Added: 5 years ago
From: queensappho
Views: 93,602
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:
see all

All Comments (181)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • She's feeling t pain .... She miss Kurt... I'm entrance in hes condition and i' feeling too the greatest pain :S i love you COURTNEY . you are amazing woman !!!

  • my fav song by Hole is Boys on the radio :)

  • -333CourtneyLove.-333

  • I just fucking love this woman with all my fucking heart. She's one of the best chick rockers <3 I love you Courtney. Love you Frances. Love you guys so fucking much.

  • I love all her stuff, but her live stuff is by far the best.

    <3 Courtney <3

  • I miss Hole

  • Kurt was very depressed at times.... just listen to his music lol , he wasn't just talking shit.

  • I don't think the writing style of Live Through This sounds anything like Nirvana's writing. Courtney's music uses a lot of metaphors and symbolism. Kurt's music was always more direct and easier for most people to relate to. They were both talented musicians, but I think their styles are totally different.

  • love her or hate her

    courtney love wrote some sick lyrics

  • Anyone tell me what DVD this is from?

  • love singing along to melissa part.. <3

  • amazing talented woman

    If I had the ability to put my pain into words this is what I'd sound like

  • Fucking awesome! ,

    Best song Ever

  • people always say that kurt wrote live thru this...but celebrity skin is a way better album on my opinion so why couldnt she have written live thru this if she could write songs like boys on the radio that are better then anything kurt ever wrote....i like nevermind but in my book it dosent even compare to celebrity skin album

  • @sergsfault then you prefer the writing stylings of Billy Corgan then Kurt Cobain..

  • @HeavenoBliss when will people give her a break she can write...ok so billy helped her a lot but that don't mean she cant write just listen to the song never go hungry again it was written by courtney alone...and its a perfect hymn of survival...she's real how can you people not see that

  • @sergsfault and doll parts!

  • Who makes the chorus in the NEW Hole band??? a boy ??? this new Hole will never be the same without Melissa, Kristen, Erick and Patty... :( :(

  • luv it

  • I always imagine being in a Hole cover band. I couldnt sing this song all the way through. I would be crying hysterically. Especially the parts "and risen every angel slain" and "when the glitter fades in the morning, turn away and see my empty eyes" its just sooooo sad but gorgeous

  • @celebrityskin - the album lyric is actually, "when the glitter fades in mourning" which I think makes the song even sadder, and probably more personal for Courtney.

  • I had no idea Melissa's voice was that beautiful.

  • This song is so fucking beautiful

  • @jhonen32629

    I agree totally. This is one of my fav Hole songs.

  • everyone should let kurt go and rest in peace....how many years has it been and still the never ending comments.....

    courtney we luv you!

  • What an awesome performance! Love and Auf Der Maur's vocals go hand in hand.

  • One of my all time favourite songs. I love the album version and this live 'acoustic' version is great.

  • wow THIS IS A GREAT VERSION

  • one of my faves from the CS era

  • This song is beautiful and for some weird reason it makes me cry

  • @jhonen32629 me too!

  • melissa's singing part is really pretty

  • this is about kurt cobain

  • Thank You courtneylove4.. i wasn't so sure. =)

    i dc what people say i admire Courtney. i don't believe all that murder crap at all. She's a woman whom I believe is just really heart broken.

  • is this the same Melissa that replaced D'arcy in the Smashing Pumpkins

  • @CjScott101 yes!

  • This song is gorgeous & I love Melissa's influence on it - but I prefer the original ("Sugar Coma" from Unplugged). I always thought that song would've been amazing if they recorded it as it was.

    And, @Mark42281, I'm sure it's at least about Kurt. I think that's pretty obvious - especially in the verses.

  • beautiful song..i read somewhere this song is about Kurt Cobain & Jeff Buckley. anyone know anything about that?

  • @Mark42281 yeah its about Kurt, especially the bridge ("he said he'd never ever ever go, and heavens heavens heavens no, and I will never ever ever go away, baby I've gone away")

  • Melissa " Vive la musique et vive la France"!

  • the only people who would have gained from kurdts death were his band members. she wanted to give his last music to his fans for free, they sued her and disparaged her for years. his father and uncle both committed suicide, depression can be genetic. heroin is a depressant. not advocating for either side but facts are facts and dave grohl needed money more than she did at the time. shes a bausch, of bausch and lomb, and will always have money. he killed himself, grohl got rich off it...

  • His father haven't committed suicide. But two of his uncles shot themselves to death, yes.

  • @butchygrrl Ok, but it really wasn't her's to give, was it? It's a noble idea and I would applaud anyone doing that, but then again, she wasn't in the band...

  • @Deshollinador Kurt obviously didnt give a shit about the music catalog or else hed left instructions on it....and legally she was well with in her rights to do whatever she wanted! Kurts estate is mostly her's! She's said in interviews that its painful to hold on to that stuff like a ghost. When u think about it what kurt did was pretty selfish leaving court to sort out that mess!

  • @butchygrrl

    Courtney Love was just not willing to be the woman put in her place. I think she had to suffer so much undeserved hatred when Kurt killed himself. Personally I think this album was a great album and I think the band is much deserving of their success.

  • I love it

  • i want these lyrics! they're different than the original...

  • @christinabermudez She's skipping over parts and making up words as she goes along. I sorta hate it when she does it. Im kinda figuring it they dont have a long time. its a long song in my opninion

  • I feel sorry for Courtney; people just won't leave her alone with regards to her relationship with Kurt and his death. It's like the same way that people won't stop criticizing Tom Cruise or Mel Gibson for their lack of height. Just enjoy the music, ppl.

  • @wowsera hahha yea well their height is a fact... and no one knows for sure what happened that day, kurt died. I myself thing he took his own life.

  • beautiful

  • i love how Melissa can sound so innocent

  • I love the way she plays with the lyrics and mixes them up. "I threw it all away...YEAH!"

  • if she killed hurt she would have been convicted. it s a never ending debate. started in 1994. its 2009. and its been non stop ever since. im not going to get into it. i think at this point in her career she is at her most beautiful! the hair, the skin, the clothes, i think she looks gorgeous! but personally i think she looks great all the time. but more so at this point in her life!

  • i totally agree with you :)

  • Wow, you have a lot of anger problems. Dont call me a sheep. if im a sheep your a god damn wolf. chill out. go join the justice legue and take her down. holy fuck, it happened like 15 years ago. you go chase her down columbo. well what are you waiting for.. get on it. i like this song. thats all. pray to the heroin gods and ask them what happened to kurt.

  • but you are a sheep, why shouldnt i call you one ? nothing angry about it love. the point is not to chase her down, but to promote the reopening of the case. anyway bye moron.

  • You really think courtney did it eh? well, why hasnt she been convicted? shes done way more stupid stuff and been caught. Kurt was suicidal all his life. he was even once quoted as saying if he doesnt get laid hes going to kill himself.

  • @TheCelebrityGirl

    i'm a leopard, then.

    never a sheep or a travel-in-a-pack wolf.

  • go get 'em buddy.

  • g f y :)

  • Its getting so damn old.. If she was really thought to have killed Kurt why is she still here, come off it and enjoy the killer music!

  • sugar coma was better...this is more poppy and that's the reason i like the former version better

  • nobody will ever know if she killed cobain, some of us dont like her, some of us worship her... when it all boils down, who gives a fuck? get off your computers and go ride your bikes

  • yeah! but wear a helmet and don't forget front and back lights when riding. xo

  • Well, you know there is a place for you to go to spread your negativity.

    She is a talented and beautiful artist.

    Your inability to find anything of value in her is no reason to trash her that way. Go find something you like and say something positive. It'll make you feel better.

  • I respect your opinion.

    There is NO PROOF she is a murderer.

    You know, it's kind of funny. Tom Grant is making a movie, to fulfill some type of ego trip, rather than expending his energy and resources to put a coherent case together to reopen the "case". He is actually doing the believers that Courtney is a murderer a total disservice. It just looks like "junk" justice in the court of public opinion.

    Sorry, man. I just don't see that there is ANY reason to call her a killer.

  • 1st of all, she's not a she-male, I've seen her naked, in pictures and many many times in The People Vs. Larry Flynt. 2nd.- if you don't like her voice, then you must hate the late great Janice Joplin, umm, Stevie Nicks comes to mind, or just plug your fucking ears and, as Tom Petty says "Don't Come Around Here No More", and 3rd- Sure....Right, she is a killer. Her trial took place when? She was arraigned when? She killed her demons when she got sober.

  • Comment removed

  • Why??? ... I feel touched ...

  • If you don't like her don't wach her videos.

  • I love this song, its kinda mellow in comparison to Holes other songs, but its really great

  • She is SO fine, beautiful and talented.

    She is the SHIT.

  • Eric's so cool  : )

  • so vulnerable but so strong =)

  • the way she smiles when she says "i'm never coming back to your surrender" is so beautiful and devious

  • I love the clothes of courtney and melissa, don't you?

  • best performance ever i never get tired of listening to hole

  • This performance should be preserved as one of the best live performances EVER ! I can't think of words to express how perfect it is . just WOW !!!

  • a beauty song for jeff buckley, love him too.

  • I EFFIN LOVE THIS VERSION!!!!!!

    imo courtney was basically Hole, melissa was just a backing singer,

    don't get me wrong, her voice complemented courtney's, but to me she was an extra bit of goodness, she wasn't essential.

  • i agrre that courtney is the heart of the music its very obvious, but courtney will be the first one to say that she's not a one man band... she admits she needs other musical talent to make music,,, she's kind of like a muse.

  • Melissa's voice gives me chills

  • melissa auf der maur the best add to hole!!! she have voice and beautiful image!!! i really miss HOLE...

  • i kinda miss courtney in general...shes gotta worry about her daughter first now instead of bein some drugged up rocker now, though...

  • Such an amazing song! One of my all time favorite Hole songs.

    So so awesome.

    <3

  • I love the interplay of the gruff voice of Courntey Love with soft, backing vocals of Melissa Auf Der Maur.

  • Melissa really did the world a favour for hanging in there with Courtney and standing up for the songs even though Courtney was hard to work with:) I don't think Hole woul'dve been the same without cred from a few popular girls

  • This has always been one of my favorite songs ever! Courtney & Melissa are just so spectacular here!

  • Totally agree with you!

  • I can't get enough of this song, especially with Melissa's angelic backing vocals. She is hypnotic!

  • Courtney's voice isn't built for songs like this and Northern Star, which is where this album falls down. She's better off with screamers like Celebrity Skin and most of the Live Through This album.

  • i think her voice was *made* for songs like "northern star". no one else could sing that song with such perfect balance of strength and vulnerability.

  • this girl rock

  • courtney's voice is amazing.

  • I like this version better than the studio because this one starts off sweet and then starts to pick up at 3:00 then even more at 3:50. I downloaded the original song and was a little disappointed my 'favorite' part really didn't stand out as much as in this version. This isn't the best video of this on here though. Still like the song.

  • the studio version of this song is a lot better and is one of my favorite songs...they seem kind of lethargic live.

  • that was beautiful

  • Love this song!

  • it can be heard that there's more than one ood signer in hole in this song.

  • gorgeous. i love you court.

  • Such a beautiful song. She sings a love song about someone everyone loved/loves, but was hers.

  • what's it about?

  • FFS why did she have to go and get plastic surgery a couple years later, she looked perfectly fine here!

  • the most persones look perfekt.. but they don't think so..

  • i know she's so cute in this video, i love her!

  • u tellin me shes my bitch!!

  • Nice tune ... pure music ...

  • i love the contrast between Courtney's and Melissa's voices :) It works well together.

    I think that she does change the lyrics on purpose.. and yeah this is Sugar Coma just improved and edited from when she sung it like on MTV Unplugged & before Celebrity Skin was released.

  • Sugar Coma was better...

  • I agree!

  • I agree with you!

  • Isnt this the "follow up" for the song Coma Sugar?

  • No, it's another version that isn't nearly as good ;)

  • i love melissa's voice

  • Billy Corgan writing a song that is obviously is about Kurt Cobain?......I don't think so..... Erick the guitaer player has writeen some great pop melodies, I'm sure he had something to do with it.

  • ever check a fucking lyric book...all hole lyrics are written by courtney. she makes no qualms on working on MUSICAL ARRANGEMENTS with other musical artists so neither should you. alot of other pop stars do it and most of it's not half as good as this so why give her shit for that?

  • Beautiful song on a brilliant record

  • i like what she´s doing with her hands and eyes ;)...i love all about courtney..

  • My favorite Hole song <3

  • not hard to tell billy corgan had a lot to do with the writing of this song

  • Has Billy written anything here? hmmm... I know he wrote someting on "dying"

  • he played the bass on HIT SO HARD and stop...

    Eric told this on Viper room forum

  • awesome performance

    ... this song always reminds me of the smiths - just the contrast of how bleak and depressing the lyrics are paired with the happy pop melodies

  • it would be better if she remembered the lyrics.

  • ::shrugs:: good enough for rock n' roll

  • :)

    I love to keep thinking that she does it on purpose, singing different lyrics, but maybe you're right and she doesn't. All the time..

  • i think its a sad song

    but i love it...great courtney rocks!

  • thats a GREAT performance, and i love ALL Hole recordiongs, its my favourite band, but anyw3ay my favourite one still is "pretty on the inside". the grungiest album ever!!

  • one of the best songs in the Celebrity Skin album... do you have any video of the "Heaven Tonight" song?

  • nice...

  • Best song of the entire Seattle movement (and well put Hole into that box wherever they came from anyway:p just that its the best song of all Courtney/Kurt/Nirvana/Hole/Pea­rlJam etc)

  • Love this song and performance I wonder if Hole's box release will be out next year?

  • My fav Hole song I think. Softer, softest too. Been listening to them since summer of 1995!

  • Courtney, at least live, always changes the lyrics. If you listen to any live albums she does change the words. In fact on kittyradio I asked to everybody "When you sing along, do you sing the album lyrics or the alternative lyrics"?

  • Well said Catherine, I always loved Melissa's voice

  • i love melissas voiceee

  • she took the blame she really did...

    God! i really admire this brave girl ahaha...

    Oyeh.. Melissa Great job!

    i can't wait for melissa and courtney's new labum

  • wow courtney looks great!!

    melissa nice backing :D

  • Whoa she must have been fucked up, she screwed up her own lyrics pretty badly...eh I love hole anyways & love this song

  • ahh i love this song to bits! cant help but sing along when it comes on! heehee.

  • Is that Auf De Mar? I love her voice

  • Melissa Auf Der Maur is the sexiest woman alive!!! She also has a beautiful voice...

  • god I love them and this song is amazing

  • this is my favorite song off celebrity skin. it's got a happy melody, i think, but the message that the lyrics portray is dark. i think also thats why its my favorite

  • yea thats a very sads song

  • I just LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOVE this song! For me it's one of the best songs from Celebrity Skin, one of the best albuns I could buy since I bought my first CD player.

  • Love it

  • i haven't heard this before, but it's like a happier version sugar coma goddamnit! O_O help me, i'm confused ^^

  • Not sure if you can call this a "happier" version, but yeah - it seems like CLove revisited the ideas in Sugar Coma. "I cannot help your suffering / I am not here to ease your pain / I'm never coming back ..." is pretty bitter.

  • oh yeah i guess. didn't really listen to the lyrics :P

  • You've never heard this song??? Do you not have Celebrity Skin??!!

  • punk is not about singing in tune, it's about the anger. ¿Comprende?

  • Her voice is absolute shit here. I went off Hole when her plastic lips got in the way. So uncool....

  • I agree, Melissa's singing in this is awesome! I am not a huge Hole fan but this song is totally wicked! I wish Melissa had sung the whole song. :)

  • clothdoll.Said it all really..

  • haha she sucks dick and the kurt wanna be haha

  • What the shit? lol that "Kurt wannabe" is Eric out of the band!! he's been there since the eighties! before Courtney knew Kurt! he and Hole was famous before Nirvana!!!! your funny lol stop talking shit though.

  • very true.... hole were bigger than nirvana yrs ago, shame nobody uses the net to understand the knowledge it holds. although i remember it all days before anyone had the net and hole are legends.. however i do miss the earlier music.. but the older you get the harshness dries up but she is still the same .

  • Melissa's vocals are painfully pretty in this. This is an absolutely beautiful performance.

  • i love this performance so much, i love them all so much!

  • Amazing performance, I love the parts where Melissa sings, beauiful !

  • I've never heard it acousticly. WOW!

  • BEAUTIFUL!!!

  • wow this is really a great performance

  • this is an AMAZING song.....sugarcoma even better. fuck you she use to be so pretty.

  • Man i wish she was a guy! so i could stare at his penis

  • im not a big fan of holes-but i do own the 'live thro this' album-& i love it & this video /song is A+:)

    -alyssa-

  • oh my god this is amazing!

  • yeh this is wicked thanku for posting. Courtneys great on this

  • i loooooooove this performance!!! seeing them live reminds me everytime why i love hole soso much.. thank you!!