I think it was a very good student video. In addition to getting the plot lines correct (like the Lucia). I would encourage pronouncing the names correctly. But I agree good tribute to the original
Good video. But you did make a few little errors. Lucia killed Arturo, the man she had just gotten married to on their wedding night. She did not kill her maid Alyssa.
I love this. Great intro to opera for beginners. However I think Merry Widow's status as an opera is debatable. It's really more of an OPERETTA which uses opera styles but is more like an early version of Broadway musical sung in German. Strauss made a lot of them and they are at most mini-operas.
It became opera after it was a play. In the 19th century, French composer Charles Gounod made it into an opera. Shakespeare's plays made it into opera. Verdi especially loved Shakespeare and turned Macbeth, Othello and Falstaff into operas.
This is terrific! My name is Kim Thompson, I made the original "All the Great Operas" short film and I love your sequel! Thanks so much, it really made my day!
you mean that was you who made that video with carmen, mme. butterfly, tosca, etc? that was soooo funny!!! -the ring...was my favorite- please, do more, and make your version of la bohéme, otello, turandot...
I think it was a very good student video. In addition to getting the plot lines correct (like the Lucia). I would encourage pronouncing the names correctly. But I agree good tribute to the original
tiggernstitch 11 months ago
Good video. But you did make a few little errors. Lucia killed Arturo, the man she had just gotten married to on their wedding night. She did not kill her maid Alyssa.
AmericanEvita 2 years ago 7
I love this. Great intro to opera for beginners. However I think Merry Widow's status as an opera is debatable. It's really more of an OPERETTA which uses opera styles but is more like an early version of Broadway musical sung in German. Strauss made a lot of them and they are at most mini-operas.
MastersoftheOpera 2 years ago
I agree that the Kim Thompson version is much more humorous. This was a student project.
tulsasas 3 years ago 4
Thanks for the effort. However I think the Kim Thompson version was much more humerous.
Quasimodo1957 3 years ago 2
Romeo and Juliette isn't an opera, it's a play.
Unibrow001 3 years ago
Actually, there are two operas based on Romeo and Juliette. One is by Gounod and one by Dusapin.
tulsasas 3 years ago 6
And Bellini's i Capuleti e i Montecchi
NannerlSullAria 3 years ago 2
Don't forget about Prokofiev's and Tchaikovsky's takes on Romeo and Juliet.
Zetapie 3 years ago
And if you really want to get into it, there are several ballet versions too. :)
figskatefan 2 years ago
It became opera after it was a play. In the 19th century, French composer Charles Gounod made it into an opera. Shakespeare's plays made it into opera. Verdi especially loved Shakespeare and turned Macbeth, Othello and Falstaff into operas.
MastersoftheOpera 2 years ago
This is terrific! My name is Kim Thompson, I made the original "All the Great Operas" short film and I love your sequel! Thanks so much, it really made my day!
cheers
kim
kimandlizzie 3 years ago 15
you mean that was you who made that video with carmen, mme. butterfly, tosca, etc? that was soooo funny!!! -the ring...was my favorite- please, do more, and make your version of la bohéme, otello, turandot...
this video was also very good, guys!
leonengard 3 years ago
Thanks so much for your comment. My students have loved the original for years and just wanted to homage in some way with this sequel.
tulsasas 3 years ago 2
you = my hero :)
lucyliesinashes 2 years ago