Siobhan Magnus-Top 12 Girls-American Idol 9

[generationaluv]

I thank AI for introducing us to this Equisite Angel! She now is above AI even! It was a blessing that she got fluked/cheated off early!

[jasunderpar]

She should've been in the finals! - To see the complete performance including the judging - type in siobhan magnus wicked game 2010" - it's 5:56 long.

[TheWall835]

I'm hoping she releases an album. She's just so unique, you know?

[jderoche5]

Oh God she is just awful...not sure how she made it so far.

[Darknezz9]

@jderoche5 welll she sure sings better than you -_-

[bearnpici]

@jderoche5 because she is outstanding. Excellent voice and range. Studios are going to fight to get their hands on this one. She is going to have a tremendous career. I hear some Aretha Franklin and Billie Holiday in her.

[Picardy]

Horror of horrors.

[Loosho10]

Why the hell she thinks now she's a diva? That's what she has to keep doing. All this misterious kinda dark thing.

[edie1231]

Siobhan is a true American Idol. She has soooo much talent. I think Kara is alittle jealous of her. The judges are trying to figure what kind of singer she is , Siobhan just says she loves to sing. Thats' good enough for me. She has all my votes!!

[lovinlavitaloco]

@edie1231 Yes. The judges after repeatedly saying that she is unique, still try to label her. I also loved her retort at Simon and Kara, saying that she doen't need a label. They all nodded their heads in agreement. Way to go Siobhan. You also have all my votes too!! I'm with you all the way.

[generationaluv]

@lovinlavitaloco I haven't liked anyone on this show nearly as much as her! I am addicted to her! I cannot wait to hear her/see tonite! these judges are gonna get wasted by her Dad if they keep mercilessly crucifying her! they hate her now, for some mysterious reason. C Box...U R OK, but Siobhan, U R Miss McDreamy! Yum!

[1gamerkid11]

I love her. and that's what matters...opinion.

[grumpmonk]

anyone heard of Lisa Stansfield (shes a british R & B singer from the 80s/90s..Google her shes more than little bit like Siobhan. Let me know what think

[edie1231]

Siobhan is the best  singer on the show. Crystal needs a dentist & hairstylist badly.

[teamvampire4ever]

I love Siobhan! my two favs are Siobhan and Lacey but Lacey's not on it anymore. on tonights episode, lacey was in the audions! also, there was a guy who booed simon then go called to the stage! my mom was going to name me siobhan. but didnt

[sherbear2345]

she sings like a prepubescent

boy who is spurting pube scent.

why is her voice always cracking o_O

take care of your voice Siobhan, damn!

[generationaluv]

@sherbear2345 how exactly does a "prepubescent" sing? it's not like Siobhan has been a professional singer before...yeah she has some stage experience, but these kids are being put through the ringer all week long...you don't see that, all we see is the final performance. she has the chops, the looks, the stage presence, and that's all that is needed. when she is finsihed this show, she can hone her voice, jsut like all the other ones did that went onto bigger things!

[sherbear2345]

@generationaluv there's a reason why you don't see many artists screaming and it is because it damages your vocal cords. when i hear Siobhan Magnus that is what i ALWAyS hear! She has a great instrument, sure... but it will take a toll on her in the long-run. She gets a little throaty to me : /

"For the woman, the man is a means: the end is always the child." --Friedrich Nietzsche

[generationaluv]

@sherbear2345 U make a good point...however, in this song she doesn't scream, nor did she scream last night.

[bearnpici]

@sherbear2345 Oh bullshit. "the man is a means". Women stand on their own these days sweetheart and Siobhan shows huge independence and conviction. She is herself. There is a way to do high pitched notes without damaging your chords and lot has to do with vocal warm ups. When signed, she'll have the best of vocal coaches surrounding her. And what I love, is this is an example of a song were she is soft and sings openly from the diaphragm.

[sherbear2345]

@bearnpici Far too long has there been a slave and a tyrant concealed in woman. On that account woman is not yet capable of friendship: she knows only love.

In woman's love there is injustice and blindness to all she does not love. And even in woman's conscious love, there is still always surprise and lightning and night, along with the light.

As yet woman is not capable of friendship: women are still cats and birds.

Or at best, cows.

[bajingosister]

she's so good

[geminigirl5]

shes one of my favs, and shes from Mass!! :)

[JudaLebu]

Lebu: She's been my favorite for a long time. Even if she doesn't win, she's definitely going to be signed by someone

[dsscam]

I love her!! In my opinion, she'll win and beat Kelly and Carrie for most successful idol ever. She's AMAZING!

[qg6ff]

@dsscam hopefully

[charliebergy101239]

I love her voice-- so haunting and beautiful. And she transforms when she is on stage and does a great performance. I hope she is in the final with Crystal Bowersox!

[gonsalves10002]

damn, dark horse my a55 she is good nice smooth vocals potenial for world class artist. goodluck siobhan

[lynnegross]

Not to mention those eyes!!!!

[Timeswish]

the choir sucks

[generationaluv]

@Timeswish Maybe they'll get voted off tonite!!!! :)

[shaunlondon1978]

she truly is the best i have heard in an age.

her voice is so hauntingly beautiful

[generationaluv]

@shaunlondon1978 Totally!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[onysak88]

i agree....she is the only reason i watch this season too

[jttwiglam3]

Was scared when I heard she was gonna sing this(first time I heard her sing), but I was not dissapointed at all, She is the only reason I watch American Idol this year.

[nemebiax]

A modern day Linda Ronstadt. The most original singer of the group. A shame if she doesn´t wine

[ChicanoLA]

i can get with that comparison, especially in this song...not to many people can make haunting sound true and beautiful.

[amorosa4life]

i like her. i do. but sometimes it really sounds as if something is clogging her nose. idk what it is...

[generationaluv]

@amorosa4life reminiscent of a younger Barbara Streisand...which is never bad!

[Joshmania2008]

@amorosa4life lmao you would mention that, im just like that in a way, besides that i could care less if somethings clogging her nose

[bluewhale18]

possibly the best ever singer in Idol

prettiest for sure

[steelz78]

Too late, I'm already in love with Siobhan!!! She is unique right down to her not so common name and not so common vocal ability. Let's not forget that she is a cutie pie too.

[generationaluv]

@steelz78 Check out "Irish Central" website for her and both of her names' origins! very cool! I honestly think people are under-rating her on this show. it's like they don't want a runaway Idol this year! Crystal is good, but she is a 1 trick pony! SM is someone who owns all of music!

[generationaluv]

@steelz78 U have excellent taste in music my man! AIC is my fav....long live Layne! and this girl is spine-tingling good! it's like Layne...it (the voice) rips at your soul! damn, i can't stop listening/watching her!

ps. Jimi is the best guitarist ever!

[5275275275275]

it's nice to see that im not the only one who is crazy over this girl, everything about her, is amazing!!! voice, face, personally, "just the way she look's out to the crowd, just the way she talk's!!! Love the way she sings!! ive never voted before this girl, 50 times last week, 60 this week!!! YOU gota do the same!!! if your as crazy as i am, about her!! YOU!!! gota vote!!! or she will be gone!!

[generationaluv]

@5275275275275 well, I voted only like 10 times last nite for her! but I will step it up next week. I never voted b-4 either and have wacthed AI since Day 1. she is the best ever! last nite proved that! it's not even close now!

[evampily212]

my fav this yearrr :)

[JuliePrus]

she is the best singer, and has personality! stands out along with Didi!

[hmpayne]

LOVE her.. would buy her cd today

[raquellybelly91]

gorgeous

[Jennieispretty1]

she is my and my daughter fav this year as well!! hope she is the winner this year

[nemebiax]

the best Am Idol contestant to appear on this show

[shisitaro]

omg, can't wait till her next performance.

america has got the best idol ever!

[MrBoxGamer]

FTW!!!!

[NationalMan]

I want to fall in love with you Siobhan!

[generationaluv]

@NationalMan Yeah! I think America beat U 2 it! She is almost too good to be true! She could put out a cd today! GO Siobhan!

[squeakyben]

Go Siobhan,, your gonna go far!!!!!!!!!

[nemtall]

my fav this year,,

[mrcowboy69]

oh shit! 08 fosho! i sure hope she wins!!

[shibbymuch09]

siobhan graduated from my school in 08' she's such an amazing person aside from being an amazing singer. one of the nicest people i know. no one deserves this more than her. KEEP SINGING SIOBHAN! BARNSTABLE LOVES AND MISSES YOU!

[My1Lament]

anyone know what key this version is in?

[My1Lament]

anyone know what key this version is in?

[KeekDaSneak1]

This girl is the TRUTH! She has got my vote!

[generationaluv]

@KeekDaSneak1 seh got 12 from me!

[06wana]

Who could belt out Aretha? Its Siobhan!!! Your vocals are much better than Kelly Clarkson.

[alabamabregan]

She should win, but too quirky for mainstream America.

[candlelight1550]

She is wonderful!...love the tone of her voice....and the way the notes glide over her vocal chords....loved the song too...love u SIOBHAN!!!

[toomuchflesh]

She is so good. Either her or Crystal should win.

[js92every]

this is horrible i thnk she tone death and i see no talent when i hear her

[winterw00d]

i think you are tone death not siobhan

[ALEXMIKE98]

Couple more lessons on Rosetta Stone and you will be speaking English. Don't give up now...

[tmomof6]

i vomited in my mouth a little.

[LiquidJello090]

GO CONSTIPATE YOURSELF!

[DOMINIW5]

in my opnion her and crystal are the best singers but i got a feeling they are gonna say they dont know what kinda artist she wanna be cause i dont see pop but i see soul jazz or something

[adamlambertrules100]

I'll be SO happy if shes the american idol this year....but i have a feeling its gonna be crystal or cassey :/

[OxarkTom]

Similar background as Adam had, she is probably headed for the top three.

[LadySaundra]

This is what music is about..

[california24k]

where's the complete video i wanna hear the judges' comments.

[dafiki123]

Reading through the comments, I see I am not the only Adam fan here. I think Siobhan is unique and would benefit the music industry. Very different and interesting, and captivating performer.

[twotimeslucky]

this was amazing..she's got " it" .. i can't wait til her aretha franklin performance from last night is on here.. i was blown away.. she has by far, the best voice of this years girls.. i do also like crystal didi and lili, but siobhan is this years adam lambert.. amaziing!

[ChrisRushtonable]

she is like adam lamberts sister

[kirabee123]

I hope she wins!

[lina5565]

simply amazing!!!

[legnaleama]

she has a very nice voice, but they've destroyed that song, why all the great songs on these contests always loose their souls?

[albaril]

since audition, I really like siobhan....

[yyykkll]

I CANT BELIEVE I HAVE TO WAIT ONE MORE DAY TO WATCH HER PERFORM,,

I HAVE WAITED LONG ENOUGH FOR THIS

p.s. I LIVE IN ASIA SO I HAVE TO WAIT FOR DOWNLOAD TO WATCH HER SING..

[erinleighsays]

her song choice was different but amazing. this song by chris isaak is one of my all time favorites.

[christrfr]

No No No can't believe this. I'm almost 60 and have a crush on an Idol contestant. This chick is awesome

[pinksparklypig]

YAY! I SECOND THAT! I'm from the Philippines too and Siobhan is MY AMERICAN IDOL! Vote for her guys!!!!!! She's amaaazing!

[eratocharter]

She's got that Natalie Merchant thing going on. Sounds good.

[PaleLittleGirl1]

in a REALLY lackluster week, she really stood out! super talented!!!

[SophomoreSlump236]

So soothing.

[japeeisalwaysthebest]

Americans pls vote for Siobhan. I love her I want her to be the runner up and Didi is the winner

[lynnegross]

Mesmerizing.

[yyykkll]

i am havin' a serious crush with siobhan

[shellamae009]

w0w... ahmpf i watch american idol every wen and thursday... agmpf my favorite girl is siobhan magnus.. oh mY goSh.. shes sang that song i was outch.. i releat thats sonG.... i hope i can vote her.. plzz support siobhan magnus in american idol.................. here in phillipines siobhan is our american idoL.. ^^ QTV 11.....

[japeeisalwaysthebest]

@shellamae009

me too I love Siobhan. I live here Philippines. But my fave girl is Didi and next is Siobhan

[4becauseofyou4]

she's beautiful and i loveee this song for her, she's amazing!

[AddictiveSingin]

love her!!! my top 3: SIOBHAN LILLY AND ANDREW!!!!

[xxsam234xx]

That's so freaky! :), cuz that's my top 3 lmao

[snuggie007]

DIDO

[Jucejolly]

She is amazing!

What is bad is that if she wins they will make her sound like any other commercial girl, and she will loose her power. That was what happened with Adam... =/

[ZyrenDelacroix]

LOLwut?

Adam lost his power? What album have you been listening to?

[KeePtheFaitH1988]

@Jucejolly and thats why she need to be a runner up like Adam.. who is now shining and rockin the world!!! Maybe they could do a duet together- that would be EPIC!

[cuchi45]

I love her! INCREDIBLE VOICE and love the song by the way!!! She is interesting, dark, mysterious, sweet (as she said) , she has art in her veins!!! I can feel it!!!! She is different from all the others. I really hope she brings it every week because I want to see her WIN!!!!!

[dafiki123]

@cuchi45 I agree with your comment 100%

[xav17mgzn]

Siobhan Magnus, YOU ARE SO UNIQUE!!! YOU ARE THE NEXT AMERICAN IDOL or at least 1 rst runner up cuz you have the new gen sound down pat! beautiful girl, beautiful song, beautiful image. TRUE TALENT ...the next Kelly Clarkson!

[AdamLambertSpears]

i love her so much she is a great great singer i hope she wins!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[boomshak]

seriously, seriously cute.

[boomshak]

Mark my words, she is the second coming of Adam Lambert and everyone will tune in every week just to hear what she does next.

Hope the pressure doesn't get to her.

I have her and Crystal #1 and #2.

[jvmalum]

What a wicked, cool, relevant, young, Indie girl. hope she wins

[yukyo902]

she is awesome! I love her voice and the song :DD

hope she will last till the final! vote for her, guys!!

[NejiHyuuga1509]

she's the best. she's cute to. i can't wait to see what song she does next. i hope she goes far.

[Titototipopi]

Wow ..Nice High Voice like Adam Lambert.

[sunrisen62]

I love this girl!!!!!!

She gives me goose bumps with this song! I hope that she goes all the way.

She's at the top in my book!

[tatianaali93]

the vid's quality is shit!!

[perciray]

Siobhan, will resurrect idol's downward rating hope she stays humble & friendly. Cape cods contribution to IDOL... she really is FANTASTIC.

[osmin0784]

wowowo

[freduleror]

love her :)

[AdamLambertSpears]

she is Amazing - Siobhan Magnus and Lee Dweyze are the best this season. I also like Crystal, Katie and Didi

[xxsam234xx]

She DOES remind me of Adam lambert, that's probably why I love her so much, she has such a unique voice and personality, she's really cute too :) I hope she makes it to the finals

[LordRez78]

hey she's sang the song so much nicer! wow she's fantastic! i just love her!!!!!!!!

[cherry30005]

she was great and ilke the way she sang it better than the original. i never liked this song until i heard her sing it and now i do like it. great job

[yomismo74]

I was very dissapointed with top 24 this year, but this is good, i hope she stays in the show long time

[bouvier21]

she sent me to a different place while singing this. the only performer out of all 24 to get me really listening. hope she wins

[xrojerx]

oh id get mad if she doesnt win..also i like that long hair dude..forgot his name tho..oh eye candy guy..lol

[albertcrsp15]

The way she sang that song was so hypnotic it was awsome. She is going to win I'm sure of it.

[kbgeventer]

She's my favorite of the girls at this point. I like Crystal and Lily too, but Siobhan's performance really stuck in my head. I like that I can't wait to see what she is going to do next. That's one reason why I liked Adam Lambert so much last year as well.

[boomshak]

There's your winner folks.

She is the female Adam Lambert. He voice cuts through to your soul. Hard to believe the judges had anything but praise for this.

[monaJolly]

the most memrable performance. of the night...idk why the judges are against her...

she's my fav this season ..

[buzzyrecky]

My favorite performance, glad someone posted it

She sang it better than the original

[PrinceTian]

my favorite too! love this girl!

[love2beat]

this was the only song i really felt like getting after that night's performances. I think she did a great job for her first performance.

[lavane26]

really odd choice of song, but i think she totally pulled it off. she's got an amazing voice.

[pockyreiko]

She sang it perfectly, but everything else was working against her. The band needs to get their act together.

[isabel2589]

I love it! She is great and she sang it wonderfully!