Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (177)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I want this video on my Liquid mt unit.

  • I got one! Cartman & a can of tomato soup vs. the iranian navy.

  • Did you forget about Jack Sparrow has a luck factor?

  • Captain America would obviously kick... you people realize these are fictional characters, right?

  • How could that guy not no Who Captain America

  • This is a STUPID comparison.... who would win Captain Morgan or Captain Crunch? STOOOOOOOPID

  • LOl this funny Mexican bucky lol

  • sparrow, he can make himself immortal on command.

  • jack looks hotter!

  • funny video

    obviously Captain America would win

  • How can thaAmericat guy don't no who CAPTAN. OMG He a man!

  • Captain America could beat the crap out of everybody in all three of those movies in 3 minutes.

  • how much of a nerd can i be? Cap has 2 teams of superheros backing him not that he would need them The original Invaders and the avengers, and come some who lived fighting in ww2 is not someone to take light. Cap would take out Jack and all his men at the same time the end.

  • no one likes captain Canada.

    But still Captain America rules!

  • True that! Thanks!

    Sparrow - 42

    America - 71

  • @ReadingRaven019 it's actually Captain CANUCK.

  • Captain America!

  • lol that unfair, Captain America is a freakin altered super solider while jacks a drunken pirate, even though jacks strangely clever, he'll probably get his @$@ kick in a one on one duel

  • Thanks~

    Sparrow - 42

    America -69

  • Captian Jack Sparrow cause he owns!

  • Thanks!

    Sparrow - 42

    America - 68

  • I love the Billy Talent in the background! I think Captain America:) He stopped Hitler!

  • Cap would rip him to bits.

  • jack. just...jack.  yes.

  • I highly doubt you have any idea what Captain American can do, or who he even is, or his abilities, and you're just a Depp fangirl who stumbled upon a character he played with a popular contemporary level fighting a comic book character with a far more developed history and list of feats

  • Captain Jack wins everything. He was eaten, he was stranded on an island, he was undead--he came back. He has dumb luck on his side, along with Disney's "happy ending every time" ideals, and he cannot be beaten. ^_^

  • CA easily woudln't even break a sweat in all seriousness what is Jack gonna do ? Cut him ? LOL

  • Thanks!

    Jack - 40

    America - 65

  • Most of the people here don't even know who Cap. America is, and I love PoTC, but even I have enough common sense to know who'd win this. I was expecting a lot of Depp fangirls the same way there are Ledger fangirls.

    FANGIRLS DON'T COUNT - MAN.

  • who would win: Cap. america vs Cap. Canada? lol im canadian and thought that was a really funny concept! i think there is already something like that

  • There's already a Captain Canada? Hahaha.

    Thanks! Glad you liked the Canadian jokes. =^)

    - TAE

  • Abilities Physical attributes enhanced to peak of human potential

    Expert martial artist and hand-to-hand combatant

    All terrain acrobatics

    Master tactician and field commander

    Vibranium-steel alloy shield

  • Thanks!

    Jack - 40

    America - 64

  • cap america should win with more much difference

  • Captain America vs. a stupid drunk?

    Hhmmmm, a hard one that.

    Captain America obviously, lol.

  • Captain America could easily beat that dirty bum.

  • Thanks!

    Jack Sparrow - 40

    Captain America - 61

  • captain america would win

  • jimmy page

  • Jack and a bottle of Rum would beat Steve Rogers back into the dirt for another 60 years

  • steve rogers would floor that wuss.............

  • Steve Rogers is back (in the comics)! I'm glad! That makes even more sense to use Rogers in the movie instead of Bucky now.

    - TAE

  • yea ive been reading reborn and im happy theyre bringin him back too!!!!! the whole time shifting thing is kinda weird, but still!!!!!!!

  • Physical attributes enhanced to peak of human potential

    Expert martial artist and hand-to-hand combatant

    All terrain acrobatics

    Master tactician and field commander

    Vibranium-steel alloy shield

  • Captain America hands down he is probably the greatest hand to hand fighter in the mavel universe so jack wouldent even have time to think

  • I think the man with super strength and agility would beat the shit out of a seemingly drunken pirate with a shitty sword.

  • captain america he is physically inhanced jack isent

  • Captain America

    Physical attributes enhanced to peak of human potential

    Expert martial artist and hand-to-hand combatant

    All terrain acrobatics

    Master tactician and field commander

    Vibranium-steel alloy shield

  • captain planet vs Captain America

  • I think Captain America would take out one of the kids and then they couldn't combine into Captain Planet. =^)

    - TAE

  • Good song choice at the start. Billy talent is the shit!!!!

  • i give jack 26 votes!

  • let's see... some dude who's a super lucky human vs. a super human who's super strong, super agile, and gave the hulk a run for his money.

    {sarcasm} hmm.... I wonder who will win...

    in case anyone doesn't get what I just said, I vote Captain America. I never really liked Marvel very much, but I use my head, not my fanboyism to vote (though I'm not really a PotC fan either).

  • i just relized

    that the backgrounbd song is

    fallen leaves by billy talent

    lol

  • Wow! Nice catch! Yeah, most of our Who Would Wins have music going on in the other room. Catch em if you can!!! LOL

    - TAE

  • Undertaker VS BATMAN Who Would Win?

  • Undertaker vs BATMAN Who Would Win?

  • Aw, come on. Batman just had a 500 million dollar plus movie. Undertaker wouldn't get a single vote. =^)

    It would be interesting though. Thanks!

    - TAE

  • Captian is superhuman, his sheild can asborb energy, so no gun works. He can KO mortals in one shot, so sorry Jack, but Cap wins.

  • Thanks for voting!

    Captain Jack Sparrow - 38

    Captain America - 52

  • People would only vote for Jack Sparrow if they didn't know who Captain America was.

  • That seems to be one of the reasons why people are voting for Sparrow. At least America is winning though. Thanks!

    - TAE

  • Omg what are Cap America's powers?? he is a world class atleat XD he is super human

  • He's super human. I think the movie coming will show us how cool Captain America really is.

    Thanks!

    - TAE

  • I can tell you guys know nothing about either character...this is the stupidest VS. I've ever seen...a human vs. a superhuman...someone who can almost go toe to toe with the hulk...Yoiu guys are a waste of youtube space

  • We know Captain America is superhuman. Have you seen the pirate movies? Jack Sparrow has died and become an immortal zombie.

    I agree that Captain America would win hands down, but we're just collecting opinions here (on video and in the comments).

    If you think this is a waste of YouTube space, then you need to watch more YouTube videos. =^)

    Thanks for watching!

    - TAE

  • Ok ok...you guys AREN'T a waste of youtube space...maybe I went a little far with that...But have you not read Marvel Zombies??? Captain American turns zombie too!! In fact...all the marvel superheroes do...

  • Hahaha. I thought that was a "what if" kind of book. (not canon)

    - TAE

  • Hmmm...maybe you are right...well, you ARE right...

  • ezex1995 (11 months ago)

    if sparow was drunk and vometed on cap

    cap would disenegrate from the acid in the vomit.

    i like sparrow better anyway.

    also you should make captin canada.

    i was lol at the pictures.

    ha ha i reposted me comment

  • Yes. Yes you did. =^)

    - TAE

  • Is this even fair. Captain America is the best hand to hand combatant in the marvel universe. He has an idestructible shield and is to the peak of human abilities and cannot get tired very easly. Cap wins no doubt

  • Thanks for voting!

    Captain Jack Sparrow - 38

    Captain America - 48

  • i think jack sparrow might win look at his movies he beat lot of people and he will do anything to win but captain america will put up a good fight sorry captain america but jack sparrow win but everyone knows that jack sparrow can't beat the joker he might beat the joker one or two times but the joker will beat him more.

  • Jack Sparrow doesn't run away, he runs to fight... Watch the movies again, each movie he wins all his fights. Part 1 - beats Will Turner & Barbosa, Part 2 - beats Will Turner & Commador Norrington , Part 3 - beats Death(Davey Jones' Locker) & Davy Jones

    He's a master Pirate/Swordsman. He comes up with a plan no matter what, so I doubt a man with Super Soldier serum would win. Captain America is awesome, but he'd lose.

  • Captain America...or BILLY TALENT!

  • very cool

  • Lets see How ol Jack can Handle himself Against an all American SuperSoilder with an Undistructible Shield & 2 Wings on the top of his Mask. Pirate Sword Vs Shield (Think about it) I say Captain America yall.

  • Thanks for voting!

    Captain Jack Sparrow - 36

    Captain America - 46

  • Ahh, touche sir. Boy we're all nerds aren't we? lol

  • sorry i meant "found and thawed out".

  • Bucky was killed in one of the first issues. Right before Cap. America was frozen in a lake from some drug. Decades later he was frozen and thawed out by the Fantastic Four. DON'T YOU KNOW YOUR COMIC BOOK TRIVIA xam3000hehe??!?!!

  • Captain America got my vote! ;)

    I'm sure he will win!!! :D

  • Thanks for voting!

    Captain Jack Sparrow - 36

    Captain America - 45

    Any mention of the animation - 1

  • Nice. Captain America wins!

  • I say Captain Jack Sparrow because he has delt with the supernatural before and has bee victorious.

  • of course Cap America

  • super powers mean nothing Jack Sparrow beats any one in a fight any where. he has many clever tricks up his sleeve that no one would see coming, giving him an edge.

  • GO CAPTAIN CANADA!

  • BTW get some effin panelists that actually KNOW comics and their icon characters abilities. CAP is the ultimate leader whenever ALL the heroes get together in a JLA/Avengers crossover Superman and Batman BOTH defer to the Cap!

    If it's acting Johnny Depp over ANYone but if it's COMBAT it's ALWAYS Steve Rogers. He was created to win and find a way. Cap's shield alone could eviscerate the Black Pearl or another faggot pirate ship around.

  • Thanks for voting!

    Captain Jack Sparrow - 34

    Captain America - 40

    Any mention of the animation - 1

  • Not only can he beat a perpetually imbibered superpirate but he can his entire crew along with Barbosa AND Davey Jones's crew. I hate how morons only think the shield is his weapon. THE MAN is a weapon of hand to hand combat and acrobatic expertise that not even Johnny Depp's sly charisma

  • Captain America was CREATED to take on armies by himself and has from 1940 to 2007 (Marvel claims he's dead....yeah right with a movie coming out). Not only that but has beaten Iron Man, The Hulk, Namor (total ocean dominion), Rhino, Spider-Man, Ultron, Kang, Thanos, Dr. Doom etc.

  • Captain Kirk. :P

  • Not an option!!!! =^P

    - TAE

  • Okay then, Captain America, since having scissored hands can't even do much to an adamantium-sheild weilding super soldier. But I swear, if Captain Kirk WAS in it...

  • Jack Sparrow.. He has to be the best pirate I've ever seen.

  • Thanks for voting!

    Captain Jack Sparrow - 34

    Captain America - 38

    Any mention of the animation - 1

  • Captain Jack Sparrow, he can use a golden coin and make himself unkillable.

  • they have a capn britin.and come one jack sparrow vs capn america.thats like saying a poodle vs a rotweiler.capn america whould win hands down

  • its captain america for sure

  • Damn... Captain america!!!

  • No Contest, Captain America. He's stronger, faster, a razor-sharp shield.

  • Thanks for voting!

    Captain Jack Sparrow - 32

    Captain America - 35

    Any mention of the animation - 1

  • captain jack sparrow would own captain america

  • captain america kills that pirate piece of shit

  • wat's a Bucky?!

  • Bucky is to Captain America as Robin is to Batman. However, everybody saw how lame Bucky was, so his character got ousted, and he became Winter Soldier and, eventually the Bucky character became what is the current Captain America: a gun-toting lunatic.

    Thanks!

    - TAE

  • Captain America baby!

  • Thanks for voting!

    Captain Jack Sparrow - 31

    Captain America - 33

    Any mention of the animation - 1

  • Captain america, i mean one he is smart, 2 he is skilled in almost everything so yeah america would win.

  • Captain America pulls ahead!!!!

    Thanks for voting!

    Captain Jack Sparrow - 31

    Captain America - 32

    Any mention of the animation - 1

  • Captain America hands down.

    Anyone who can say Jack Sparrow with any degree of seriousness is worthy of a laugh.

  • Thanks for voting!

    Captain Jack Sparrow - 31

    Captain America - 30

    Any mention of the animation - 1

  • so yes captain american would kick sparrow ass.:)

  • America is catching up to the pirate!!!

    Thanks for voting!

    Captain Jack Sparrow - 31

    Captain America - 29

    Any mention of the animation - 1

  • Pre Civil War Cap or BUCKY CAP???

  • Either Captain America. Do you think one is more likely to win?

    - TAE

  • yeah good point i'd say...

    Captain America

  • Capatian americans powers is just the maxium peak attributes that a human being could ever possibly be.  Like the max strengh and agility and such that a normal human ever got.

  • capt. america hands down

  • America is catching up!!!

    Thanks for voting!

    Captain Jack Sparrow - 31

    Captain America - 28

    Any mention of the animation - 1

  • This is stupid. Anyone who knows who the f##k captain america is knows its retarded to even suggest jack sparrow could beat him. Damn uneducated masses.

  • Captain American would put that limey faggot in the ground.

  • Thanks for voting!

    Captain Jack Sparrow - 31

    Captain America - 26

    Any mention of the animation - 1

  • :S yaeh this is just a game.. but is really sad how stupid is people...

  • seriously captain america took on the hulk twice and survived no matter what he would destroy captain jack

  • captain jack sparrow will win i know that he runs away lot of times. But he beat barbossa if he can barbossa then he can beat captain america.

  • Thanks for voting!

    Captain Jack Sparrow - 31

    Captain America - 24

    Any mention of the animation - 1

  • Captain America would rape and take a dump on the face of Jack Sparrow...then he would castrate him.

  • Thanks for voting!

    Captain Jack Sparrow - 30

    Captain America - 24

    Any mention of the animation - 1

  • Dont forget captian amercia died from a sniper and what does jack sproow have a sniper.

  • But Buckey's the new Captain America and he's psycho. =^)

    - TAE

  • Actually, bucky died right before Cap. America got frozen. Then he was discovered many years later by the Fantastic Four, DUH!

  • jack sparrow would pwn captain america

  • thats fucking captian america he would pwn jack sparrow

  • Ok I liked the video and all but the canadian racial stereotype was just wrong we dont always curl we dont always say eh and bags of milk are cheaper to make than cartons. Ayway I choose captain america cuz his shield can also ricochet of of walls and everything!

  • Captain Jack beat a giant squid creature, a tribe of angry/crazy cannibals, Davey Jones, two of his bitter enemies on a spinning watermill, and a sea goddess. He would find a way.

  • Captain A would pwn his Depp's ass!

  • Thanks!

    Captain Jack Sparrow - 29

    Captain America - 21

    Any mention of the animation - 1

  • sorry second point, jack grabs gold coin...INVINCIBLE

  • Thanks!

    Captain Jack Sparrow - 28

    Captain America - 20

    Any mention of the animation - 1

  • jack easy, talk/annoy/confuse america to death, seriously? jack, i shot kills america

  • Captain Jack Sparrow is alreasy dead so Captain America would loose because what more could he do to a person who is already dead? Althouh it's possible that Captain America could maybe figure out a way to "lift the curse" (so to so say ) as it were and then destroy him but by lifting the curse he would in a sence set him free to go to his next umm next afterlife but then hey he would win. But I choose Captian America because he is the gooder guy of the two. :) yes I mean "better" :)

  • Captain America has died a few times himself. =^)

    Thanks!

    Captain Jack Sparrow - 27

    Captain America - 20

    Any mention of the animation - 1

  • Darn it. But what if Captain America gets so angry that he defeats Captain Jack for being so annoying? Well if he tried to do that I would step in and we both would kick Captain Americas BUTT! Ha Ha.

  • You're hilarious! Thanks!

    Captain Jack Sparrow - 27

    Captain America - 19

    Any mention of the animation - 1

  • I love Captain Jack Sparrow. It's hard to vote against him. But I've thought about it and I've come up with an answer. Captain Jack could lock up Captain America in a room with him, then Jack could ramble on, and on, and on, AND ON, about some nonsense and use his famous hand gestures and body movements. That would drive Captain America so crazy that he would break out of the room and go hurl himself off the plank! :)

    Thanks for posting that video. That gave me something new to think about....

  • Too many people listening to their crotch and not their brain.

    Captain America (or Canada) obviously

  • LOL

    Awesome! Thanks!

    Captain Jack Sparrow - 26

    Captain America - 19

    Any mention of the animation - 1

  • why would you ask that?!! any person with brains would know Captain America would destroy him!!! read a Comic book and you would know who Cap is.

  • They actually redefined Cap by killing off Steve Rogers and replacing him with the old Bucky (who's much more psycho now).

    Thanks!

    Captain Jack Sparrow - 26

    Captain America - 18

    Any mention of the animation - 1

  • Capt. America would absolutely destroy Catp. Sparrow. Thumbs up soldier! lol

  • Thanks!

    Captain Jack Sparrow - 26

    Captain America - 17

    Any mention of the animation - 1

  • I would say Captain America because of his gun and his shield and Jack wouldn't stand a chance against Captain America since he has taken on tough enemies like the Red Skull and plus he teamed up with Marvel Comic heroes like Spiderman and even Spidey would own Jack Sparrow all the way.

  • Yeah, the new Captain uses a gun!

    Thanks!

    Captain Jack Sparrow - 26

    Captain America - 16

    Any mention of the animation - 1

  • definately captain america.. he blocks/ dodges sword with shields and sparrow tires out

  • True. Thanks!

    Captain Jack Sparrow - 26

    Captain America - 15

    Any mention of the animation - 1

  • Jack rox!!!! He should win!

  • Thanks!

    Captain Jack Sparrow - 26

    Captain America - 14

    Any mention of the animation - 1

  • Captain America! He is cappy!

  • Thanks!

    Captain Jack Sparrow - 25

    Captain America - 14

    Any mention of the animation - 1

  • Jack Sparrow! He'll kick Captain America to davy jones and back again. AND ALL WITHOUT A DROP OF RUM

  • LOL

    Captain Jack Sparrow - 25

    Captain America - 13

    Any mention of the animation - 1

  • Captain America cause he has the shield and it comes back to him. Not only that he could use it to repel the bullets from Jack Sparrow's gun.  However, if you are refering to the first movie with ol' Jack, then it would be Jack Sparrow cause of the coin!

  • Thanks! I think we are going with where we left Jack off, resurrected after the third movie.

    Captain Jack Sparrow - 24

    Captain America - 13

    Any mention of the animation - 1

  • No problem. Here's an idea how about Master Spartan vs. Samus Aran, who would win that?

  • Oooh, good question. Who do you think would win?

    Search for "Haloid" to see an interesting animation of that battle.

    - TAE

  • I've seen that movie and it was awesome!!!

  • Jack Sparrow would win

  • Thanks!

    Captain Jack Sparrow - 24

    Captain America - 12

    Any mention of the animation - 1

  • Yup Jack has that stupid luck factor he can't lose which is crazy.

  • Yeah. That makes no sense. =^)

    Captain Jack Sparrow - 23

    Captain America - 12

    Any mention of the animation - 1

  • You know it comics luck is an actual power its minor reality warping.

  • What are some comic book characters with the power of luck? I know of Longshot from the X-Men. Any others?

    - TAE

  • Black Cat had it Domino still has it can't remember anymore off of the top of my head but Jack has it or he would have been dead in the first film.

  • sparrow cuz when the shield misses the first time on the way back it would just get stuck in that hair sparrow has then sparrow could just stab america at will win

    go jack (even thought i hate you)

  • Stuck in his hair? LOL

    Thanks!

    Captain Jack Sparrow - 22

    Captain America - 12

    Any mention of the animation - 1

  • captin america

  • Thanks!

    Captain Jack Sparrow - 21

    Captain America - 12

    Any mention of the animation - 1

  • Jack Sparrow would win.

    -Why?

    Have you seen how insanely lucky he is?!

    (plus Pirates of the Caribbean is a much better film than;

    "cpt. America and friends on new adventures to save the world from an evil super-villain.... again" )