陶吉吉 - 愛我還是他 MV

[Elegyofhappiness]

我好入戲.



[martymaherb]

mv 看了很火大

[ohohohohnonoohoh]

既然你最後還是選擇了元配,那又為什麼當初要來招惹我呢?我拒絕­,我忽視,我推開你一次又一次,因為我的理智知道這樣不對...­但又為什麼當我最後真的愛上你時,你卻把我丟在原地去和她結婚?­為什麼要這樣玩弄人?我才不要當你們之間的試煉!我也是人,我也­會痛會哭會難過,你到底憑什麼這樣子傷人...

[Elegyofhappiness]

@ohohohohnonoohoh 我們都是會哭的人 我們只想找個陪伴 只是事與願違  真相總是傷人 開心點: )) 不值得為他難過: )))

[Orz0717]

來看林可彤的 .. 看來美女真的比很多好音樂都重要 .. 有誰是來聽好音樂的麼 ? ..

[Meyoyoyoyoyo]

是很像洪金宝。。哈哈

[acasunny]

陶喆這個壞蛋!

[leannecarol]

向來第三者總是被人唾罵破壞完好感情的人，但何曾想她之所以成功­地介入，是否又意味着原來的感情早已有缺口？ 第三者也是人，愛從來不是容易的事，她同樣地付出心力、感情。感­謝演出及製作MV的各人，令我感受如此深，太棒了:)

[johnwu1125]

剛看完康熙 現在來看林可彤.... 原來大家都一樣, 下一個該不會是劉德華吧?

[andyboy76815]

林可彤長髮比較好看!!

[Phijay37]

看完康熙來找林可彤的XD

[lovekpopsong]

@Phijay37 我也是耶~

[jennteo1]

Listening to the song, I thought the story is about David's girl is caught in betwen two men. Disappointing that its the old story again.

Disappointed with his latest album too. What's has change David Tao - fame? lots of money? lots of women? His music is reflecting himself. I sure hope David wakes up soon.

[sn1020]

短頭髮的女人感覺就很會殺價 吵架

[terrisahu]

i love him, but he's ugly... i think richie ren is a lot more handsome than him...

[TDEVOLI]

陶吉吉的歌真是越聽越有味道，第一次聽可能沒有怎樣，但是他的音­樂是會嵌進心口的。

[henry60808]

最後一段:紅玫瑰與白玫瑰

[demei0615]

借分享唷!!! 謝嚕^^

[chelseakhoo]

i love the song ... but i dont understand the meaning about this video ==

[A9041513]

In my opinion

red rose means sex, while white rose means love

we may desperately pursue sex, not permanently.

what we need permanently is LOVE

[diabolowhite]

谁知道开头音乐曲？

很熟悉，但是想不起来……



[Cinderella122278]

@diabolowhite

Debussy, Clair de lune：）

[adia87]

吃過再 say sorry 喔，爛人

[fai091999]

= =

[iloveddt]

4:15 

[luivayu]

0:55. 洪金宝

[waisight]

@luivayu lol...好像丫,,,



[goo6132]

@luivayu 山寨版的= ="

[jacky94609]

@luivayuMD你超好笑 = =

[herouuu1]

@luivayu 這樣你都能發現 真的超屌的啦...幾像的

[zhanzack]

我比较喜欢 白玫瑰...=P

[tingchane]

其實兩人都是傷的，最後就算復合一定心中都有各自的遺憾。

而最傷的大概就是一直陪在身旁的女人，因為世上最殘忍的事情就是­明明知道他心中有人，但卻要假裝不知道

[TDEVOLI]

DT, you have to continue to sing... please come back to music after you have fulfilled your movie director's dream... the Chinese pop music scene will be a yawn without your soulful presence!

[zhq09Y]

最后那个觉悟让我很感动 

[TheMrAceX]

@zhq09Y .........

[chloe0725]

安全牌吧!先後不是問題，問題是哪個女人可以讓他有安全感?最後­的港灣，未必是自己愛的那個人。

[farewellmy93]

多清楚明白的現實阿！感情就是這樣，更不用說是婚姻。

跟你一起走最後的那位男子...他心中的最愛的根本不是你

他不是選擇『你』，也不是跟『你』在一起...

男人選擇的是『安全感』，他要得是跟『安全牌』在一起！

別傻了，他愛得不是你！！！

[kurrencyyy]

馬厝卡

[kurrencyyy]

classsical piano deeping abstract

[quecool]

he born in shanghai mailand

[stacysawera]

谁也怪不了谁，怪不了出愧的他，也怪不了做第三者的她。。。因为­爱情就是那么的自私，那么的不道德。你永远都不会在一个人的身上­得到你所想要的全部，人永远都不会满足，这就是为什么很多现在的­人都出愧。。。谁也怪不了谁。。。

[jojosan3068]

@stacysawera

說的真是好

愛情的確是自私的

正確來講

每個人都是自私的

愛情由不得我

要怪誰...

又該恨誰呢

[stacysawera]

@jojosan3068

是呀， 爱情。。。 让人变得面部全非。。。

[jojosan3068]

@stacysawera

沒錯!

愛情讓人面目全非，怨天怨地也改變不了什麼，你說的很好，每個人­都不滿足，只是夜深人靜時候，總會讓我又想起到她....很多事­總是問不出個所以然，總是克制自己不想再思念她，但總是無意識又­想起來，真正困擾我或許就是這個原因吧!



[telcom6661]

Why no body consider the feeling of the red shirt girl. I stand with her.

[kikkolee]

@telcom6661 cause ur a slut

[efish321321]

好終於原著〈紅玫瑰與白玫瑰〉

請問導演是？

[Zenxhaze]

到最後還是選了本來的女朋友。

時先後問題吧。

[bignissan66]

這種事...我一輩子辦不到...

因為我知道罪惡感會殺死我

最令人難受的不是失去的心痛

而是背叛人之後衝擊自己的罪惡感

因為心痛只要找到下一個就會獲得平復

而罪惡感卻會糾纏自己一輩子...

[bignissan66]

更正"我可能一輩子辦不到"

因為把話說死了好像被詛咒似的-.-

[hpy1210]

好像都有這樣的人在感情世界裡穿梭 打擾安寧 也或許感情已經變質...

[kollipoping]

nice old song

[SuperBshit]

i see him acting as an educated, attractive asshole in this mv. i luv this song tho.

[tungtungchiu]

應該係講緊個長髮女仔既~~

[Jayteewoofed]

I'd go for the innocent white one, she's much more prettier than the red one

[hurryporter]

短髮的比較漂亮

[cutedoll1000]

bothg gals are so pretty

[charlenechc]

心有戚戚焉....說出內心的掙扎

[funleongch]

tats wat makes tis song interesting

cz the guy sang the girl's feelings...and the Question u love me or her....but in chinese wording ppl owes tot the word "ta" reveal him, but actually is "her"

[pzb1937]

陶喆在MV裡面 好壞喔!!

[nckuyuting]

紅玫瑰的艷跟野,白玫瑰的靜默卻潔淨

that's it!!

[wanini21]

Eaaa claro de luna

[BaBiijo520]

姐係佢要白色個位定係紅色個個!?

[heikoyh]

这歌貌似应该是女的对陶喆唱才对丫。。。

[XxGinoDxX]

he proposed to the long haired girl.

[kuiztopher]

是不真的她有比我好

你回到她身邊

是因為不愛我ma

[0530erica]

我很无奈.....他的心中还有她.......

[zbxxxx]

每次聽都想哭

[Apt192]

「我覺得要堵我的嘴的話，只有一個方法．．．」, lust lust lust, mmmm... 男女感情總是這麼百般糾纏無奈。

[lolaiieng]

點解愛情往往要有先後之分? 第三者總是輸的!

[howieting]

瞿穎好美~簡直是才子配佳人~個mv由平靜到激情嘅感覺~拍攝手­法有序~有感受~觸動心寧~眼神中流露著現實的無奈~絕~!!!­

[tubeloving]

i think it's simpler than that.

He is caught between two contrasting women in his life, the innocent white and wild red. based on the story of Chang Ai Ling's "Red Rose & White Rose"

In the end he says sorry to both girls, and we don't know who he was proposing to. Tao left the ending ambiguous on purpose.

[jacky8077616]

anyone know the piano in the beginning of the video?

邊個知道一開始個鋼琴係乜啊??

thxxx

[mozarrowitz]

Clair de Lune composed by Claude Debussy

[LyricAce]

Clair De lune, Debussy

[chilluout]

debussy: clair de lune. it is also known in english as moonlight

[junkoohan]

who do you love..?

[a6123annie]

喜歡這MV

[ale03000]

原来是爱我还是她，多谢！！！

[954849]

我覺得又是周格泰拍的mv

[tvbifreak]

do you know if david tao has any fast songs or ones with a quicker beat?

[088x088x088]

I believe he has several that has a faster beat. I don't really listen to his songs so I couldn't tell names. Sorry!

[myacnt8999]

actually i could say 80% of his songs are light RnB/pop songs. i actually don't know all of his songs, but i like his songs like ai hen jian dan, melody, tian tian, liu sha...he's the godfather of chinese RnB. he is well-known for his amazing live performances.

[tvbifreak]

david's tao's live performances are amazing

[lmicss]

是林錦和導演喔

[954849]

喔喔 是喔 因為周格泰拍的都特別長

原來是林錦導演 呵呵

[deadbanana]

Does anyone know the piano in the first 50 seconds of this music video? its so famaliar but i cannot pin point where i know it from.

[marvelouise]

Clair de Lune by Debussy

[retta53]

nice video. David Tao is a favorite of mine. also claire de lune is a classic....

[schase10353]

Can someone help me find a way to learn this on the piano? I'm having a hard time figuring it out on my own. I speak chinese ok, but I don't read it. So, I'm having a hard time finding it.

[Cathedrial]

wonderful. it's the highest level of kiss drama in every MVs filmed by chinese director I've ever seen,

[mixedups]

what is this video so long??

[jiduziwo]

我喜歡 陶吉吉﹐

不過 7:50, 他從紅玫瑰床上起來時,

露出的 t-shirt 跟深色boxer

真的讓氣氛整個鳥掉

可惜紅玫瑰還穿那麼漂亮的浴袍

王力宏可以出來一下嗎﹖

[bullshit198800]

better than other

[chan808yuen]

幹多一次才說不可以這樣下去 太爽了吧

[teddycheong]

anyone know what's the piano part at the beginning call??

[jazzinretro]

Claro de luna  - Debussy

[wamooo]

良い曲だね～まじで

我喜欢这首歌!真好听，动人。

[teddycheong]

what's the song played in the beginning again??

[naitomeamogu]

are you japanese?i wish if i could understand chinese!

[wamooo]

yes I'm Japanese. I have studied Chinese for 3 years.

[faynestwater]

张爱玲的"白玫瑰与红玫瑰"?

[760330197]

沒腦子的男人.和傻女人!!(我是指劇情)

結局很爛!!男人哪!!自以為是的東西!!

陶唱得很棒也演得不錯

[pukitiu]

好料喔！百听不厌！！！

[felixten]

我喜欢白衣的女孩儿，讨厌红衣的...简直狐狸精！

[sophia0324]

不是新歌

聽起來 配上畫面

還是有不同的感受

很棒......

[SnowFilly]

Pretty voice......but players can go 2 HELL! lol

[GeeksGetGirls]

he's not handsome but he's sexy one of the best Taiwanese singers

[ahhe1986]

i think he very lose his face from doing this mtv,because he is not handsome and why wanna two girls love him, he pursuit a girl with a man better lah!

[Hardbeez]

The 2 girls love him because he is talented and fucking rich!!

[TiptheJester]

Really good singer... but what a crappy storyline to MV... xD its not to normal logic that he ask her to marry him...

[ccha9999]

So who does he ask to marry? His girlfriend or his mistress?

[anfernee1111]

Girlfriend.Because he've told the other he wants to stop that affair

[cobs1130]

but did he still love her?

[anfernee1111]

Best among the chinese singers~

[iwao1986]

Ｄａｖｉｄ　ｉｓ　ａ　ｇｅｅａｔ　ｓｉｎｇｅｒ！

[slahonevdleyly]

i don't get it =[

[pheelyhsm54321]

cheaters...