Added: 3 months ago
From: SmashCastVEVO
Views: 208,521
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (462)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Beautiful!!! Beautiful!!! Beautiful!!!

  • A voz mais bonita que já ouvi em toda minha vida.

  • She had everything.. but decided to get married... Now she's just older and really not improved... She must be alliance...

  • glee did it better

  • she is so pretty

  • She's unreal

    

  • Love this! Katherine McPhee is amazing!! So glad she's in Smash!

  • <3 Karen

  • this song sung by her is awesome!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • This is a good song for her to sing after her troubles with eating disorders.

  • who won season 5 of idol?

  • this is not better than the original. the original christina hits all those high notes during the bridge. kathrine doesn't even try. christina shows off talent when doing that and is very loud and not all soft and quiet, kathrine doesn't try and is all soft and quiet. it's a strong song, she missed the best part of it. -____-

  • @therandomgirl25 I personally liked it. Everyone in the music industry tries to sound like eachother- wailing into high notes that nobody could possibly hit, and showing how powerful they can sound. I'm not dogging on high notes and power at all. I really love that stuff, don't get me wrong. But for there to be a high and powerful, there has to be a soft and quiet. I love it.

  • I love the replay button <3

  • This is gorgeous! Katharine McPhee is so talented! Smash is still new, but it has already put out some great songs. One of my favorites is 'Rumor Has It' by Adele, which is up on NBC's website right now. Seriously I'm in love. This show rocks. 

  • 29 people are not beautiful.

  • Her voice sounds amazing, it has improved and developed so much more than when she was on American Idol.

  • lets all remember why this song was made. To show everyone that they matter not to argue about whose a better singer or which is a better show.

  • Does anyone know in what gorgeous old theatre this video was filmed ??

  • Much better than Christina's version..Katharine voice is smooth and she doesn't sound like a horse bull-frog when she rounds out her 'o,s", very beautiful !!

  • Obviously 29 people are not beautiful. 

  • McPheever>>>Snookitina

  • BREAK IT DOWN ON KNIGHTS! 

  • No. This version is NOT better than the original. That's impossible. How can a COVER of a song be BETTER than the ORIGINAL? Someone explain that statement to me. Without the original song, no one could have even though of doing a cover of it. The original will always be the best version of that song. A cover can be AS GOOD as the original, but not BETTER. That's preposterous..

  • @zackthedumbone99 Actually there's quite a few examples of the cover being better than the original. All along the watchtower by jimi hendrix is obviously better than bob dylan's original. Same with Sinead O' Connor's rendition of nothing compares to you (the original was by prince).

  • @zackthedumbone99 Your statement is "preposterous"... Not to take anything away from the original, but to claim that the original is always the best is simply wrong. Was the first car ever better than a 2012 Mercedes S-Class? Not a chance... the new version is better in every single way. Time brings experience and subsequently improvement. To suggest that the original is always the best is to suggest that humans are simply stagnant, which despite you making a good case for, is simply note true.

  • i dont care what people think. i love her version sooooo much more then christina!!! <33333 oh and check out my video singing this song pleaseee at kylieclark95 :)

  • yea i mean Megan Hilty has a good voice, but she's got nothing on Katherine McPhee

  • vanessa hudgens kinda looks like her

  • Perfect Winner !

  • shes hot

  • Katharine McPhee's voice is PERFECT for jazz and musicals!!! She was never meant to do generic pop!!! Love her in Smash :)

    And yes, she should've won AI.

  • Ummm Why in the WORLD is she JUST NOW acting?! She is BRILLIANT!! Love her 10X more than I already did!! I love you Kathrine McPhee <3 You. Are. My new FAVORITE actress and singer.

  • I watched the pilot last night online and totally was amazed... As long as this show doesn't make it all about sex, and instead continues to focus on the lives of the characters it will be a hit. Katherine absolutely makes this show.

  • i totally agree, but im gladd American idol didnt out their grimy hands all over her, she IS beautiful, and im really liking this show, i hope its a hit.

  • Is this in episode 1?

  • TAYLOR HICKS....NOW IVY LYNN? F*** THAT! D:

  • Finally TV is living up to all it can be.Thank you for realizing we can get it. On all level, with all emotions. The Music the Acting the Writing the Dancing...True Amazing. Thanks You

  • Smash may be the best thing on TV. Wait, it already IS.

  • I love Katherine McPhee, she KILLED this song :)

  • Taylor.. who? :P

  • goosebumps. she is beyond incredible.

  • I'm happy she didnt win American Idol because she isnt trapped and told what to sing because of a contract. She found her own way to say at the top.

  • @KalypzosMuse that's a good excuse for the fact that she wasn't good enough to win.

  • @xxbluejay21 Oh, and Taylor Hicks was?

  • @KalypzosMuse well obviously better than this girl.

  • i've got goosebumps on my goosebumps, this rendition was absolutely marvelous

  • She's no Lea Michele.

  • Her voice just never goes anywhere - there is never a "moment" that gives you chills. Just dynamically flat and dull.

  • Didn't she used to have large breasts?  What happened? Never have liked her voice.

  • i would "smash" katharine mcphee

  • Glee and Smash are two different shows.. not really even comparable accept their both musical. (shrug) As to Katherine Mcphee.. :D

  • I always knew she would be a great actress. I love her. Literally. Her husband is so fortunate to have her in his life. A beautiful wonderful singer and great actress. What more can you ask for. I'm sure she can cook as well. That would be a bonus. It wouldn't matter to me, I can cook my ass off.

  • Beverly Mclelland (sp?) did this 10x better than anyone, including Christina, on The Voice. This is weak.

  • Glad she's back.

    Almost forgot how incredibly beautiful she is.

  • People are comparing this to glee? ARE YOU SERIOUS? glee is like some high school stuff but this is about an actual career. This is way better in my opinion

  • Good, but they shouldn't have lowered the bridge

  • Beautiful song, beautiful voice, beautiful girl.

  • I liked this for 2 reasons, She is amazingly hot, and she has a beautiful voice. In that order, probably a 60/40 split. Don't care about the show.

  • Kinda makes you realize what a joke Taylor Hicks is. Man has she got really hot!

  • Why is everybody comparing glee to smash? They are two totally different shows! But, i have to agree with this, smash is kicking glee in the butt! I love both of the shows and that is just my honest opinion!

  • It's amazing but not as good as Christina

  • i used to love LOVE glee, but after watching the pilot of smash i changed my mind, smash is now one of my fav shows.

  • does anyone else find her hotter in the theater?

  • jeez she grew up..what year was she on idol? '05 she shouldve won instead of that creep...

  • @Xstarsushi i think 06 actually

  • the best...not over cooked..just perfect all around..

  • She is beautiful, and honestly, I like her rendition even more than Christina's. (cue the rotten tomatos and other slimy veggies)

  • @yowee1234 Don't mistake her though Christina CAN sing if she wants too.

  • @yowee1234 I don't think many people will argue with you on this one.

  • @yowee1234 She sings it well but she doesn't nail the emotion that the song has. I think if she had that and they added say a heavy guitar it would make it absolutely perfect.

  • I wish I could be on a show like this one! When I come back to LA I'm auditioning like no other..

  • Katherine is a fantastic singer! She should be on The Voice!!!!!!

  • Katharine Mcphee's voice: amazing, pure, unique. I honestly love this version, it's simple. LOVE IT. LOVE HER.

  • I love how the American Idol runner ups always get it better than the actual winners, well except Kelly Clarkson and Carrie Underwood. I knew Katharine would do better than the winner for her season. Go Katharine! I've always believed in your success!

  • @BigTimeRusher72 only cuz she's a hot girl...

  • This show is nothing compared to glee. This show understands the hard work that us actresses have to go through. Glee is just singing in a room, with the same people ruining songs. SMASH shows competition, and the real work it takes to get on Broadway. Fighting against the girl who always gets the lead.... and the sacrifices it takes.

  • @LuvzHugz Well i agree except glee shows hard work too sometimes its just singing in a room but others its about the struggles in life while following your dreams

  • Comment removed

  • justin's face made me throw up, but her voice made me feel better instantly

  • Like if you knew Katherine McPhee from American Idol.

  • whats with justins face next to the vid???

  • i love this show

  • i dont really c how a christina aguilira song lets a cute girl like her in a marylin monroe play.

  • @CarlsonOfTheArmy they had three original songs in the first episode alone.

  • Jack Davenport is the sex.

  • To RichVallejo and david90531: Of course Smash will be compared to Glee. It's the only other musical on network TV right now (or even cable, as far as I know). Both do covers of pop songs. How can you possibly avoid the comparison?

  • The only issue I have with this is the same issue that I have with a lot of what Glee does. It sounds too much like its just a karaoke track. I want them to take songs and breath a new life into them. What Glee did with The Warblers, that's what I'm talking about. Taking a great song, and putting a fresh spin on it.

  • @CarlsonOfTheArmy You mean like KAT did with 'BEAUTIFUL' ?....You won't ever find a 'fresher spin' than that. PLUS the song was made for Kat's voice...... PERFECTION !

  • anyone seen The L.A. Complex? That just premiered too, but Smash is waaaaaay better

  • Smash > Glee

  • She's amazing!! Definitely will watch :)

  • when Katharine started to sing this during the show...good God i was hypnotized & compelled so fast!!!!!!

    honestly i love the show the Pilot was beyond brilliant and honestly people getting referred to watch this show or comparing it to gLee...just wow open your eyes hears stop being sheep be the damn Shepard...all the hype of this show is worth it.

    "Sometimes dreams are hard." if nothing else take away from that simple line with endless possibilities.

  • just saw it, its a great show, the audition scene was very moving

  • Needs moar Megan Hilty.

  • Smash > glee.

    

  • My brothers a dancer in Smash, he says shes amazing :)

  • This is why katharine mcphee should have won american idol not taylor.

  • @UniqualovesAustin Even though I agree, but I'm over that by now. Taylor was also a great performer, but just not contemporary. Katharine has a natural talent with her beautiful voice, and not to mention she looks stunning every time she goes on stage

  • @UniqualovesAustin Kat has improved immensely since AI, and NOW she can be maybe the very best singer today. All she needed was the chance to shine and gain experience. Is she shining now.....or what...! Spielberg knew ! ! ! GO KAT....

  • @UniqualovesAustin FINALLY someone agrees with me on this issue.

  • @UniqualovesAustin It's okay, she's still more successful than Taylor. And on top of that we all know that the reason why Taylor won is because they needed a white guy to win. Not that that is a big problem but you know.

  • @UniqualovesAustin I was totally disappointed that she didn't win it. She was far away better than Taylor Hicks. Just look at what they have done individually since. I still haven't seen any records or songs by him, but have seen a couple releases by this amazing young woman.

  • @UniqualovesAustin This is the reason why I hate shows like this: superficial BS. The only reason she got as far as she did was because of her breasts. She proved herself to be a shallow publicity hunter, coming out with that sob story afterward about her anorexia. Taylor Hicks deserved his win.

    Paris Bennett deserved far more than she got then. Let's also remember Susan Boyle's audition on BGT.

    As Gene Simmons said on being fired from the Apprentice: "It's an image thing."

  • @UniqualovesAustin This is the reason why I hate shows like this: superficial BS. The only reason she got as far as she did was because of her breasts. She proved herself to be a shallow publicity hunter, coming out with that sob story afterward about her anorexia. Taylor Hicks deserved his win.

    Paris Bennett deserved far more than she got then. Let's also remember Susan Boyle's audition on BGT.

    As Gene Simmons said on being fired from the Apprentice: "It's an image thing."

  • Smash > Glee

  • she's so amazing she's my new role model

  • great version, but i dont really see how this song fits in with a marylin monroe production :/

  • stop singing start acting please ! rich cause it is simularites are so much alike but just an adult Glee why can t producers get their own writing skills

  • @Kevin198898 Every single episode of Smash will have original songs. The pilot alone has 3 original songs!

  • I'm watching the premiere tonight

  • Comment removed

  • i don't remember her from american idol...

  • Aw... What happened to the ending thats on the commercial????

  • I'm actually really excited to watch this show. The Pilot episode was AMAZING and I'm loving this song and video! Smash is looking to be a smash hit, and I plan on watching every second of the way! AMAZING singer, AMAZING song, and AWESOME show! =))

  • Your beautiful. to anyone who is reading this.

  • better than the original!

  • Katharine, you are an absolute goddess. Transcendent!

  • Best version ever! I can't wait for the show to premiere!

  • In all my life I havent heard a version of beautiful that topped christina aguilera's. I think i just found it!

  • 27 don't feel Beautiful!!

  • This show is amazing and this song :)

  • When the interviewer were looking at each other like "Yah, this is our girl", I was like "hell yah, she is"

  • so happy this (me) musical theatre baby gets an awesome birthday present this year im turning 21 on feb 6th --- the day this comes out.....

  • the pilot was so awesome! katherine was my FAVE american idol!! im so proud of her!! shes a great actress tooo!!! GO KAT!!!

  • I'm excited to watch this!! : )

  • 1. This show has nothing to do with Glee, the only similarity is that it's a musical show

    2. The production team and cast looks fantastic, lots of talents including Kat Mcphee and Davenport

    3. Pilot was very well-done, slow at first but picks up with great drama, instead of throwing a bunch of things to the audience in the first episode

    4. ORIGINAL SONGS every episode, can't get any more exciting than that!

  • @kac5318 her voice is not auto-tuned that is her real voice, i have the same kind of voice as her..bugg offf

  • She can sing so STOP AUTO-TUNING it!!!

    STOP AUTOTUNING PEOPLE WHO CAN SING! She is can sing, leave her voice alone!!!

    STOP AUTOTUNING PEOPLE WHO CAN SING! She is can sing, leave her voice alone!!!

    STOP AUTOTUNING PEOPLE WHO CAN SING! She is can sing, leave her voice alone!!!

    STOP AUTOTUNING PEOPLE WHO CAN SING! She is can sing, leave her voice alone!!!

    STOP AUTOTUNING PEOPLE WHO CAN SING! She is can sing, leave her voice alone!!!

  • LOVED the 1st episode and can't wait for more.

  • It really irritates me when they say "Introducing" Katherine McPhee in the commercials...... Come on, America, did we REALLY forget that she was the runner up of American Idol Season 5????

  • Can't wait for the series to start!!!!! only 1 week!!!

  • she is stunnningg!

  • Omg I'm obsessed with this. The pilot episode is amazing, and I seriously can't wait for the season to officially start on 2/6!! Love this!!!

  • i love it it makes me happy

     <3

  • she lip sinking Christina ? 

  • @MoreBankrBailoutsPLZ you spell-checking your comments?

  • @david90531 how about you piss off jackwad,so sweet how you have to dress up guinea pigs to have a girl friend

  • Wonderful new show. I love GLEE but this is different. Love Ivy and Karen.

  • Who else agrees that there is going to be a Team Karen and Team Ivy when it comes down to who gets Marilyn?

    P.S. Team Ivy all the way

  • thumbs up if you wish you had her voice <3

  • if you have comcast/xfinity its already on NBC on demand

  • awesome voice

  • Yes, i quite agree Katey McPhee. You are Beautiful.

  • I don't understand the glee comparisons i watched the pilot of smash and it was nothing like glee, I love them both. I guess the comparisons come because they both have music on television. But people saying watch out glee really need to stop they're completely different. The pilots on itunes for free

  • The best!

  • Kat and Smash are amazing. Feb 6 NBC Watch it

  • just watched this on nbc.com! this show is already my favorite show on television! i love it!

  • Just watched this on hulu. BRILLIANT!

  • Why do people compare this to Glee? Just because they sing? That's ridiculous lol. This is about a girl trying to make it big in broadway. Glee is about high school kids. I don't see the relations lol

  • @RichVallejo You KNOW this is a singing TV show so the producers can milk the money off the songs when they release it on iTunes.

  • @RichVallejo Glee is fake!

  • @RichVallejo What's Glee?

  • @RichVallejo Have you ever heard of the term ' MUSICAL' ? Age has nothing to do with it,... It never will ,... music has no boundaries ,... other than styles and variations

  • Can't Wait!!!!! Katharine Mcphee is so gorgeous!

  • Amber Riley's voice is more suited to this song.

  • The full Pilot episode is now available on NBC's website, Youtube, and Itunes!! GO WATCH IT NOW!

  • haha taylor hicks who's laughing now

  • OMG! I went to hulu which is a website where they show free episodes of series without downloading and their showing the first episode of SMASH now! Just type in hulu and click the first one!

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • be careful glee, cause SMASH just came to town :)