wow you never hear myung like this amazing the can sing there's nothing wrong with his voice it's because he had never sung before but if you watch the documentry on score it explains it all
Well thats what the bass should do, tune down its volume until a section that requires a bass protagonism appears, and thats were the bass do its work.
The fact that Ruddess went to Julliard at the age of 9, and that Petrucci, Myung, and Portnoy went to Berklee and practiced their asses off really says something. As for James LaBrie, he's just a damn amazing singer.
I just saw Dream Theater last night. Rudess and Petrucci ended up playing solos in other music genres(which was amazing).
There was really so much going on. It's something you should all see. The other bands were nice and Zappa Plays Zappa was especially amazing.
I love the lyrics to this song, a huge shame theres no singer on this record! Try the Score version, just beautifully sung by James, the lyrics are so great and poetic, makes me cry evertime...
we are all agree. one thing i don't understand is why myung accepts that now he is not as important as other member of the band. in the WDAD Reunite DVD audio commentary, when Mike says ``in those times bass was like a lead guitar´´ and JM didn't say anything (as always). i don't think that the rest of the band ignores his compositons, i just think that JM has changed his mind about what is the bass in a band. and when i think about it i feel so sad....
I know, in WDADU Myung has a wealth of bass solos and loud, powerful,parts, but nowadays he is hardly even heard. Its almost like he's too shy for the spotlight, even with his vast potential. He shouldn't just be doubling Petrucci's riffs.
He's as important as he was then, now he is more rythm which is the bassist his duty, back then he was way more melodic (which is really cool) But without him it still is empty and i probably won't like DT without him, but guitar is way more up front because mindless musicians only hear guitar.... And think that that is the most important instrument (actually it's the least important instrument in a band)
oohh come on, what's with the "actually it's the least important instrument in a band" thing? there are no "more important instruments" in a band. Maybe in a song.. But try to take guitars out a band. It'll suck
Liquid Trio Experiment is cool. Why? Because without the drum and bass you fucked up guitarheads won't have anything to play to just a fucked up hell lot of noise you are making and 80% of all guitarplayers (especially death metal) don't know wtf they're doing. The other point is rehearsels: Every time you're discussing, this guitar fag plays his fucked up riffs so no one can hear eachother and everyone has to get cranky and mad at eachother just like the other times the guitarist was present.
Oooohh Shut up. that's a tone of bullshit. Is not my fault if all the guitarists you know are shit or total dickheads. Stays the fact that "actually it's the least important instrument in a band" was total bullshit. A band is made by its complexity. Taking out something makes it shitty. And for the death metal thing, it depends on every single player.
Well it´s quite difficult to talk to someone who doesn´t answer to my comment, but just making the same statement as before. You actually make me think of one of those guitarplayers, seeing himself better and more worth then the other instruments in the band, THAT's the reason why i dislike the guitar. Yes i play bass.
How can i answer to that? you just stated your opinion about guitar players. And i said that you probably know gay guitarists if you consider them all like that. And -->( A band is made by its complexity. Taking out something makes it shitty) should explain you that (seeing himself better and more worth then the other instruments in the band) this is not true. cheers
He said a band becomes shitty if you take an instrument out of it, he didn't say it's shitty if it doesn't have a guitar player when it's founded. I guess you just refuse to understand what people tell you, he said that all the instruments and players in a band are important, and that you probably heard shitty guitar players if you think the way you do. Well what can I say, just don't call guitarists ignorant bastards if you keep ignoring other people's opinions...
Then you might watch your mouth for 1: I never said ignorant, i said arrogant. 2: Fuck off i wasn't talking to you. 3: Why are you even in this discussion? Because you have no fucking live you just scroll around old youtube pages to irritate people?
"Ignorant bastards" was the summarize of the whole description you wrote about guitarists in general.
And this argument really makes me laugh, I just love the people who say I have no life because you just know you come here every 2 minutes to see if you convinced anyone, and you for sure know you're trying to irritate BY FAR more than me when you say a half world and his mother suck because of their instrument, and you say it behind a YT random username.
hehe, well the funny part is that you actually just turn things around because: I get an email to replys on my posts, i only come back to this place just to listen to this song or reply someone back. YOU on the other hand, searched a 2nd page to see if you can be irritating by entering a 1 on 1 discussion.
Oh btw quote to "he didn't say it's shitty if it doesn't have a guitar player when it's founded" LTE was founded with guitar, but that album was without guitar.
I came here to watch the video just like you, but then I saw weird comments about that "one on one" argument and I was interested to know what it is about. And what can I do, I like and appreciate each one of DT's members. So if you don't like an instrument, or anything else, coming to the people who do and saying it won't help you. Go to Liquid videos and post there, why do you have to keep saying guitarists suck in a video of a band that was founded by 4 people including a guitarist?
@Carlos7492 dude... you don't know how important a bass guitar in a band is... together with the drums, they make a background... no background, no BALLS!!! what is metal without bass?
When he came in he would have added the vocals but this particular performance is before they had Dominici in the band. They wrote the song without any vocals first
hm. watching the budokan dvd would be the best. there's a feature where you can listen to ONLY MYUNG or watch him playing to be exact. search for it on youtube.
Cool that you put this up! GREAT MAN im pretty sure I havnt heard this one! Its so mystical so beatufiful full of life and joy!! GREAT! They are AWESOME! I might have heard some of it if they played some of it before a concert in Sthlm hmmm... 2005 or something... but great song, atleast I like the tones and stuff alot on... alot of it! AWESOME!!!
They perform it on Score. It's done really well. Plus, I don't think this version has keyboards. The Score version has lyrics as well, and James sings it very well.
Rush Theather!
DreamLizard 3 months ago
Okay, so i made an executive decision: the producers will go back in and remix every DT album and finally make JM the loudest track :)
WowzaGuy 11 months ago
Wow, this was like pure Rush here! lol
nickguitarfreak17 1 year ago 3
This song is so electrifying and cool!!!!! :D
tealfootball2832 1 year ago
pure Maiden worship
MagnaThor 1 year ago
wow you never hear myung like this amazing the can sing there's nothing wrong with his voice it's because he had never sung before but if you watch the documentry on score it explains it all
drummerveress 1 year ago
perfect bass!
woorso 1 year ago
The songs during the Majesty period don't get me much... They're very good, just not my type of music. (Ytse Jam rocks, though)
This is a very good song, it wasn't bad at all on Score.
nekezajebancije 2 years ago
Niice instrumental... this song is MAJESTY. I can try singing to this one too :P
EvilSkeltos 2 years ago
best
baktagogen 2 years ago
cool! that's history, man!
zakkwyldeverehrer 2 years ago
Reminds me a lot of Rush in a way, but more faster.
tomer1224 2 years ago 7
Myung's bass sound is amazing!!
wesander 2 years ago 23
yeah, he really rocked back then (he still rocks now, but alas, he has tuned down because he wanted to serve the band...)... darn shame says I
Rimes87 2 years ago 5
Well thats what the bass should do, tune down its volume until a section that requires a bass protagonism appears, and thats were the bass do its work.
sebastianDTBeat 2 years ago
Wow! You can actually HEAR John Myung's bass!
FrancescoK 2 years ago 26
jajajajaja
and it sounds awsome
ricardoestrella11 2 years ago
This is what Iron Maiden would sound like on acid..
AndreasLuna 2 years ago 7
Hey, now Avenged Sevenfold doesn't suck. They're just not even a quarter as good as Dream Theater and never will be. :P
Element404 2 years ago 4
Pretty much
KnownEnemy2 2 years ago 2
It's funny that that really doesn't say much. Who IS a quarter as good as Dream Theater? =P
shishkebab09 2 years ago 2
The fact that Ruddess went to Julliard at the age of 9, and that Petrucci, Myung, and Portnoy went to Berklee and practiced their asses off really says something. As for James LaBrie, he's just a damn amazing singer.
I just saw Dream Theater last night. Rudess and Petrucci ended up playing solos in other music genres(which was amazing).
There was really so much going on. It's something you should all see. The other bands were nice and Zappa Plays Zappa was especially amazing.
Element404 2 years ago 6
This is totally like Rush, even Myung's bass tone sounds just like Geddy's. I wish his bass was as prominent now as it was back then.
Diastavrones 2 years ago 5
avenged sevenfold sucks a big nut. FOR F*CKS SAKE PLAY IN A KEY OTHER THAN D MINOR!!!!
ChowderDingus 2 years ago 12
I love the lyrics to this song, a huge shame theres no singer on this record! Try the Score version, just beautifully sung by James, the lyrics are so great and poetic, makes me cry evertime...
Erotomaniac92 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
this reminds me of avenged sevenfold
chunkychickensoup 2 years ago
avenged sevenfold was influenced by dream theater :/
monkeylemur 2 years ago
so? they still suck
cronology 2 years ago 9
HAHA awesome comment cronology!
z341 2 years ago
Love the chorused guitar. And Myung rocks!
timephoenixnz 2 years ago
oh my god i get goosebumps and almost start to cry when i listen to this.
Accavarium 2 years ago 2
brutal, just brutal
Cuchimanmrs 3 years ago
I agree with Azloah
"Thats how basslines should always be! Equal with everything else."
luc454545 3 years ago 9
we are all agree. one thing i don't understand is why myung accepts that now he is not as important as other member of the band. in the WDAD Reunite DVD audio commentary, when Mike says ``in those times bass was like a lead guitar´´ and JM didn't say anything (as always). i don't think that the rest of the band ignores his compositons, i just think that JM has changed his mind about what is the bass in a band. and when i think about it i feel so sad....
Carlos7492 3 years ago 5
I know, in WDADU Myung has a wealth of bass solos and loud, powerful,parts, but nowadays he is hardly even heard. Its almost like he's too shy for the spotlight, even with his vast potential. He shouldn't just be doubling Petrucci's riffs.
DTismajesty 3 years ago 2
He's as important as he was then, now he is more rythm which is the bassist his duty, back then he was way more melodic (which is really cool) But without him it still is empty and i probably won't like DT without him, but guitar is way more up front because mindless musicians only hear guitar.... And think that that is the most important instrument (actually it's the least important instrument in a band)
Sproeikoei 3 years ago
oohh come on, what's with the "actually it's the least important instrument in a band" thing? there are no "more important instruments" in a band. Maybe in a song.. But try to take guitars out a band. It'll suck
deathmetaliscool 2 years ago
Liquid Trio Experiment is cool. Why? Because without the drum and bass you fucked up guitarheads won't have anything to play to just a fucked up hell lot of noise you are making and 80% of all guitarplayers (especially death metal) don't know wtf they're doing. The other point is rehearsels: Every time you're discussing, this guitar fag plays his fucked up riffs so no one can hear eachother and everyone has to get cranky and mad at eachother just like the other times the guitarist was present.
Sproeikoei 2 years ago
Oooohh Shut up. that's a tone of bullshit. Is not my fault if all the guitarists you know are shit or total dickheads. Stays the fact that "actually it's the least important instrument in a band" was total bullshit. A band is made by its complexity. Taking out something makes it shitty. And for the death metal thing, it depends on every single player.
deathmetaliscool 2 years ago 2
Oh, btw, what do you play? drums or bass?
deathmetaliscool 2 years ago 3
Well it´s quite difficult to talk to someone who doesn´t answer to my comment, but just making the same statement as before. You actually make me think of one of those guitarplayers, seeing himself better and more worth then the other instruments in the band, THAT's the reason why i dislike the guitar. Yes i play bass.
Sproeikoei 2 years ago
How can i answer to that? you just stated your opinion about guitar players. And i said that you probably know gay guitarists if you consider them all like that. And -->( A band is made by its complexity. Taking out something makes it shitty) should explain you that (seeing himself better and more worth then the other instruments in the band) this is not true. cheers
deathmetaliscool 2 years ago 2
I don´t play drums, i play bass and guitar. as i already said, liquid trio experiment, no guitars at all, it ain´t shitty at all.
Sproeikoei 2 years ago
He said a band becomes shitty if you take an instrument out of it, he didn't say it's shitty if it doesn't have a guitar player when it's founded. I guess you just refuse to understand what people tell you, he said that all the instruments and players in a band are important, and that you probably heard shitty guitar players if you think the way you do. Well what can I say, just don't call guitarists ignorant bastards if you keep ignoring other people's opinions...
RockRulez124 2 years ago
Then you might watch your mouth for 1: I never said ignorant, i said arrogant. 2: Fuck off i wasn't talking to you. 3: Why are you even in this discussion? Because you have no fucking live you just scroll around old youtube pages to irritate people?
Sproeikoei 2 years ago
"Ignorant bastards" was the summarize of the whole description you wrote about guitarists in general.
And this argument really makes me laugh, I just love the people who say I have no life because you just know you come here every 2 minutes to see if you convinced anyone, and you for sure know you're trying to irritate BY FAR more than me when you say a half world and his mother suck because of their instrument, and you say it behind a YT random username.
RockRulez124 2 years ago
hehe, well the funny part is that you actually just turn things around because: I get an email to replys on my posts, i only come back to this place just to listen to this song or reply someone back. YOU on the other hand, searched a 2nd page to see if you can be irritating by entering a 1 on 1 discussion.
Oh btw quote to "he didn't say it's shitty if it doesn't have a guitar player when it's founded" LTE was founded with guitar, but that album was without guitar.
Now i'm done.
Sproeikoei 2 years ago
I came here to watch the video just like you, but then I saw weird comments about that "one on one" argument and I was interested to know what it is about. And what can I do, I like and appreciate each one of DT's members. So if you don't like an instrument, or anything else, coming to the people who do and saying it won't help you. Go to Liquid videos and post there, why do you have to keep saying guitarists suck in a video of a band that was founded by 4 people including a guitarist?
RockRulez124 2 years ago
It isn't shitty but it isn't exciting. There's like one good riff on L3E.
And 0 emotionzzzzzzzzz
dimedizzle 2 years ago
ah that´s true ^^ It really is for the patient and pink floyd level but even beyond. Sounds alot like Dave Weckl you know, also strange music.
Sproeikoei 2 years ago
@Sproeikoei
You're a fucking idiot
VanishingDigital 2 years ago
He's pretty much been replaced by Jordan Rudess.
Although I love his bass lines on Octavarium
Samoriah 2 years ago
@Carlos7492 dude... you don't know how important a bass guitar in a band is... together with the drums, they make a background... no background, no BALLS!!! what is metal without bass?
dreamtheat3r 9 months ago
this cam e on the lifting shadows cd i love it
pspsean 3 years ago
I wish they would make a studio recording of this! amazing
DTismajesty 3 years ago
this song does´t need any vocals!!!! this is the best of DREAM THEATER
HenriquesRusso 3 years ago
It has Vocals on Score.
jvl101993 2 years ago 2
there was another version of Another Won with Chris Collins singing on it...I wonder what happened to that video I loved it!
if anyone knows where I can watch it please lemme know
Rakim360 3 years ago
Thats how basslines should always be! Equal with everything else.
Azloah 3 years ago 5
Rush on steroids!!! Dream Theater doesn't jam quite like that any more. And I'm not saying this is better, just a little different.
RAP511 3 years ago 2
Where is the vocal?
There is supposed to be a vocal in this song...
kvilvik 3 years ago
This is before they had a singer
Azloah 3 years ago
No i have another version of Another Won with Charles Dominitchi on the vokal...
kvilvik 3 years ago
When he came in he would have added the vocals but this particular performance is before they had Dominici in the band. They wrote the song without any vocals first
Azloah 3 years ago
myung needs to sound loud again
trustobey1016 3 years ago 11
This was so influenced by Rush. It's awesome.
Tom89Wog 3 years ago 3
yeh it sounds soo very much like it :) ;)
Sproeikoei 3 years ago
Myung is soooooo loud!!!!
jackeddemon 3 years ago 8
yes!!!! isn't that great????
also, the bass lines were treated as another melody line (not as harmony in the background as it's nowdays :(
Actually i think i like more the majesty demos than WDADU
Carlos7492 3 years ago 4
Rythm ;) Myung isn't a very rythmic bassist in his first years, at FII he got more into it :)
Sproeikoei 3 years ago
he has still rhythmic problems today. and i say this as a fan mostly inspirationed by him.
Accavarium 2 years ago
could you give some examples of that? i'm just curious that's all.
Thanks!
Woilem 2 years ago
hm. watching the budokan dvd would be the best. there's a feature where you can listen to ONLY MYUNG or watch him playing to be exact. search for it on youtube.
Accavarium 2 years ago
This is a Beautiful song!
metallero85 3 years ago
Cool that you put this up! GREAT MAN im pretty sure I havnt heard this one! Its so mystical so beatufiful full of life and joy!! GREAT! They are AWESOME! I might have heard some of it if they played some of it before a concert in Sthlm hmmm... 2005 or something... but great song, atleast I like the tones and stuff alot on... alot of it! AWESOME!!!
jimmyalexanderl 3 years ago
you gotta get this cd on internet... ihave searched everywhere to get this can't get hold of it... ARGH
woodsterix 3 years ago
They perform it on Score. It's done really well. Plus, I don't think this version has keyboards. The Score version has lyrics as well, and James sings it very well.
Tom89Wog 3 years ago
thanks man, i haven't got a copy of score yet, i ordered it off amazon yesterday
woodsterix 3 years ago
this is great man, thanks so much!
ThrashCatchem 3 years ago 2
thank you for watching ;)
PS: we need more views!!! can you help me?
Carlos7492 3 years ago
thank you!! i thing i am
thanks for watching
Carlos7492 3 years ago
hahaha ure a good fan n.n
sicarinpinpon 3 years ago