Added: 2 years ago
From: JimmyKimmelLive
Views: 72,705
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (212)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Carrie AND Taylor !

    = amazing

  • Incredible singer, first time I heard her sing I was sold! Great song

  • U should be arrested for putting CARRIE UNDERWOOD and TAYLOR SWIFT's names together in one sentence.! Carrie is 1000000000% better than her!

  • okay, lets compremise, carrie underwood is the queen of country, taylor swift is the princess.

  • @emusic4life21 lol, taylor is the princess of pop,well she would be if she could sing

  • @carriefan1392 you know? its not like taylor doesnt have any talent! i love taylor but i do agree that carrie is better. so for everyone that says taylor sucks, she really doesnt, carrie is just better.

  • @emusic4life21 sorry, but you're wrong on that, taylor has absolutely NO talent whatsover. Everyone knows it, everyone can see it, taylor would be a nobody if it weren't for her tweeny fans who will forget her when someone cooler comes along

  • @carriefan1392 okay, everyone has their own opinion and thats yours, i like them both

  • Carrie is way better than Taylor at singing, that's all I've got to say.

  • Don't get me wrong, I love Taylor Swift, I listen to her all the time, she's a good singer and her songs are relatable and fun. But when it comes down to pure talent, Carrie is just amazing. Her voice is so strong and she just seems like a great person. I love them both, but can you really compare them? They're almost too different.

  • @Caitlin44444 I agree with that 100%!!!!

  • Not bad if she can stay on pitch. Still better pitch than that Swift girl.

  • I was there. That was awesome.

  • I love how everyone trys to compare taylor and Carrie on her videos. but sorry there is no compareson, Carrie has a way better voice live and on her CD.

  • i love this song

  • She is sooo amazing live!!

  • @cilas0607 Carrie cowrote her first song (I ain't in Checotah anymore) at 22 and, whilst I love the song, I don't think the lyrics are that mature at all. I do think that Carrie is a better writer than Taylor yet I don't think the two of them are comparable. Taylor is barely out of her teens and Carrie is going on 30. Carrie is an adult, Taylor is not.

  • Yes, Taylor's songs are all about high school drama and Carrie's songs cover a wider variety of issues, yet you have to think that Taylor was a teenager when her first and second album came out and so the songs she wrote dealt with teenage issues. I am not particularly crazy about Taylor's music yet I think that's it's pretty impressive that at such an early young age (I think she was 15 when her first album came out) she was able to write all of her own songs.

  • @Gwisemua the majority of taylor's songs are talking about boys and how they hurt her and etc. while it is a "teenage" issue-just whining about it isn't exactly what I would call the right approach. sure, she may be able to cowrite the songs on her album at a rather young age but most of them don't have substantial value. Carrie was just discovered much later but if she were discovered sooner, her voice and talent as an artists would STILL have exceeded taylor's.

  • @Gwisemua when we say "carrie's the best", or "carrie's just perfect". We mean it in that she's awesome. Sure, she may have some flaws but why reflect on it? I just don't think it's relevant as far as her as an artist. She has far more pros than cons and that is what makes her "perfect". We all have our personal opinions though about who we like more or less and that's fine. Just that I don't think it's necessary to point it out when on carrie's video because it's rather irrelevant.

  • @c4sweet OMG YEAH AND ILOVE HER LIVE CUZ THEN IT JUST SHOWS HOW AMAZING SHE REALLY IS AT SINGING......!!!!!.......... THATS WHY YOU SEE PPL LIVE TO SEE IF THEY SUCK OR NOT AND CARRIE YOU NAIL IT EVERYTIME GIRLFRIEND. UR BEAUTIFUL AND TALENTED AND WHEN YOUR REACHING FOR A HARD NOTE YOUR NOT THINKING IN YOUR HEAD OH NO IS SHE NOT GONNA GET IT AND EVERYTIME YOU DO SOMETHING LIKE THAT YOU ARE AMAZING :] KEEP SINGING AND NEVER STOOOOP!!!!!!!!!! LOVE YOU :]♥

  • Voting is now open for the 2010 Entertainer Of The Year category at ACM Awards. Please head on over NOW and vote for Carrie!!! Every.single.vote counts, so we need to make sure we really step it up and vote hard!

  • All CARRIE UNDERWOOD FANS!! Don't forget to vote Carrie for THE ENTERTAINER OF THE YEAR AWARD. Voting is now available and VOTE VOTE VOTE. Help Carrie make ACM history she well DESERVES IT.

  • Freakk she is super pretty in this video!!

  • haha at 2:13 theres a kid in the audience who has some madd dance skills! LOL

  • Her dance moves make me giggle!:

  • gives her all to every darn performance, not my fave song of hers, but great performance.

  • I still remember little Carrie on Idol and Simon saying after her last performance before results were announced "You are not only going to win this competition but you will go on and sell more records that anyone before you and maybe well after you!" GREAT SONG FROM A GREAT PERFORMER NEVER STOP MAKING MUSIC CARRIE!!!

  • the guy this song is about just got told.

  • @chrissypat300 that is so true but its not about one guy because she did an interview and said it was about all those time wasting relationships she had and how she wants to take it all back

  • This is my second favorite song on her new cd. I love it!

  • her hair looks amazing

  • did anyone notice she messed up the words? lol... she said playin' instead of fallin' lol. still good though.

  • @SinginAnnie89 no she didn't she sang it right I <3. her

  • yeah she did I hate to tell you

  • she did say it wrong..oops! hopefully she gets it right when i see her on friday! :)

  • @jamie9lynn seriously? i hope she got all the words right so your concert experience wasn't ruined... good grief!

  • @SinginAnnie89 who cares? she kicked ass.

  • i absolutely LOVE Carrie... i have for the longest time, still do very much... but what is that shirt that she's wearing? o_O lol

  • @cilas0607 =) is all i have to say to that

  • I like taylor swift and carrie underwood, but Im sorry, carrie underwood is way better

  • @emacification i agree...i love taylor..i'm her biggest fan..but carrie is incredible am i right?

  • @emacification seen them both in concert, floor seats, and you're right! ;-)

  • When I feel angry I listen to this song and go out for a run. When I get done I feel so much better. I love this song.

  • carries freakin amazing. i was there

  • One of my faves from the album. Carrie is amazing. End of story.

  • Typical Carrie................sexy, classy, and beautiful beyond measure.

  • AMEN!!!!!!

  • @cilas0607 is relevant because of your assumption that i was a starry eyed teenager and that only naive high school kids would go for taylor's music while grownups would ditch her cd's for carrie's. well real people who have been through real crap and live real lives and struggles way past high school appreciate taylor's writing as well. she has a gift for storytelling if not for big notes and you need to get over yourself.

  • No, I don't think Taylor deserved to win 'Female vocalist' at all. And what makes it worse is that, when she won it, she won it over Carrie. BUT I also think that when Carrie won that award over Faith Hill she didn't deserve it, since I think Faith is a better vocalist than Carrie (and don't get me wrong: I love them both, but I can still be objective). What upsets me is that some Carrie fans can disagree with Taylor winning over Carrie but not with me disagreeing in Carrie winnig over Faith.

  • I can tell you that being a Carrie fan myself I have had the same problem with some her fans that you have had with Taylor's: because of some of them I was about to turn my back on Carrie and hate her. I once said that I didn't like a live performance from Carrie and I got lynched. If Taylor's fans think she's the best thing to happen to music... well: they have the right to do so. I don't like Taylor, but I respect people who do (the same way I respect people who don't like my 'idols').

  • @Gwisemua seriously? you were about to "turn my back on Carrie and HATE her" over some of her fans?! WOW! doesn't take a lot to deter your taste in music obviously. and on that note, i think you might deserve an Emmy nod for most dramatic performance here...

  • @alysonbrown13 If you think my "dramatic performance" was good you should check out the ones of some Carrie's fans who take a negative comment about her as if you were insulting their mother. My taste in music is based on my likes and dislikes just like everyone else's. Yes, I like Carrie a lot (not only as a singer but also as a person -my opinion based, obviously, on what I've seen from her in interviews-) yet I hate it how the only opinions allowed are the "She's perfect" ones.

  • My point is that I don't understand why so many Carrie Underwood fans seem to hate Taylor so much. I love Carrie and I don't feel the need to bash Taylor, I just don't listen to her music. But what I was trying to say was that, right now, Taylor is the one with international renown. Here in my country (Spain) people do know who Taylor is but they have never heard of Carrie (which is a shame since I think Carrie's songs are much more consistent). Taylor's is "disposable" music.

  • @cilas0607@cilas0607 actually i'm a twice married, 25 year old mother of two,survivor of abuse, trying to make ends meet, raise a blended family of six in a tiny walkin apartment without even a living room, building myself as a makeup artist, dealing with lots of grown up stuff. i still say taylor writes better than carrie. mot of carrie's songs are not written by her. she has the better voice ut taylor is the better writer. you are not the world's authority on country music.

  • @cilas0607 lol im 22 and i adore taylor swift and carrie underwood :)

  • I love her! ahhhhh

  • love her and the song shes one of the best singers out there..shes gorgeous too ....but whats she wearing? lol

  • if u like carrie add me please:)

  • I wanna uh uh uh uh uh undo it! :D

    I love her.

  • best song ever!!!=]

  • i love her... shes so much better than taylor.. my favourite singer of ALL TIME!!

  • @cute123pink taylor is a better writer

  • @wadyano taylor is not necessarily a better writer just because it comes to her faster. yeah maybe we can relate to it-drama-guys-school and all but sometimes just being relatable isn't everything. Sure we can go on and on about guys and drama but...what comes after that? there's more to life than just drama and guys. carrie's songs deals with everything. songs like "so small", "play on", "temporary home" has deep meaning. not just complaining about it but how to deal with it-life and its

  • @wadyano disappointments. just relating to something isn't all there is to music. IT needs depths. now, I like taylor swift. she's a really sweet girl and all but I have to admit that taylor is very overrated right now and carrie deserves a lot more awards and is truly the queen of COUNTRY music.

  • you aint lyin

  • you aint lyin

  • Carrie Underwood Is One Of The Best Singers Out There :) I Love This Song Alott...

  • I'm going to see Carrie Mar 13 XDDD

  • I don't understand why Carrie Underwood is a Country singer, when her voice can side with Christina Aquilera and Beyonce?

  • I ask my self the same question she is not as famous outside of the usa becaus she sings country... She needs to sing different types of genra cause she is to good just to be country.....

  • @casanoba09

    that's whre her heart is though.

    maybe one day she'll do a different genre, but i doubt that will happen anytime soon.

  • yep you might be right. I just cant get into country music i dont like it.. But carrie is the only country artist i listen to i dont know why..

  • carrie is the whitney houston of the country music world...so much power!! sang it girrrrl!

  • simply one of the best puriest singers out today .

  • i would say she is the 3rd best vocally in today music for sure!

  • Taylor can't sing for shit, lmao.

  • I want to meet her so bad!

  • Me and my bf(best friend) love this song!

  • Taylor Swift can't hold a candle to Carrie, especially vocally.

  • shes amazing and from oklahoma ! taylor swift is good but carrie is ah-mazing !

  • how did she know about my ex-husband,she is great this a awesome song,i love to sing it loud in the car windows down who cares i cant sing,this song is cheaper than therpy,thanks carrie.

  • shes as googd as taylor

  • TAYLOR SUCKS

  • Sorry. Our friend was on our account :U

  • She's far better.

  • she is soooo good!

  • carrie is so hot and she knows how to sing a lot better then taylor

  • @13DaviT1 TOTTALLY!

  • true dat!

  • i love carrie and i like taylor, but taylor does sort of have a shrieky voice, and she's definatly not country. taylor did not deserve cma entertainer of the year. go carrie! long live ur awesomeness!

  • @soonosoo ikr? i was so freakin pissed when she won. she cant sing..at all.

  • @soonosoo taylor is awesome and she deserved entertainer of the year i love carrie to death to but do honeslty think carrie would have got nominated for entertainer of the year again plus with all of taylors success thats why she won it

    Start reading more

  • Watching Carrie sing makes me want to be a singer- and man! It's got to be SO hard singing like that live! Oh! And she's BEAUTIFUL!!!!!

  • Comment removed

  • WOW!!! Whew!! I'm out of breath just wathching her sing LIVE!!! AMAZING!!! My favorite American Idol FOREVER!!!!!!! God Bless You Carrie!

  • carrie by far hotter then taylor. Carrie cna sing, and is sexy!!!!

  • She deserves much more fame worldwide.

  • Carrie Underwood is my third favorite singer ever! She has the best songs!!

  • OH MY GOSH! THIS SONG IS AMAZING!!!!!

  • Does carrie get into the officiol like top 10 music chart in USA, she doesnt get in top 50 in uk cause no one knwos her unlike me XD

    just wondering, or does carrie only enter the country song charts because its country genre, or no where near enough people buy her songs to get into the charts

    btw i am not slagging her off if it sounds it i think she is amazing :P

  • Carrie refuses to remix her songs for POP - why do you think Taylor Swift is at the top? Because she remixed her songs for POP- Carrie believes remixing a song to another genre compromises the song - Taylor releases her songs to two genres POP and country that's why she's atop seller- she's definitely more popular in POP not so much in country - Carrie is a country singer and has had 11 straight #1 singles on country radio and is always at the top

  • Carrie is at the top too, WOOT.

  • What would happen if carrie makes two cds one pop and one country????

  • Her voice is so amazing!! it's always perfect when she sings i love her!! [:

  • I too noticed she sang the wrong words but that is the first time I've ever heard her mess em up! Her voice is AMAZING as always though! She's the best of the best

  • She messed up at the begining. It's fallin' for your stupid games. Still great though!

  • Carrie isn't known much outside the US except for her many fans from Idol because she's a country singer which isn't appreciated much overseas - Taylor's label markets her as a POP artist that's why Taylor and Kelly are known more internationally - they are POP, Carrie isn't, she's country

  • I don't think Carrie being a country singer is the reason why people don't know her overseas. There are a lot of people outside the States who love country (I do). Furthermore, there have been country singers who have sold well worldwide. I'm sure Cowboy Casanova' would be a hit in my country. Carrie isn't known overseas because they don't promote her. It's a shame, because her music is saleable. And I don't think she's THAT country. Like a lot of singers, she's pop-country.

  • I live in England and I think some of Carrie's crossover songs would so great over here..Shania Twain did excellently over here and some of Carrie's songs are in a similar style, all she'd have to do is sing amazingly and the rest would sell itself..they just don't bother to market her over here =|

  • @JackLiberal Same here. Shania Twain was very successful in my country and, right now, Taylor Swift is doing well too. I don't understand why Carrie is not promoted here. I'm sure she would do fine.

  • And her "uh-uh-uh-uh-uh-undo it" is sung really well, considering this is live.

  • Whoo I love this song!

  • her new album its the best

  • i love Carrie so much,she is such a good person.

    stop comparing her with Taylor or Kelly anymore:(

    Their fans are voting her all great performance to one star:(

    stop fight fans!

  • I love her outfit - cool togs

  • I LOVE the song. Just not sure about the outfit!! I like the pants, not sure about the top.

  • Her outfit is interesting.......

  • I Love Carrie Underwood and i love her album...but that outfit!?!?

  • hot performance...her new album is so rocky!!!

  • Awesome performance! Love this song..it is one of my many favorites from Carrie's new Play On album!!!

  • did i mention how HOT she is? whoooo!!

  • @trea3123 two words kanye west

  • whats that supposed to mean?

  • oh sorry i definately clicked on the wrong response sorry.

  • oh. well she is amazing!

  • sassy! love it! great vocals!

  • She's pretty overall.

  • Ooh ooh ooh I love her earrings! And her hair clip matches. And kind of her shirt.

  • Ya hey. whats up

  • Why is it that every Carrie video I look up, people always bring up Taylor Swift?

    If you wanna discuss Taylor, then can you talk about her on her vids, so we can all love Carrie without reading people getting into fights about who is better? Cuz I love Carrie, and I hate when people fight about who's better. If u like Carrie, u like Carrie. If you like Taylor, you like Taylor. So can we just plz stop comparing them on vids? Im rly NOT trying to be rude, but it's everywhere. on most vids.

  • i just like her cause she hot

  • taylor swift is more popular with the teeny boppers the highschool kids carrie underwood is for grown folks lol

  • carrie is way better than taylor swift...

  • absolutely without a doubt no comparison. Better voice, better performer better music. Although i like talor too but carrie better

  • of course!!! taylor did NOT deserve Female Vocalist of the Year! rip off!

  • i agree... i don't get it why she won instead of carrie...

  • @flirtwd, You're the one that sounds stupid! By growing older she meant in a couple of years when Taylor would have to start singing about something other then high school not when she's old and grey...lol!

  • @donnachun , you sound so fucking stupid. We all grow older and won't be able to do certain things in our old age like we do in youth. You are just pointing out the obvious which has been known since man was created. Get a fucking life asshole.

  • Is she having a hard time walking in those boots?

  • I love Carrie, but I don't know about this song.

  • in my opinion, you always see carrie in magazines, and shes won SO many awards, shes extremely succesful and even if the outfit is different, she still rocks it :)

  • *cheers and claps*

  • wow love this song!!

  • that was amazing performence but HOLLY CRAP! carrie those are some big earrings lol but they're very pretty though

  • whats she wearing??

    i love her but thats ugly

  • i agree with you it's very ugly but i still love her

  • LOVE LOVE LOVE CARRIE, the BEST!!!

  • this is better =)

    better than cowboy casanova

  • Carrie will live on while Taylor is just a fad.

  • true

  • i would have to disagree most people know about taylor carrie is the one who is fadding sorry but she is when kelly performed awhile back he said while ALL the american idol stars have fadded kelly has still kept living or something like that so wouldn't be so sure

  • It's been years and Carrie has still proven herself in every single song that she sung. I do admit that Taylor is talented in creating songs and has a pretty voice, but there's not much vocal power or strength. She may be popular now, but what happens when she grows older and her "pretty voice" doesn't fit songs anymore? Love her, but just saying..

  • But carrie isn't someone you hear about in the papers or magizine and if so only when she has a new cd which is now but if it's any different taylor swift is always there and she's won more awards that WAY more. I love carrie in fact i love her to death but that's just my opinon

  • @4evakellyclarksonfan

    Carrie will have longevity in the music industry but my bet would be that Taylor won't. So what if Taylor is shoved down your throat 3 million times a day? It's all gonna go away one day. The big thing about her is being 19 and being able to write "pretty" songs about boys and high school. Once she becomes older, she'll just be another artist who can't sing for shit.

  • @coolidge909

    I didn't even read this i'm just letting you know i didn't ok cuz i could care less about people's opinon and you do saying you replied to mine just let be and get over it it's not like i hate carrie I LUV HER TO DEATH!!!

  • @4evakellyclarksonfan

    She is the number one search on all of yahoo today. how is she fading away exactly? A lot of people know about taylor because she is promoting herself to pop music, carrie is not as much. Taylor is dating taylor from twilight, which seems like a huge pr stunt.

    just because Carrie chooses keep her private life relatively private doesn't mean she is fading away. its her decision. and us mag and people talk about carrie and her bf mike all the time.

  • I DIDN'T MEAN FADING PEOPLE!!!

    alright i love carrie to death i truly do someone just said that taylor is fadding away or something like that but i didn't mean it like that ok. i meant kinda they just attrack different people to their music that's all i meant by it i don't even know why i said fadding...and Taylor swift isn't dating the hottie, taylor from twilight that's just a romour

  • I love Carrie Underwood but I have to agree with you on that one. Taylor is the one with international renown (and Kelly, of course) whereas very few people know about Carrie outside the States. I am from Spain and people here do know about Taylor but they have never hear or Carrie.

  • @Gwisemua

    Thank you so much for understanding what i was saying people with like almost yelling at me and i was just making a point about it so Thanks so much =D

  • agree...when taylor runs out of ideas about teenage love stories and tragedies what now...

  • Carrie is the best!

  • yay carrie,,,boo taylor on the singing

  • love this song and your great