@elizerxoxo Judging whether someone's singing or not by watching a video on YouTube is quite difficult in my opinion, the audio could easily be out of sync after the video was rendered.
amo a shakira.. pero en las ultimas presentaciones la veo un poco mas demacrada y con mas añitos de edad hehehe :D .. debe de ser por la giraa que esta haciendoo eso la debe tener un poco cansadaa.. pero igual te AMO!!!
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
This live singing stinks, more like Piuuuuu!!! than auuuu, She sings like shes on american idol and not going to Hollywood. Plus, u cant even understand her when she sings. Cant she wait to get home to ahve sex, looks like she wants to do the speaker box.plain ridiculous
Au début j'ai vraiment pas accroché mais ensuite aprés avoir entendu la chanson une ou deux fois je commence à bien l'aimer, comme je suis hispanophone j'ai également pu comprendre les paroles de la version espagnole, elles ont une certaine subtilité.
She practically always wears black, cant she come up with some more colors?? Her singing here stinks by the way!! Theres a Poo Poo in the closet, it smells bad that I cant breath PIUUU!!! Theres a Poo Poo in the closet, Take it out so I can breath Uhh huuu huuu LOL ,Go Britney #2!
@HernanCol her dad is Lenanese and her mother is Colombian and she is born in colombia..but u cannot forget that she does have a arabien side because of her father being Lebanese lol!!
Love the lights, the stage, She is so Hot, Sexy, Rich,Beautiful,Mamasita,Famous etc; and of course Sweet Heart.....Love u Shaki for helping the kids in your country..
all the moves she is doing is basically impossible because i sing at concerts and dont have a good enough diaphram to go very low and sing prfect and she can.. men have better diaphrams than woman..
i don't think she is miming, the fact that her lips are moving slightly out of tune is probably to do with the video being slightly out of sync. In the verses it definitely sounds like she's singing live
A couple of points: 1) that's her style of singing; 2) she's dancing and singing; 3) autotune and constant lip synching by poptarts have screwed up the average listener's perception of what live singing should and DOES sound like.
It used to be the imperfections that gave live AND studio performances their character and soul. Now everyone sounds like a god damn robot.
who cares if she is not singing in live, but is a real shakira, or u think she is not shakira???? i just care to see her performing, to see her that is a real shakira..Love u Shaki...
I think she sounds great considering the moves and disco pace of the song. And her dancing--I tried the routines, the popping, locking, gliding and bending and couldn't do it for my life. It's harder than you think and unquestionably unique. And I'm a latin dancer btw.
Check out my channel for hot women, Just made a hot women of 2009 compliation for the men of youtube. Simple if you like women you need to see this video
2:20
rachamore 1 week ago
I love her voice cause its so different and she's one of the few that actually sounds good live
phillyphan24 2 months ago
pause at 2:29
=D
tosonotorimi 4 months ago
love it
RuloisHot 8 months ago
If shes not going to actually sing she should at least move her lips in time with the music
elizerxoxo 1 year ago
@elizerxoxo Judging whether someone's singing or not by watching a video on YouTube is quite difficult in my opinion, the audio could easily be out of sync after the video was rendered.
Pugge1993 9 months ago
@elizerxoxo this is definitely live, the video is just slightly out of sync. when shakira lip-syncs it's way obvious, she sucks at it
mohit0702 1 month ago
amo a shakira.. pero en las ultimas presentaciones la veo un poco mas demacrada y con mas añitos de edad hehehe :D .. debe de ser por la giraa que esta haciendoo eso la debe tener un poco cansadaa.. pero igual te AMO!!!
flex5991 1 year ago
i love shakira
ChloeDust 1 year ago
She makes me wish that I were Colombian lol.
foreignboy221 1 year ago
She gets it on with... with a speaker? oh she's hot..
XicMalix 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
no tits - no voice
donnyscott1 1 year ago
nea tits - poor voice.
donnyscott1 1 year ago
lovely voice...and she really knows how to move that gorgeous body
440rko 1 year ago
she's got a great voice and a gorgeous body... the dancing is.. flexible lol
Ruud10Devil 1 year ago 3
She is really amazing, her music is great.
I love She Wolf album!!!
whiteandgreen1983 1 year ago
so beautiful!!!....hmm by the way who said that she can´t sing this song live....?
.....ok check it up!....and shut the F&&% up!
LucasBkillero26 1 year ago
sex
shooterwall 1 year ago
ahi que apoyarla comprando su album SHE WOLF!! :D
TDonaBarbaraM 1 year ago
hermosa como siempre.....
3014985656 1 year ago
no solo de colombiaa DEL MUNDO :D
camejoandres 1 year ago
shakira es fabuloza .... es lo mejorq d colombia ....... ella deveria ser la reina del pop .. no la veja d la madonna.. saludos desd venezuela
21086212 1 year ago
viva shakira duela a kien le duela
giomarelshakiro 1 year ago
Lol loveing the black guy on the keyboard
P0tbum 2 years ago 4
@P0tbum His name is Albert Menendez. He´s from Cuba
JohnA1980 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This live singing stinks, more like Piuuuuu!!! than auuuu, She sings like shes on american idol and not going to Hollywood. Plus, u cant even understand her when she sings. Cant she wait to get home to ahve sex, looks like she wants to do the speaker box.plain ridiculous
bewise08 2 years ago
shaki bn por tu presentacion super
P
E
R
F
E
C
T
A
jaco362 2 years ago 4
Au début j'ai vraiment pas accroché mais ensuite aprés avoir entendu la chanson une ou deux fois je commence à bien l'aimer, comme je suis hispanophone j'ai également pu comprendre les paroles de la version espagnole, elles ont une certaine subtilité.
GUESSWHO123ful 2 years ago
Love her!!!!! The BEst!!!
Eddie2412 2 years ago 2
She practically always wears black, cant she come up with some more colors?? Her singing here stinks by the way!! Theres a Poo Poo in the closet, it smells bad that I cant breath PIUUU!!! Theres a Poo Poo in the closet, Take it out so I can breath Uhh huuu huuu LOL ,Go Britney #2!
bewise08 2 years ago
love the lights stage
vicfue66 2 years ago
Dayum!!! She is HOT. Ala Colombiana.
DiNatalli 2 years ago
A la colombiana.
NovoBrooklyn 2 years ago 2
one of the sexiest women alive
jeminiany222 2 years ago 9
excelente stage!
great full color lights!
no room to dance...
aullaralaluna 2 years ago
She's colombian!!
HernanCol 2 years ago 6
@HernanCol her dad is Lenanese and her mother is Colombian and she is born in colombia..but u cannot forget that she does have a arabien side because of her father being Lebanese lol!!
feburary13 2 years ago
omg ........shes A gorgeous!!!!!!!!!
iloveshama 2 years ago 5
OMG I ADORE HER, She's perfect!! *^__,^*
I'm Colombian, And this is a proud....
*Love the drummer!! (Drooling) lol
embilak 2 years ago 7
she doesnt shake her booty in this performance as she does in her other ones
alaskacity 2 years ago 3
Love the lights, the stage, She is so Hot, Sexy, Rich,Beautiful,Mamasita,Famous etc; and of course Sweet Heart.....Love u Shaki for helping the kids in your country..
mexwau 2 years ago 4
She Is Fantastic What A Beautiful And Talented Woman She Is. Now That Is The Features Of A Fantastico Singer..x
TheShakirafan2009 2 years ago 7
i doooooooooooo
Gus1234Gus1234 2 years ago 2
i cant see the clip! i love shakira!!
carlosxtinajlo 2 years ago 4
all the moves she is doing is basically impossible because i sing at concerts and dont have a good enough diaphram to go very low and sing prfect and she can.. men have better diaphrams than woman..
chrisslashproduction 2 years ago 4
People don't be jelouse Britney is death as artist
georgemen2009 2 years ago 9
i don't think she is miming, the fact that her lips are moving slightly out of tune is probably to do with the video being slightly out of sync. In the verses it definitely sounds like she's singing live
hog3y 2 years ago 5
Gorgeous Colombian woman, doing her thing.
Viva Shakira!
JayPC21 2 years ago 23
the more I hear this song the more I love it
01irishgirl 2 years ago 6
no she is singing live this time watch her other perform. live she is lip syncing for alot of them but not this one an she isnt dancing to much
curvaciousMammi 2 years ago
Love it. Sure...
virginiourbina 2 years ago
pple missing the point thats her style of voice
wisdomistheway 2 years ago
POP QUEEN
hinchaamericano 2 years ago 11
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Same 'ol thing.
elevationnnnnn 2 years ago
AGREED!
LDN92 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I'm also a straight female - and find her very attractive.
But is it me, or is she not great at singing?
:S
LDN92 2 years ago
no one is live.
redcoatrifle 2 years ago
sorry, but when was the last time you did a half bridge while still singing...?
kirstyasher2 2 years ago
Never?
and i'm not trying to either, that's my opinion - yeah she can move, her voice isn't that good.
not trying to prove i can do that!
LDN92 2 years ago
A couple of points: 1) that's her style of singing; 2) she's dancing and singing; 3) autotune and constant lip synching by poptarts have screwed up the average listener's perception of what live singing should and DOES sound like.
It used to be the imperfections that gave live AND studio performances their character and soul. Now everyone sounds like a god damn robot.
howtofaint 2 years ago 9
I'm a straight female...but whoa she's hot. Like, insanely hot.
PreityLuva 2 years ago 51
I know exactly what you mean! She's just so sexy
AlicetheCamel7 2 years ago 8
I am in the same boat.
And hot is an understatement!
foreverkate 2 years ago
@PreityLuva Damn right
Axeface1 1 year ago
0.22-26 Some mad move going on with the right shoulder.
Benjani7 2 years ago 4
New Queen of Pop !
donniedarkUK 2 years ago 7
This comment has received too many negative votes show
miming at the worst!!!
BD5gangstar 2 years ago
I love Keytars
diamond3187 2 years ago
Shakira looked incredibly fit in that outfit. LOVED the way she gyrated, and contorted her body. She sure is very flexible > athletic, and energetic.
If I could have my way with her sexually, I would get seriously animalistic.
hicm1of12 2 years ago 5
<3 her
Menace2591 2 years ago 2
she's so fucking sexy
bobbobertson69 2 years ago 7
who cares if she is not singing in live, but is a real shakira, or u think she is not shakira???? i just care to see her performing, to see her that is a real shakira..Love u Shaki...
mexwau 2 years ago 5
that was not live at all
k0oki720 2 years ago
I dont know how can she go back down, thats kinda deangerous with her back. She must be becareful every time when she do that,.
mexwau 2 years ago
I LOVE SHAKIRA!!x
HelenDiazOfficial 2 years ago 2
Love the song, like Shakira, HATE miming, especially BAD miming :(
tedmagnum 2 years ago
the lights were so cool!
love her!
noelmsp007 2 years ago
POP QUEEN
hinchaamericano 2 years ago 5
I LOVE YOU SHAKIRA
Vidalin21 2 years ago 2
I love you SHAKIRA you are the best artist
quinuagomez 2 years ago 4
The Best She wolf performance
Serkiro 2 years ago 3
amazin'!
love it when she goes
awoooooo!
hehehaha! ;)
jasperhaleROXmaWORLD 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
not sure bout the song
improm2u 2 years ago
She is thousand times better than Beyonce.
In singing in beauty etc......
Nazar25 2 years ago 7
live live live five stars!!!
norika21 2 years ago 4
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Here wingcott the guy on the keyboard and u must be related cause ur both really really gay!
alisonisreallyhot 2 years ago
I LOVE THE GUY ON THE KEYBOARD!!
(right at the beginning) :P
WingCott 2 years ago 3
ye lol, his dancing is immense
93scarface93 2 years ago 3
it's LIVE! the band is also playing LIVE!
leduchiep 2 years ago
Wonderful that she singing live!!! I love her voice!!! 5 stars for you!!!
SaKuRa7913 2 years ago 4
Miming 100%!!!!!
Kev1982uk 2 years ago
she is singing live.
pannom15 2 years ago
lip synch??? where?? she is singing live
lebrunpaisa 2 years ago 3
she is singing the 1st and 2nd verse live its only the chorus that she is lip sync-ing! come on give her a break...she is great at what she does!!
aadriannsmhs2006 2 years ago
Fucking miming retard
jzelol 2 years ago
No sings live anymore you douches...... she is singing but they have the track playing in the backround, shes savage!!
fergietackerstt 2 years ago
SO COOL SHE IS A GODDES
MJQ78 2 years ago
nah you can hear that shes singing after the bit when she sings the 'awooo'.
you can hear the backing track thou lol
what an ass! :D
ddred13 2 years ago
What An Ass!!
Clearly Miming , Its Obvious ha
ako1993doyle 2 years ago
she is so miming its embarassing
modemwoody 2 years ago
lol.. she is not
lebrunpaisa 2 years ago
a goddess
h8meatspin 2 years ago
YOU ARE TOTALLY CORECCT
MJQ78 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
This sounds really bad, but she doesn't playback, that's lots better. And she dances like a wet dog
june9girl 2 years ago
I think she sounds great considering the moves and disco pace of the song. And her dancing--I tried the routines, the popping, locking, gliding and bending and couldn't do it for my life. It's harder than you think and unquestionably unique. And I'm a latin dancer btw.
korruptangell 2 years ago 2
Shes clearly miming here.
ksmxx 2 years ago
She didn't mime, the video's just out of sync.
Lewisk2008 2 years ago
don´t say something bad like this about shakira... she´s perfect
muldinsi 2 years ago
Jealous much
assezdansrose 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I just ejaculated..over my own face!
gamesmaster90 2 years ago
she is beautiful
Mrslovett401 2 years ago 4
wasnt really into her but this performance ad me howlin at the telly!! best bird out there!!
sausagewall 2 years ago
Shes a beauty!
underpantswedgy 2 years ago 2
Comment removed
elcesarcely 2 years ago
the most amazing woman ever...
elliotmurtaugh 2 years ago 4
part from mrs t
horselaverda 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
she fagget
AGuyWithDownsyndrome 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
she sings with a song (if that makes sense) she sings and mines basically
missuniverse678 2 years ago
beautiful woman, beautiful voice, beautiful body movements :-)
scott1990scott 2 years ago 7
This comment has received too many negative votes show
She looks like a retard trying to dance...at one point it looks like shes trying to wank her dick LOL 0:21 seconds....
Flamboyantkid1 2 years ago
I love her, awesome live performance!!
Eurofan26X 2 years ago 2
This was blatantly live! You can hear how she huffs and puffs like she does when she performed live on her DVD's.
Also, you can just tell if you know Shakira like a true fan!!!
Lo hecho esta hecho ;)
ILoveMrJM 2 years ago
Was She Scarry? =S I Love Her But... I don't like this Performance U_U
Josemaproductions 2 years ago
who gives a bollix if shes singin or not, just mute it and have a wank........
seanydee500 2 years ago 8
AHMEN
Flamboyantkid1 2 years ago
If it wasnt live then the howels in the chorus wouldnt be there, thats obviously her voice!
Ibanezer21 2 years ago
Yeah when she does the "a-wooo" you can hear the backing singers carry on the chorus.
kookie888 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
she unfit she maggets in her bum she is a she maggot
AGuyWithDownsyndrome 2 years ago
1:30
Donal111 2 years ago
this is live and stop hatin on shakira ... i actually like the song ANS SHES HOT :)
jakatak13 2 years ago
she is so fit !
12dommy12 2 years ago
defintiley!
underpantswedgy 2 years ago
of course its her singing watch her live on anything she never lip syncs
god wats the crac wit everyone gangin up on shakira, god !!!!!!!!
XxxSaraxxX2k8bby 2 years ago
do u sing ?
this is live...
just because she's not flapping her voice like they do on Americas got talent
FuriousBOIAngel 2 years ago
it's totally live. listen to the original...this is live.
korruptangell 2 years ago 2
brilliant !
what agreat performer !
donniedarkUK 2 years ago
i love this song and this womennnnnnnnn
Amazingggggggggg
She is so cute and lovely
:)
jucauca 2 years ago
she`s completely amaizing! she made me laugh on the intreview, she`s so smart and grounded. (beautiful, talented etc)
CristianoLavander 2 years ago
i agree she was a amazing , lovely person!!
XxxSaraxxX2k8bby 2 years ago
a woman, a wolf, a myth!!!!!!!
clois95 2 years ago
her voice was a bit shaky at the start but otherwise, good :)
HeWhoLovesTheWeb 2 years ago
Yeah I was thinking exactly the same thing and not just staring at her with my mouth open and dribbling on my shoulder!!!!!!!!!!!!!
IamaNihilist 2 years ago
Sexy body pop 3:01
kookie888 2 years ago
THIS IS LIVE!!!!! yey!! :)
moclov77 2 years ago
natz, this is LIVE ; this isn't playback. Gees people.
korruptangell 2 years ago
oh my, this is good
tomes55moon 2 years ago
she got maggets in er bum?
AGuyWithDownsyndrome 2 years ago
1:30 sutch a sexy butt moves!
It drives me crazy
shmurklamashas 2 years ago
gostosa
jony24121 2 years ago
mr. bassman, see the interview preceding this performance and then you'll see who the tart is: YOU!
korruptangell 2 years ago
yeah..like that makes any sense!!! idiot
mrbassman25 2 years ago
The way her ass moved , I'm its illegal in some countries!
Kaneoism 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
best song ever!!
guppy4661 2 years ago
PERFECT! Great moves, singing, looks, clothes.
<3 Shakira.
korruptangell 2 years ago
ai na minha umilde residencia, muito gostosa , putz .
fdfdfd14 2 years ago
man she's hot and all but if she started shackin out like that near me i'd have to deck her
oebs1 2 years ago
She Wolf Album out October 12th/13th... Buy it!
HurlingVictim 2 years ago
she's the best...
I lov Her
shak2412 2 years ago
can anyone tell me what "jajajaj!!" means
Lotrioni 2 years ago
It's spanish for hahahaha.
You pronounce it like hahaha, either way.
Micamelus 2 years ago
laughing in spanish lulz
shakiluvr 2 years ago
its hahaha
chikbadger 2 years ago
She's perfect.
YouKnowWhereThisEnds 2 years ago
shes hot. and (hopefully) not big headed.
hassmann2000 2 years ago
hmmm
FidgetHermz 2 years ago
A dança é de menos ai, importade que ela é muito boaaa. OoOoooo la em casa
menali07 2 years ago
LINDAAAAAAAAAA.
SuperGCO 2 years ago
Não é porque ela não dança do jeito das outras que ela não sabe dançar, ela sabe SIM, e muuuito!
Shakira ARRAAAAAASA! x3
alde016 2 years ago
OMG!! I LOVE SHAKIRA SO MUCH!!I
juicespirit 2 years ago
that is one amazing hinnie! i want to be friends with it!
87captainawesome 2 years ago
Best friends.
turxxx 2 years ago
she is amazin
deusdo 2 years ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Check out my channel for hot women, Just made a hot women of 2009 compliation for the men of youtube. Simple if you like women you need to see this video
Morbazon 2 years ago