Christianity and Islam - Can they Tolerate eachother? Sami Zaatari vs Jay Smith

[bustacapinlutha]

I have never met one Christian who tolerated Islam. But I have met several Muslims who not only tolerate Christians, but believe they are children of the book; they believe Jesus talked in the crib; and they believe Mary was a holy woman.

[RedSevenNine]

Well done Sami, you have practiced what you preached! Unlike the intolerant Jay Smith who would have us believe he loves everyone while he evidently cannot even tolerate anyone other than a Christian! Tolerant Muslims and Christians in the audience recognised the hypocrisy and un-Christian behaviour of Jay Smith. Smith is a divider of mankind not a joiner!

[muslimwhacker]

Poor sammy looked like a schoolboy in this debate...

[MrMk2908]

Quran says its nt deffrnt beween torah n Quran nt whateva paul or luke said

[muslim9x9x]

JAY SMITH SAYS "YOU'LL WHAT YOU FIND in the Bible 1:37:26, yes, This is what I found:

w w w drunkwithbloood c o m. Also, jay smith admitted the BIBLE IS MORE VIOLENT THAN THE QURAN in debate with shabir ally

[frostedflakes1972]

HAHAHA!! People are funny.. Going off topic!!????? Is that your only argument?? Love is much stronger than tolerance, to tolerate someone u don't have to love them, but if u love everyone u will most certainly tolerate them! Come on now.. The God of Love? Or the god of tolerance? God created man and obviously loves us, not just kinda tolerates us..

[Nazam44]

@frostedflakes1972 But the Bible does not teach that God loves everyone so Jay's argument is fallacious. See; Pslams 5:5-7, 11:5, Romans 9:13, Leviticus 20:23, 26:30.

[Terrorist12341]

Love does not meing tolerance, Jay did this in a recent debate, he COMPLETELY goes of topic. In the most recent debate "Jesus or Muhhamad, who is a better role model for today?" he said during his statement "so who is the better man of God for today?". FFS Jay, love does not mean tolerance and 'who is a better role model for today' does not mean 'who is the better man of God for today'. Christians love to go off topic. whatever just had to let that of my chest..

[member100xy]

"Every one that is found shall be thrust through; and every one that is joined unto them shall fall by the sword. Their children also shall be dashed to pieces before their eyes; their houses shall be spoiled, and their wives ravished." (Isaiah 13 punishment using NAIL IN A HEAD IN BIBLE ["Then Jael Heber's wife took a nail of the tent, and took an hammer in her hand, and went softly unto him, and smote the nail into his temples, and fastened it into the ground: for he was fast asle

[member100xy]

jay smith realized his Christianity and his bible preach intolerance and he switch to LOVE in the bible , he for get hes nasian jessus said [If anyone comes to me and does not hate his father and mother, his wife and children, his brothers and sisters--yes, even his own life--he cannot be my disciple.] luke 14 to be a christian you must start by hating your own mother and father first and the rest of your family according to the bible how can you hypocrites talk about love in Christianity ?

[jamestrekky]

these two are debating in 2 totally different levels or expertise/scholarship. student debating professor? Sami needs to go back to school.

[JabrilAbdullah]

Why does Jay keep talking about abrogation in Al-Qur'an? Nothing within Al-Qur'an abrogates Al-Qur'an. Surat 2:106 refers to Al-Qur'an abrogating the previous revelations. Not Median vs Meccan like Jay is trying to do.

[saltofearth60]

It would be nice to have a free exchange been Christianity and Islam, but, thus far in the United States that does not seem possible. Muslims in Deerborn, Michigans attacked a group of Christians for passing out Christian flyers.

[Sohyb09]

Hands down! Look how Sami defeated Jay! Beautifully and easily done...

Sami hit the topic head on: Islam and Christianity: Can they Tolerate Each Other? Sami says yes! And get his facts straight.

Jay, zig zags in a Jigzaw Christian way trying to elude from the topic.

This is your worst debate Jay.

This is your best debate Sami

[xfactorb25222]

tolerance?,,,they verily got along at this debate,under their best behavior. I only heard one intelligent comment that entire time...burn both books and start over,why are we so primitive still?

[iffi0014]

please do not use abusive words against any religion..

[Logia1978]

Well Jay says he can not tolerate muslims with their faith wich is wrong as he thinks

And Sami says Islam tolerate others...

So who is the tolerating one ? -)

[MegaFraudbuster]

Sami should have stopped the debate because he only quotes the meccan suras !! LOL all muslims do this but when in power they quote sura 9:5 - kill the unbelivers !! 

[Logia1978]

@MegaFraudbuster

What about 9:6 and 9:7 and 9:4? Have you ever read them ? no, of course not...

Kill the Unbelivers because they are killing you!

[TheRockZH]

Zaatari defends the Jizya like the Mafia defends protection money. You pay us and we will not destroy you. So he admits that Islam works like organized crime.

[SamiZaatari]

@TheRockZH the mafia don't actually protect you from anything, maybe you should learn that, there's already a police force PROVIDED BY THE STATE that protects people, which is just like the Jizya, which the actual force of the state that protects the people just like any normal state does.

[JabrilAbdullah]

@SamiZaatari Mash'Allah, brother! Great debate!

Jay kills me when he go off on a tangent in his debates. The debate was about tolerance and he's talking about love.

Salam.

[pantherlake2002]

@TheRockZH lol you are sad. How about the USA government?  the taxes you pay.

[Logia1978]

@TheRockZH

Jizya is something no muslim must pay.

but they are not paying the zakat wich muslim pay.

Both are the same, but zakat is religious and islam does not need a religious tax from non muslim

[harleybunt]

The power of pardon! A true King this Mohammad guy. - releasing Pagans with whom He was at war - IZ this not Loving unavailable in most Christian communities. God is not happy about those who reject him in Christianity and Jewish Scripture.Good - Jay is not God! How much love is in Jay? Take a look! The Bushes are born again. Jay does not comment on this. Hitler was Christian no? Ivan the Terrible? Loving, Justice?

Difference between reading and practicing the Golden Rule? No?

Discernment?

[harleybunt]

The power of pardon! A true King this Mohammad guy. Can't find love of enemies in the Qur'an - releasing Pagans with whom He was at war with - IZ this not Loving unavailable in most Christian communities. God is not happy about those who reject him in Christianity and Jewish Scripture. Loving enemies is the basis of his crusade how much is it practiced in Christianity The Bushes are born again, politically anyway.

Difference between reading and practicing the Golden Rule? No?

Discernment?

[sicker57]

sami tolerated jay smith

[TripStyleZz]

Jay don't love his enemy because God say love your enemy.Who is Jay to question why and what about the Islam.God knows why!Jay ain't a real Christian I'm a Christan and I know he's right love your enemy not read his teachings and question them!Why do that if you were to love them for who they are!Jay is out to scandalize the Muslims.Not loving his enemy,Please I hope you Muslims know there are Christians who know our religion has been infiltrated!Our own priest killed Christ,these kind of guys!

[TripStyleZz]

I'm a Christian and Jay S. is fraude.He should preach like Sami Z.Jay attacks Muslims.Sami preaches toleration and don't even defends himself because his verses speak fot itself.A tru Christian wouldn't compare the whole time but respect their believes because when Christ cames he took away the rights from the Jews and salvation became possible for every tribe!If you don't break God's laws,we shouldn't mind eachothers traditions.The time of attacking other religions is gone with Christ!

[TripStyleZz]

If Mohammad en Christ where alive they wloud respect eachother and their religion because they are respresenting the same God!I am a Christian One of my best friends is a Muslim.And we talk a lot about religion!And we respect both eachothers traditions because we don't harm nobody and don't break any of God laws!Why and what should we fight over?Stupid details?!Instead of trying to live proper and respect one anotherWhat does it matter how you serve God,as long as you do!And respect eachother

[CorporalNym]

Such tedium all based upon the supposition of a god existing. Prove that, then debate. Such nonsense. Variation and division based upon fairytale and myths.

[BoudiccaBlanc]

Oil and water don't mix....

Unless the two are mixed with an emulsifier (i.e. a strong secular government that respects all human rights and all personal religions)

[muslim9x9x]

The NT is peaceful because the Christians didn't need to fight back, they didn't have that position. When Jesus returns he shall NO LONGER be the "Prince of Peace". He shall destroy disbelievers (Luke 19:27) and its okay. But if the Quran says "destroy the disbelievers" it suddenly becomes evil. Double standards! The difference between the Quran and Jesus' genocidal commands (Luke 19:27) is that the Quran only targets COMBATANTS while Jesus orders the mass KILLING of Jews in general. his "enemi

[moshigirl1]

@muslim9x9x Obviously you did not read NT. If you had you would not be quoting that verse and giving it the usual stupid muslim interpretation because they choose to ignore preceding verses.Start reading from verse 11.....and you will see that the verse is part of a parable about a nobleman. Read the whole thing . Jesus was not a murderer. If Jesus and Mohammad had lived today, Mohammad would be in prison and Jesus would win nobel peace prize.

[Nazam44]

@moshigirl1 And Christians nearly always give the same reply; that it is a parable. But whom is parable about? Jesus!. Who related the parable to his disciples comparing himself to a king who will say when he returns to his minors "But those enemies of mine who did not want me to be king over them--bring them here and kill them in front of me." I don't think the people who will be having their heads chop will want to give Jesus a noble prize for peace.

[Nazam44]

@Nazam44 CONT- "I believe that if a man like him were to assume the dictatorship of the modern world he would succeed in solving its problems in a way that would bring it the much needed peace and happiness: I have prophesied about the faith of Muhammad that it would be acceptable to the Europe of tomorrow as it is beginning to be acceptable to the Europe of today.”

[CorporalNym]

@Nazam44 SO you are a prophet?

[Nazam44]

@CorporalNym Lol, no I'm not a prophet.

[Nazam44]

@moshigirl1 George Bernard Shaw a non-Muslim and a renowned Irish play writer had this to say;

“I have always held the religion of Muhammad in high estimation because of its wonderful vitality. It is the only religion which appears to me to possess that assimilating capacity to the changing phase of existence which can make itself appeal to every age. I have studied him - the wonderful man and in my opinion for from being an anti-Christ, he must be called the Savior of Humanity." CONT-

[CorporalNym]

@Nazam44 You should read Winston Churchill on the same matter

[muslim9x9x]

Read this paper:

loonwatch c o m/2011/04/jesus-loves-his-enem­ies-and-then-kills-them-all/

The Book of Revelation depicts a VIOLENT Jesus who'd destroy his enemies. You forget Abraham, he would be arrested today for attempting to kill his SON. Muhammad is comparable to Moses, Jesus is comparable to Buddha. That's fairBut did Buddha behave violent? Jesus would be arrested for whipping people

h t t p : // thefactsaboutislam.blogspot c o m/2010/12/john-macarthur-jesus­-supports-war.h t m l

[JackSparrowDepp]

@moshigirl1 LOL what do you know about Muhammed to even mention his name? The word "brainwashed" comes to mind.

[muslim9x9x]

jay smith compares Jesus and Muhammad in a political context, but it's unreasonably NOT fair to compare Jesus to Muhammad based on the vastly different cultures, time-periods, environment, different social and political context. Each prophet was sent born into varying circumstances, it's more logical to compare Jesus to Buddha and Muhammad to Moses. Who is superior? Muhammad didn't kill women and children, Moses did. Buddha didn't whip anyone with a lash, Jesus did, who is superior?

[almao2006]

Allahu Akbar

Very sally Christianity and Tolerance!!

No one case in the history of prakticable Tolerance in the Christian World!!!

I repat mySelf even one case

[islamreligion100]

The funniest thing that Jay all debate insist to repeat what typical CHRISTIANS always Do like" jesus loves you" or "read the Bible again" or " come back to your lord"

that people don't have anything only try to play with people Emotion.Really losers.

I laughed much when you bro sami said "End of story,Debate over.Toleration" 

[harryfear]

In this debate: the Muslim on the defence and the Christian on the attack. Metaphoric or what?

[islamreligion100]

@harryfear

whole the debate i was wonder why bro Sami Don't attack but he mentioned the reason in the end of the debate

he showed them (CHRISTIANS) how can muslim Tolerate them .he could easily attack their False SCRIPTURE but he chose To tolerate them.

[jollierancher123]

Jay is preaching love and tolerance and yet he seems to be attacking Sami personally and spiritually. Pure hypocrisy.

[Ashrafhossain2010]

jay smith speaks rubbish

[islamreligion100]

Great Debate Bro sami

I enjoyed it much .

you are so smart in refute "love your enemies" by that great Question

" Can jews love Hitler? "

liked much that strong muslim woman in the end when she told Jay

"I don't need to go back to the Bible you jay who need to go back to the Noble Quran .i added that debate to my Favourite.

[muslim9x9x]

GOD hates everyone according to the Bible (Ps. 5:5). The Bible describes ALL mankind as sinners (Gen. 7, Ps. 103:10). When read in conjunction with Ps. 5:5, it implies GOD hates everyone! Muslims believe “Every son of Adam is a sinner”, best are those who REPENT and forgiven (Prov. 16 6, Hos. 6:6, M. 9 13, 12 7). There’s nothing in Quran that says ALLAH HATES the sinners. Both the Bible and Quran teach we must EARN God’s love, we must earn salvation (M. 19:17, 17:21, 23:2, Ecc. 12:13, Jam 2:1-24

[muslim9x9x]

"If anyone comes to me and does not hate his father and mother, his wife and children, his brothers and sisters--yes, even his own life--he cannot be my disciple (Luke 14:26)

The Christians apply a dancing interpretation, not allowing the text to speak for itself. Jesus used ambiguous language BUT NOT in Luke 14:26, he plainly teaches HATE.

Matthew seems to soften this passage, he wrote: "Anyone who loves his father or mother more than me is not worthy of me" (Matt. 10:37). He was embarrassed

[muslim9x9x]

christians and muslims believe in two different Gods? No, muslims, christians, and jews believe in the SAME GOD but uphold a different "version", separate ideas, concepts, and views. There's only One Creator and Deity, Allah isn't a moon god or idol, it's all been refuted.

[muslim9x9x]

GOD hates everyone according to the Bible (Ps. 5:5). The Bible describes ALL mankind as sinners (Gen. 7, Ps. 103:10). When read in conjunction with Ps. 5:5, it implies GOD hates everyone! Muslims believe “Every son of Adam is a sinner”, best are those who REPENT and forgiven (Prov. 16 6, Hos. 6:6, M. 9 13, 12 7). There’s nothing in Quran that says ALLAH HATES the sinners. Both the Bible and Quran teach we must EARN God’s love, we must earn salvation (M. 19:17, 17:21, 23:2, Ecc. 12:13, Jam 2:1-24

[muslim9x9x]

While GOD in the Quran is neutral (does not love nor hate), the Bible God hates sinners (Ps. 5:5) but LOVES the righteous. This is clearly a CONDITIONAL love, not an "unconditional love". The concept of "unconditional love" was MADE UP by some psychiatrist to make MONEY. Marcion (d. 140 CE) had a good point, based on the contradictions he said "The God of Judaism is different from the Father" (The NT god). So two Gods according to Marcion. How do Christians reconcile Ps. 5:5 and John 3:16?

[muslim9x9x]

"If anyone comes to me and does not hate his father and mother, his wife and children, his brothers and sisters--yes, even his own life--he cannot be my disciple (Luke 14:26)

The Christians apply a dancing interpretation, not allowing the text to speak for itself. Jesus used ambiguous language BUT NOT in Luke 14:26, he plainly teaches HATE. Matthew seems to soften this passage, he wrote: "Anyone who loves his father or mother more than me is not worthy of me" (Matt. 10:37). He was embarrased

[muslim9x9x]

Is there a verse in Quran resembling the hypocritical "Love thy enemy?" Yes:

Nor can goodness and Evil be equal. Repel (Evil) with what is better: Then will he between whom and thee was HATRED become as it were thy FRIEND and intimate! (41:34)

And He is the Oft-Forgiving, Full of Loving-Kindness (85:14)

DID JESUS LOVE HIS ENEMIES? NO, he verbally abused them (Matt. 23, John 8) He whipped and lashed people (John 2), is that love? The Jews are his enemies (Lk 19:27), did he love them? NO

[muslim9x9x]

The arrogant cannot stand in your presence; you HATE all who do wrong. (Ps. 5:5, NIV)

The foolish shall not stand in thy sight: thou HATEST all workers of iniquity. (KJV)

The Bible god HATES the workers of iniquity, he doesn't LOVE them. He destroys them in the flood (Gen. 7:1-20, he kills 50,000 (1 Sam. 6:19). Yet, according to John 3:16 GOD suddenly "loves" the world. Many contradictions exist between the OT and NT

When the Quran says "Allah does not love", it doesn't say HATE, He's neutral

[XxTheAMDPOWERxX]

i think some can ask , Why if he is the same God , he made bible and Quran ? Answer is that simply if God said it all from the beginning Humans will never believe it so God dealt with us in Steps and after that humanity became more advanced, God revealed Quran and said thats all and Prophet Mohamed is the last messenger and God said he will protect Quran from who corrupts his words and play with it cause that happened before with Bible and thats why there isnt a united book for the Bible now ..

[XxTheAMDPOWERxX]

About the Question , if the same God who said these words in both Quran and Bible .. Answer is simply YES , God never changes his words .. About the point that Christians think that Jesus Christ killed ,no he didn't but God raised him up and once the end of the world is near he will be send again to earth to save humanity from danger and thats what Prophet Mohamed said and what the Quran says .. He's only GOD and he never changes his word and both Mohamed and Jesus are messengers of GOD ..

[truebeliever786]

Funny, I bet the moderator guy was pissed that he gave Sami the conclusion, because in the conclusion, he practically refuted every single one of Jay's points and proved that he was intolerant, since he was against multiculturalism lol

This was a great debate. Subhanallah.

[truebeliever786]

1:15:47-1:16:00 -

Jay Smith: God always loves us even if we reject him, but he still gives us that choice, whether to accept or reject him. Islam doesn't give you that choice.

"Yes it does" - says the woman near the camera lol

[THAT1UMMAH]

The mediator is obviously bias. Every time Akhi speaks, he squirms around like a snake and rolls his eyes.

[muslim9x9x]

jay smith definitely doesn't love Muslims. jay smith seems to argue that just because the word "love" is mentioned MORE in the Bible than the Quran proves nothing. Here's one: The word 'sword' is only mentioned twice in the Quran but HUNDREDS OF TIMES in the Bible! The Bible describes GOD as a MAN OF WAR (Ex. 15:3), it says GOD HATES the workers of iniquity (Ps. 5:5) which includes ALL mankind according to the Bible (Gen 7:1-20). The God of Islam doesn't HATE, he is neutral, "does not love..."

[muslim9x9x]

@chitrakuut There is tolerance in the Quran:

The truth from your Lord (has come in this Qur'an). " Then, whoever wills (to believe), let him believe; and whoever wills (to disbelieve) 18:50

Did not Allah check one set of people by means of another, there would surely have been pulled down monasteries, CHURCHES, synagogues, and mosques, in which the name of Allah is commemorated in abundant measure (Q. 22:40). IT is churches in general, that's the Clear meaning, notice it mentions mosques last

[THAT1UMMAH]

No tolerance. There is one God and this is Allah! Point blank, no debate, no talking, BOOM, that's it.

[HyperDarkness91]

The God of the Bible loves the Jews who "killed him"?

[HyperDarkness91]

The God of the Bible loves the Jews who "killed him"?

[HyperDarkness91]

The God of the Bible loves the Jews who "killed him"?

[MrGrandDragon]

The God of the Bible loves the sinner.

The God of the Bible loves the murderer

The God of the Bible loves the rapist

The God of the Bible loves the Jews who killed him

The God of the Bible loves Muslims.

So James should stop debating and trying to convert Muslims because the God of the Bible loves Muslims, and Muslims therefore will enter the kingdom of God. Including the sinner, the murderer, the rapist, the Jew and of course the Christian

So James has refuted him self

[HyperDarkness91]

@MrGrandDragon

The God of the Bible loves the Jews who "killed him"?

[oOADROo]

@MrGrandDragon God loves sinners, rapist and murders but kills 50,000 people for looking in to a box.( 1 Samuel 6:19)

God hates innocent people

[hypnonebula]

God love those who reject him, Yet I still am going to hell if I don't embrace christianity. Ha!

[aveyowyns]

"Do not take the Jews and Christian's for friends."

[hypnonebula]

@chitrakuut troll much?

[alienraven]

im an Athiest so im neutral in this debate, but im only 30 mins in and this Jay Smith guy is already annoying me Love and tolerance are not the same thing. I love my Perants, and i tolerate the idiot on thge street corner playing guitar really badly. theres a big difference

[DawahMultiMedia]

brother SamiZaatari - Assalamu Alaikum

May Allah reward you for your great efforts to spread the Deen of Allah - ameeen

[SoProudMuslim]

I was confused, there are a lot of subjects u could have brought and refute his attacks which were out of the subject of the debate

But your summary "actions speak louder than words"

make u win within the scope of the subject of the debate which he's gone far from.

I am waiting for the links of the March, 3 debate ?

God bless you

[SoProudMuslim]

"Love" , the spanish inquisition was motivated by love that they loved muslims so much, so they ve been forced to be "saved" from their "false" belief .

maybe they ve done this because of love !!

[scrap222666]

@SoProudMuslim And the Islam suicide bombers blowing themselves up are spreading "love" also.

[AshManXP]

Well done in defending Islam, and yes, you were being attacked.

[TheBookOfAllah]

Good job Sami Zaatari

[joniindo78]

One is explaining his religion and one is attacking his opponent's religion using "LOVE" word. What a joke!!

[TheKap1an]

Im about to watch this, but from my experience of Jay Smith I do not expect too much honesty from him, Ive seen him lie about the Bible at places, twist Islamic sources,latch onto fabrications and more, watch his debate with Hamza Andreas Tzortis, the levels which people like Jay Smith will go to is just sad, when proven wrong, will quickly try and slip out of it.

[TheBookOfAllah]

Both Islam and Christianity are from Allah (God)

[Terrorist12341]

OMFG the double standers of Chirstian man!! unbeliveble!! LOL

[muslim610]

"If Muslims couldn't have a relationship with God we'd be Atheist"......LOOOOL, Go Sami.

[2redpapers]

Sami is saying we can tolerate, jay is saying we cant tolerate actually he is saying Muslims can not tolerate christian. He is promoting hate towards Muslims.

[2redpapers]

the topic is 'Can they Tolerate each other?' but jay twisted the topic to 'can Muslims tolerate Christians'!

How much christian tolerating Muslim?! think about abundance of burkah, the Quran burning day, the draw Muhammad day, Americans killing Muslims etc.

[ragenFOX]

@2redpapers the topic was about the religions, not the followers of those religions, but still, he kinda went away with the subject.

[robin4good]

Why is Jay so bitter and all about attacks, baseless assertions and accusations. judging by human example rather than the text etc. Also seducing all to believe in a man-god who died!. I pray Allah for Christians to open their hearts, because they live in a dream. No one sins for no one else, and none dies for another. what does it mean love everyone! how can I love rapists, murderers, hitler etc. come people, stop dreaming about this non-sense. Though lets all be tolerant and deal in justly.

[robin4good]

Why Jay so bitter, and all about attacks, baseless assertions and accusations, judging by human-example rather than the text...etc and also seducing all to believe in a man-god who died!. I pray Allah for christians to open their hearts, because they live in a dream. No one sins for no one else, and none dies for another (let alone GOD!). what does it mean love everyone! how can I love rapists, murderers, hitler etc. come people, stop dreaming about this non-sense. though lets all be tolerant.

[ZZzzzzzWhat]

...Aryan race was supposed to be a race* in the image of god/jesus...

[robin4good]

Why are christians so bitter, and all about attacks, baseless assertions and accusations, judging by human-example rather than the text...etc. I pray Allah to open their hearts, because they live in a dream.

[indimaya]

Jay keeps emphasizing on the word "LOVE" but everytime he opens his mouth he incites nothing but hate. Just listen to him carefully when he delivered his answers to the audience, you'll notice the only message he wanted to convey is "keep on hating on the muslims cuz their scripture is dangerous"...am i right or what!

[ZZzzzzzWhat]

(...) Even if Hitler uses God in his speeches and book, only as a tradition and not because he was a believer, God was used to promote the Nazi ideals. Hitler's Aryan race was supposed to be a rare in the image of god/jesus. There was no separation of state and religion under nazi regime. When someone says Hitler was a atheist that person is being dishonest or strongly ignorant.

[2redpapers]

if christian does wrong he is not following Juses, if Muslim does something wrong, that is the teaching of Islam, that is the rule! double standard

[SquirrelFromGradLife]

The speakers are both equally delusional and lying bastards... they're completely cherry picking the verses to build their argument upon and just taken your scripture and basis for an argument are completely insane...

The fact the the Quran tells every muslim that every country in the world must be conquered by Islam and every infidel must either by subjugated, killed or converted is evidence that slam can not live peacefully next to anybody...

[trainhard3]

nice job Sami

May Allah bless you for your Dawah ^^

[abdhamidmatsain]

How many thousands the Serb Christians killed the Bosnian Muslims in 1992-1995??......

[Muslimgirl191]

after listening to jay smith thank god am a muslim with proud good job sami but

i wished i was on that chair to answer his qeustions its not fair sami didnt had a time to respond to alot of lies that guy said

sami remain respectfull but jay didnt at all

[NinjaKiyo]

Jay can say he "loves" everyone for as long as he wants, but until he stops misquoting the Qur'an, ignoring historical contexts, sidetracking the debate topic and trying to emotionally manipulate the audience, I won't believe him.

Nevertheless Sami did a great job. Never lose the main point.

[24fanbran]

@NinjaKiyo How did Jay misquote the Qur'an? I'm not a Muslim. I would like to know.

[xerxes876]

@24fanbran He did not say the entire verses from the Quran.

[fivecrownsful]

@NinjaKiyo I'm catholic and even i agree that Jay is being a little manipulative. I also agree that Islam is a very tolerant religion. There is only one god and that god is god to all. I agree with Sami 100% why argue over religion.

[La19000]

In hadith if one move closer to Allah, Allah will move even closer to the person. This is how love of Allah to humans. So It's impossible to love God of Islam more tha Allah love the person. But lets consider the points for Jay. If someone Allah love less attack someone Allah loves more -that is what hell is for. And Jay clearly can't explain that. Instead just saying "it's hard to understand" - Allah gave us logic to seek the truth not to let God serve you instead

[SamiZaatari]

ttt

[skarfaced]

it doesn't matter who "won" the debate.anybody can be a good debater and win, but not actually gain any truth.the thing i'm laughing at is that each person grew up in a particular country/cultural background & has beenclearly influenced to believe in certain beliefs.coincidence ofbirth place,not choice, made the 2men either christian or muslim.then these people actually think that their views are correct,that what they were told @birth is Truth.despite their intelligence, they are quite stupid

[skarfaced]

once again, sami comes off as rude, condescending, and arrogant.

[La19000]

This guy needs to learn islam properly. non muslim dont pay other taxes just jizya

[La19000]

Fitna means false accusation idiot!

[BrotherSkillz]

Luke 19:27 jesus said But those enemies of mine who did not want me to be king over them--bring them here and kill them in front of me.'"

[faith200e]

mashallah sami may allah bless you

[Sncc1]

I'm impressed by Samis approach, he so young and staying focused whicle debating with a scholar like Jay Smith. Jay Smith came off as an islamaphobe, maybe he was trying to bait Sami into losing his cool. The topic was simple, but he veered off. Even the Christians in the audience saw through his lies.

[HyperDarkness91]

Good job Sami, god bless you man, nice wise words, keep it up!

[ZZzzzzzWhat]

Hitler non religious secular!? Secularism/atheism brings intolerance? Jay Smith is truly an ignorant bigot. I Hitler was catholic and invoked 'gott mit uns' on his book 'Mein Kampf' and his speeches. And the country Jay Smith lives is under Secular law.

[SiegfriedTarnovo]

@ZZzzzzzWhat

Gott mit uns was the moto of the Kaiser Army before 1918, so Hitler only took it as a tradition, it does not mean that he was a catholic believer.

[ZZzzzzzWhat]

@SiegfriedTarnovo He was a Catholic believer with a very strong Catholic education. He had some disagreements with some of the catholic policies (didn't agree much with the power of the Pope) and had some protestant views as well. But in the end he was strongly religious, God, was for him, The Creator and The Provider (his words) and one of his fears was that the soviets would invade Germany and turn it into a godless nation.

(...)

[theracemixer]

Jay won.

Sammy lost.

[Sandzak95]

@theracemixer

Sami won*

Jay lost*

Jay couldn't even hold himself to the topic.

[theracemixer]

@Sandzak95

He did. time after time he gave reference, Samy couldn't give and example where Christians were protected by Muslims in regard to jazzia tax.

[fivecrownsful]

@Sandzak95 What makes anyone believe that one religion is better than another? There is only one god and that god is god to all. Why does it matter what religion someone is. Why argue over religion?

[serkiznatz]

simply amazing debate, good work Sami. May Allah reward you for your efforts

[sinchampion]

this is good stuff but sami do you have any of your debates in mp3 format? so we can listen on the go? i prefer to download the audio

[MilkShaykh01]

the christians really like sami, they said well done to him after the debate. may Allaah preserve sami zaatari

[Sandzak95]

Well done Sami! Always nice to see you debate.

[DrXoz]

The rebuttals were toooo short man! And it should have been 5-6 rounds rebuttals atleast - , -... Besides that yet again Sami did wonders...

[MetalHeart678]

God be with you, brother.

Keep up the good work and keep learning and sharing.

Assalaamu alaykum.

[indaclub20066]

such a great debate from both sides. i vote for SAMI . what a great debater

[Drago19930713]

Arguing religious people are quite strange... They believe in essentially the same thing- a diving force. Only difference is their funny dogmatic indoctrinations. And they manage to get into conflicts over them. Its like watching kids arguing in sandbox on whose sand-cake is better.

[Hkhan23]

Islam and Christianity can very well tolerate eachother, It's the Zionists and their media that is preventing that from happening...

[dryflyguyok]

I keep saving it to watch where i left off. Good vid Sammi

[mimimw123]

Sami is such a stud...

[dryflyguyok]

Nice work Sammi! Keep the face Bro. Inshahallah!

[SamiZaatari]

And I meant chapter 109, not 108, i keep mixing that up.

[SalamToMohammed]

@SamiZaatari ohh , nice debate bro ,.may allah give u jannah :D

[umerpeace]

@SamiZaatari Did it effect the debate?

[truebeliever786]

@SamiZaatari

25:48 - That's the first and only time I've seen you smile lol

[heavensentboy]

@14:45 This is not the verse of the Quran but hadith.

[SamiZaatari]

@heavensentboy yes, it is a hadith, but in the hadith the prophet was quoting the Quran, that was what i was saying.

[heavensentboy]

Just finished watching the debate. That was fantastic. Never watched before any long debate.

Sami u were patient & stick to the topic throughout the debate while your opponent, even though he was much much senior in age, didn't stick to the topic at all. And you explained it well all in your conclusion.

Also bro there is a story where a non-Muslim filed a case against Umar (ra) or Ali (ra) & that non-Muslim won that case. You can use that story if someone asks about non-Muslims protection.

[SamiZaatari]

tt

[HaligonianType1]

Ooo.. I can't wait to watch this later.

[aveyowyns]

Sami Zaatari is such a joke.

Qur'an (5:51) - "O you who believe! do not take the Jews and the Christians for friends; they are friends of each other; and whoever amongst you takes them for a friend, then surely he is one of them; surely Allah does not guide the unjust people."

[saeed319]

Wow mashallah. Many months ago, I emailed the church about putting this video on youtube.com, and they replied, it was important for them to retain "CONTROL" of it. Therefore they would not be allowing it to be embedded. Well done for getting it up.

[ajhersi2]

This should be awesome! Sami makes up proud bro :)