Which Ciel do you perfer?

[ukissx501]

I think Yukito... He fits Ciel better in terms of looks, height (heh heh :3), physique and voice. (in fact i doubt anyone can suit Ciel better than him) While Shougo kinda looks like an older version of Ciel :/

[Sapphirecute14]

NISHIIIIIIIIIII YUKITO IS DAMN CUTE I LUBB HIM ME GLOMPS AT HIM AT CLINGS ON TO HIM

[DokixYumiNyan]

Nishii Yukto is my love forever Q U Q HE IS JUST SO ADORABLEEE

but honestly I like them both..

[MissRyo1997]

西井幸人です！！幸ちゃん最高~~~ ^0^~~~

[clarissima33]

nishii yukito is so cute nishii yukito 4ever

[ChristineErinKeyson]

Well, they're both brilliant actors and Yukito is more sympatic to me, but, Shougo is more likeCiel, however. :D But Yukito sings soo nice... Shougo too. ^.^ How could I decide? :D

[sandydivina]

Yukito is really cute ^^

[SasuSakuloveispower]

NISHII YUKITO HANDS DOWN!!!!

[bikiniboo]

Shougo sakamoto is more like adult while Nishii yukito is more like child. Ciel phantomhive is a child too. I prefer Nishii yukito as his voice matches Ciel's voice too.

[vaneneji15]

Nishii Yukito !! is so CUTE >.<

[MsMechanicalManson]

#11111111111111111111111111111­11111111111111111111111111

[pinkilo167]

Shougo was the bestest ciel. yes i said bestest. if he brake dance he would have done alot better. your good to nishii. but shougo has the attidued that ciel needs. >u<

[Sayuri7789]

Nishii Yukito-he is a vary cute! and voice the better than the first

[MsHitachiin15]

Yukito!!! He's so cute and funny!

[SweeneyShannon]

nishiiiiiiii :D

[mjliin246]

Shougo!!! ♥

...but i like yukito too, hmm... CAN'T CHOOSE!!!

oh, now i know I'll choose ---------> Yuya♥♥♥ ahaha

[mjliin246]

shougo!!! ♥

...but i like yukito too, hmm... CAN'T CHOOSE!!!

[Chiyotam]

Yukito is the best!! he is too kawaii >.<

[NarutoUchiha1998]

Just asking, where did u get the vids for shougo ciel? Cuz I really wanna watch :3

[TheLavi01]

yukitooo :X:X:X:X

[lillianclaire0267]

SHOUGO !!! For me his hotter , cuter,and sings better than Yukito...

that's my opinion......

[viverevericorosow]

and no need to be sarcastic. i think Shougo and Yukito get along well :D

so no need to ask who's better ^w^a well that's what i think.

[viverevericorosow]

well, no human is perfect. one is good at something, and also the other way.

Shougo could learn how to dance, and Yukito could learn how to sing.

their acts are equal. so if you ask me, it's a TIE.

but if there's a video where both of them are in it, i'd love to watch it. because in the end, i'm a fan for both of them. : ) seeing them working together? my life will be complete.

[bubbles4xoxo]

Nishii CIEL FOREVER

[SkullyDUB]

YUKITOOOOOOO

[abidarogers]

6...so pleas don't say until you read my comment Ciel.N. 4 Ever... ; 3

[abidarogers]

5 ....Okay lits faceit God made Nishii's face to look like Ciel on prpis ''Om did i spall that wright'' He is the REAL LIFE Ciel God wunti'd Nishii to be Ciel .N.Y. Phantomhive the same for Yuya .....Ciel .Nishii.Yukito. Phantomhive ... PS. My name is NOT Abidarogers thats my mom i'm =====.... ;3

[abidarogers]

...aaahhhhh and...Shougo sakamoto didn't do a dance. And even if he did he cant do it as CUTE....Nishii has a Ciel type baby face. sakamoto noafents but you have a long face....and....

[abidarogers]

3 ....''LOOK-A-LIKE'' if Mr.phantomhive were real he'd look like Mr.yukito. I men HOLD A F===ING PHOTO OF Ciel AND Nishii NEXT TO ECHA THER DO YOU SEE IT I DON'T F===ING BELEVE THE RESEMBLANCE...ahh..and....

[abidarogers]

2 ....if Ciel ever singed i think he wood sound like Nishii AND....

[abidarogers]

1 I think if ''Ciel Phantomhive'' was real.... he'd be Nishii BECAUSE....

[kasey13madrid]

I love them both, but I like Nishii the best. He's got the cutest baby face EVARR!

[ChasmagoricalYaoi]

SHOUGO FTW QAQ!! 

[christine0528]

Nishii Yukito!



[DarkNanaki1]

Nishii Yukito ♥

[AliceSanhora]

Nishii-kun !!!<3

[RawwrPandas]

Shougo is Cuter~! XP

[kuromi411]

They're both wonderful o-o

I believe Yukito would be more like Ciel, because they're both ADORABLE ^o^

But, they were both great :D

[alwaysinxs]

Yukito all the way ;D

[alwaysinxs]

Yukito all the way ;D

[IxAMxLAWLIET]

Yukito-kun!!!! He was perfect as Ciel! <3

[cloudieyuen]

Yukito Nishii >w< because he is more like ciel than Shougo Sakamoto

[cloudieyuen]

Yukito nishii >w< because he is more like ciel than Shougo Sakamoto

[iSPABZ]

both !

[wilvana]

even though that dance at the end was chorgraphed,nishii has moves,but since i knew about nishii first(i went backwards on the muscials),i'm going to pick.....NISHII <3!!!!!!!

[eloisaHaRu]

i like them both!!!! they're just awsome!!!

[starrystarla15]

yukito~ <3

[animegirllover1]

@kara151097 ya i like him better cuz hes around the same age as ciel plus he is just amazing! >/////////<

[animegirllover1]

which one was the one danceing at the end? i like nishii overall

[Kara151097]

@animegirllover1 it was nishi :3

[Kara151097]

i haven't seen 1st musical >____< but... i prefer nishii... He's more cute XD

(Shougo is like o3o or it's just me...?)

[YepYepYepNo]

SHOUGOOOOOOOO <3 <3 

[MsKagome123]

Shougo Sakamoto!!!!!

[ArabellaTV]

YUKITO ALL THE WAYYYY!!!

[PrincessCrystalDream]

Nishii Yukito Sounds more like Ciel than Shougo does, and Yukito is cuter and can sing and dance, So Yukito has my vote.

[KIVA0913]

yukito nishiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii­iii............a member of dboys...i really love the way he act...and have a a soft voice

...shougo is the one who played ryoma echizen in musical...

[DarkAngelVampire69]

anime

[AuroraAlchemist]

SO hard to decide...ugh- let's just splice them and create an ultra Ciel, yes?? Haha, I saw the 2nd musical first actually so my heart is loyal to Yukito, though I think Shougo seems more polished in singing and acting- though Yukito is still impressive...but since you threw in THE dance- I'm going to have to give Yukito the win- cause the dance really is the best...ive already learned it, yep, im lame, watchout anime cons- ima do it like Ciel

[Kiradepp16]

Yukito Nishi is so cute :D

I love him ^^

[krasota19]

shougo

[dollerbabe]

yukito ist better , because he is not so tall and his voice sounds like ciel out the anime an he is soo cute and funny an he can dance

[ayano973]

yukito is the best i guess?

[doedoe181]

#1 is #1!!! ( :

[pikachu749]

Yukito Nishii is better~

[SweeTCaz54]

yukito nishii omg i love him! <3

[Momsku]

I like Yukito-san more... of course!!! ><''

[Gaybaby15]

Yukito nishii!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!

[ChuushiteAgeru]

They're both so cute! x3 Its kinda hard to choose based off of youtube videos too :/ I wish I would see it liveee!!! x] But for me, one more vote for Sakamoto Shougo!!

[DarkMiyuri]

nishii yukito is better..

[GingerMcHeart]

Nishii Yukito nailed the cute Ciel (*Lizzy moment* KAWAII!!!!) and Shougo Sakamoto nailed the "Yes, Bitch?" Ciel. But personally, I laughed my ass off when Yukito wore that dress, all the scenes! *Watching dark scene hearing Ciel make "funny sounds" and saying "Sebastian, be more gentle!"* *laughing* *watching Sebas-chan jump around as a cat and spanking Ciel* *Laughing* *Hearing Ciel say "Ika, Sebastian. Mereda, kondokoso. Kondokoso Eric okorose!" (Yeah my japanese sucks)* *nosebleed* Love both

[YulixxDark]

yukito <3 is my favorite

[scytheXmaster425]

yukito nishii because he is cute and has skills. *cross arms and nod* he can dance and do backflip

[SuicidalCandeh]

dude, ciel is supposed to be liek 10 xDD wtf! thats liek a 17 year old!

[iloveinoo]

Nishii Yukito is the best Ceil Phantomhive<3

[Hebisan]

Shougo, gosh I would have loved to see him wear the dress.

[netta9581]

Shougo is obviously much better. He sings better, acts better, looks better (and more like Ciel). And if you watch him in Tenimyu, you can see he can dance too.

Also I agree his relationship with Yuya reminds Ciel & Sebastian's relationship.

Shougo <3 forever!!

[Miaicegirl1]

To me, Shougo looked, sounded, acted more like Ciel to me personally. Also the parts with Sebastian, I found Shougo to have that similar relationship between CielxSeb in the Manga/anime. But yes, Shougo was too old and tall to be Ciel but he still did great. Also Yukito was too cute, not really Ciel like...

[thesweetz131]

They are both amazing ♥ Shoudo is like Ciel  and Nishii is soo cute :)

[NatsukiTohru]

Shougo!

[HalfAngelMe78]

shougo!! he is exactly like ciel but just taller xD

[tsukiyomimia19]

yukito!!<3..



[RivaButterfly]

Yukito xD

Definitely. I think he's perfect Ciel and I really loved him 'cause this role ;p

And he's so cute... <33

[chocoholicO1]

SHOUGO<3

[lovevokanimesgk]

yukito nishii!! *w* is so cute

[mylinhle801]

yukito looks sooooo cute in that pink dress *kyaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa*

[NikkiandRisa12]

they are both so cute, and wonderful.....i really can't decide!

[NumaNumaRiiko]

Shougo seems a bit too tall and has too thin of a face for ciel. For me, I'd have to go with Yukito. :'3

[Lingyna]

I prefer Yukito, this role suits him :) I think he is better Ciel

[xPnaiikatiex]

YUKITO! OMG I LOVE HIM HE'S SO CUTE! <3

[LilShirosLover]

I love Yukito!!! He is sooo cute he fits ciel perfectly.

[gothica8228]

shuogo is hot...

but nishii is a better ciel...

[Mai2xchan]

As a big Shougo fan, I have to say that I think Yukito's more suited for Ciel's role.

[FUNKittyV]

I think Shougo is more serious than Yukito. I like Yukito's child-like behavior, so he wins. :3 <3

[silvarza]

Nishii Yukito!!!!!!!

[RikiyaTakuma]

Hands. Down. Shougo. XD

[Ciruliku]

nishii is the best ciel in the world!

[PrincesaLunardeKou]

yukito nishii!!!!!

[pshycopanda]

Niishi-kun!!

[MikaXKempo]

Shougo!!! But Nishii wasn't that bad. I don't like the reason why they changed him though, just because Shougo was to tall and had to deep a voice. 1. Nishii isn't that much shorter than Shougo and 2. They have the same Tone of voice and singing voice, but nishii's a little bit of a pitch difference. I don't mind Nishii, I just don't like why they changed Shougo. I'm team Shougo!

[Ougi]

I prefer Nishii Yukito!! He's so cute! And personally I think Yukito and Yuya combination work a little better... or feel closer to how Ciel and Sebastian would be. With Shougo, it always feel a little off... distance on stage. But that's just my opinion and how I feel. I watched both musical and totally fell for Nishii. He just fit the role so well, both in looks and attitude. Not to mention he's so cute when he's dancing!!! XD I fall for him all over again everytime!

[PrincesaLunardeKou]

@Ougi yeah you´re right! the relation between yuya and yukito looks more closer xD I love yukito nishii <3

[amayachidori]

Nishii Yukito is just so adorable!..

same with Shougo Sakamoto...

i jest can't pick any of them... but...

arggh! yukito is just really my pick!!

[QueenFairy100]

theyre both adorable :'3

[crazysmilingirl]

Shougo Sakamoto <3333333

Even though Niishi might be "cuter" cause he's younger, I think that Shougo plays Ciel's part better. He matches the attitude, voice, and may I say freakishly handsome looks of Ciel <3 :D

[sasusakuXnarusaku]

nishii *Q*____

[ricchan12]

I love Nishii Yukito~

Shougo Sakamoto is cool

but, i love nishii yukito because he is cute

xD

[NoticsSymphonia]

.....yukito fits ciel well, but like, i think shougo acts better :)

[babugigi]

Nishii Yukito!!!

[1chokoko1]

My favorite is Shougo Sakamoto.

But I gotta admit that Nishii Yukito wasn't that bad.

[RetasuMew]

I like Sakamoto Shougo, but I just like Yukito Nishii better ^^ <333

[AnimeButterfly90]

I love Yukito Nishiii *-*

But I like Sakamoto Shougo, too :D

But Yukito is the one I like a bit more :)

He's just cute, and he can dance sooo well *-*

I like how he is backstage :D

[miku0hinasaki]

Shougo Sakamoto =)

[teexne]

 i saw them for the vey first time in their respective musicals, i mean... i saw the first one, and my heart melted for shougo, then i saw yukito and i was like "humm, he is cute, but..." you know, like protecting my new idol, but then i saw the 2nd musical, and i HAVE to say... yukito is awesome.

i just think that yukito suits ciel better because of his face and body, is more like ciel (?)*duh* asdf his face is so cute and adorable!

shougo is more like handsome : D

[kriolXx]

Yes, Shougo Ciel can sing

But Yukito Ciel can DANCE x)

[NatsukiX3chan]

Yukito Nishii~~! 4 ever 

[akana019]

nishii yukito☆

[reika7667]

well i choose Nishii :D:D , he just fits Ciel well :DD

but Shougo is also great :)))

[TheFamilySon96]

Do not complain about the voice of Yukito Nishii because Ciel would sing well, as a child and has no voice way too serious as it is the age where men are to change the voice;)

YUKITOOO I LOVEE YOUU!! (crazy fangirl xD)

[TheFamilySon96]

Yukito Nishii I prefer because it looks like closer to heaven, however Sakamoto Shougo notice that is much bigger for a musical that would represent Kuroshitsuji Ciel is Yukito better for the reason I said earlier. If they make another musical (which is of Kuroshitsuji II) Shougo would fit the character of Alois Trancy, as it gives the requirements for it (height and voice);)

Nishii Yuki is adorable and cute !!!!! xD

[CeliaPhantomhive]

OH MAI GAAAHHHH I CANT CHOOOSEEEEEE!!!

I died of cielgasms at the starting at the backstage scenes ;w; <33333333333

[Royza16]

I like them both ^^

[Mayliesmay]

I like Sakamoto Shougo!!!XD

[MysticWolfy17]

nishii as cute as a button and a really great ciel but shougo is better ^-~

[DeusaSaori]

shougo Sakamato I prefer

[PockyWarriorsInc]

Nishii Yukito! x3 oh man what a cutie! hes the cutest thing ive ever seen! <3 <3 <3 <3 <3 Nishii ftw!

[naminaruxtsubahina]

Nishii Yukitoo

the most kawaii for me O_<

[lillykuran]

Shougo Sakamoto ^^

the best ciel for me :D

he is perfect :D

[MuraiMaiko]

NISHII YUKITO FITS THE PART!!!! but he looks to innocent....

SAKAMOTO SHOUGO FITS THE PART!!!! 'cause of how he looks like he wants to achieve something and all but....he looks to old to be ciel >.<

But sorry to say to those who prefers Sakamoto i like Nishii playing the part!