this is live.she had a good day. you can tell the small differences from the album version, especially at the belting parts. if you cant tell the differences, you simply don't know this song well enough.
The only thing live about this performance was the background singers. I still have not seen a video of this song where she performed this live. She is lipping.
@LoboAscuridad1 they both lipped it and i said joe lip synchs terribly because it's like a proof that it's lipped. and it's kind of obvious that mariah in 2000 could sing exatcly like she did on the album (all those F#5's and F5's without even 1 point in the whole song that was different than the studio version. she didn't even do it in her prime.
@LoboAscuridad1 no i said mariah is lipping here because it sounded 100% like the album version and mariah never sounds 100% like the album version, not even in her prime. :) mariah always sang live in her prime! :)
@LoboAscuridad1 on the rainbow tour and AMA's performance :) she rarely lips on those big award shows (ama's vma's grammys etc...) i love the one she did in Milan (on the rainbow tour)
i dont think its lipped, i think the person who put this video onto youtube has put the song over the top of the video and made it soundlike it was live, becuase the music sounds to like the song as well and you cant hear them breathing. she wouldnt have lipped, its just the song over the performance
I love Mariah, but this sounds exactly like the studio version...I'm not going to say it was a lipped performance, but I am skeptical about it being live...but I still love Mariah.
Both Joe & Trey Lorenz are in the video with mariah carey, inspirational.
MDAPioneer2010 2 months ago
she never sang this song live
TheMushroomville 3 months ago
this is live.she had a good day. you can tell the small differences from the album version, especially at the belting parts. if you cant tell the differences, you simply don't know this song well enough.
davidchubo 5 months ago
The only thing live about this performance was the background singers. I still have not seen a video of this song where she performed this live. She is lipping.
nicholask95 5 months ago
Im a lamb too... But c'mon guys this is lipped... -__-
theovanua 8 months ago
BTW for live performances of this song you can search in her Rainbow tour or the one in the AMA's
iiAmitx3 1 year ago
guys im a lamb and im telling you it's lippe
1. it's completely like the album version
2. Joe is a horrible lip syncher
3. YOU NEED TO LEARN TO ACCEPT SHE CAN'T ALWAYS SING LIVE AND SHE DOESN'T (THANK GOODNESS SHE DOESN'T)
iiAmitx3 1 year ago
@iiAmitx3 Joe Lip syncing has nothing to do with Mariah lol. Maybe only Joe lipped?
LoboAscuridad1 3 months ago
@LoboAscuridad1 they both lipped it and i said joe lip synchs terribly because it's like a proof that it's lipped. and it's kind of obvious that mariah in 2000 could sing exatcly like she did on the album (all those F#5's and F5's without even 1 point in the whole song that was different than the studio version. she didn't even do it in her prime.
iiAmitx3 3 months ago
@iiAmitx3 What? Mariah never lipped in her prime. Why would Mariah lip in her prime?
What do you mean? Mariah could have sang it live but didn't?
LoboAscuridad1 3 months ago
@LoboAscuridad1 no i said mariah is lipping here because it sounded 100% like the album version and mariah never sounds 100% like the album version, not even in her prime. :) mariah always sang live in her prime! :)
iiAmitx3 3 months ago
@iiAmitx3 Oh that makes much more sense lol. You should of said that lol xD
Is there a TGIFU videos that is 100% live??
LoboAscuridad1 3 months ago
@LoboAscuridad1 on the rainbow tour and AMA's performance :) she rarely lips on those big award shows (ama's vma's grammys etc...) i love the one she did in Milan (on the rainbow tour)
iiAmitx3 3 months ago
@iiAmitx3 Okay I will look for those videos :) THANKS!!!
LoboAscuridad1 3 months ago
its not lipped, idiot
oqyrandy 1 year ago
@oqyrandy With her it's all lyped! LMAO!
GospelAccording2ME 8 months ago
Completely LIPPED. I'm a huge fan of Mariah, but this shit is sadley lipped. Look at Joe, he sucks at Lipping, no real facial expression. FACT
AmariChampion 1 year ago
Comment removed
LoboAscuridad1 3 months ago
I love this song very much
My favourite #1 from Mariah
But she never sung it live,even lipped in this time(I must say it,because it's really lip-syned)
She just sung the remix live
But i don't really like the remix
wendycharlie123 1 year ago
LINDO!!!
Oscar1977bio 1 year ago
aarrrggggg !! where 98 degrees? i miss them :'(, hey its lipsyn?
dennyfuul 1 year ago
this song is always lipped...i have yet to see a performance of this song live...
1dreamlover1 1 year ago
i know he is lipping i dont know bout her but i think she does too but i noticed she lips when she sings with someone else but i dont know
iiAmitx3 1 year ago
it's a playback!!!!! huge one :)))
AirBourne86 1 year ago
Is that in France?
jayamee 2 years ago
@jayamee : Yes ;)
ekiiim 1 year ago
i dont think its lipped, i think the person who put this video onto youtube has put the song over the top of the video and made it soundlike it was live, becuase the music sounds to like the song as well and you cant hear them breathing. she wouldnt have lipped, its just the song over the performance
audrinaismyhero 2 years ago
It's not lipped!!
hyday94 2 years ago
I love Mariah, but this sounds exactly like the studio version...I'm not going to say it was a lipped performance, but I am skeptical about it being live...but I still love Mariah.
blaxican8705 2 years ago 5
this is SO lipped. We can even listen the 98 Degrees dudes here.
rcocenzo 2 years ago
@blaxican8705 she performed LIVE here...it's just that probably the uploader of this video dubbed it with the studio track
Libogzxh 2 years ago
@Libogzxh OK...thanks...I've actually noticed that about a lot of YouTube videos...thanks for your response.
blaxican8705 2 years ago
haha welcum
Libogzxh 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
so lipped.... if live:: ... before I'd (breath).... separate myself from you.
juniorvz1 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
it's so lipped
songbirdreg 2 years ago
This is NOT lipped
brandinj 2 years ago 20
yeah, its not lipped!!!
stevenct0701 2 years ago 22
@stevenct0701
yo i got a question
do you think they is lip sining ? cus its sounds just like the recording of the cd
sexiebaby2009 1 year ago
no da fuck itz not u dumb bitch!!!!
steviegohard100 2 years ago 6
This comment has received too many negative votes show
LIPPED!
ssaturn 2 years ago