Love the guy, but he butchered one of the best songs ever composed. I don't care for his rendition at all... you just don't completely alter a classic until it's unrecognizable! Pointless!
As Jazz has seen its Glories Fade,,,Its Idols Vanish and Stars Decay,,,,Yet shall some tribute of regret be paid,?,,, When its long life has reached its Final Day,,, A Pat Metheny Puritan would say,,, The Evil Kenny G,, Dug its Grave
I'm sorry Pat, but this song isn't "The girl from Ipanema", it seems another song, the accords that you make aren't the accords of Jobim, look it with more attention. I really don't like it.
@Lidiaponomareva Not for everyone's taste, but realize it's his rendition in a totally different arrangement. The main melody in the verses is there if you listen for it.
@Lidiaponomareva Pat doesn't need your apology or your request that he look at the song with more attention. There are only about three or four people in the world who can play this song correctly, and Pat is one of them. Once you can do that, you have license to put your own interpretation on it, and that's what Pat's doing here. Yes, the song is most definitely 'The Girl from Ipanema.' Whether or not you like it is another story.
Great stuff ....Just so so creative ... One of my favourite Jobim songs ... Pat you are so great at creating wonder melodies from standards...quite amazing , Thanks for posting
Oh my god, once I found the melody and understood how he was stretching the chords just outside of the original framework it became one of the most mind-blowingly profound and achingly tender interpretations I've ever heard. Fucking Pat Metheny. Fucking God!
If I want to play jazz/bossa nova on nylon strings like pat does should I get a flamenco or classical guitar and what technique should i learn (classical,flamenco,or something else)?
I don't think this song works with a 're-harm' to that extent. I hear the melody...but the harmony is mental; sounds improvised. The harmonics at the end are just plain nuts. Beautiful and haunting...but not the garota; more like desifnado
Metheny deconstructs and reconstructs the most played brazilian music outside Brazil, crossing paths of the melody, at the same time so distant and so close of it. Walks between tunes by Jobim and himself, defining what is a personal reading of a masterpiece work of a genius by another genius.
Metheny, who makes it sound all the sounds of his 42 strings guitar in "Sound of Silence", in "Girl From Ipanema" does not play, making the listener imagine the quiet notes of this song, known worldwide.
ok, maybe i have to listen to this 100 times before i understand it, or at least 10x maybe. i love pat metheny, but i dont hear the "girl from ipanema here yet"
Fajnie, ze nie poszedł na łatwiznę. "Girl form Ipanema" każdy zna, więc nie ma sensu powtarzania dźwięków zagranych miliony razy, bo to nuda. Brawo Pat!
that was my experience too, i liked Fma7 way better when i was starting out lol...also i within a few days i learned E and moved it up one fret with the open strings to get Fma7b5 hahahaha...now i understand soooo much about music theory its crazy!
Good on it's own, but horrible "version" of the song. It's not ipanema anymore, call it something else. He's amazing, but he bastardized the melody, harmony, and the essence of this song.
@zosobeatles actually i went away but your comment got the opposite and made me come back to a video i would never go back to otherwise. so think twice before posting comments. oh and go fuck yourself.
@MrZaf12 not trying to rebuke you or anything, but I think its more about the music than the way he plays it. I personally play with the thumb and find it work well for me. Of course if this type of music ain't your cup-o-tea then it doesn't matter but I'd still listen to his stuff if he played with his feet. Again, not trying to sound like a know-it-all, just putting out my opinion :)
I guess it's like trying to tell a Christian that the Bible is not the truth...that things like Noah's Ark are ridiculous myths...but you believers are gonna just ignore scientific fact.
You believe what you want...but grant me the same right.
I know you Christians have trouble with independent thought.
And most Jazz guitarists bore me. Guitar has taken a huge leap forward with fingerstyle players who can play counterpoint and three voices running with Classical technique and control of timbre and dynamics. PM has a beginner technique and no idea how to play an acoustic except in a one dimensional way. He's the Kenny G of acoustic.
@Rexicano haha most of the vids you have are about classical guitar playing, almost no jazz, you probably don't like it, and that's ok :) Thanks for sharing. You know, this version wasn't the best, but it was nice and I appreciate Pat to keep experimenting and finding new ways, tones, scales,etc you keep practicing and doing different stuff everytime and you suddenly have more than 15 Grammys =P He's a good researcher and after that, a good musician. Shame that he bores you.
You asked and I answered and now you think it's cool to act like a petulant child.
I could give a shit who wind Grammies...so I guess you love B. Spears, Madonna, Beiber and all the other people who win shit. Don't give me that sort of crap about commercial success.
There's plenty of Jazz players at my site but you have narrow definitions re Jazz.
@bre4k00 try being offered a teaching position at ANY university before you're 20, then maybe we'll consider the fact that you think he's horrible. Besides, being able to play many guitars at different tunings equally effortlessly, coming up with reharm like he does, you can't say that isn't amazing. As a matter of fact, these renditions weren't meant to impress technically, (neither do the rest), but these were simply extensions of his own style, perhaps for us to enjoy (:
@Q2W3e4r5tss I think it has to do with pauses between notes. Often i feel guitarists dont allow the depth to reveal itself, because they are too tecnically oriented.
@iialves its a baritone guitar with the D and G strings strung an octave higher. not sure if he plays his Bari B to B or A to A....without a guitar in hand I'm guessing B to B. So it would be B E A D F# B. the A and D strings are an octave higher.
Pat Metheny en esto es igual que todos los genios, llega un momento en que se cansan de tocar tan bien, que se les va la olla y entran en terrenos que incluso músicos aficionados como yo, ya no entendemos. Esta versión es su mundo, tan íntima que es inaccesible a lo simple mortales.
Pat: Not sure about this. The first chord is F major seven, no need for a bar chord, much less to put the seven in the bass; it is a neat idea, but the explanation does not seem right, unless the teacher was showing you a simplified chart. Ora, the next chord is G7 (alt option) and then yes you could be barring on F3 instead of using a non-bar voicing. Creio estar com a razão neste particular.
@charlesaperrone you misunderstand what hes saying.he stumbled upon f major seven when an f chord was too hard for him.he then recognized that chord to be from this tune.
Versión distinta, no tanto del original, si no de las múltiplex versiones.
Para mi me acerca a la Ipanema triste que en el fondo nos quiere trasmitir, la canción. De rápida lectura, pero de mucha enjundia por dentro, no me canso en repetirla y escucharla. Me gustaría mucho unida con el piano de Lyle.
Love the guy, but he butchered one of the best songs ever composed. I don't care for his rendition at all... you just don't completely alter a classic until it's unrecognizable! Pointless!
juju2005z 3 hours ago
This has been flagged as spam show
this is an effing disrespect to the original song.[2]
jhonsatriani 1 day ago
Sorry, can't see any relation to the song... why not just compose your own music? lol
GrandeRio01 4 days ago in playlist YouTube Mix for Antonio Carlos Jobim
In Poland don't exist ipanema , for happiness to all polish girls .
MegaNormalhuman 4 days ago
Se parece a yuyin
jose044 3 weeks ago
the 2nd string looks so strange!! Is pat using some alternative tunning..??
Victooriux 3 weeks ago
As Jazz has seen its Glories Fade,,,Its Idols Vanish and Stars Decay,,,,Yet shall some tribute of regret be paid,?,,, When its long life has reached its Final Day,,, A Pat Metheny Puritan would say,,, The Evil Kenny G,, Dug its Grave
JazzKeyboardist1 3 weeks ago 15
I'm sorry Pat, but this song isn't "The girl from Ipanema", it seems another song, the accords that you make aren't the accords of Jobim, look it with more attention. I really don't like it.
Lidiaponomareva 4 weeks ago in playlist Altri video di PatMethenyMedia
@Lidiaponomareva Not for everyone's taste, but realize it's his rendition in a totally different arrangement. The main melody in the verses is there if you listen for it.
Beautifully played.
funkster007 2 weeks ago
@Lidiaponomareva Pat doesn't need your apology or your request that he look at the song with more attention. There are only about three or four people in the world who can play this song correctly, and Pat is one of them. Once you can do that, you have license to put your own interpretation on it, and that's what Pat's doing here. Yes, the song is most definitely 'The Girl from Ipanema.' Whether or not you like it is another story.
00s00m 1 week ago
it's so nice to whitness a magicians work - thank you for the music! :-)
trankgrappa 1 month ago
cant say I like this
gammypage 1 month ago
Great stuff ....Just so so creative ... One of my favourite Jobim songs ... Pat you are so great at creating wonder melodies from standards...quite amazing , Thanks for posting
Dave
Alberta
dwebster50 1 month ago
This man is a hero. seriously. an american folk hero.
finexample 1 month ago in playlist YouTube Mix for Antonio Carlos Jobim
Holy shiiiiit!! This guy is an animal. I wonder what the tuning is.
concordguitarlessons 1 month ago
Cool arrangement and sweet voicings ..I will say Hi to Joe Diorio for you Pat : )
SIRONEDRAGON 2 months ago
Genius as always.
DougGershuny 2 months ago
Oh my god, once I found the melody and understood how he was stretching the chords just outside of the original framework it became one of the most mind-blowingly profound and achingly tender interpretations I've ever heard. Fucking Pat Metheny. Fucking God!
adipsous 2 months ago
Yeah, he really knows hot to annoying.
Listening this for more then 5 seconds can lead to suicide.
PrckoBas 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
If I want to play jazz/bossa nova on nylon strings like pat does should I get a flamenco or classical guitar and what technique should i learn (classical,flamenco,or something else)?
FantomOfFear 3 months ago
Wonderfull!!!! Monster!!!!!
Yanzazzzz 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I don't think this song works with a 're-harm' to that extent. I hear the melody...but the harmony is mental; sounds improvised. The harmonics at the end are just plain nuts. Beautiful and haunting...but not the garota; more like desifnado
iamahumbleman 3 months ago
Comment removed
iamahumbleman 3 months ago
you,re havin a laugh
MarkAllison57 3 months ago
this is an effing disrespect to the original song.
ryanz06 3 months ago
Metheny deconstructs and reconstructs the most played brazilian music outside Brazil, crossing paths of the melody, at the same time so distant and so close of it. Walks between tunes by Jobim and himself, defining what is a personal reading of a masterpiece work of a genius by another genius.
And he makes sounds the sound of silence.
sjatoba 3 months ago
Metheny, who makes it sound all the sounds of his 42 strings guitar in "Sound of Silence", in "Girl From Ipanema" does not play, making the listener imagine the quiet notes of this song, known worldwide.
sjatoba 3 months ago
obrigada - perfection!
MikeandEdie 4 months ago
ok, maybe i have to listen to this 100 times before i understand it, or at least 10x maybe. i love pat metheny, but i dont hear the "girl from ipanema here yet"
robbielg 4 months ago
wheres the tune?!
thenamesfrancisco 4 months ago
Fajnie, ze nie poszedł na łatwiznę. "Girl form Ipanema" każdy zna, więc nie ma sensu powtarzania dźwięków zagranych miliony razy, bo to nuda. Brawo Pat!
menforum 4 months ago
Não é mais bossa nova!
daldantas 4 months ago in playlist YouTube Mix for Antonio Carlos Jobim
excelent .
marcossoterguitar 5 months ago
its like halloween!!!
noisesuppressor19 5 months ago
that was my experience too, i liked Fma7 way better when i was starting out lol...also i within a few days i learned E and moved it up one fret with the open strings to get Fma7b5 hahahaha...now i understand soooo much about music theory its crazy!
geoffreyefloyd 5 months ago
Melhor versão de Garota de Ipanema que já ouvi... harmonia incrível..
Uma pena que o Pat não vem mais ao Brasil...
Felidaviscg 5 months ago
Unbelievably skillful and what a beautiful artistic interpretation. Fabulous!
pbossa1 5 months ago in playlist YouTube Mix for Antonio Carlos Jobim
Good on it's own, but horrible "version" of the song. It's not ipanema anymore, call it something else. He's amazing, but he bastardized the melody, harmony, and the essence of this song.
BrannonMcConkey 5 months ago
Qué belleza, Maestro!!!
milonga1960 5 months ago in playlist Más vídeos de PatMethenyMedia
asta el minuto 2.40 es un poco siniestro.....de la proxima pelicula de saw..... ya estoy vendo..saw....rio............
xurdegg 6 months ago
@xurdegg
me gusta pero es siniestro
para la bada sonora de saw rio 2011.......... brutal!!
xurdegg 6 months ago
i can't see this kind of playing, with the thumb over the fretboard, that's just horrible! i can't look! hold the guitar properly !
MrZaf12 6 months ago
@MrZaf12 Go away prick.
zosobeatles 6 months ago 5
@zosobeatles actually i went away but your comment got the opposite and made me come back to a video i would never go back to otherwise. so think twice before posting comments. oh and go fuck yourself.
MrZaf12 6 months ago
@MrZaf12 not trying to rebuke you or anything, but I think its more about the music than the way he plays it. I personally play with the thumb and find it work well for me. Of course if this type of music ain't your cup-o-tea then it doesn't matter but I'd still listen to his stuff if he played with his feet. Again, not trying to sound like a know-it-all, just putting out my opinion :)
TwoBitSodapop 5 months ago
Let me repeat this classic YouTube comment:
Pat = God.
jipjoy86 6 months ago
Pat's playing is beautiful. Brings tear to my eyes.
jazzgboy 6 months ago
this is more like "the girl from area 51" or something...
marsimoni 6 months ago 5
Pat ruined this great song with his awful reharms that make people hate jazz.
Tuukatime 6 months ago
haha well I guess he focuses on good music rather than what people think about "jazz" ..
olivercarlehed 6 months ago
That last harmonic lick.......the last lick of the tune.
Unfuckingbelievable and so full of beauty.
Thanks Pat.
casszen 6 months ago
he really influenced my life...
ClariDiez 6 months ago
one of my favourite brazilian song!!!!! revisited as incredible !!! must be listened several times !!! so did I !!!!
hmzic 7 months ago
Quien compara,critica o menosprecia el Talento ,la Creacion y el Corazon de PAT....SIMPLEMENTE TIENE EL OIDO "CUADRAO" como decimos en mi tierra
Who compares, criticizes or despises the Talent, the Creation and the HEART of Pat...JUST have the ear "CUADRAO" as we say in my country.
Thanks Pat to let me know the new Garota with more Madurez luego de 50 años....
PELE2NCHO 7 months ago
Disconnected noodling.
Wow, look at me...I can play altered chords!
Of all the professional guitarists I've ever heard play acoustic guitar, he is the worst.
Rexicano 7 months ago
@Rexicano Oh how I hope you are being sarcastic...
crishhh 7 months ago
@crishhh
I guess it's like trying to tell a Christian that the Bible is not the truth...that things like Noah's Ark are ridiculous myths...but you believers are gonna just ignore scientific fact.
You believe what you want...but grant me the same right.
I know you Christians have trouble with independent thought.
Rexicano 7 months ago
@Rexicano Who's you favorites in jazz better than Pat?
bre4k00 7 months ago
@bre4k00
Look in my FAVS section...
Almost any African American player from the 60s.
And most Jazz guitarists bore me. Guitar has taken a huge leap forward with fingerstyle players who can play counterpoint and three voices running with Classical technique and control of timbre and dynamics. PM has a beginner technique and no idea how to play an acoustic except in a one dimensional way. He's the Kenny G of acoustic.
Rexicano 7 months ago
@Rexicano haha most of the vids you have are about classical guitar playing, almost no jazz, you probably don't like it, and that's ok :) Thanks for sharing. You know, this version wasn't the best, but it was nice and I appreciate Pat to keep experimenting and finding new ways, tones, scales,etc you keep practicing and doing different stuff everytime and you suddenly have more than 15 Grammys =P He's a good researcher and after that, a good musician. Shame that he bores you.
bre4k00 7 months ago
@bre4k00
You asked and I answered and now you think it's cool to act like a petulant child.
I could give a shit who wind Grammies...so I guess you love B. Spears, Madonna, Beiber and all the other people who win shit. Don't give me that sort of crap about commercial success.
There's plenty of Jazz players at my site but you have narrow definitions re Jazz.
Shame on yourself, moron.
Rexicano 7 months ago
@Rexicano LOL!!!!!
bre4k00 7 months ago
@bre4k00 try being offered a teaching position at ANY university before you're 20, then maybe we'll consider the fact that you think he's horrible. Besides, being able to play many guitars at different tunings equally effortlessly, coming up with reharm like he does, you can't say that isn't amazing. As a matter of fact, these renditions weren't meant to impress technically, (neither do the rest), but these were simply extensions of his own style, perhaps for us to enjoy (:
thedng 7 months ago
@thedng Hey don't get me wrong, Pat is definitely one of my favorite Jazz Musicians! And I do love this cover :) Cheers.
TheJessy54 7 months ago
@TheJessy54 haha my comments was meant for bre4k00 (:
thedng 7 months ago
Love all songs on this record, but this one is my favorite. Not sure why.
Q2W3e4r5tss 6 months ago
@Q2W3e4r5tss I think it has to do with pauses between notes. Often i feel guitarists dont allow the depth to reveal itself, because they are too tecnically oriented.
Q2W3e4r5tss 6 months ago
Comment removed
jazzgboy 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
I recommend using Media Outlet Online for doonnlooading fffreeee m..uzzic like this. You should try and search it using Yahoo.
NicolasaaPat 8 months ago
Armonie bitonali , sovrapposizioni di tonalità , ect....ne fanno un capolavoro. Grande Pat
gabri3l367 8 months ago
totally amazing. does anyone know what tuning is that ? i'm having a hard time to figure out.
iialves 8 months ago
@iialves its a baritone guitar with the D and G strings strung an octave higher. not sure if he plays his Bari B to B or A to A....without a guitar in hand I'm guessing B to B. So it would be B E A D F# B. the A and D strings are an octave higher.
lanerant 8 months ago
As always... THe MASTER!
mactoja 8 months ago 2
PAT IO TI ADORO!!!!! MERAVIGLIA....
Afterangie 8 months ago
MERAVIGLIOSA!!!
jonioj 8 months ago
Not only does the man have the virtuoso talent of a technical player along with the theory to put many Juilliard students to shame...
drrojogochu 8 months ago
Beautiful re-harm. Love it.
AtmosMusic 8 months ago 7
did he forget the chords or something forgot to tune up,, sorry just kidding be to me thats how its sounds,, its all very deep
simonmcglynn 8 months ago
@simonmcglynn
Sorry, but you are only stupid!
Listen to Kenny G.!
willibald99 8 months ago
Brilliant!
SenorACaraballo 8 months ago
Pat Metheny en esto es igual que todos los genios, llega un momento en que se cansan de tocar tan bien, que se les va la olla y entran en terrenos que incluso músicos aficionados como yo, ya no entendemos. Esta versión es su mundo, tan íntima que es inaccesible a lo simple mortales.
Brouagh 8 months ago
Uma bela releitura da obra original, livre e sem vínculos diretos com a Bossa Nova, apesar de homenageá-la.
O intérprete (Pat Metheney) brinca desenvolto com as cordas, demonstrando grande habilidade e sensibilidade.
As notas saem da alma.
Parabéns.
copaseagull 8 months ago
Thank you Andy, (that is my middle name); it was hard to imagine PM in that situation.
Then there are the pianists who play "Girl" in all sorts of strange keys.
charlesaperrone 8 months ago
@Ccffect If you get the CD, it might tell you what mics they are using. Just a guess :)
TheFlamsalad 8 months ago
the next chord is G7...commonly.
thepontif 8 months ago
Pat: Not sure about this. The first chord is F major seven, no need for a bar chord, much less to put the seven in the bass; it is a neat idea, but the explanation does not seem right, unless the teacher was showing you a simplified chart. Ora, the next chord is G7 (alt option) and then yes you could be barring on F3 instead of using a non-bar voicing. Creio estar com a razão neste particular.
charlesaperrone 8 months ago
@charlesaperrone you misunderstand what hes saying.he stumbled upon f major seven when an f chord was too hard for him.he then recognized that chord to be from this tune.
andymcguitar 8 months ago
Versión distinta, no tanto del original, si no de las múltiplex versiones.
Para mi me acerca a la Ipanema triste que en el fondo nos quiere trasmitir, la canción. De rápida lectura, pero de mucha enjundia por dentro, no me canso en repetirla y escucharla. Me gustaría mucho unida con el piano de Lyle.
Saludos.
Arrutzi 8 months ago
Magnifique , merci
nono83666 8 months ago
Best one heard from the cd to date.
chatonpmg 8 months ago
Thats an intriguing arrangement, will be pointing some of my students to this version.
DaleCampbellAcoustic 8 months ago
Comment removed
dalecampbellextras 8 months ago
Love IT!!!!
methenychile 8 months ago
beautiful revoiced song
Sanyahoo 8 months ago
すごい
whitegreatwall 8 months ago
only Pat can play Ipanema like that! perfect! LOVE IT!
TrustNooooo1 8 months ago 3
@TrustNooooo1 Jobim can :D
albertoaranda 7 months ago
heart and spirit
melomaniacco 8 months ago
it sounds always fresh.
RaerY1959 8 months ago
Great!!
I love you.
hentai4545877 8 months ago