Anna Netrebko - Vedrai Carino - Don Giovanni

[Wamofan]

Listen to the Gold Standard = Erna Berger's Vedrai carino (1953) and compare.

[GiuseppeSaronno]

Molto fredda...come il 90% delle sue interpretazioni...

[pinomarra43]

grandissima anche alla SCALA

[moonpearl666]

She has a GREAT voice but, like me, she may have problems with consonants. A lot of opera singers do. For example Sarah Brightman and her rendition of Phantom of the Ah-Bra.

[Markeygirl]

You bunch head up your arses!! She has a beautiful voice... get over yourself over inflated sense of yourselves!!

\

[bluewavesboi]

SHe is hot mmmmm



[climbnprana]

Are there performance enhancing drugs in singing too? I kid I kid. Damn, but did she ever score with beauty and talent.

[sparrowmeyer]

i dont know about all you haters, but i like it!!!

[dibladiblup]

Das ist echt schrecklich.

[BillH00d]

@dibladiblup Agreed!!!!!

[BillH00d]

Respond to this video... Ugly is the word for that voice!

[Songbird117]

her voice is too much... it makes this sound boring...

[numetutelare]

@Songbird117 Ma a ,lei non importa nulla! Canta tutto ed in tutti i ruoli... crede di avere i registri di contralto, mezzo, soprano leggero, coloratura, drammatico e lirico. Dio é grande ma non fa pasticci!!!

[Cissy97]

yes, always - been over-parted in operatic roles.

Her's is a lyrical spinto in the making, even more than a full lyrical soprano, but she insists on 'light' roles liek soubrette, coloratura leggiero......

With such a full voice and without the finishings of a Joan Sutherland, she handles the coloraturas with frequent smudges that should not have happened at all had she diligently stuck to her true repertoire of lyrical soprano.

[osinging]

Compare with this:

Erna Berger.

youtube.com/watch?v=lmkSuMyLHD­A&feature=related

[PeaceLoveFaith08]

I sang this song as a sophomore for disrticts and state in choir!:D

[osinging]

@PeaceLoveFaith08 You are probably better than this also. :)

[sobefobik]

It seems that a lot of people don't like this lady. Why is that?

[operafanize1]

Zerlina is not for soubrette.This is for mezzosoprano or for low soprano

[classicalgal14]

I love Anna but yes this aria is too small for her voice she deserve bigger :) Like Tosca ;)

[Poantsiki]

The Paris Hilton of the Opera World!

[hammer55292]

Anna got destroyed by the critics for her San Francisco and Met tours. She is having great problems lately. I knew it would happen.

[hammer55292]

Anna got destroyed by the critics for her San Francisco and Met tours. She is having great problems lately. I knew it would happen.

[hammer55292]

Anna got destroyed by the critics for her San Francisco and Met tours. She is having great problems lately. I knew it would happen.

[xx1625]

She shouldn't sing Zerlina cuz it's not for his voice, she's not soubrette... not at all

[hhaidar09]

She is a second class opera singer. Lousy technique and she wobbles rather than uses correct vibrato. It is a pity that people buy this "act". Just because she's pretty and goes out half naked for every concert doesn't mean she's good enough to be a star.

[tonchik101]

I haven't heard much of her music, but this seems wonderful!

I especially understand that this woman is a great singer by how much a certain few individual dislike her.

This shows that there is something to be jealous of, for jealousy or revenge is the root of all hate, and only jealousy is applicable in this instance.

[PhoenixFlowerSophia]

@tonchik101 What you say is definetely not always true. People don't dislike her because of jealousy. It's just that some have spent many years studying music and don't apperciate mediocre people passing for divas. Anyone with even a tiny knowledge about music and operatic singing can see that she is far from good. Hope I din't offend anyhow. :)

[maa10able]

People, do no mind hammer55292 (former striker) - he is a you tube idiot and everyone knows that.

Striker - you are going to die a terrible violent death - you deserve it for insulting a baby and a great soprano.

[striker9410]

Yes, it appears that Anna is very deficient in many technical areas. Her career will not do well. I believe that child of hers is destroying her practice and training sessions.

[striker9410]

Dr. Leoperarm, as a Professor of Music, could you please give an analysis of Ms. Netrebko's technical qualifications? I believe she is deficient in many areas, and relies on visual impressions to carry her through difficult arias. Thank you Professor, I anxiously await your reply.

[hammer55292]

@Royhorse1 HA!HA!HA!HA! Anna stinks!! Not only does she have bad ASS ODOR, but her singing is declining! She is not training and practicing properly. She spends too much time with that muppet of hers Toledo, eating ice cream, and getting fat. BLAH ANNA!

[Royhorse1]

Leoperarm and Striker9410 are a couple of bastards, conspire against Anna Netrebko, here test what I say. The two, Striker9410 and Leoperarm make a friendship to commit crimes.

[glitters22]

every word is felt but never overdone. it's much more lyrical.

[cherrypuff4]

A great artist like Anna Netrebko has a powerful voice and a great expansion of sound.

[Razor5740]

Wonderful!

[Megara33]

She's not fat--she just had a baby in September 2008!

[Razor5740]

Is it a boy or a girl?

[Razor5740]

The baby, is it a boy or a girl?

[cherrypuff4]

Her baby is a boy.

[cherrypuff4]

His name is Tiago.

[striker9410]

Smoldering SOUBRETTE!

[tissetatten]

love her.. do your thing gurl!!!!!!!!

[Julianabischoff]

kakakakakaka!!!!

[Kuririn08]

She shouldn't sing Zerline! Her voice is not made for soubrettes. You can't even really understand , what she is singing. For a soubrette role impossible to imagine...

I don't why someone could call this the definite version..

[Spiceofmadrid]

@Kuririn08 I agree. Why is she singing this?! Probably to get famous.

[baritonebynight]

@Kuririn08 I'm no fan of Anna Netboko in this role either.

[osinging]

@baritonebynight Or any other. Erna Berger for me (well, I'm biased).

[striker9410]

Yes, it's just been reported that Anna will not play La Scala!!! I told you all, she was afraid to play there!! The AFFICIONADOS will greet her with fine, ripe tomatos from the hillsides of Milan!!

[leoperarm]

such a shame! I'd fly to Italy to see the tomato thing xDDDD

[maggeo78]

Yes come to Italy XDDDDDDDDDDDD

[maggeo78]

Yes she will sing in 2011....

I don't know if she will be greet with tomatos XDDDDDDDD

Anyway I will be @ la Scala to see jijijijijiji

[leoperarm]

don't you waste your money if you are not sure of the tomatoes ¬¬

[leoperarm]

By 2011 lady Anna will be FAT and VOICELESS. I have great expectations, Professor Striker xD

[maggeo78]

XDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD­DDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDDD Prof Leoperarm ahaahahahahahahahahahahahahaha­hahahahahahahahahahahahah

Questa è buona jijijijijijijijijijijijijijiji­jijijij

[Spiceofmadrid]

@leoperarm Lol!!!

[FlyingElephant20]

Message me the date of tomato festival in Milan.

[striker9410]

MAGGEO 78, OK, can you be our official reporter of Netrebko's performance at La Scala!!! I will put it on my calendar, and we will anxiously await your report.

Oh, by the way, do you like Diana Damrau by any chance?

[maggeo78]

XDDDDDDDDDDD We will see! Anyway 2011 is not so far. This year there will be Schrott's Don Giovanni....

I don't like Diana Damrau... I love Diana!!!!

[classicalgalNYC]

@striker9410 She is scheduled to sing late this year in Don Giovanni at La Scala but as Donna Anna ;)

[ad80ad]

Instead I think this is the only modern performance that can compete with Schwarzkopf one. Anna is doing an immense effort to clean out all the shit accumulated on singing style in 40 years of pure trash and shameful circus freak underculture who dominated everywere. And La Scala, the theatre of the most provicial and arretrate musical country of contemporary world, won off course first prize of this ridicolous trash "do di petto" subculture. What a big load of ignorants, my God.

[Trowkr]

Which singer do you mean 40 years ago? There were nobody to be worthy to be called as opera singers. Only Anna. NO opera singers exist before Anna.

[leoperarm]

ARE YOU SERIOUS??? please tell me you both are joking!

[Trowkr]

We are not joking. This is the definitive version you will find. It has been approved by critics and musicians worldwide.

[leoperarm]

Ridiculous! The 'definitive' version could probably be the one that Mozart actually conducted, don't you think? The definitive version recorded should be one on period pitch and by a true soubrette.

I would like to know the names of your called critics and musicians (as if you were one).

To think that this is the definitive version (which I casually found and uploaded to Youtube) is just a stupid (excuse me) idea.

[Trowkr]

A soubrette doesn't sing professionally. Anna is more than soubrette. She's better than the definitive version. All the musicians and critics who have watched her said she's very beautiful voice.

[leoperarm]

Names of the critics and musicians please.

Professional Soubrettes: Lucia Popp, Ileana Cotrubas, Kathleen Battle, Dawn Upshaw, Barbara Bonney, Graziella Sciutti; even Cecilia Bartoli, Natalie Dessay and Diana Damrau have performed soubrette roles... are they not professional??? BE SERIOUS!

Who are you to say that Battle or Popp were not professional?

[happytalk94]

Joan Sutherland. Oh yee of little faith.Learn more before making foolish comments.

[Raisilwen]

I'm a big fan of Anna Netrebko but unfortunately, his aria is not for her.

[winston874]

what is for her?

[mtnmanjt]

Why no La Scala for Netrebko?? Is she not good enough?? Popera/MTV girl!!

[classicalgal14]

I agree :)

[Charna777]

too big voice for a soubrette role

[classicalgal14]

True enough, Donna Anna is her best from this opera absolutely divine :)

[TheOnlyOriginalKebim]

the same with her susanna. just sucks. and for this skipping i hate her.

[thugman30]

Sounds like she wearing a nose clip.

[eradesso]

Will someone make this woman sing Micaela or Pamina?

Of course she won't. Those aren't the leading roles or prima donnas. She just wants the popular arias, she just wants to be famous. She wants to touch the ears of those who don't know the difference between a role and another.

It is very sad.

[eradesso]

as opposed to you being a very well known looser, poser and groupie. you already made the history of youtube!

[mtnmanjt]

Sorkin, are you, Bellafredina, and Filaredo paid to bring criticism against Netrebko? If not, you should be. Your comments are bringing a global wave of scrutiny and criticism against Netrebko.

[winston874]

paid against or paid for defending?

[mtnmanjt]

NO Sorky, she will NEVER sing at La Scala! Why no La Scala??? Why not????

Is she afraid to sing at La Scala? If she's as good as you say, why no La Scala??

She will need her Tomato-Proof Helmet, if she goes there!!

[classicalgal14]

@eradesso Actually she sang Micaela at Vienna State Opera this past May 2010 she was amazing! :)

[thugman30]

Shrill interpretation. Her lyric voice is worse than coloratura.

[vittorja123]

Mozart is not Verdi. I think she is not well versed to sing classical arias, especially Mozart. Lighter voice is needed!

[OperaGIRL777]

OMG! Where did you find this recording???

[awixa2]

Her "Air de Bijoux" from Faust is delightful

[eradesso]

delightful? she doesn't sing a single trill in it lol

[awixa2]

well, I'm prejudiced inher favor, maybe everything she does is not perfect, but her voice and beauty are undeniable...she adorns any stage

[psych006]

wow lol everyone's comments are super negative i find this funny, not one nice comment lol.

[sorkin777]

psych006, there losers leave negatine commnets on Anna's pages beacuse they cannot stand her talen and success,

it is very sad

[fairlytaleofnewyork]

No no no no no!

[welovegorillas]

Sorry but can't stand the wobble, not open and bright, not appropriate for anything but certainly not for Mozart.Could we have more proper Bel Canto please?!

[Lindoron]

I want to see and hear her as Donna Elvria or Fiordiligi.

[eradesso]

She graced us with a horrible Donna Anna though.

[madziua90]

what?? she did 'non mi dir' very good and beautiful..

[serRudyll]

sorry, i DON'T like it. But i'll rate, anyway! This aria should be sung quite, cutely and caring. But everybody knows Netrebko just can't do that.

[fairlytaleofnewyork]

I agree with you. Zerlina is not for her

[Hollowfernes]

Her voice is too big for Zerlina. I don't think she's bad, it's only that other roles suit her better.

[leoperarm]

May I ask the people who like it to please rate? Thank You!