petebj, it loses all meaning only if you let it lose all meaning....this is Erasure's version and it probably will have a different meaning to PG's; spiritual or not depending on the listener and how he/she interpret it...but it is most definately not a 'folky' version :)
It's all about 'feeling' and being able to appreciate the new and different.
Personally I absolutely adore Erasure's version and the film clip is raw, industrial and sexy.
I LOVE IT A LOT!
Some people are limited to what type of music they like.....it is the creative, lateral thinking mind that is open to new and wonderful music, possessing eclectic taste, whilst still being discerning. Amen
Personally, I think this version is way more powerful than the original. This is simply a matter of all you people being old farts who doesn't know how to appreciate electronic music.
And for your info, this was actually a bigger hit than the inferior original, charting higher on the UK charts.
Peter Gabriel is nowhere near the success Vince Clarke has had.
Doesn't an artist have to give consent for a remake of their song?? I can't believe Peter would ever give consent for this...they RUINED an outstanding song. This song is about a personal experience of Peter's...no one (ESPECIALLY ERASURE) has any business remaking a song like that....I love Erasure, but this song shouldn't have even crossed their minds...
Yes, everybody can cover a song if they want, the royalties still goes to the composer. Even you can cover this song and release it.
Having said that, maybe you should realise that since this cover was a actually a bigger hit than the original, they did old, bald has-been Peter Gabriel quite a favour!
The original is a powerful piece of music, spiritually. It has an amazing affect with beautiful singing. Doing that has nothing to affect people with. It has no soul.
this isn't my favourite erasure song, and i think that peter gabriels version was better, but vince and andy are just trying to pay tribute to people that influenced them, like their abba stuff.
It sure is right now. We've had a really good two weeks of great weather: sunny, warm, and absolutely delightful after the harshest winter in recent memory. Thanks.
sou fã de peter gabriel e quando ouvi pela 1ª vez esta versão estranhei mas depois de a ouvir varias vezes reconheço q os erasure fizeram um grande trabalho!!
I love this video; every time that I listen to it makes me forget my problems, and I begin to imagine that I am in the bowling but important of good airs, being the queen of the night
this version is an utter and blunt insult!!! to peter, to the listeners
LostGentlemen 3 years ago
If i was peter, i would track them down and beat their friggin asses, this is fucked up right here.
ronnyanddebbi 3 years ago
But this version rips the folky spirituality completely out of the lyrics. It loses all meaning.
petebj123 3 years ago 2
petebj, it loses all meaning only if you let it lose all meaning....this is Erasure's version and it probably will have a different meaning to PG's; spiritual or not depending on the listener and how he/she interpret it...but it is most definately not a 'folky' version :)
Courses for horses and all that jazz.
SaveStef 3 years ago
It's all about 'feeling' and being able to appreciate the new and different.
Personally I absolutely adore Erasure's version and the film clip is raw, industrial and sexy.
I LOVE IT A LOT!
Some people are limited to what type of music they like.....it is the creative, lateral thinking mind that is open to new and wonderful music, possessing eclectic taste, whilst still being discerning. Amen
SaveStef 3 years ago
why he's disguise?? aw lol love this song so much xD
SillyLoveSongBeatles 3 years ago
Fugly!
najseba 3 years ago
Personally, I think this version is way more powerful than the original. This is simply a matter of all you people being old farts who doesn't know how to appreciate electronic music.
And for your info, this was actually a bigger hit than the inferior original, charting higher on the UK charts.
Peter Gabriel is nowhere near the success Vince Clarke has had.
CarlOscarAlsen 3 years ago
LoL, comparing this to Peter Gabriel's, FFS.
Charting higher in the charts doesn't mean anything, just uncultured people & kids listening.
najseba 3 years ago
screw you all. This song is good no matter who plays it. Thats the fucking point idiots.
Sparklehorse1269 3 years ago 2
It's like a real bad drag show!
djavatar68 3 years ago
BLASPHEMY!!!
IlliniJake 3 years ago
Am I allowed to laugh? I really want to laugh. Sorry... but I do =X
sdstarlightqt 3 years ago
Doesn't an artist have to give consent for a remake of their song?? I can't believe Peter would ever give consent for this...they RUINED an outstanding song. This song is about a personal experience of Peter's...no one (ESPECIALLY ERASURE) has any business remaking a song like that....I love Erasure, but this song shouldn't have even crossed their minds...
dinkyklg 3 years ago
Yes, everybody can cover a song if they want, the royalties still goes to the composer. Even you can cover this song and release it.
Having said that, maybe you should realise that since this cover was a actually a bigger hit than the original, they did old, bald has-been Peter Gabriel quite a favour!
CarlOscarAlsen 3 years ago
The original is a powerful piece of music, spiritually. It has an amazing affect with beautiful singing. Doing that has nothing to affect people with. It has no soul.
DeathOfADagger 3 years ago
This is a mockery of the original. They have a foul nerve to destroy such beautiful music.
DeathOfADagger 3 years ago
this isn't my favourite erasure song, and i think that peter gabriels version was better, but vince and andy are just trying to pay tribute to people that influenced them, like their abba stuff.
wobzilla1 3 years ago
this fuckin blows! peter is rolling in his future grave.
roachcoachman 3 years ago
then you have to have no clue of music, faggot
m2theichi 3 years ago
muy buen cover !!!!!!!!!!!!!
opcondiego 3 years ago
andy rules and everyone is jeolous
katydydit2 3 years ago
is that a frickin CORSET??! O_O
FrayGirl123 3 years ago
Andy haven´t fear to the critics!!
darwleg 3 years ago
uh.... what in the holy fuck is that thing on stage wearing?
bphutchins 3 years ago
I love their cover of this song. Give this band credit where it's due.
katcatlike 3 years ago
Thank melancholy1rose...
langenberger71 3 years ago
i think it sounds better in 7/4 time, but it's still a good cover. that guy's a bit scary tho. O_O
FrayGirl123 3 years ago
^ i meant 7/4, obviously
NYCJockCub 3 years ago
It's an impressively good transformation of Peter Gabriel's 5/4 time to 4/4.
NYCJockCub 3 years ago 2
Looks like Lisa Stansfield-but I don't ever remember her acting that feminine. Lisa, what has become of you?!
PhildaShrink 3 years ago 2
Is that Lisa Stansfield?
DerVeet 3 years ago 2
Peter Gabriel's cover was a Single In The
Late 1970s, but Erasure Charted Their New
Hit, "Solsbury Hill" In Early 2003.
shirleygibson 3 years ago
I Thought Phil Collins Realised Their Single,
In Late 1985, with a Song, "Bramberry Hill"
But It's A Great Song, I Listened This Song
when I Was 5 Years Old.
shirleygibson 3 years ago
Good cover but still, peter is unbeatable
Parsirius 3 years ago
It sure is right now. We've had a really good two weeks of great weather: sunny, warm, and absolutely delightful after the harshest winter in recent memory. Thanks.
hopefulever 3 years ago
Thanks for clearing that up. I just got confused by all the postings spelling it Solsbury. I understand now. I live in Canada, Toronto actually.
hopefulever 3 years ago
Hi hopefulever. I'm from Toronto too. Nice to see a YouTuber from the T Dot here.
hoktak 3 years ago
very nice music, greetings;))
Markus18x 3 years ago
Isn't Solsbury actually spelled "Salisbury"? even though it's pronounced solsbury. Just asking.
hopefulever 3 years ago
sou fã de peter gabriel e quando ouvi pela 1ª vez esta versão estranhei mas depois de a ouvir varias vezes reconheço q os erasure fizeram um grande trabalho!!
jbernardo38 3 years ago
fisrt time i saw this video in 2007 i thought andy was a woman but then a friend told me she was a he
stockton110 4 years ago
I don't blame you.. D:
t3hn00berer 3 years ago
|Love Erasure but they do nothing for this old classic.
cyrilfuckdust 4 years ago 3
The most electrifying feature of the original song is its 7/4 bar. This was destroyed in this cover version.
Sorry, I don't like it.
marpicentertainment 4 years ago
OMG, what did they do to this wonderful song? They butchered it! Making it a meaningless 4/4 bar electro dance tune.
CriticXXL 4 years ago
so much fun to listen and observe. had no choice
rando222 4 years ago
major fail
noxcovenant 4 years ago
I had no idea Erasure covered this Peter Gabriel classic!
kingslice75 4 years ago 2
I love this video; every time that I listen to it makes me forget my problems, and I begin to imagine that I am in the bowling but important of good airs, being the queen of the night
ShirleyMagali17 4 years ago
I like this video
ShirleyMagali17 4 years ago
Vanguardiste, i like it cos it´s shoking.
floteamo 4 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Gays
bluedemon86 4 years ago
Yep, welcome. I am glad you came.
msturn1975 4 years ago
I wouldn't say its better then the original version but its good in its own way.
wolfbait74 4 years ago
me gusta mucho esta cancion, me hace sentir muy bien, nose esto neogay me mata!!!!!!!!
ShirleyMagali17 4 years ago
Gr8 version of a realy good song, is this the new Erasure single?
Marcus1050 4 years ago
no this is off their cover album, "other people's songs"
their new single is called "sunday girl"
wobzilla1 4 years ago
I Agree
ShirleyMagali17 4 years ago
Andy looks like a freak in this video....glad tattoo was fake.
VInce should stay away from directing.
ebm14 4 years ago
Superb portrayal of a great original. Love the way Erasure have tweaked the track to give it their own spin. Great post, Kudos!
adpmzg 4 years ago 2
Thanks dude i have been looking for this everywhere! thanks for the post! good work!
nuuke 4 years ago
This is one of my favorate songs. Much better than the origanl verion.
minniemupet 4 years ago
I agree!!!!!!!
msturn1975 4 years ago