Added: 3 years ago
From: RhettandLink
Views: 29,283
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (715)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • I can do that!

  • haha i talk

  • not unless you are Louis Armstrong or Harry Belafonte

  • I agree with bonescso

  • f**k no

  • Vocal fry does not count as a note.

  • screw all you guys. that is a note, its just a really low note which has a low frequency which means the soundwaves travel slower you get the crackling sound. get youfacts straight. please no back talk,"its over it doesnt matter anymore" i know i just wanted to make my point.

  • no it doesn't count

  • Who won?

  • Nope

  • It shouldn't count unless you can pick up the note on a tuning device.

  • f**k you

  • hell no!!!!

  • IM IN THIS VIDEO ZOMFG LOL

  • shouldn't count . . .

  • I don't think it counts as a note. it's just a kind of rumbly funky thing...

  • A note should be constant not that cracking noise.

  • heck yeah it counts. it's still vibration->frequency=note. albeit kinda lame.

  • NO DON'T!

  • No I don't think that counts. I can barely hear it!

  • i think if somebody whistles then it counts...yup...

  • no you cannot make that ugh sound a supernot!

    i don tink so!

  • yooo!! msg me! id is in my profile on the top. <3 muah bye 2

  • no dont count that. then everyone will be doing it and it'll ruin the experiment

  • besides if it really was a note, how could you count it as it is breaking up constantly.. it's not solid.. can't you hear that???

  • hello it is NOT a note! that's a rumbly thing.. it's not even in any pitch.. that's no good.

  • Come on its a note. And super high notes (like mine) count too! <3

  • it is a note

  • yes, it is a note!)

  • soooooooo not a note

  • no its not a note (at least i don't think it is)

    ... but it might be fun to have a supergrowl contest when the supernote one is over

  • it should NOT count

    it is not a note

    the noteyness is lost in the fearsomeness

    these people are trying to expell upon us all

    just answer me this...would u want to find one of these growlers lurking in UR room? growling thier fearsome growl at u?

  • i don't think it should count. It IS a note, technically, but it doesn't amount to the difficulty of holding a regular note.

  • no that doesn't count

  • Technically, it is a note... it's a really really low note... known as the "fry register" among within the vocal music circle... but no, I don't think it should count anyway.

  • Yes!!  Supernote is amazing!!

  • no way. i don't think it should count!

    nope nope nope(:

  • No that is not a note you have to have some voice.

  • not a note .. i can do that for 5 minuts

  • I say no go... not a note.

  • That doesn't count

  • nope. not a note.

  • no its not a note

  • no way that counts!!!! u gotta hear voice.

  • i thank it should count because you will get a lot more notes that way...and anyways, im tone deaf, i cant really tell the difference, lol. and actually, the uhing may seem easier, but it really hurst ur voice if u do it too much

  • i dont think the note should count because then it would be to easy. plus it's not even a note.

  • I think shay had a headstart was because him and his wife were soo quick to get their vids up if charles trippy put his up first i would been on that team lol thats what i think anyway and wow i saw me in that vid

  • musical note

    noun

    a notation representing the pitch and duration of a musical sound; "the singer held the note too long" [syn: note]

    The key words are musical sound. It shouldn't count.

  • i think that that is not a note because it is not used at all in musical tunes

    IT SHOULD NOT COUNT!!!

  • i think it should be counted as a note, because you are still giving off air to make that noise.

  • i say its not a note and you should not count it

  • that is not no note

  • I wouldn't count that because it more than a grunt/moaning/grunt than a note... but that is just my opinion.

  • i wouldn't count that. it doesn't even sound like singing, its just a weird noise. its one thing if you try and hit a note and your off, but to just moan? that's not cool to the others who actually tried! so i don't think that the moaning/croaking should count!

  • its not a supernote if it isnt a note, a croak is not a note. end of story =P

  • i was gonna say yes it should count cause you guys said any note. but really i dont think it should count cause its cheating the competition.. love u guys! ur awsome!

  • disqualify apprenticeA

  • its more like a supergrunt. Not really a supernote. Don't count them because then everybody is going to start to cheat with grunts. Mumbles is my homie!

  • has long has they dont inhale, its a note

  • that sounds like a growl tho, i think thats a lame excuse for a note

  • thats nota note.. thats a bad impression of the grudge

  • Hey! thats my shirt that the guy on the right is wearing

  • wow!!!??!

  • I don't believe that it should be counted and I highly agree with OhMyOlive, its not a real note people! I hope that my decision is the right one, and choose wisely, your choice might completely ratify the competition.

  • i dont think it should count becase it's suposed to be a note not a growl you dont sing with growls unless it's screamo music

  • No! i dont like that note!... its more of a growl - totally shouldnt be allowed! and besides, the higher notes are hilarious to watch :)

  • it's really pretty simple. it is a note and those that say otherwise are just jealous.

    I nearly killed myself making my supernote, if it's disqualified because of these idiots and their lack of understanding of waveforms and frequencies i'll be so upset.

  • Well if the GROWL should count then they should allow everybody who accually made what in MY opinion (yes, my opinion which doesn't mean it's the correct way to think) is a note, to upload a growl instead. I'm sure some people will manage to make a lot longer notes then.

    I guess it all comes down to your own definition about what a note is, but in my opinion the growling sound is not a note. Atleast not a supernote.

  • sorry to dissapoint you but it's not opinion it's fact.

    the grawl is a note too just a very low frequency note and in the rules they did not specify a frequency therefore it is a perfectly acceptable note. in the rules they did however say only one video per user, in which case means no you cannot try again just because you did nt think to do a low note.

  • Well to me a _super_note should be loud and clear, hence the term "super".. So opinion accually do count. Wether it should be Loud/Strong and very long, or just plain long...

  • i think it's made pretty clear in rhett and links original video that the notes are super notes because they are held for a long time.

    a long time being longer than average or super long. hence the whole aim of the competition, to see who can do it for the longest. who is most super. who's super note is most super, who's long note is the longest... etc

  • all these people saying no are just jealous they didn't pay close enough attention to the rules. you said it had to be a super NOTE. there was no mention of what the frequency should be. at the end of the day it's just seeing who can hold their breath the longest while expelling the air in their lounges through their voice box. a lower frequency requires less air and therefore can be held longer.

  • a note is simply an audible waveform. just because the waveform has a low frequency thus making it sound like a "grudge" does not make it any less of a note.

  • That's a super grunt, not a super note.

  • yes

  • Hi I would like to know what you think about the new world order, and what people are facing.

  • nope...that sooo dosent count

  • nope. its too low to be a note.

  • no note is too low u tard, as long as it's audible, read a little about wave oscilation.

    just because the wave frequency of the note is low does not mean it's not a note.

  • NO WAY MAN!

    or..MANS!

    MEN!

  • no.

  • i dont think it should count as a note.

  • supernote REGECTED!!!!

  • that isnt a note!!!

  • no way it isnt a note!

  • no way (unless there shaytards)!!!!!!!!!

  • NOT A SUPERNOTE!

  • That's the freaking GRUDGE! Not a supernote! Throw it away! Make room for the REAL pros on there!

  • i rlly dont think those should count as notes. like there just grumbles or whatev

  • i dont think that those should count as notes.

  • Im in this Vid!!!

    AND NO ITS NOT A NOTE!

  • no... its not even a note. its like a fart coming out of ur mouth

  • shyatrd rebelionites rule!

  • technically the controversial gutteral note is in fact a note. A note is merely a voiced frequency, so though these gutterations may not sound to us as "notes" or "musical" indeed they are. One should not be excluded from the contest for their choice of frequency or octave. A note is a note.

  • They're looking for a continued note. This "grudge" is not continued (if you listen closely, you'll hear it break at certain points). Besides, a note is a musical sound or note. A voice is "merely" a frequency.

  • wtf is a super note?

  • EVERYONE IS CHEATING ON THEIR DANG SUPERNOTES.

    some of us actually tried.

  • i did mine legit :)

  • no it is not a note

  • nope not at all a note

  • Nope, by technical definition its not a note.

  • its a note if your trying to be an elephant

  • Its next week already.

  • well duh dont count that

  • no dont count that

  • yes y not

  • Low notes are fine...but that is not a note at all...

  • i have a reasons why its not a note,  its not even a note because i tried to see if that would be picked up on my guitar tuner.

  • Singing low notes is definitely fine because not everyone is a soprano or a tenor. There are some pretty good altos and basses out there. That at the end that you were talking about, though, didn't sound like a note at all and I don't think it should be counted. It sounded more like a very long burp. :P

  • no i don't think that is a note because then it will be too easy for everyone

    its not even a note

  • Nah, I don't think that's a note and shouldn't count.

  • no, it's not a note XD sounds more like a throat gurgle in base lol

    haha, and the bit right at the end... sounds funny when you put the clips together of all the people that said 'tard' :P then again, i'm immature!

  • well, they might just be hurting their chances, because basses certainly expell more air than sopranos! experiment with both, and you'll see what i mean.

  • If that counted as a supernote, then everyone would just be groaning, and it wouldn't even really be fun to watch. It's okay to sing low, but not to groan.

  • no cuz i can do that for 15 min

  • no i don't think they should count it

  • Nope, does not count!

  • NO BECAUSE THATS NOT A MUSICAL NOTE

    :D

  • i think it doesn't have to be on a higher octave. its supernote so it can be low-pitched but prolonged at a certain minute. if you want a higher pitch, it's not supernote anymore...it's gonna be POWERNOTE!!!....'

  • Maybe you should set an octave level that the note has to reach to be considered in the supernote contest? This would probably deter those un-supernote super notes.

  • NO not a note...

    i should know.

  • No you shouldn't count that

  • it should not count.

  • it should count

  • I really think you should count that as a note cause alot of people don't want people to hear the way they sing.

  • no, not a note

  • Not a note!

  • That's definitely NOT a note.

  • no it shouldn't count

  • i think it should count though

  • radon krypton xenon oxygen hydrogen and helium are the six gases I remember from the periodic table.

    ignore this comment

  • That is not a super note- more of a super grumble. There definitely needs to be tone to what is coming out of ones mouth to qualify.

  • Yeah, it's more like a sound then a note.

  • I agree with everyone else, that is not a note. If it is a super"note" contest it should be a note not a uhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

  • Noup that isn't a note

  • NOT A NOTE ;)

    A note is One sound not some burp sound :P

  • That sounds more like a super burp than a note. A super note is should be sustained, supported and should have a strong ending, not just dribble away with an "uh..uh..uhhhh...cough."

  • that is so not a super note

  • Yeah, definitely not a note. A note needs to actually work the vocal chords, not just expel air.

    Can't join this, as I can't afford a camera, but good luck to all of the people that posted actual notes.

  • that ain't no note. that's a gargle. the note don't got to be pretty, but it needs to be a note.

  • There is a point in everyone's lower register where the vocal tone transitions into a vocal growl. The difference is that in the vocal tone vocal chords are tightened and loosened to vibrate with different sine wave frequencies; whereas, a growl is using the vocal chords to click a note on and off in a frequency that sounds like a low tone. Growling is not a note because it is not constant and is broken.

  • A supernote is an audible musical note. Thats not audible unless your a dog. therefore that can't be counted.

  • no, I don't think that should be counted as a supernote.

  • This Is NOT a note. A note is something more audible then a... well... that... sound !

  • that note is NOT legit.

  • NOOOOOOOOOO I SHOULD HAVE WAITED AND POSTED MY DAVID CHOI VIDIEO LATER. no ratt and link i do not think that counts as a supernote go team david choi

  • yeah its more lik a zombie noise not a SUPAHNOTE! and sometimes they even stop during it a couple secs

  • their stoping in between each breath making it not continuos i e not a super note

  • NO! It is not a supernote and it should not be counted as one!

  • In my highly qualified opinion, that is just reverberation of the vocal chords, not actual singing or a so called "note." Don't allow it!

  • THAT IS NOT A NOTE! a super note is supposed to be awesome.

  • Yeah...I don't think that should count..

    It's pretty much cheating..

    like..

    hrmmthe point of supernote is breath control and that noise hardly requires breath at all..

    yeah...

    my vote is nay

    it shouldn't count

  • I don't feel that the ''supernote controversy'' sound should count...it doesn't take as much effort to make a mindless sound like that as it does to make a proper note. ^^''

  • thats no note thats a moan

  • the supernote should be SUPER... screamed at the top of your lungs

  • Hey Guys i NC ;)

    i just wanna say this competition is hilarious!! and my supernote is coming soon, and of course i'll join the Rhett and Link powerteam.

    as for the lownoted supernote, as Rhett is exclaiming it, it is NOT a supernote, it is not even a note. But when other peoples supernotes collapses into an animal sound like that, should we stop the counting?

    regards

    Rasmus Denmark

  • that is so not a supernote, it sounds like the girl from the grudge and it isnt fair to those people who actually are doing the supernote

  • no way is that a note...people who do that should be disqualified

  • thats totally not a note, thats like a groan. dont count those

  • No, that is not a note. I do not think it should be counted. Of course you can sort of moan longer than holding a sustained note so there is no challenge to that.

  • NaN.

    Not a Note.

  • do NOT count them.

  • i mean of course

  • don't count them!!! No offense to whoever did that over course.

  • NO I WOULDNT COUNT IT

  • don't count them- totally.

  • they edited the fucking video!!!!

    he didnt say that!!!

  • They didn't edit the video...

  • No that is not a note its not superduper

  • Uhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh­hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh­hhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh............­.TARD

  • Should be a note... I don't think that's really a note you'd see in a song.

  • dont count them

  • Don't count them!

  • a note implys musical right? when was a grunt ever musical? don't count them!

  • don't count them

  • If you can't win by fair means then cheat by all means! ´... Count those grunts!!

  • Rhett&Link are their fancy foot works of editing! Blasphemy! Shaytards REtar..Rebellionites FTW!

  • alot of the top ranked notes sound like there edited, and the ones that dont sound edited arent even notes, there little grunts. DONT COUNT THOSE GRUNTS!

  • Definitely do not count the noises that sound like they're coming from the Grudge. It's not... a note.

  • dont count them

    unless the on shays team