Added: 3 years ago
From: jaysmomosu
Views: 174,343
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (311)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • 今の歌に透明感が出たれいなと愛ちゃんにまた歌ってほしい!

    というかハロカバ的に販売してほしい!

    ハロじゃないから無理かもだけど欲しいよ〜!

  • Reina lose her breath more easily than Ai....they're really talanted but is this song....Takitty surpass Reina easily... I think Reina should use her diaphragm voice (well the producers should let her use this voice and maybe she can be at the same level of the best voice in Momusu history a.k.a Takahashi Ai

  • 愛ちゃん鞘師がハゲる前に戻ってきてくれ

    あんたが居なくなって娘。は羅針盤を失った船だ

    

  • この動画を見て愛ちゃんとれいなに惚れました。

    カラオケで歌ってみたけどこれかなり

    難しかったです!!

  • Jazz feel have another style ?? nice dressing & voice.(無處不在)

  • I think Ai has a better sound solo. But Reina hits high notes better. They're both very talented.

  • 思えば、3年ぐらい前にYouTubeでこの動画(このバージョ­ンではなかったけど)を見たことがきっかけで、それまでアイドル­なんて全く興味なかった俺が一気にモーニング娘。そしてハロプロ­にはまってしまったんだな。それから他の動画を見まくり、CD・­DVDを買いまくり、ついにはいい年してライブまで行くようにな­っちまった。

    何度見てもいい。素晴らしい。

  • i love this so much.

  • これ聞いてモー娘。が歌下手って人がいたらどうかしてるな・w・­;

  • もはやアイドルじゃない・・・。アーティストだ!

  • 今のれいなで愛ちゃんと歌ってほしい!

  • これはすごい。。。

    

  • I love their voice range! :) I'm a saprono and i could only do Reina's high notes,

    Ai-chan's are untouchable<3

  • 太陽とシスコムーンのファンの方には失礼かもしれませんが

    個人的にはライヴでの歌では

    完全にこっちが食ってしまった感があると思います。

  • アイドルとアーティスト

    

  • I am never tire of watching this video, Ai-chan has a great voice and Reina-chan blended in perfect, over all they are a perfect duo.

  • 田中は狸顔

  • これには心掴まれましたね。

    いつかまたこれより成長した二人のこの曲を聴きたいね

  • Ai-Chan ♥!!!!!!!!!

  • やっぱりうまい!!

    愛ちゃんもれいなもすごい才能の持ち主!!

    2人の共演もまだまだ見ていたいな…

    卒業してもずーっと続けてね! 愛ちゃん!!!

    たまには娘。に戻ってきてね…><

    本当にレベル高い! だからこそもっとメディアに出て欲しい!

    みんな損してますね、本当…

  • 共鳴する歌声

    同じ時期に同じグループに在籍したことはある意味奇跡かもしれな­いね。

    しかし高橋は器用だね。

  • 愛ちゃんのフェイク中の転調とコーダのフェイクが絶品!

    

  • 何これ!?スゴイ…

    今初めてこの曲聴いたけど、度肝抜かれた。

    これだけの高音を、こんなに透き通った声で、しかも感情込めて歌­えるなんて、2人共凄すぎ。

    きっと歌うために生まれてきたんだろうな。

    

  • @cogito119 さん ワンダフルハーツ年中夢求途中のDisc1ですね。

    参考になりました。情報ありがとうございます。

  • アルバムに是非入れて欲しかった・・・

  • 最高!!やばい!!まじで泣いた><

    この曲ほんと名曲だね。歌詞も好き。

  • pretty song :]

  • Reina, please keep singing like this and stop squeaking!

  • love their utfits! :D and reina's hairstyle! :D tis time her hair ios done pretty! :D

  • これが収録されてるDVDの名前教えて下さい!!

  • @sachisachi1323 遅いかもしれないけど、"Hello! project 2008 Winter Live DVD Box Disc1 ワンダフルハーツ年中夢求” でございます。

  • キラキラ華やかなれいなと凛としていて美しい愛ちゃん。バランス­がすごく良い。

  • How come we never hear anything like this in their singles?

  • Its kinda awkward how the end o the song fans mostly male are screaming reina while theres barely any for ai :P great song ^^

  • @2010blackpearl some source say that in MM, reina and miki had the most of crazy wotas O_O

  • HERMOSO <3

  • I LOVE AI. done. end of story. she's my all time favorite. XD XD XDDDDD

  • オリジナルも知っているだけにこの二人の歌唱力の高さを感じます­。

    原曲のイメージを変えることなく自分のオリジナリティも出ていて­歴代メンバーにも引けを取らない最高の組み合わせのひとつかと思­います。

    自分でもこのライブDVDは持っていましたがずっと見てなくて持­っていたことすら忘れていたくらいでしたが、数か月前にこの映像­を見て持っていたことを思い出し最近はオリジナルのPVとともに­見入っております。

    個人的にはオリジナルと同じ人数…メンバーは高橋愛・田中れいな­・鈴木愛理・松浦亜弥で一度歌ってもらいたいです。あくまでも個­人的な人選ですwww

  • 本家の方が好きです

    でも自然と涙が出ました

    いい歌はこうやって継承されてほしいと、切に思った

  • beautiful performance as expected from tettekete and reina.

    btw, who sung this song originally?

  • @lovelyslickyvixenLSV

    Original is "Taiyo to Ciscomoon"

  • これはスゴイ。生で見れた人がうらやましいなぁ。

  • 愛ちゃんが卒業するまでにもう一回歌って欲しい!

  • i like this version better then the original!!!! <3

  • MoMusu <3<3<3

    It's sad to see the older generations go slowly, but that's what makes MoMusu unique. <3

    I wish I could see them, but sadly no one comes to Canada.. =\

  • I changed my thoughts of Reina. I read someone's opinion on a forum saying that Reina is just popular because of her looks. I believed in a sudden and never thought of finding it out myself. But when I stumble on this, OMG. REINA!? I already expected Ai to be great. But Reina?! I love Reina now! xD more than before! xD

  • @skyangel127 I think they mean Ai with Goddes:) I don't know people personal opinions of course but many people find Ai a goddes^.^

  • これはすごいよ。憧れる。かっこいい

  • Fabulous!!

  • この2ショットもあと半年で、、、と思うと寂しい。

    もっと評価されるべき娘たち、だと思う。

  • that dude in the beginning who announces the song looks like moe from the three stooges...hahahahaha

  • れいなってなんでこんなに華があるんだろう

  • Hearing Eri's vibrato, I would have loved to have seen her and Ai-chan perform this.

  • I swear to God, in some parts Takahashi Ai, sounds like a flute, its impossible to reach some of those high notes,

  • the two best voices in morning musume the first (Takahashi Ai) and the second (Reina Tanaka) they're beautiful and talented the perfect combination

  • @coldestcoolest

    yeah just like the song kioku no meiro wich ai and reina sing together in the nine smile 2009 concert. that was a great song too!

  • Comment removed

  • 鳥肌たった!!

    感動!!

  • 50のおじさんですが、この2人は最高にかっこいいと思います。

    高橋愛さんが今年引退するのは、実にもったいないと思います。

  • no autotune nothing eventhough i love jpop and kpop but jpop will always be above kpop and no wonder most kpop artist are running to japan now especially this new year

  • aw man, i know i already commented on this video but now that i knw Ai is leaving.. its crazy, i started crying and she wont be gone until the autumn but it still gettin to me. Reina,Ai,Eri, & Junjun was basically who i loved the most in mm. and now they 3/4 are gon it hurts my heart.. Idk if i can continue to watch MM.

  • I don't like this new Momusu!!!!! Eri, Linlin, and Junjun are gone and now Ai is leaving! Risa, Sayumi and Reina is left.....:/

    I don't like it...

  • @triniblossom You forgot Aika

  • @Xxmyriam1212Xx XD and Aika

    My bad

  • ;__; I don't want her to graduate ;___; AICHAN I'LL MISS YOU!

  • Comment removed

  • @skyangel127 eh really? ^-^

  • @skyangel127 uhu i know, no need to bash or something, you're taking it too serious..... i was only joking, to be honest since there almost no johnny's ent. groups vids on youtube anymore i'm little getting bored with jpop, i do still like, it's still my number one but momusu isn't my no. 1 girl-group anymore..... after 4/5 years 2ne1 took that place..... but this performance still blows me from my seat...... i dunno how much i watch it, think more than i watched beast (ke ke and i'm a b2uty xD)

  • なんだこれ。上手すぎなんだけど(笑)アイドルの定義って何なん­だろう。完全にアーティストと名乗れる気がする。

  • i have right now big urge to say: Srew Kpop, but i can't since i love it too much.... but for me jpop will always stand above kpop and thats for 90% of this wonderful performance, there has never been 1 other that managed to blow me of my seat < 3 i love it! ai-chan's high notes, the girls with only a song to prove something..... < 3

  • the only part I understand is Everyday Everywhere, during the rest of the song I'm lost in Reina's eyes.

  • eburidei, eburiwea!

  • 花子私はそれを愛とも東側音楽に関する考え

    高橋鳥は非常に誇張されたが、実際の心の高菜は、彼女があなたが­上手に歌う2は、特別なロットカ月を誇張して驚くべきことです。

    

  • 2人とも嫌らしいほど上手い。安定感も抜群。スタイルが違うのを­聴き比べるのも面白い。田中はアイドル歌唱が過ぎることもあるが­、ここではそんなことはなく素晴らしい。

  • 二人の歌の安定感にびっくり!

    とくにあいちゃん

    れいなはアイドルとして上手すぎるくらいだけど

    あいちゃんはレベルが高すぎる

    プロフェッショナル!本当素晴らしい!

  • amazing

  • Reina! <3

  • OMG!! I knew Ai-chan could sing but who knew she could sing like that and reach those high high notes. Goodness i have fallen in love with her, in my opinion i think she's the best singer in H!P at the moment. Wow and Reaina did well to, she also reached some high notes. Goodness i L-O-V-E-D this performance.

  • 愛ちゃんってドスのきいた低いカッコイイ声からこんな高音まで

    出せるなんて声の領域広くて凄い!

  • 愛ちゃんすごい!!!

    

  • The Goddess and the Queen... perfectly together!

  • Ai has such a beautiful voice ,

    && i never thought reina`s voice would be able to suit a song like this <3

    they both did SUPER good .

  • I love Ai !

    Cette chanson est parfaite !!!!

    The best !

  • What a beautiful music!

    I love it.

    want to go to their concert.

  • tanaka reina you are the perfection!

  • 原曲のファンだけど、このカバーは見事!!

    先輩の曲をちょっくら歌わしてもらってます

    っていうレベルじゃない。

    特に高橋愛のルルの高音パートは凄いの一言。

    太陽とシスコムーンのメンバーも満足してるだろうな。

    とにかく素晴らしかった!!

  • これはすごい

  • 鳥肌立った

    エンターテイナーだな

  • Holy balls, Ai has a HELL of a range O_O

  • WOW AI ♥ O.O I really didn't know she could sing like that~

    And I don't dislike Reina as much now.. xD

  • INCREDIBLE!!!!! :D THIS is why Reina and Ai are always paired together! They make an absolutely amazing duo :D Reina's vocals were amazing and i love how she carried her notes ♥ I also loved Ai's harmonies, absolutely beautiful ♥ ReinAi FOREVER! ~♥~

  • 鳥肌たったわうめぇ・・

  • I find some of the MM members really can sing..good..

  • @GuimarasManga

    thank you ^.^

    nice video :xD

  • Go! Takahashi! ♥

  • 愛れなが真理。

  • この曲だけはオリジナルの完成度が高すぎたかも。

  • @skyangel127 the one with the short hair is Ai Takahashi and the other one is Reina Tanaka

    they're both very talented!! ^^

  • なんかくすぶってるの勿体ないな。もっと世に出ればいいのに。

  • @mammys0827

    昔みたいにまた再ブレークして、忙しくなるとまた何か崩れそうな­気がするから、個人的には今くらいの存在感が一番良いと思うけど­ね。影の実力者的な感じ。

    メジャーになったら必ず沈むときがやってくる。沈むときの喪失感­や焦燥感はファン的にももう二度と経験したくないし。

  • こりゃ驚いた(+_+)

  • 鳥肌ものですね…

  • Wow,I'm sorry but Ai throws Reina off the stage

  • これはすごい!!!実力を見せつけられたって感じ。

  • 原曲知らない子の方が多いんだろうね。

    つんくのこういう音楽(癖はあるけどまっとうにシリアスで綺麗な­曲)も聴きたいけど、

    ハロプロのコンサートっていう場がすでにこういう曲と合わないん­だよな。衣装も含めて。

    娘。単独のライブの中のレパートリーの一つとしてしっとりとした­凄味のある曲があった方が緊張感と感動があって、いいとは思うん­だけど。

    田中はアイドル唄い癖が強いから好き嫌いが分かれると思うけど、

    高橋は叩かれながらも、攻撃的な歌の魅力があると思うから

    こういう歌ももっと増やしてほしいんだけど。

  • Decent version, but doesn't come close to the Taiyou to Ciscomoon original; IMO they don't have nearly enough emotion in this version to pull it off. The original is full of soul, heart, sadness and emotion, and I really don't see that conveyed here. Don't get me wrong, I like Ai and Reina, but I just don't think their performance is as good.

  • @writerserenyty

    Completely agree with you. You'll probably get thumbed down for saying that, but it's the truth. I've said similar things in the past and the same happened to me haha. T&C had a lot more power to them, Ai + Reina are decent vocalists but they are sort of a step down.

  • この衣装、とても素敵!!!

  • 最近気になりだして動画観まくってます。

  • Wow they make a perfect duo..Am I slowly becoming a RenAi fan? Of course I love both of them, their vocals are amazing.

  • somehow reina sounds good singing any song

  • ai && reina are the perfect singing pair , both so talented in singing && dancing , && when they sing slow songs always sounds so seductive && beautiful at the same time , also to mention they are gorgeous girls ,

    relaly love them && everything they have to offer the world . : ]

    also they hit the high notes perfectly , gave me the chills .

  • this is an amazing performance!! ^^

  • Never recognized Reina for her singing, but if Ai leaves the group it's obvious who will be lead in vocals. Ai is so amazing, that gurl can sang~

  • Wow Reina is really good and Ai has a great voice in this song, I am a big fan of Tanaka Reina and morning musume but Ai does a good duo with Reina and think both of them kick ass seriously. Love you both Reina-chan and Ai-chan sugoi!!

  • DAMN, those are high notes. O_O

  • 年齢的にさすがにライブには行けないけど、正直生で見たいです。­この代のクオリティーは非常に高く、オリジナルメンバーの時代よ­り曲も踊りも、そしてルックス的にもかなり向上していると感じま­した。ただ時代の流れで当初の(社会現象的な人気)勢いがないの­は残念ですが仕方ないでしょう。今はAKBですからね。

  • who's the song original sung by?

  • @wuviez i think the original is by Taiyo Ciscomoon or also known as T & C Bombmers...their disband now

  • Ai-chans solo at 2:22 is AMAZING! <3 ;D

    Love Reina

  • COOOOOOOOLLLLL!!!!

  • for a typical japanese singer in a group...ai takahashi is pretty good...^^

  • Reina rocks this completely. <3

    Ai is apparetly tired, her voice is kinda shaky. Usually she is the star no matter what she does so I'm kind of happy that Reina had a chance to be better due to Ai's tiredness. It is rare, not because Reina is bad but because Ai tends to be rather asskicking. :b

  • Karol <3

  • I LOVE THIS SONG !

    I'M A BIG FAN OF THE MORNING MUSUME !

    LOVE REiNA <3

    LOVE Ai <3

    The Song is great ^.^

  • @xBabyKingx 新垣 里沙 Niigaki Risa :)

  • I wish I had Reina's voice and her costume is amazing there !

  • Niigaki Risa :)

  • Lubis5, please... you do not know talent if it were to slap you in the face. I love Reina & Ai. ♥ Their voices are amazing and unique.

  • That isn't what you said. All you said was 'singing live while dancing is actually very hard.'(like you were making excuses for their vocals). And obviously live is different, because there aren't any studio enhancements; which is why I was comparing this to a T&C live performance. I wouldn't be so naive to compare anything live to anything studio recorded. That's my opinion, thumbs down again if you want.

    I am a Takahashi fan(she's the best vocalist now), but I just call it like I see it.

  • Beautiful :) Personally I am not a fan

    of Ai or Reina... But this was AMAZING.

    It makes me like Ai much more :3

    Reina.. she looks bored? She sounds

    wonderful, but like her face looks, soul

    less? It's like she's just singing..

    Not feeling it, like Ai is.. You know what I mean? Not trying to be hateful, really.

  • i am just in shock that Ai could hit those high notes so clearly, now if she cld only clear her voice up so it'd b strong and clear instead of this full of vabrato. im also in shock that Reina didnt drop her microphone with those silky-looking gloves on lol.

    great performance, though!!!

    ♥Smoochies!!!♥

  • i love reina, reina is cute, i love you reina

  • すげーかっこいい!歌うまい!!

    ちょっと驚いた。

    モー娘史上最強のツートップだな。

  • This is so beautiful,takashi ai ant reina are such perfect together ^^ and takashi ai voice is so..WOW!! XDD

  • Well this was a concert... If they got a chance to record this song, I'm sure they could do better-.- They just can't go back and say 'oh let's take that one more time'... That's just what I thinks...

  • I agree 100%

    The people who voted down, are

    most likley Reina fans..

  • A masterpiece of Ai-Reina decade

  • RenAi...^_^

    I like them as pair. And then, GakiKame.

  • i love ai and reina´s duets, this one too!!! they are very awesome together!! <33 this live is wonderful, better than the original version!

  • I'm not a huge Takahashi fan but she has garnered mega points for this. Too bad Tsunku doesn't let her have songs like this all the time to sing and show off that beautiful voice. This is my favorite T&C song and they did a great job!

  • Nothing can compare to the original Taiyo to Ciscomoon vocally, especially RuRu. However, this was a really good attempt, they did the song justice, especially Ai.

  • ai is the best voice i found in Hello :3 and Mikitty and Ayaya~ ^_^

  • This is so beautiful <3 Ai-chan never fails to wow me ^^ <3

    who made the original of this by the way??

  • Taiyou to Ciscomoon (later called T&C bomber) are the original singers for this song ^^

  • thank you ^^

  • Tanaka Reina <33333

  • I'm wondering.. what will happen if they made Eri sing this with Ai, instead of Reina? Or if it's GakiKame singing it instead? :D No, I don't dislike Reina. In fact, I like her. :D I'm just thinking.. because it's always the Ai-Reina pair that gets nice songs. D: Ai's voice is great, btw. MUAHA. <3

  • I don't think either pair you mentioned would hold up to this pair.

  • I was just trying to make a guess, no harm done. In actual fact, GakiKame have nice voices, actually. Give them a ballad, and they'll sing it better than Ai-Reina.

  • I was giving my opinion, no harm done either. I didn't say they don't have nice voices, but I still rate Ai-Reina as the superior pair.

  • I would rate them as a superior pair too, but I would prefer if they gave GakiKame something nice and difficult to sing too. (:

  • i dont think so, Gaki sing Yowamushi (live) and she it was so hard for her to keep her voice in tone. Everyone could notice she was trying so much to keep her in balance.

    Kamei is awesome live too, but Ai-Reina is better than GakiKame in that aspect.

  • Well, I mean ballad. DX No offence for my previous comment, but I'd slightly prefer GakiKame in singing ballad. As for Ai-Reina, I would prefer them to sing songs like these.

  • They are the best singers :) i love Ai, she's so good i can't believe it

  • Reina!!! I'm coming for you!!

  • wow...... <3

  • Is Ai-chan learning opera by any chance?

  • AI-CHAN LEARNING OPERA?!?!? Just let me lol here. :D You really do not seem to know what an opera singer is. Haha. Opera singers don't usually sing with mics and they are trained in completely different way. I know it for i'm in this kind of training.

    Ai is an Pop singer and that is absolutely what she should be. I dont want her to be 200 kilos of alto on en opera stage.

  • Lol.