I don't believe in saying that one good singer is better than another good singer, just different. I do like fantasia's version a lot better. I'm not much of a fan of Hudson. But I feel she as be "competing" with a lot of other singers since she lost the weight. I think she has a voice, but lacks natural "soul"....Just my own un-bias opinion
What an absolutely gorgeous performance, to die for vocals- those that make your hairs stand up on the back of your neck... Jennifer Hudson is such an amazing performer.
This woman has the best voice I have ever heard. God be with her. She will be a legend. She is Like the Williams sisters, she has suffered a tragedy and still holds on. A truly strong Woman of Character and Spirit. God watch over her please.
I think she got Fantasia on this one. She doesn't run as much, but her voice quality is fuller and more resonant, and so provokes more emotion. They are both beasts, tho!
such a glorious sound, ring & clarity in her voice...was all goose pimplely when i first heard her sing this...easily one of the true voices of her generation!
Why do people insist on comparing Hudson & Fantasia? They both have their own style... This one was beyond Elegance and Perfection.... just Awesome!!!
At 2:58 wow, that was amazing! Couldnt be more beautiful!!! .... and then "Ladies and gentlmen the Tennessee's State University Choir" ok I was wrong!
Go head on Jen!!!! I have never heard her sing it b4 and she did it justice baby! I can't even compare her against Tasia!! They are both song diva equally..even onj American Idol!
If the emotion being portrayed is empowerment, then J-hud does an amazing job. Why is everyone all up in Arms comparing her to Fantasia...they are both incredible vocalists, and who you think did better is a matter of opinion...The fact of the matter is, they both add two different dimensions to one amazing song...People on youtube need to stop fighting to compare, and just enjoy whats on the screen...
People are so ignorant, did you guys not see what happened to her family a few years before? Obviously there's emotion there and you can see it in her beautiful voice tisk tisk
This extraordinary performance and inspiring tribute makes me travel to a place. At some point in human history, the term "breath-taking" was coined. I can only imagine that at THAT time, someone beheld something as powerful as this woman's voice and strength. I love the choir, but I would have loved to hear her GO and GO, unbridled... on her own to deliver what, to me, is the type of tribute that truly validates such an extraordinary woman herself. You deserved this Oprah Winfrey.
Sorry but for me Jennifer blows this out. Yes I like the emotion of Fantasia but the REAL voice of Jennifer is OUTSTANDING!!!!! More soulful, crisp - Mega props Jennifer
You are so right Mr. Tink! Fantasia can take any song you give her and sing it from her heart. She is our next little Patti Labelle! Jennifer can't move you like our girl Fantasia can. That's realness to the fullest!
This Was Okay.. But This Song Is More Suitable For A Person With Vocal Control Like FANTASIA... I Love Jennifer But Fantasia Kills Everything You Hand Her !!
PLEASE everyone BEWARE the #1 weight loss pill is killing people PLEASE type in JILLIAN MICHAELS THE TRUTH and then please help spread the word and maybe we can save a few lives and then please do it the right way the healthy way like J.H. what a great voice and talent she rocks
@TheCreolesoul see I think even the power in her voice is forced which is why she has such difficulty keeping control. Because she's trying to maintain the pitch and the power at the same she has difficulty staying on key. If she sings naturally I'm sure she'll be able to do it well, which is where I think Fantasia has succeeded. Not only does she have a unique sound, it's also natural which makes it easier for her to transcend musical genres. She's quite versatile and can sing anything.
I really dont think Jennifer can sing very well. She has amazing potential but if you listen to her carefully you'll hear that she has trouble controlling her voice. She over extends herself and tries to go beyond a manageable range within the scope of her abilities. For this song, the choir ruined it. You couldnt hear her. That aside, I think Fantasia not only sang this song better but is also a better singer. Fantasia is the real deal. Go to one of her concerts and you will become a believer.
@ObeahGyal couldn't agree with you more. I never witness fantasia mess up on a song but jennifer I have more than once. Its just sum ppl are more blessed with better pitch and control but Jennifer have bigger voice tho more power.
@DirtyRottenScoundrel: You read my comment wrong. Smh. That was in my opinion. Duh I know the song is written for Celie. Dummy. Im tired of people assuming too, like you. I said, "And I really believe this song was mad for Fantasia." I didnt say this song was written FOR FANTASIA. Do you know the difference between a fact and a person's opinion??? (NOPE!)
PLEASE everyone BEWARE the #1 weight loss pill is killing people PLEASE type in JILLIAN MICHAELS THE TRUTH and then help spread the word and maybe we can save a few lives and do it the right way like JH she rocks thank you
This tribute will go down in history as one the best tributes to Oprah W. Jennifer Hudson you really delivered your own version of this song. I was very proud of you and the outstanding job without comparing to Fantasia version of the same song. Fantasia also did an excellent job on her own version of the song as well. So many haters on this site.
I will say this. I prefer Fantasia's version because I love Fantasia. But Jennifer did just as well as far as actually singing the song. So in my opinion, Both nailed it and thats all that matters. Fantasia cries when she sings because she sings from that pain she has and still experiences. People have to understand that Both Fantasia and Jennifer have suffered greatly so when one wants to cry, they can do so.
Sorry, Im not even going to lie, I don't get the same emotion from her performance that I get from Fantasia. And thats the truth. The song is excellently written and structured. And I really believe this song was mad for Fantasia.
@Shybaby863 Except that it WASN'T written for Fantastia. This was written for Celie in The Color Purple. It is a musical theatre piece written for a character, and therefore is intended for interpretation by a wide variety of performers.
I'm so tired of people assuming that Fantastia Barrino owns this song, or originated it. LaChanze was the original Celie on Broadway, and she got the damn Tony. So we should show her a little respect.
I love jennifer! One of chi town's finest! I love fantasia,my sisters BOTH did a beautful job. However, everybody s missing th key here that both performances are different, that's all. fantasia's emotion you can see and hear. jennifer's power in her voice is different and her emotion is reserved but nonetheless present. fantasia made it hers,jennifer made other songs her own.
I think they both did very well, I enjoyed both versions but when it comes down to who did it better, it all depends on who you heard sing it first no matter if they're the originators
PLEASE everyone BEWARE the #1 weight loss pill is killing people PLEASE type in JILLIAN MICHAELS THE TRUTH and please stay healthy the right way like JH
Fantasia and Jennifer are my top favorite! They both sang this beautifully and with so much emotion. However I must say Fantasia owns this song. Hands down. She make me cry everytime Lol
this is great... and this isn't Fantasia's song... it's from the Color Purple and Fantasia was not the first one to sing it. Just wanting to clarify. I love both of their versions. Learn to see the good in everything.
Here what i have to say about this video. Although, it's Fantasia's song (which she song the hell out of) it is always a compliment when someone else, especially another artist, sings their song. Both Tasia and Jenn are friends and I am sure she didn't mind her singing it. I kinda like this performance. She really did her thing. I love Fantasia's version but again, it was nice to see someone sing her song. And this is coming from a REAL FANTASIA FAN!! #TeamTasia STAND UP!!!!
@TiannaEwing Neither is Summertime but when she sang it, she made it hers. Also, this is on her album which gives her ownership rights to the song. All I am saying is, she made it her own but Jennifer did a very good job at it.
2 elements to this: (1) Everyone interprets and emotes things differently. Which one you prefer comes down to your own experiences. (2) The same song for a different occasion or in a different setting has different demands for the performance. I enjoyed this one. A lot.
Does anyone notice if you look closely it looks like Hudson is about to forget the words at 2:40. ;)
Regardless of what anyone has to say, this was a beautiful rendition of a beautifully written song. Unless you are Jennifer yourself, you can't judge as to whether or not the emotion was there - you don't live in her mind after all. And obviously Oprah preferred to hear Hudson's rendition at the time. Who cares? They're both incredibly talented artists. Celebrate their talents; don't defame because of a bitter opinion.
You cannot compare Fantasia to Jennifer. Pardon the cliche, you cannot compare an apple to an orange. Yes Fantasia may have sung better to some, but to others' they live for Jennifer. Either way, can't we just be happy that there are two version or two million version of this song. You have your favorite, but just keep it positive!
When Fantasia sings this she doesn't sing just for herself alone. It feels like she's telling the audience "You know what, no matter what you've been through, it's okay. You're here now and you can move one to do greater things." That's what touched me so much about Fantasia's version. It just speaks to me.
Jennifer did sing with emotion too you know and I think she sung it brilliantly. Jennifer on one hand seems to be just putting up a "performance". On the other hand, Fantasia was was just living the song. Fantasia threw all her past troubles(teenage pregnancy, being called ugly all the time, being formerly illiterate, coming from a broken family etc.) into the song and just SANG the hell out of it. (con't)
That high note @2:46... love, love, love... I love Fantasia but agree with wTrevorh. Jennifer's version remains emotional but is delivered with more confidence. I got teary eyed with Jennifer's version while Fantasia's left me a tad irritated. I'm a fan Fantasia but you can't cry your way through every single song...
I like Jennifer's version more. There's more confidence in her voice. It seems like when Fantasia sings it, she seems more like a victim, who lacks the confidence the song requires. Fantasia finds too many tears.
Jennifer and Fantasia did awesome jobs singing this song. It's just about whose version you like better. I ,myself, enjoyed Fantasia's much better. I felt the emotion of the song from Fantasia.
Estimated friend, if you want to listen again this song and an endless number of successes of the love I suggest you to visit Radio MUSICA PARA MIMOS - looks for his direction URL in Google ( search Musica para Mimos in Google)-. best romantic music of all the times in Internet, is great, is very good ...!!!
Singing her whole life in these words. Beautiful performance JHud. This woman has gone through so much. She is very deserving of everlasting happiness.
I LOVE J HUD(EVEN MET HER IN PERSON AND HUGGED! AHH MEMORIES LOL) BUT I HAVE TO SAY I LIKE HOW FANTASIA DID IT BETTER. FANTASIA GAVE IT DEPTH AND FEELIN. I JUST LOOKED AT THIS BUT FANTASIA MADE MY MOUTH DROP WHEN I FIRST SAW HER DO IT. BOTH STILL AMAZING
Jennifer Hudson is a class act! This is the BEST version of this song ever! Frickin awesome!!!
nanjanmc1 15 hours ago
you can see that oprah feels IT'S RIGHT!
lilithmoon1979 21 hours ago
SHE FUCKED THIS UP BIG TIME #TEAMTASIA
kewashag 1 day ago
@kewashag shut up!
lilithmoon1979 21 hours ago
I don't believe in saying that one good singer is better than another good singer, just different. I do like fantasia's version a lot better. I'm not much of a fan of Hudson. But I feel she as be "competing" with a lot of other singers since she lost the weight. I think she has a voice, but lacks natural "soul"....Just my own un-bias opinion
remyfacade 1 day ago
Different voices..both great performance. Good job ladies!
Ngunongon 1 day ago
What an absolutely gorgeous performance, to die for vocals- those that make your hairs stand up on the back of your neck... Jennifer Hudson is such an amazing performer.
PissyJamesPants 2 days ago
Fantesia and Jenifer are different , but they are sing wonderfully!
177coc 3 days ago
She Sucks!!!
Leelyn05 4 days ago
@Leelyn05 you suck....retard.
kadyyyxoxo 4 days ago
@kadyyyxoxo nope she does!!!
Leelyn05 3 days ago
@Leelyn05 omg., you suck
violencegolden 3 days ago
@violencegolden no I said she does!!!
Leelyn05 3 days ago
gone Jennifer!!!!!! that girl can sing her butt off ;)
babygirl91580 4 days ago
god that dress is just amazing!!!
drkmgic 4 days ago
although she did a good job, she is NO WHERE NEAR Fantasia's version
ritchscott 5 days ago
she look gooooooooooooood
donmoreno25 6 days ago
I love Jennifer Hudson. God bless her and her family. What an inspiration.
aristatole1 6 days ago
that brought me to tears and took me in!!!
happyorganist 1 week ago
This woman has the best voice I have ever heard. God be with her. She will be a legend. She is Like the Williams sisters, she has suffered a tragedy and still holds on. A truly strong Woman of Character and Spirit. God watch over her please.
John
UKITAFRA1981 1 week ago 6
now i know where that gif came from..
cnjisdf934 1 week ago
I love Jennifer Hudson! Wow! Jennifer, you are such an inspiration to many young women! God bless you!!!!
df363 1 week ago
I think she got Fantasia on this one. She doesn't run as much, but her voice quality is fuller and more resonant, and so provokes more emotion. They are both beasts, tho!
Lucious25 1 week ago 2
LOL... Love the black guy at 3:15... he was just Enjoying the song...
rapharesto 1 week ago
where's the soul the heart and the emotion all i hear is screaming...epic fail!!
immature0916 1 week ago
@immature0916 Fantasia fan struggling with JHud's success. .
ba4774 5 days ago
Tears. Running down my face. That was BEAUTIFUL
TripleThreatHannah 1 week ago
I love anything that moves me, this moved me
fhumphrey1 1 week ago
CCTV
Isiahc56 1 week ago
jennifer please... sing this beautiful song for Whitney... i'm in tears when i think of this angel
rimbaud15 1 week ago
LOVE IT
rondell911 1 week ago
Comment removed
cococrane1 2 weeks ago
I hate to do this, but...it wasn't as good as Fantasia's.
sblxi 2 weeks ago 3
i just BAWLED
MOKandRIFF 2 weeks ago
such a glorious sound, ring & clarity in her voice...was all goose pimplely when i first heard her sing this...easily one of the true voices of her generation!
harlemhomme 2 weeks ago
This was one powerful performance!
Mr2009general 2 weeks ago
PLEASE MAKE MORE RECORDS
PianoMan1191 2 weeks ago
Why do people insist on comparing Hudson & Fantasia? They both have their own style... This one was beyond Elegance and Perfection.... just Awesome!!!
rapharesto 2 weeks ago 8
Comment removed
nanjanmc1 15 hours ago
I got.. goosebumps.
TheOAnu 2 weeks ago
This has been flagged as spam show
:] VISIT my channel and watch Jennifer Hudson covers!!! :)
VivianaGomezMUSIC 2 weeks ago
fantasias better than this.
joshua09217886390 3 weeks ago
Fantastic :D
JenniferHudsonTribe 3 weeks ago
Powerful!!!
mochanflowerz 3 weeks ago
Flawless.. Just amazing!
richstpete 3 weeks ago
that was exceptional
omarieswifey 3 weeks ago
At 2:58 wow, that was amazing! Couldnt be more beautiful!!! .... and then "Ladies and gentlmen the Tennessee's State University Choir" ok I was wrong!
teddy37300 3 weeks ago 2
I usually don't make comments like this but how could anyone dislike this? It's perfection!
borntosing22 3 weeks ago
perfeita,linda ainda mais uma musica pra melhor apresentadora do mundo
wendellpozo1 3 weeks ago
Go head on Jen!!!! I have never heard her sing it b4 and she did it justice baby! I can't even compare her against Tasia!! They are both song diva equally..even onj American Idol!
MsSexyDiva4Lyfe 3 weeks ago
Simply one of the greatest singers that is currently living. I solute Jennifer Hudson who is one of most underated singers.
sexycubanchocolate 3 weeks ago
I love Jenny singin this as much as I love Fanny singin it they both killed it in different ways
KomplexiveMind 3 weeks ago
I GOT CHILLZ
Ahtivah 4 weeks ago
@Ahtivah Amazing isn't it... Jennifer is one of the best things to ever happen to all of us.She's simply amazing!
richstpete 3 weeks ago
I loved that dress...I want to get it in white nd where it to my wedding
jensinetosine 1 month ago
love the look on Oprah's face when the choir appears, love Jennifer Hudson. It is very rare you get someone who sings with that much passion
l0veDali 1 month ago
46 people have tomatoes in their ears
carentje2009 1 month ago 2
I love Jennifer shes amazing:)
blossomcandy01 1 month ago
sexy JHud...
gino825 1 month ago
If you have "Anything" negative to say about this performance , you're a hater. She was AMAZING.
rickyybobbyy01 1 month ago 2
@rickyybobbyy01 didn't like it..
tytheeman20 1 month ago
If the emotion being portrayed is empowerment, then J-hud does an amazing job. Why is everyone all up in Arms comparing her to Fantasia...they are both incredible vocalists, and who you think did better is a matter of opinion...The fact of the matter is, they both add two different dimensions to one amazing song...People on youtube need to stop fighting to compare, and just enjoy whats on the screen...
brennastyify 1 month ago
Paul is like...dayum that's a surprise! hahaha!
beautofdreams 1 month ago
I love her voice it is ohh soo powerful n annoited..thank u Jesus.!<3 her..!!
HandsomeKhyree19 1 month ago
@HandsomeKhyree19 Honey it "a'int" jeesus.. It's here talent
richstpete 1 month ago
People are so ignorant, did you guys not see what happened to her family a few years before? Obviously there's emotion there and you can see it in her beautiful voice tisk tisk
JakeReeves001 1 month ago
This extraordinary performance and inspiring tribute makes me travel to a place. At some point in human history, the term "breath-taking" was coined. I can only imagine that at THAT time, someone beheld something as powerful as this woman's voice and strength. I love the choir, but I would have loved to hear her GO and GO, unbridled... on her own to deliver what, to me, is the type of tribute that truly validates such an extraordinary woman herself. You deserved this Oprah Winfrey.
GetSet7754 1 month ago in playlist Favorite videos
Both are great
adriannajackson15 1 month ago
Fantasia did it better, hey but it is fantasia song, originally. But I still like J. Hud
adriannajackson15 1 month ago
@adriannajackson15 i think its from color purple. thats the original singer of the song.
MrFoolish2009 1 month ago
im in love
hannahEDRECOVERY 1 month ago
45 PEOPLE ARENT " HERE"
Burgess1924 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
if you actually give a fuck and read all of this, then thank you
I work my ass off 2 make it in the music biz, but its impossible 2 make it if no one
ever hears you and its hard to get people to hear you when you have no
exposure...i dont have the money for amazing music videos or big youtube
advertisements....so all im left with is spam
if you could take two seconds to give me a thumbs up just so people know i
exist.. you dont have to like me, just gimme a chance to be liked
edisonromain 1 month ago
I am so proud of Jennifer Hudson! She betta work! :)
aworrell110 1 month ago
The best version ever but The Big O looks pissed that jenny bout to make her cry...
SweetShot20 1 month ago in playlist More videos from jhudfannamedken
Remarkable!
dij7878 1 month ago
The best rendition of this song... Incredible Jennifer!!!!!! <3
AL3XANDER3 1 month ago
I love this you keep singing Jennifer!
debbie20045 1 month ago
Blessed !!!
Hoover5823 1 month ago
What an amazing rendition by an exquisite vocalist.
Asierramoore 1 month ago
She did great, but she took that note at 1:46 lightly, and realized too quick that sh shouldn't have lol...still great though ;)
XanderLiveTV 2 months ago
Tears stream down my face each and every single time I hear this. I am still here.
nelidahill 2 months ago
That girl can sing
misstique08 2 months ago 35
This has been flagged as spam show
@misstique08 Love her, She is my favorite singer! :] Visit my channel and watch Jennifer Hudson covers!!! :)
VivianaGomezMUSIC 2 weeks ago
She is sooo slim now! what happened???
suzzannamaniest 2 months ago
Sorry but for me Jennifer blows this out. Yes I like the emotion of Fantasia but the REAL voice of Jennifer is OUTSTANDING!!!!! More soulful, crisp - Mega props Jennifer
TheMogjo 2 months ago
Sing it Effie White!!
mdfinest 2 months ago 16
Fantástica essa homenagem á One and Only Oprah Winfrey.... E ainda interpretada por Jennifer Hudson... Super! Loved.... Isso que é voz.
33459579 2 months ago
every time i'm listening to this beautiful song i have to cry!!!.. so much feeling
carentje2009 2 months ago 2
Jennifer and Oprah are a beautiful people.
julietacamargo1 2 months ago
You are so right Mr. Tink! Fantasia can take any song you give her and sing it from her heart. She is our next little Patti Labelle! Jennifer can't move you like our girl Fantasia can. That's realness to the fullest!
mothermineral 2 months ago
This Was Okay.. But This Song Is More Suitable For A Person With Vocal Control Like FANTASIA... I Love Jennifer But Fantasia Kills Everything You Hand Her !!
MrTiink 2 months ago
I actually don't like this version of the song. It is not sincere to me. I love Fantasia's version.
clara9203 2 months ago
Jennifer hudson did really good.
TheNewlife1995 2 months ago
Jennifer got the looks and talent out of her family. Omg she proves you dont hav to be light skin to be beautiful
ayanni1999 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
PLEASE everyone BEWARE the #1 weight loss pill is killing people PLEASE type in JILLIAN MICHAELS THE TRUTH and then please help spread the word and maybe we can save a few lives and then please do it the right way the healthy way like J.H. what a great voice and talent she rocks
TheRobMargolin 2 months ago
@TheCreolesoul see I think even the power in her voice is forced which is why she has such difficulty keeping control. Because she's trying to maintain the pitch and the power at the same she has difficulty staying on key. If she sings naturally I'm sure she'll be able to do it well, which is where I think Fantasia has succeeded. Not only does she have a unique sound, it's also natural which makes it easier for her to transcend musical genres. She's quite versatile and can sing anything.
ObeahGyal 2 months ago
I really dont think Jennifer can sing very well. She has amazing potential but if you listen to her carefully you'll hear that she has trouble controlling her voice. She over extends herself and tries to go beyond a manageable range within the scope of her abilities. For this song, the choir ruined it. You couldnt hear her. That aside, I think Fantasia not only sang this song better but is also a better singer. Fantasia is the real deal. Go to one of her concerts and you will become a believer.
ObeahGyal 2 months ago 2
@ObeahGyal couldn't agree with you more. I never witness fantasia mess up on a song but jennifer I have more than once. Its just sum ppl are more blessed with better pitch and control but Jennifer have bigger voice tho more power.
TheCreolesoul 2 months ago
@ObeahGyal Fantasia has a pretty voice but jennifer kills every song
ayanni1999 2 months ago
OMG at Oprah LOL!
Luchiano 2 months ago
just crazy, amazing, she got my vote,
MOVIMKR7 2 months ago
it´s so emotional...AMAZING performance!!
SimonNMusic 2 months ago
1 girl 5 gays brought me here. thanks yerxa!
KAVELism 3 months ago
@DirtyRottenScoundrel: You read my comment wrong. Smh. That was in my opinion. Duh I know the song is written for Celie. Dummy. Im tired of people assuming too, like you. I said, "And I really believe this song was mad for Fantasia." I didnt say this song was written FOR FANTASIA. Do you know the difference between a fact and a person's opinion??? (NOPE!)
Shybaby863 3 months ago
She is absolutely incredible.
MetalLaLa 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
PLEASE everyone BEWARE the #1 weight loss pill is killing people PLEASE type in JILLIAN MICHAELS THE TRUTH and then help spread the word and maybe we can save a few lives and do it the right way like JH she rocks thank you
TheRobMargolin 3 months ago
I love her
ueblondon 3 months ago
This tribute will go down in history as one the best tributes to Oprah W. Jennifer Hudson you really delivered your own version of this song. I was very proud of you and the outstanding job without comparing to Fantasia version of the same song. Fantasia also did an excellent job on her own version of the song as well. So many haters on this site.
sexycubanchocolate 3 months ago 3
She is just to best.. the true voice of all time
missselina25 3 months ago 2
I will say this. I prefer Fantasia's version because I love Fantasia. But Jennifer did just as well as far as actually singing the song. So in my opinion, Both nailed it and thats all that matters. Fantasia cries when she sings because she sings from that pain she has and still experiences. People have to understand that Both Fantasia and Jennifer have suffered greatly so when one wants to cry, they can do so.
JumperSC 3 months ago
Sorry, Im not even going to lie, I don't get the same emotion from her performance that I get from Fantasia. And thats the truth. The song is excellently written and structured. And I really believe this song was mad for Fantasia.
Shybaby863 3 months ago
@Shybaby863 Except that it WASN'T written for Fantastia. This was written for Celie in The Color Purple. It is a musical theatre piece written for a character, and therefore is intended for interpretation by a wide variety of performers.
I'm so tired of people assuming that Fantastia Barrino owns this song, or originated it. LaChanze was the original Celie on Broadway, and she got the damn Tony. So we should show her a little respect.
DirtyRottenScoundrel 3 months ago in playlist Favorite videos
I love jennifer! One of chi town's finest! I love fantasia,my sisters BOTH did a beautful job. However, everybody s missing th key here that both performances are different, that's all. fantasia's emotion you can see and hear. jennifer's power in her voice is different and her emotion is reserved but nonetheless present. fantasia made it hers,jennifer made other songs her own.
grandladyducesane 3 months ago
Yea she is good....BUT I FELT MORE EMOTION with Fantasias version of the song
rmmatthews21 3 months ago
I think they both did very well, I enjoyed both versions but when it comes down to who did it better, it all depends on who you heard sing it first no matter if they're the originators
naldosims 3 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
PLEASE everyone BEWARE the #1 weight loss pill is killing people PLEASE type in JILLIAN MICHAELS THE TRUTH and please stay healthy the right way like JH
TheRobMargolin 3 months ago
Fantasia and Jennifer are my top favorite! They both sang this beautifully and with so much emotion. However I must say Fantasia owns this song. Hands down. She make me cry everytime Lol
breanabtfl1 3 months ago
where i can dowland this song?????
inktonermexico 3 months ago
Fantasia song dis song way betta!!!
MoneyGoonette 3 months ago 3
yeah after all the shit thats happened to her, dont even think about saying she doesnt sing this with emotion. are you blind? 2:57
harajukukevin6657 3 months ago
FANTASIA DID BETTER!!!
MsGirlGucci 3 months ago
Just amazing
amac4hotmailcom 3 months ago
I dont like it
KnocKout099 3 months ago
Um dos melhores vídeos do youtube.
schjefferson1 3 months ago
shit
discouniverse 3 months ago
this is great... and this isn't Fantasia's song... it's from the Color Purple and Fantasia was not the first one to sing it. Just wanting to clarify. I love both of their versions. Learn to see the good in everything.
MrCtblade 3 months ago 2
Here what i have to say about this video. Although, it's Fantasia's song (which she song the hell out of) it is always a compliment when someone else, especially another artist, sings their song. Both Tasia and Jenn are friends and I am sure she didn't mind her singing it. I kinda like this performance. She really did her thing. I love Fantasia's version but again, it was nice to see someone sing her song. And this is coming from a REAL FANTASIA FAN!! #TeamTasia STAND UP!!!!
mylast1stkiss 3 months ago
@mylast1stkiss this is not Fantasia's song.lol
TiannaEwing 3 months ago
@TiannaEwing Neither is Summertime but when she sang it, she made it hers. Also, this is on her album which gives her ownership rights to the song. All I am saying is, she made it her own but Jennifer did a very good job at it.
mylast1stkiss 3 months ago
I believe I have inside of me
Everything that I need to live a bountiful life
With all the love, a love in me
I will stand as tall, as the tallest tree.
Great line, song and performance!
david2008long 4 months ago
lol at the fantasia stans on this page XD this was an amazing performance
ablackguy123456789 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
2 elements to this: (1) Everyone interprets and emotes things differently. Which one you prefer comes down to your own experiences. (2) The same song for a different occasion or in a different setting has different demands for the performance. I enjoyed this one. A lot.
Does anyone notice if you look closely it looks like Hudson is about to forget the words at 2:40. ;)
redtrainer 4 months ago
Comment removed
redtrainer 4 months ago
Comment removed
redtrainer 4 months ago
Regardless of what anyone has to say, this was a beautiful rendition of a beautifully written song. Unless you are Jennifer yourself, you can't judge as to whether or not the emotion was there - you don't live in her mind after all. And obviously Oprah preferred to hear Hudson's rendition at the time. Who cares? They're both incredibly talented artists. Celebrate their talents; don't defame because of a bitter opinion.
jblainecabrera 4 months ago 13
n oprah a stupid bitch for lettn her sing fantasia song that shows u how phoney she is
grobinson20 4 months ago
fantasiaassss wayyyyy betterrr cant no one take this song from herr
grobinson20 4 months ago
You cannot compare Fantasia to Jennifer. Pardon the cliche, you cannot compare an apple to an orange. Yes Fantasia may have sung better to some, but to others' they live for Jennifer. Either way, can't we just be happy that there are two version or two million version of this song. You have your favorite, but just keep it positive!
Avongkaysone87 4 months ago
WE SEEM TO FORGET JENIFER HAS BEEN THROUGH SOME SHIT TOO... &.... I....FEEL IT IN THIS PERFORMANCE
LePercyLicious 4 months ago
When Fantasia sings this she doesn't sing just for herself alone. It feels like she's telling the audience "You know what, no matter what you've been through, it's okay. You're here now and you can move one to do greater things." That's what touched me so much about Fantasia's version. It just speaks to me.
LuigiKwok 4 months ago
Jennifer did sing with emotion too you know and I think she sung it brilliantly. Jennifer on one hand seems to be just putting up a "performance". On the other hand, Fantasia was was just living the song. Fantasia threw all her past troubles(teenage pregnancy, being called ugly all the time, being formerly illiterate, coming from a broken family etc.) into the song and just SANG the hell out of it. (con't)
LuigiKwok 4 months ago
FANTASIA ALL DAY LONG ON THIS ONE!
OptimalOpinion 4 months ago
That high note @2:46... love, love, love... I love Fantasia but agree with wTrevorh. Jennifer's version remains emotional but is delivered with more confidence. I got teary eyed with Jennifer's version while Fantasia's left me a tad irritated. I'm a fan Fantasia but you can't cry your way through every single song...
Mahoganyhues 4 months ago
I like Jennifer's version more. There's more confidence in her voice. It seems like when Fantasia sings it, she seems more like a victim, who lacks the confidence the song requires. Fantasia finds too many tears.
wTrevorh 4 months ago in playlist new
nossa linda
/
gabriela39766 4 months ago
Jennifer and Fantasia did awesome jobs singing this song. It's just about whose version you like better. I ,myself, enjoyed Fantasia's much better. I felt the emotion of the song from Fantasia.
MsBrookeDification 4 months ago 4
I like Fantasia's version better
Misskeyoniatresha 4 months ago
Jennifer Hudson need I say anymore.
david2008long 4 months ago
Jen thank you
cindavakautas 4 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Estimated friend, if you want to listen again this song and an endless number of successes of the love I suggest you to visit Radio MUSICA PARA MIMOS - looks for his direction URL in Google ( search Musica para Mimos in Google)-. best romantic music of all the times in Internet, is great, is very good ...!!!
robertoamor2011 4 months ago
i like the pace--she slows the song beautifully.....
pearpeas 4 months ago
i think this song is more positive than sentimental crying. I think both did good job
yhonnycorrea12 4 months ago
1:56 Awwwwwwwwwwwwww!
utterbullspit 4 months ago
Everyone. Everyone. deserves ONE moment.
ONE moment in time!
pearpeas 4 months ago
linda a sua voz
gabriela39766 4 months ago
Burger King?! This is where this chick started out singing?! GTFOH!!!!!!!
allmyownlady 4 months ago
jennifer is very passionate with her singing!
blmrfacebook1 4 months ago
lindo podia ter a musica
gabriela39766 4 months ago
Singing her whole life in these words. Beautiful performance JHud. This woman has gone through so much. She is very deserving of everlasting happiness.
honeyluv15 4 months ago 4
and u know she felt this song RIP to her family.
maviehb 4 months ago 2
esta si es una presentacion fabulosa... una voz increible que traspasa cualquier calificacion......
MrCostarica35 5 months ago
fantaisa who??? She KILLED THIS!
paulieboi1978 5 months ago 15
@paulieboi1978 FANTASIA DID DO GOOD YOU CANT TAKE NOTHING AWAY FROM HER
lilseaxydee 4 months ago
wao!!!!
TheEvangeline07 5 months ago
idk , i cant decide between her and fantasia , they both had different strong points in the song , together however it would be PHENOMENAL !
brandanmusic 5 months ago
WTF is wrong with Oprahs face she looks constipaded or just plain pissed the fuck off lol
asisoyyo 5 months ago
If they did not say it was Jennifer Hudson, I would have never recognized her. She looks so thin!
buriedlovely 5 months ago
Jhud did good but fantasia put my ass to tears.when fantasia sings this song,I feel like I am Celie.
dynasty21dreams 5 months ago
@dynasty21dreams Yes Lawd!!! Fantasia live at the Tony's version will have you slinging snot everywhere!
the1atcpc 5 months ago
I LOVE J HUD(EVEN MET HER IN PERSON AND HUGGED! AHH MEMORIES LOL) BUT I HAVE TO SAY I LIKE HOW FANTASIA DID IT BETTER. FANTASIA GAVE IT DEPTH AND FEELIN. I JUST LOOKED AT THIS BUT FANTASIA MADE MY MOUTH DROP WHEN I FIRST SAW HER DO IT. BOTH STILL AMAZING
L3monH3ad89 5 months ago
Comment removed
L3monH3ad89 5 months ago
fantasia cant compare to this oprah new fantasia was gonna play dis role and still chose jhud to sing it 4 her
teamomizzriri 5 months ago