@ThoixHeoro LOL!!!! this was ausome until that vader stunt!!! Date would not have been effected and would have taken control of the enterprise quickly....
@obiwankenobi511 You know Vader actually never pwned anyone in the movies. He got his ass kicked by Luke then threw the emperor down the shaft. That's about it. The rest of the time he walked around acting all badass but never did anything badass.
@mrsparkle001 Yeah well maybe that's the point, i.e. there was still some good in him? He didn't want to destroy Alderaan,that was Tarkin's decision; Vader trusted in the Force.
Vader also saved Chewbacca's life when he went crazy on the platform and Boba Fett was going to shoot him, but Vader pushes Boba's gun down. He didn't even kill Han, and he didn't injure him permanently. He only broke his deal because Boba Fett demanded Solo as a bounty.
you pttiful fools star track nothing you have would mach the power of the dark side muhaaaaa and we use super heated tabaner gas wich is the same as molten plazma u fools hahahaha
When exactly has he ever made a galaxy-spanning empire vanish? By far, too many people inflate his power to a degree which has never been witnessed by anyone. That is the utter height of wanking a character....
Half of the problem with this vid is that Picard -- as always -- decided to TALK to his opponents. Had it been Kirk, the moment Vader opened fire, all negotiations would cease, he would've disabled the ship, beamed Princess Leia right into his quarters, destroyed the Star Destroyer WITHOUT ever giving Vader a chance to Force Strangle him, relieved himself for the evening, gone to his quarters, shagged the Princess, and then made his mission report and then gone to fight the Gorn. :P
@AllTerroristsMustDie lol I like how TOS fans try to act like that was the best series, as if they're somehow trying to convince them selves that it wasn't a waste of time looking at that pathetic garbage budget bullshit.
Kirk wouldn't have destroyed shit; He'd have been too... busy... talking with delays, and
taking what seems like forever... to finish... even the simplest sentences.
Just kidding but I really hate old low-budget shit... even when it was new.
@trekkie117 If the shields cannot stop a fruity A-Wing from taking out their command ship, or if they can't stop asteroids (Starfleet deflector shields certainly can though), I highly suspect they could contain Kirk's libidinal urges...
@AllTerroristsMustDie Man, everyone gets hung up on what is displayed in either the shows or movies. I mean, why can't a vs just be fun and awesome? If there were ever a legit cross over I would hope that an Star Destroyer would still be a rather scary presence... Not as hopeless if the Millennium Falcon took it on, but still a daunting task.
but seriously Star trek and star wars are both great! its just different takes on a genre we all love and care about. Star trek is great because its more realistic and it actually makes sense on how we end up where they are and star wars is great because its none stop action with light saber battles. look nobody can say what is better then what since we all have different tastes.
can we all just agree that Futuristic space movies are the best!!!
Check out this website, stardestroyer . net, for an objective view on both Star Trek technology, tactics, abilites, and how it would compare evenly with Star Wars (Empire vs Federation).
@fayt296133 No it doesn't. Its a clear Fanwank site that has few Star Trek references and overpowered Turbolasers based on no evidence: I've been there.
This entire video is inaccurate. While Star wars ships may use weapons called Turbo lasers they are actually self-contained plasma bolts that do 200 gigatons of energy per bolt minimal every 2 seconds. A enterprise shield only has the ability to withstand, at maxium, a few dozen megatons, meaning that one shot by a stardestroyer would be more 2000 times the amount of energy needed to destroy the enterprise.
Anways Q is just one (indestructible) person... he would have to destroy the entire imperial fleet, which number in the millions (not including the 19000 star destroyers) before they razed the 150 measle planets the feds control (compared to the empires 1 to 12 million planets).
@elcap22, why the hell would Q help the Federation against the empire? He doesn't about anyone only his own amusement. He personally set plans that almost destroyed the federation more than once and had Picard solve it because he was bored? As far as he would be concerned, it would be superior humans (brutally) destroying inferior humans and doesn't involve them.
@MORPHIOUS1011, How the hell is star trek more realistic? They have alternate deminisions, time travel, etc... That doesn't sound real to me. Anyways star wars is in "another" galaxy, not the milky way: remember: A long time ago in a galaxy far far away?
@fayt296133 well if you believe in the big bang and evolution then star wars makes no sense. They would have to have been really fast at developing which i doubt or else they would have to be past regular human form.
@AwsomeTrekkie but they have phazers HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ITS SO NERDY HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOL
*yawn* energy output of the enterprise D 1.3×10^19 J energy output of an venator star destroyer (which is obsolete by now...) 3,6x10^24 J enterprise just produces about 1/276,923 of the energy the venator produces... :) that's like nuking a guy from stone age bye bye star trek - was nice having you arround :) as someone from the british guys said about the chinese fleet back in 18th century... 1 of your ship can handle their whole fleet! bwahaha :) raw facts rule
@Philahall5 Thats only because george lucas said " i wanna bagilion ships the size of planets and just wrote that" when Star trek is more realistic because its in the future
@MORPHIOUS1011 Most of what you said is correct. In fact in a interview with G. Roddenberry Jr. SW vs ST came up. And G. Lucas reminded us that it's science fiction not science fact and you can make it the way you you want it.
@EPICT0ASTER i know that but this video is called Star Wars Vs. Star Trek, not The empire vs The federation.... and beside you could say Q is apart of the federation cause he wears the starfleet uniform frequently and it's been hinted that the Q continuum are actually highly evolved humans from the distant future....
@NEXTGENCRAFTING yeah but that was in one episode, not in all the episodes Q was in, what's that episode got to do with this video anyway? and besides Q got his powers back in the end and when he lost his powers, he didn't lose his intelligence, when he was human, he had an IQ of 2005 so he could beat vader in a mind game, like a game of chess lol, anyway you do realize there is more than one Q don't you lol?
@NANOFORGE No, its not. He has watched humanity for eons, teleported planets, changed the gravitational constant of the UNIVERSE, and generally done things that would make Jedi go insane thinking about.
@Idazmi7 If Q commited suicide that proves that Q's are not omnipotent. Quinn was also improzoned inside an asteroid. You don't seem to know the meaning of omnipotent, God for example is omnipotent and could destroy the entire mulitverse infinitly easier than you or I would blink. Omnipotent means exactly what it means, all powerful and seeing that Ben Sisko punched Q and knocked him on his ass proves that he is not even close to being omnipotent.
@Idazmi7 The Q's are NOT omnipotent, They are stated to be seemingly omnipotent but that does'nt mean they are. Not of the Q's ahve ever stated that they are all powerful.
"Despite its high efficiency, hypermatter still required massive amounts of reactant fuel to power the great starships of the spacelanes. For example, at peak power, the Venator-class Star Destroyer's main reactor annihilated the equivalent of 40,000 tons of matter each second. Even small starfighters required significant fuel supplies—the Utapaun P-38 starfighter consumed 6.2 kilograms of hypermatter each second at full power." As expected, the full quote shows that I'm right.
@Perion oooh your going to love this. ok this is from the RotS novel "The shining hairlines are light-scatter from turbolaser bolts powerful enough to vaporize a small town." powerful enough to vaporize a small town. seems a lot less than the north american continent vaporizing power from before... im going to give you the benefit of doubt and call hiroshima a small town. 67% percent was destroyed by an 18kt warhead. sooo im gonna say that the max of a turbolaser is closer to 27 kt
@MrVeruckt I've heard that one before, and again nuclear blasts of kiloton to megaton only reduce towns to ruins, not vapour. If you're going to take "small town" literally using real world standards (rather than star wars standards which are much, much larger) Then you're going to need to take "vapourize" literally as well, which means a hemisphere of both the city and the ground it's on to be vapourized, leaving a steaming crater. Which again, gives us numbers consistent with the CCS.
@Perion ok, well no there hasnt been on screen footage that proves 7 megaton firepower. you can geuss and speculate but in the end its impossible to truely know unless it is said on screen. once again im going to give you the benefit of the doubt. (hiroshima is not a "small town" in the slightest, with a population of well over a million) and give you a minuteman warhead with 167 kt youll get the results your talking about. The quote also specifically says "turbolasers" not light guns.
@MrVeruckt It doesn't have to be said on screen, only shown. The calcs from ESB asteroid destruction gives us 7 megatons, dialogue or not it's G Canon. Turbolasers are more powerful than light guns by definition, so they MUST be greater than 7 megatons. Anything less is a contradiction.
Again the ROTJ novelization quote is nothing new to me, nor is it evidence against the CCS. Also your constant use of the "Spell-it-out-for-me" DDT has always been ineffectual.
@Perion again, the density can only be guessed by other people. warsies can claim its super dense, i myself dont think it was that big of a deal, and regardless of everything else i would think that a quote from a movie novel has more wieght behind it than the CCS. so yes it is evidence against it. you say 7 megatons for light guns, well the books say high kt to low mt for turbolasers.
@MrVeruckt The CCS itself states that the fuel in the silos is "denser than the ship's bulk by many orders of magnitude"
The movie visuals say 7 megatons for light guns, book dialogue can be interpreted to say high kt. but since visuals trump dialogue then said interpretation is wrong. The CCS is consistent with the movie visual (7 megatons for light guns is listed on practically every capital ship)
@MrVeruckt Visuals are kind... esp the kind that show a fireship spraying water streams thru the air as if they're standing still lol I LOVE visuals!! LOL But many visuals arguments I've seen have flaws, no doubt. For one, I've seen ppl say the power of a blast that destroys a ship is evidence of the power of the weapon. #FAIL
@MrVeruckt Also, ILM gives the CCS their full backing. "They've taken the process that the concept designers started and painstakingly brought it to conclusion, filling in the millions of details we never had time to think about. In that sense, Complete Cross-Sections is the last chapter in the creation of the vehicles of the Star Wars saga." John Knoll.
@MrVeruckt Are you serious? you do know that ILM is a branch of Lucasfilm right? They were the ones who originally designed these ships and vehicles and did all the special effects (which thus determines the observed, G canon capabilities, such as megaton scale Light guns and Gigaton scale Seismic charges) Which were approved by GL himself. John Knoll was the supervisor for the prequels and special editions of the OT (as well as a few Trek episodes and films).
@starknight97 Yes, and apparently maximum damage from turbo lasers is measured in kilotons. Phasers do alot more damage with smaller power outputs so superior in energy efficiency, superior in destructive potential, superior in refined versatility. Just all around better.
Both shows are campy good fun to watch but Star Wars fans trying in vein to prove Star Wars tech is superior have always made me giggle.
@Jermbot15 true but ships as small as treks would need to be more energy efficiency as like the corvette they most could be fit inside of a star destroyer. star war cannon don't come till after the second set movie for a scientist that reversed the process to she what energy would be needed to to do why they did. so that kinda shady too. that why if you want a fair fight cannon or popularity though at least get the sizes right lol
@Jermbot15 BUT ANSWER THIS ON QUESTION WHY ARE THEY SO NERDY EVRYTHING IN STAR TREK IS SUPER FUCKING NERDY AND HOW DO YOU NOW THAT IF THEY RUN OUT OF AMMO SO FAST A BLASTER HAS 100 OR 200 SHOTS SO YOUR FUCKING WRONG
@sandvichman327 Star Trek is nerdy because of its superior predictive power. Star Wars teaches us to expect a future full of telekinetic priests with laser words and cantinas full of various lovable rascals who travel to far distant worlds for seemingly no reason, stupid I know.
Star Trek teaches us to expect a future where nerds are supreme.
maybe nut then another glareing flaw data escaped cause they didnt read him as a life form.......or maybe vader is an incomptent comander dont get me wrong i personaly LOVE both franchizes and im not critiseing the franchizes im just pointing out glareing flaws to the creation of this :) and though it is good.....thats how people make better stuff :) keep trying ((why i said vader is incompetent is cause well he saw him on the viewer he should had reconized force not efecting him and he escaped
@canishunter Keep in mind that this video is a parody of the VS debate, by making fun of both Trek tech wank and Wars force wank, I mean the first 10 seconds of it is a bit of a give away.
Most likely they are not lasers. Lasers are invisible to the human eyes and travel at the speed of light.
muttonchopswitcello 2 days ago
can't choke data...
FredFotze 2 days ago
0:34 Oh shit, the new Tron game!
gamerxXx2377 3 days ago
"To hell with our orders"
bigcool89 4 days ago
Still by far the funniest and best SW vs ST vid.
RaPositivist 5 days ago 2
Star wars ftw
mrnemesis900 6 days ago
Your damn right I did.
imsokewl27 1 week ago
how do u make vids likr tht
tweanimations 1 week ago
Very well put together. Awesome job!
KayleePhoenix 1 week ago
Vader fuck yeah.
CaptainRon956 1 week ago
Fucking butthurt Warsies, they can't handle getting their asses PWNED so they CHEAT.
First of all that only works on one person at a time, and IT DOESN'T WORK THROUGH SHIELDS-- that's they they call it a FORCE-FIELD!
SouthParkBear 3 weeks ago
@SouthParkBear Um.....calm down. It's a show/movies.
And yes you can use it on multiple people if the Sith Lord is strong enough.
rambosteephens 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@rambosteephens "Um.....calm down. It's a show/movies.And yes you can use it on multiple people if the Sith Lord is strong enough."
Bugger off.
1. That was never shown in any movie, and
2. Never through a force-field.
(Now here's the part where you show your ignorance by quoting from the EU.... pass it up, it's all fanfic as far as canon goes.)
SouthParkBear 2 weeks ago
@rambosteephens If it's Never shown, never happened.
Idazmi7 2 weeks ago
From 3:28 is hilarious
33na3rd 3 weeks ago
Worf's head looks like a giant vagina.
Sarnius26 3 weeks ago
You know that the Imps should could and would have destroyed the Enterprise if Vader had made this video
But Picard had to stick his shiny head in it
TheKilBorne 3 weeks ago
@TheKilBorne I don't think Vader knows how to use video editing software.
slicktyler 2 weeks ago
Fucking trekkies, god damned i hate them
Saintironarm 4 weeks ago
@Saintironarm Please tell me, why do you hate Trekkies?
theemrpoint123 4 weeks ago
i have to be honest
this all seems a bit like Trek -wank
trekkie117 4 weeks ago
Very, very well done! I about fell of my seat while Picard downed the drinks.
Kimishibai100 1 month ago
Can anyone tell me what star trek episode this is from? thanks!
juntao1985 1 month ago
Comment removed
DigitalAlpine 1 month ago
lmao facepalm
SunFlightx 1 month ago
Comment removed
SunFlightx 1 month ago
Data was the best part of this entire video. Great video.
ThoixHeoro 1 month ago
@ThoixHeoro LOL!!!! this was ausome until that vader stunt!!! Date would not have been effected and would have taken control of the enterprise quickly....
MuscleManDaniel 1 month ago
I find that star trek is more believable, mostly because it takes place in a universe where earth exists
chriscos123 1 month ago
It's called tibana gas actually. But ya vader and the dark side would pwn star treck
obiwankenobi511 1 month ago
@obiwankenobi511 Not likely. The Force likes light, not dark, and can one Dark Jedi take a whole galaxy?
Idazmi7 1 month ago
@obiwankenobi511 You know Vader actually never pwned anyone in the movies. He got his ass kicked by Luke then threw the emperor down the shaft. That's about it. The rest of the time he walked around acting all badass but never did anything badass.
Q would wtfpwn them all :)
mrsparkle001 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@mrsparkle001 Yeah well maybe that's the point, i.e. there was still some good in him? He didn't want to destroy Alderaan,that was Tarkin's decision; Vader trusted in the Force.
Vader also saved Chewbacca's life when he went crazy on the platform and Boba Fett was going to shoot him, but Vader pushes Boba's gun down. He didn't even kill Han, and he didn't injure him permanently. He only broke his deal because Boba Fett demanded Solo as a bounty.
Luke knew he was still good inside.
SouthParkBear 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@mrsparkle001 Same as Bobba Fett and Jango Fett since they never do anything but they look badass but Anakin was badass in Revenge of the sith only.
Azhari1998 8 hours ago
you pttiful fools star track nothing you have would mach the power of the dark side muhaaaaa and we use super heated tabaner gas wich is the same as molten plazma u fools hahahaha
TheShockxwave 1 month ago
@TheShockxwave Wutwuzzat?
Spell correctly moron.
Idazmi7 1 month ago
toe to toe we know who would win vader.
TrueSomename 1 month ago
The Data laughing bit got me.
Phazonaddict 1 month ago
If Vader could kill people with the force like that across ships, then star wars would have ended very differently... He can't.
AnduinX 1 month ago
/watch?v=9em7DIK0Ajw
TheSZZy 1 month ago
"Hold your fire? What are we charging by the laser now?"
southparkfan2719 1 month ago 18
Spock would have given Vader a mental bitch slap.
supressorgrid 1 month ago
@supressorgrid Correction, Spock would have given Vader a logic bitchslap.
NANOFORGE 1 month ago
LMFAO That was great! I loved it when Data was laughing his ass off!
emperorofmoldavia1 1 month ago
"Incoming message, sir. Code 47."
"Is there any nudity in it?"
SawdustProductions 1 month ago
Comment removed
The559California 1 month ago
Picard got pwned!
Cobrawolf 1 month ago in playlist More videos from TheGreatLink
The ability to destroy a -ship- is insignificant next to the power of the force.
BaconManiac5000 1 month ago
Comment removed
BaconManiac5000 1 month ago
Now that was funny as hell!!
762rockettravis 1 month ago
More plz:D
VWRacingXZ 2 months ago
They are locking "lasers on us", lasers?
XD
Vat, waz sooo funny.
Malcolmali100 2 months ago
When exactly has he ever made a galaxy-spanning empire vanish? By far, too many people inflate his power to a degree which has never been witnessed by anyone. That is the utter height of wanking a character....
CommissarASSHOLE 2 months ago in playlist Star Wars vs. Star Trek
Soo who won
superfiremario53 2 months ago
I was a star treck fan the i fuck your mom now im a star wars fan(;
thefresh50 2 months ago
Half of the problem with this vid is that Picard -- as always -- decided to TALK to his opponents. Had it been Kirk, the moment Vader opened fire, all negotiations would cease, he would've disabled the ship, beamed Princess Leia right into his quarters, destroyed the Star Destroyer WITHOUT ever giving Vader a chance to Force Strangle him, relieved himself for the evening, gone to his quarters, shagged the Princess, and then made his mission report and then gone to fight the Gorn. :P
AllTerroristsMustDie 2 months ago 45
@AllTerroristsMustDie Yeah he would have used his terrible acting to defeat vader
HalfWereHaiti 1 month ago
@HalfWereHaiti Whatever works. Kirk plays to win. Haven't you ever seen Boston Legal? His record is 4,000 to 0. SHAT ATTACK!!!!!
AllTerroristsMustDie 2 weeks ago
@AllTerroristsMustDie lol I like how TOS fans try to act like that was the best series, as if they're somehow trying to convince them selves that it wasn't a waste of time looking at that pathetic garbage budget bullshit.
Kirk wouldn't have destroyed shit; He'd have been too... busy... talking with delays, and
taking what seems like forever... to finish... even the simplest sentences.
Just kidding but I really hate old low-budget shit... even when it was new.
DigitalAlpine 1 month ago
@AllTerroristsMustDie he would have beamed out the princess... through a Star Destroyers shields?
trekkie117 4 weeks ago
@trekkie117 What shields?
Idazmi7 2 weeks ago
@trekkie117 If the shields cannot stop a fruity A-Wing from taking out their command ship, or if they can't stop asteroids (Starfleet deflector shields certainly can though), I highly suspect they could contain Kirk's libidinal urges...
AllTerroristsMustDie 2 weeks ago
@AllTerroristsMustDie Man, everyone gets hung up on what is displayed in either the shows or movies. I mean, why can't a vs just be fun and awesome? If there were ever a legit cross over I would hope that an Star Destroyer would still be a rather scary presence... Not as hopeless if the Millennium Falcon took it on, but still a daunting task.
RaPositivist 5 days ago
@AllTerroristsMustDie
And then Kirk woke up in the Rancor pit waiting to be anal raped. xD
KennethMoreland 1 week ago
@KennethMoreland Pfft. He'd kill that thing with his hands.
Idazmi7 1 week ago
@AllTerroristsMustDie Data wouldn't of been affected by the force lol, and would of fired all weapons and save the day. Lasers lol
mimmobucchianico 3 days ago in playlist Startrek
listen here virgins! hahaha im j/k.
but seriously Star trek and star wars are both great! its just different takes on a genre we all love and care about. Star trek is great because its more realistic and it actually makes sense on how we end up where they are and star wars is great because its none stop action with light saber battles. look nobody can say what is better then what since we all have different tastes.
can we all just agree that Futuristic space movies are the best!!!
SDMEX04 2 months ago
What a bunch of BS.
DOSU344 2 months ago
This was so cool. So well put together. I loved it.
Sarasdad91 2 months ago
Geeks fucking rule.
SuburbanoidMisfit111 2 months ago
Is there any NOOODITY in it??
SuburbanoidMisfit111 2 months ago
Check out this website, stardestroyer . net, for an objective view on both Star Trek technology, tactics, abilites, and how it would compare evenly with Star Wars (Empire vs Federation).
fayt296133 2 months ago
@fayt296133 No it doesn't. Its a clear Fanwank site that has few Star Trek references and overpowered Turbolasers based on no evidence: I've been there.
Idazmi7 2 months ago
This entire video is inaccurate. While Star wars ships may use weapons called Turbo lasers they are actually self-contained plasma bolts that do 200 gigatons of energy per bolt minimal every 2 seconds. A enterprise shield only has the ability to withstand, at maxium, a few dozen megatons, meaning that one shot by a stardestroyer would be more 2000 times the amount of energy needed to destroy the enterprise.
fayt296133 2 months ago
@fayt296133 Kirk: I killed Zeus with a torpedo. Your argument is invalid.
Idazmi7 2 months ago
@fayt296133 I'm glad somebody knows their facts about Star Wars! gees... this whole "Star Trek ships are superior" is getting annoying
Ps. i do love Star Trek, but fair is fair.
XxXbelacXxX 1 month ago
Anways Q is just one (indestructible) person... he would have to destroy the entire imperial fleet, which number in the millions (not including the 19000 star destroyers) before they razed the 150 measle planets the feds control (compared to the empires 1 to 12 million planets).
fayt296133 2 months ago
@elcap22, why the hell would Q help the Federation against the empire? He doesn't about anyone only his own amusement. He personally set plans that almost destroyed the federation more than once and had Picard solve it because he was bored? As far as he would be concerned, it would be superior humans (brutally) destroying inferior humans and doesn't involve them.
fayt296133 2 months ago
@MORPHIOUS1011, How the hell is star trek more realistic? They have alternate deminisions, time travel, etc... That doesn't sound real to me. Anyways star wars is in "another" galaxy, not the milky way: remember: A long time ago in a galaxy far far away?
fayt296133 2 months ago
@fayt296133 well if you believe in the big bang and evolution then star wars makes no sense. They would have to have been really fast at developing which i doubt or else they would have to be past regular human form.
MORPHIOUS1011 2 months ago
@AwsomeTrekkie but they have phazers HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ITS SO NERDY HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH LOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOLOL
sandvichman327 3 months ago
why is star trek soooooooooooooooooooooooooooo nerdy!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
sandvichman327 3 months ago
@sandvichman327 so is star wars
MORPHIOUS1011 2 months ago
@MORPHIOUS1011 A LONG LONG TIME AGO NOT A LONG LONG TIME FROM NOW
MORPHIOUS1011 2 months ago
JheakrynaKyAlur 3 months ago
@JheakrynaKNERD NERD
sandvichman327 3 months ago
If everthing from star wars fought Star Terk star wars would win with no lsses
Philahall5 3 months ago
@Philahall5 Thats only because george lucas said " i wanna bagilion ships the size of planets and just wrote that" when Star trek is more realistic because its in the future
MORPHIOUS1011 2 months ago
@MORPHIOUS1011 Most of what you said is correct. In fact in a interview with G. Roddenberry Jr. SW vs ST came up. And G. Lucas reminded us that it's science fiction not science fact and you can make it the way you you want it.
MrKellG 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Can't I like both?
F0rr0r 3 months ago
*Shrug* Fire torpedoes!
JoshShaps 3 months ago
lol data RIP
ecopirate1 3 months ago
Also, Data could send the ship to warp
Kalashboy762 3 months ago
Massive fail. The Enterprise doesn't fit
Kalashboy762 3 months ago
riker: "you enjoyed that" picard: "youre damn right"
NEXTGENCRAFTING 3 months ago
3:22 captain picard is like "really is this really happening"
NEXTGENCRAFTING 3 months ago
I'm with starwars
leafs6798 3 months ago 4
This is AWESOME!!!! Great job :D
darkmatter1977 3 months ago
And then the Imperium arrives to cleanse both galaxies in the Holy Fire of Exterminatus.
Imperator Victrix, bitches.
Sharagran 3 months ago
Star Wars has always been better and it still is!
PC19996 4 months ago
Star wars rules!!!
Peterkyle123 4 months ago
LOL at Data laughing at the lasers!
Krystle171 4 months ago
Roflmao
starwatcherusa 4 months ago
3:21 FACEPALM!!!!! :)))
rust1313 4 months ago
Anyone know what episode that is where they laugh at the laser weapons of the other ship? And the one where they're choking?
scepticthinktank 4 months ago
@scepticthinktank The part where Data laughs is from '"Deja Q'' and the episode of them choking is from ''Transfigurations''
starwatcherusa 4 months ago
@starwatcherusa Thanks mate, appreciated.
scepticthinktank 3 months ago
Great video.
duxinarowe0 4 months ago
Lol best part was Data abandoning ship
CrazyFoo501 4 months ago
what about Q? Wouldn't Q just snap his finger and kill vader and destroy the empire?
elcap22 4 months ago 29
@elcap22 because Q isn't apart of the federation? noob
EPICT0ASTER 4 months ago
@EPICT0ASTER i know that but this video is called Star Wars Vs. Star Trek, not The empire vs The federation.... and beside you could say Q is apart of the federation cause he wears the starfleet uniform frequently and it's been hinted that the Q continuum are actually highly evolved humans from the distant future....
elcap22 4 months ago
@elcap22 Q lost his powers cus was being punished and he is now human
NEXTGENCRAFTING 3 months ago
@NEXTGENCRAFTING yeah but that was in one episode, not in all the episodes Q was in, what's that episode got to do with this video anyway? and besides Q got his powers back in the end and when he lost his powers, he didn't lose his intelligence, when he was human, he had an IQ of 2005 so he could beat vader in a mind game, like a game of chess lol, anyway you do realize there is more than one Q don't you lol?
elcap22 3 months ago
@elcap22 lol
NEXTGENCRAFTING 3 months ago
@elcap22 why would Q give two turtle shits about the fight?
bonestar305 2 months ago
@elcap22 It is unknown if Q's powers are that great.
NANOFORGE 1 month ago
@NANOFORGE No, its not. He has watched humanity for eons, teleported planets, changed the gravitational constant of the UNIVERSE, and generally done things that would make Jedi go insane thinking about.
Idazmi7 1 month ago
@Idazmi7 That does'nt mean Q is an omnipotent being.
NANOFORGE 1 month ago
@NANOFORGE "It is unknown if Q's powers are that great."
Yes, it is, simply put, and the show says he's omnipotent, so he is.
Idazmi7 1 month ago
@Idazmi7 Quinn is a Q and he said they are not omnipotent.
NANOFORGE 1 month ago
@NANOFORGE All Q insist that they are omnipotent. Quinn committed suicide. There is a difference.
Idazmi7 1 month ago
@Idazmi7 If Q commited suicide that proves that Q's are not omnipotent. Quinn was also improzoned inside an asteroid. You don't seem to know the meaning of omnipotent, God for example is omnipotent and could destroy the entire mulitverse infinitly easier than you or I would blink. Omnipotent means exactly what it means, all powerful and seeing that Ben Sisko punched Q and knocked him on his ass proves that he is not even close to being omnipotent.
NANOFORGE 1 month ago
@NANOFORGE "and knocked him on his ass proves that he is not even close to being omnipotent"
Q plays games that are meant to be won.
All Q are omnipotent: only a large number of Q can defeat a lesser force of Q, at all.
God is not in the Atheistic Star Trek, and God is beyond omnipotent as 'omnipotent' is represented in Star Trek.
Either way, Q is powerful enough to erase either Star Trek or Star Wars as a reality, unless he is stopped by 2 or more Q.
Idazmi7 1 month ago
@Idazmi7 The Q's are NOT omnipotent, They are stated to be seemingly omnipotent but that does'nt mean they are. Not of the Q's ahve ever stated that they are all powerful.
NANOFORGE 1 month ago
@Idazmi7 Though I do agree with you, A Q is far more powerful that any jedi or Sith and he can erase either Trek and Wars from existance or both.
NANOFORGE 1 month ago
The Enterprise would never be able to destroy the Death Star. Star Wars rules!!!
1980guitarman 4 months ago
And that is why we all love Data :).
MammonDaughter 4 months ago
I have to take the biggest shit ever right now.
MrYoureAdouche 4 months ago
Star wars
starwarsjongen 4 months ago
Very clever.
PCCphoenix 4 months ago
witch ep is laser's from
borgCube100 4 months ago
@borgCube100 The Lasers part is from ''Conundrum''
starwatcherusa 3 months ago
lol is there any nudity what was w/ riker O_o
Kingicetre 4 months ago
the original enterprise could destroy the surface of a planet so imagine what the enterprise E could do
godzillaisnuclea123 4 months ago
@godzillaisnuclea123 BUT ONE STAR DESTROYER CAN DO THE SAME THING ONLY BETTER
sandvichman327 3 months ago
Picard facepalm FTW.
Jermbot15 5 months ago
Star Wars ownssssssssssssss
lapinell081 5 months ago
LOL. This was awesome!
Umbreona 5 months ago
One of the best edits i ever seen ;]
Wierzbovsky 5 months ago
That's bull. The Enterprise trashed the Star Destroyer. To me, that's a win for them.
RyanSellman1 5 months ago
Wow, awesome job! Looking forward to the conclusion! (I hope?)
Kolibri2005 5 months ago
Star trek rules!!!
jeapiat 5 months ago 20
Comment removed
bmuhlestein123 4 months ago
@jeapiat star trek is fuck
darthsidius88 4 months ago
@jeapiat Seems your Fleet has been strangle.LOL.
DOSU344 2 months ago
Star Wars >>>>>>>>>>>> Star Trek
freeway996 5 months ago
@freeway996 Quite Ilogical
ThePmadsen 4 months ago
Is there any nudity in it? Any nudity? ....Oh....
nosorab3 5 months ago
"Despite its high efficiency, hypermatter still required massive amounts of reactant fuel to power the great starships of the spacelanes. For example, at peak power, the Venator-class Star Destroyer's main reactor annihilated the equivalent of 40,000 tons of matter each second. Even small starfighters required significant fuel supplies—the Utapaun P-38 starfighter consumed 6.2 kilograms of hypermatter each second at full power." As expected, the full quote shows that I'm right.
Perion 5 months ago
@Perion oooh your going to love this. ok this is from the RotS novel "The shining hairlines are light-scatter from turbolaser bolts powerful enough to vaporize a small town." powerful enough to vaporize a small town. seems a lot less than the north american continent vaporizing power from before... im going to give you the benefit of doubt and call hiroshima a small town. 67% percent was destroyed by an 18kt warhead. sooo im gonna say that the max of a turbolaser is closer to 27 kt
MrVeruckt 5 months ago
@MrVeruckt I've heard that one before, and again nuclear blasts of kiloton to megaton only reduce towns to ruins, not vapour. If you're going to take "small town" literally using real world standards (rather than star wars standards which are much, much larger) Then you're going to need to take "vapourize" literally as well, which means a hemisphere of both the city and the ground it's on to be vapourized, leaving a steaming crater. Which again, gives us numbers consistent with the CCS.
Perion 5 months ago
@MrVeruckt Besides sub megaton firepower contradicts on screen evidence of light guns having 7 megaton firepower, so your interpretation is invalid.
Perion 5 months ago
@Perion ok, well no there hasnt been on screen footage that proves 7 megaton firepower. you can geuss and speculate but in the end its impossible to truely know unless it is said on screen. once again im going to give you the benefit of the doubt. (hiroshima is not a "small town" in the slightest, with a population of well over a million) and give you a minuteman warhead with 167 kt youll get the results your talking about. The quote also specifically says "turbolasers" not light guns.
MrVeruckt 5 months ago
@MrVeruckt It doesn't have to be said on screen, only shown. The calcs from ESB asteroid destruction gives us 7 megatons, dialogue or not it's G Canon. Turbolasers are more powerful than light guns by definition, so they MUST be greater than 7 megatons. Anything less is a contradiction.
Again the ROTJ novelization quote is nothing new to me, nor is it evidence against the CCS. Also your constant use of the "Spell-it-out-for-me" DDT has always been ineffectual.
Perion 5 months ago
@Perion again, the density can only be guessed by other people. warsies can claim its super dense, i myself dont think it was that big of a deal, and regardless of everything else i would think that a quote from a movie novel has more wieght behind it than the CCS. so yes it is evidence against it. you say 7 megatons for light guns, well the books say high kt to low mt for turbolasers.
MrVeruckt 5 months ago
@MrVeruckt The CCS itself states that the fuel in the silos is "denser than the ship's bulk by many orders of magnitude"
The movie visuals say 7 megatons for light guns, book dialogue can be interpreted to say high kt. but since visuals trump dialogue then said interpretation is wrong. The CCS is consistent with the movie visual (7 megatons for light guns is listed on practically every capital ship)
Perion 5 months ago
@MrVeruckt Visuals are kind... esp the kind that show a fireship spraying water streams thru the air as if they're standing still lol I LOVE visuals!! LOL But many visuals arguments I've seen have flaws, no doubt. For one, I've seen ppl say the power of a blast that destroys a ship is evidence of the power of the weapon. #FAIL
DigitalAlpine 5 months ago
Comment removed
MrVeruckt 5 months ago
@MrVeruckt Also, ILM gives the CCS their full backing. "They've taken the process that the concept designers started and painstakingly brought it to conclusion, filling in the millions of details we never had time to think about. In that sense, Complete Cross-Sections is the last chapter in the creation of the vehicles of the Star Wars saga." John Knoll.
Perion 5 months ago
@Perion and since when does ILM have any say in this, they arnt in control of star wars. lucas film is.
MrVeruckt 5 months ago
@MrVeruckt Are you serious? you do know that ILM is a branch of Lucasfilm right? They were the ones who originally designed these ships and vehicles and did all the special effects (which thus determines the observed, G canon capabilities, such as megaton scale Light guns and Gigaton scale Seismic charges) Which were approved by GL himself. John Knoll was the supervisor for the prequels and special editions of the OT (as well as a few Trek episodes and films).
Perion 5 months ago
superior lol that a joke right max phaser output = 50,000 TeraWatts ISD turbo laser output = 8 million terawatts of firepower.
starknight97 5 months ago
@starknight97 Yes, and apparently maximum damage from turbo lasers is measured in kilotons. Phasers do alot more damage with smaller power outputs so superior in energy efficiency, superior in destructive potential, superior in refined versatility. Just all around better.
Both shows are campy good fun to watch but Star Wars fans trying in vein to prove Star Wars tech is superior have always made me giggle.
Jermbot15 5 months ago
@Jermbot15 true but ships as small as treks would need to be more energy efficiency as like the corvette they most could be fit inside of a star destroyer. star war cannon don't come till after the second set movie for a scientist that reversed the process to she what energy would be needed to to do why they did. so that kinda shady too. that why if you want a fair fight cannon or popularity though at least get the sizes right lol
starknight97 5 months ago
@Jermbot15 BUT ANSWER THIS ON QUESTION WHY ARE THEY SO NERDY EVRYTHING IN STAR TREK IS SUPER FUCKING NERDY AND HOW DO YOU NOW THAT IF THEY RUN OUT OF AMMO SO FAST A BLASTER HAS 100 OR 200 SHOTS SO YOUR FUCKING WRONG
sandvichman327 3 months ago
@sandvichman327 Star Trek is nerdy because of its superior predictive power. Star Wars teaches us to expect a future full of telekinetic priests with laser words and cantinas full of various lovable rascals who travel to far distant worlds for seemingly no reason, stupid I know.
Star Trek teaches us to expect a future where nerds are supreme.
Jermbot15 1 month ago
@Jermbot15 Star Wars teaches us that if you see Gandalf with a glowstick, you suddenly become the Chosen One.
Idazmi7 1 month ago
You gotta admit though, a lot of these guys do well with what they have.
MrKellG 6 months ago
maybe nut then another glareing flaw data escaped cause they didnt read him as a life form.......or maybe vader is an incomptent comander dont get me wrong i personaly LOVE both franchizes and im not critiseing the franchizes im just pointing out glareing flaws to the creation of this :) and though it is good.....thats how people make better stuff :) keep trying ((why i said vader is incompetent is cause well he saw him on the viewer he should had reconized force not efecting him and he escaped
canishunter 6 months ago
@canishunter Keep in mind that this video is a parody of the VS debate, by making fun of both Trek tech wank and Wars force wank, I mean the first 10 seconds of it is a bit of a give away.
Perion 5 months ago
i only find one OBVIOUSLY glareing flaw to the whole thing......data doesnt breath air and wouldnt been efected by the force in that manne