David´s performance is absolutely great, so deep and expressive! It is not the same thing, just listening to the track in Heathen, than watching this wonder live.
I think most users who have viewed this video already know the original of the great Neil Young and this doesn't mean that they cannot appreciate a lot also the Bowie version: free opinions!
Perhaps it's more prudent not to underestimate a priori...
As for my comment to which you're referring, unfortunately I don't recognize which of the 3 is because YT does not organize more in chronological order.
I like to think that unconsciously, Bowie got the the idea from the Pixies who covered it first (on the Velouria EP). After all, he covered the Pixies on the same album as this Neil Young cover. In any case, it's a fine cover of one of Neil Young's many masterpieces.
Bowie's voice is great b/c it's kinda deep (and in my own limited viewpoint) I can sing along a lot easier. There's just not anyone or anything cooler than David Bowie; it's just a fact.
His voice does more than justice to any song he covers. I think he improves them. But I love David Bowie. His voice is so intense and unforgettable. As he is. Thanks for sharing this terrific video Fiorella. He's amazing.
Another beautiful video, so sweet and charming and full of life, every song he does is just a pleasure to enjoy to it's fullest. His totally charismatic nature, forever present, forever unforgettable. Every cover song touched by his own special magic.
Bowie and Young are not definable in one musical genre, both suspended between renewal's desire and past's nostalgia. David never indicates definite certainties, as an open mind, respectful: "For in truth, it's a beginning of nothing" declared in his album "Heathen". Perhaps, David performs subtly (with a vein of melancholy) not so much a love song, but the hidden questions that stand between dream and reality ... and emerges an outside-class of splendid Music.
Such a great performance of a Neil Young song! Bowie's cover versions of songs by other artists are always very interesting to listen to, and this one is brilliant!!!
As always, deeply studying his repertoire to be proposed,
Bowie said he chose this cover for various reasons, personalizing it in a perfect "Bowie-isation": a mental climate vague, uncertain, suspended, striated of obscurity, accentuated by "hard" sound of guitars, bass, drums. But, by the soft and emotional singing of David's voice, the original song is faithfully kept ... A powerful song !
David´s performance is absolutely great, so deep and expressive! It is not the same thing, just listening to the track in Heathen, than watching this wonder live.
Thank you so much for sharing, Fiorella!
queenofgoblings 1 week ago in playlist BOWIE ON STAGE
so good the drummer
panomenson 1 month ago
pixies version is the best!
nathantwomey 2 months ago
great choice of songs
katrin99verified 3 months ago
Gail Ann Dorsey is absolutely tearing it up here on bass.
MrChandragupta 4 months ago 2
I remember that evening with Bowie in Berlin very well, one the best shows I have ever seen !!
Great !
vjaspers0608 5 months ago
great version! amazing bassplaying !
Byskebild 5 months ago
What a crappy cover.
pjautuvas 5 months ago
Sorry folks - Neil's is far superior! Go and listen to it.
terrybriody 6 months ago
@terrybriody
I think most users who have viewed this video already know the original of the great Neil Young and this doesn't mean that they cannot appreciate a lot also the Bowie version: free opinions!
Perhaps it's more prudent not to underestimate a priori...
As for my comment to which you're referring, unfortunately I don't recognize which of the 3 is because YT does not organize more in chronological order.
Thanks anyway for your opinion.
theMusicofmyLife1 6 months ago 4
@terrybriody tried it, i still have more tolerance for David's voice than Neil's.
LMMEjsmith 4 months ago
I like to think that unconsciously, Bowie got the the idea from the Pixies who covered it first (on the Velouria EP). After all, he covered the Pixies on the same album as this Neil Young cover. In any case, it's a fine cover of one of Neil Young's many masterpieces.
ifutureman 9 months ago
Bowie's voice is great b/c it's kinda deep (and in my own limited viewpoint) I can sing along a lot easier. There's just not anyone or anything cooler than David Bowie; it's just a fact.
vschauf 10 months ago
Bowie is Bowie, so simple and complex, they change that song in something very very strong to ours sounds. Wonderful...
Adoro as musicas dele, em especial este album, Heathen, otimas musicas....
Alioli1 1 year ago
His voice does more than justice to any song he covers. I think he improves them. But I love David Bowie. His voice is so intense and unforgettable. As he is. Thanks for sharing this terrific video Fiorella. He's amazing.
naumnn 1 year ago
@naumnn
I agree, my friend. Thank you for your watching.
The Art of Bowie is so free and innovative that even on songs by other authors is able to transform the performance in a singular and original jewel.
Furthermore, David Bowie has always known recite his singing, making rich the spectacle, full of all beauty.
theMusicofmyLife1 1 year ago
Another beautiful video, so sweet and charming and full of life, every song he does is just a pleasure to enjoy to it's fullest. His totally charismatic nature, forever present, forever unforgettable. Every cover song touched by his own special magic.
Scoobydoonut 1 year ago
@Scoobydoonut
Bowie and Young are not definable in one musical genre, both suspended between renewal's desire and past's nostalgia. David never indicates definite certainties, as an open mind, respectful: "For in truth, it's a beginning of nothing" declared in his album "Heathen". Perhaps, David performs subtly (with a vein of melancholy) not so much a love song, but the hidden questions that stand between dream and reality ... and emerges an outside-class of splendid Music.
Thanks, I agree!
theMusicofmyLife1 1 year ago
@theMusicofmyLife1
A tad pretentious this comment and not entirely clear.
terrybriody 6 months ago
@Scoobydoonut I´m totally with you dear friend!!!!!!!
I drool.. I melt .. I faint hearing and watching David Bowie!!!!!!!!!
Ladystarify 1 year ago
Such a great performance of a Neil Young song! Bowie's cover versions of songs by other artists are always very interesting to listen to, and this one is brilliant!!!
redsails2008 1 year ago
@redsails2008
As always, deeply studying his repertoire to be proposed,
Bowie said he chose this cover for various reasons, personalizing it in a perfect "Bowie-isation": a mental climate vague, uncertain, suspended, striated of obscurity, accentuated by "hard" sound of guitars, bass, drums. But, by the soft and emotional singing of David's voice, the original song is faithfully kept ... A powerful song !
Thanks for the comment, shared.
theMusicofmyLife1 1 year ago