • wow. manson actully doesnt seem too be fucking skin and bones...

  • Something tells me that Twiggy is getting a lot bigger piece O' the pie, this time around...

  • can someone please tell what line up that plays with Manson here?

  • Sure. Ginger Fish - drums, Twiggy Ramirez - bass, Rob Holliday - Guitar, Chris Vrenna - Keyboards and Drums, and of course Manson

  • Thanks, haven`t listened to Manson in years so this line up is new to me...What happened to Tim Skold and Pogo then? I know that John 5 left a few years ago. And when did Twiggy come back??

  • you are very lost dude... where do you from??... mars?

  • lost?? Maybe I am....