Well. I guess it's ok. But I liked her version of Let it Be much better, her voice isnt soft enough to sing a song like this. It lost some of it's feel.
Song is good, but what's with the yellow dress? I, too am glad that her career is going. It was nice to see her return to Idol and be relaxed! I would not be able to do Idol, so she definitley has my respect!
Listened to a few other songs by Brooke White and I see your point; her choice of music and her unique style make it difficut to assign her to any one music genre. But, in my opinion (and I'm a southern girl born and raised), her voice and accent still have a country flavor. She definitely has the It Factor going for her--Brooke's destined for greatness.
yeah but you don't hear like the audidence screaming and her voice is alot stronger because she isn't like walking or running around the stage even a bit out of energy... so the studio version is kind of better
i like some of studio versions better, but i also like some of her live versions better. overall, she does a good job of reproducing what she records in studio for a live performance, which bodes well for her future concert performances. when she's live, she does push the range on her voice a lot more. she usually plays it safer in the studio.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Brooke's current singing voice is not my style. She had a better voice when she was younger. I like Jewel's version of this song. She has a guitar voice like what one would sing with a guitar at a night club serenading the patrons.
omg whoever you are 'aarontse1994' you are the meanest person ever! why would you ever hope for that? your not a good person and i dont think you should say that to anyone no matter how much you mean it. obviously you werent thinking when you ssaid that cuz its stupid.
loser me? loser you. you shouldnt wish the worse to others you never know when someone you love may die im just saying. what you wish to others may happen to you.
Oh my goodness, this is amazing - I loved it when she performed it, couldn't understand why all the judges hated it! It's so sweet sounding, I love how her voice twangs a bit when she says 'little darling'...Thanks for posting! ♥
i love her in this song...she has such amazing low pitches. it's a shame she screwed it up so much in the real performance! oh well. she's my favorite to win!!!
Unfortunately, no. Only her actual cut live performances are being offered on iTunes. I wish they would let her do full versions of semi-finals performances though.
She was nothing special she should've gone home durong the Hollywood rounds.
900highguy 3 months ago
still to this day!! she was the best out every girl ever on AMERICAN IDOL!!!!
tashababy270 4 months ago
Love Brooke
martellexox 1 year ago
Ahhh She made me like this song. I love her! <3
SyAlmighty 1 year ago
if she joined this year maybe she will win
wreckero4 1 year ago
i remember she made me like this song...
BrickByBoringBrick7 1 year ago
Well. I guess it's ok. But I liked her version of Let it Be much better, her voice isnt soft enough to sing a song like this. It lost some of it's feel.
gaeira 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
the Sheryl Crowe verison is better she has a 10 times better voice
jackieawsome 2 years ago
This is bearable, but it just can't compare the the Beatles.
TotalTortilla 2 years ago
i LOVE this song(: and it sounds so much better with her singing it tooo!
soccernumber18 2 years ago 3
i love this song my friend does a solo for it
pitamorales08 2 years ago
flawless
vasepills 2 years ago 3
This is ok.
Still not good enough for a beatles' song
emzyrooroo 2 years ago
yes my friend amy has a solo dance for it
pitamorales08 2 years ago
Song is good, but what's with the yellow dress? I, too am glad that her career is going. It was nice to see her return to Idol and be relaxed! I would not be able to do Idol, so she definitley has my respect!
star99springhill 2 years ago 3
This has been flagged as spam show
this is scary if u read this this far u will die in 10 days if u dont send to any 15 videos in 2 hour
lyndsey919 2 years ago
i loveeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeit
abed466 2 years ago 4
i loved this version
aylabell1 2 years ago 2
I wanted Brooke to win so badly, but I'm so glad she is doing well w/ her career.
She is versatile and talented and I wish her continued success!
denman1953 2 years ago
I liked her she has a classic thing about her. I could see her being like joan baez back in the 70s .
dialtechd 2 years ago 2
i think this is a pretty good cover
i like brooke a lot..shes very talented..
not as good as original but good nevertheless..
shaka055 2 years ago 4
she did good i dont know why the judges did not like it
Tinkerbell1000p2 2 years ago
you're wrong, simon was in love with her
MeAreAwesome1 2 years ago 2
yeah he was in love with her, but not the rendition of the song
candles121 2 years ago 3
george harrison is probably rotating in his grave....this made me want to kill myself...this song shouldn't be touched....ever
jeffwalker3 3 years ago
why?
bastyo1 3 years ago
Plus, He should be proud, his song passed the test of time. :|
bastyo1 3 years ago 3
i really do like her,
watched AI once in my hometown berlin and she's so great.
best wishies
psychocillerin 3 years ago
I liked it when she sang this live and this version.
yourzonly 3 years ago 2
but not the dress.
yourzonly 3 years ago
Her version of this is by far the best
kvnrox6 3 years ago 4
Not the biggest fan of country music, but this li'l gal is the real deal. Best of luck to ya, Brooke!
Thanks for the post.
SavedandSound 3 years ago
but she's not country, watch her other stuff and you'll see
saqua608 3 years ago
Hey, saqua608~
Listened to a few other songs by Brooke White and I see your point; her choice of music and her unique style make it difficut to assign her to any one music genre. But, in my opinion (and I'm a southern girl born and raised), her voice and accent still have a country flavor. She definitely has the It Factor going for her--Brooke's destined for greatness.
SavedandSound 3 years ago
Actaully I think She has more of a folk sound..I'm sure she loves folk like dylan and so forth... You can tell from her song choices. my two cents
THeSwimm3r 3 years ago
For THeSwimm3r: I liked your two cents! very insightful. I could see her doing Joni Mitchell covers; Linda Ronstadt, too.
SavedandSound 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
A country voice had t be sexy.
This is absolute garbage.
renger29 3 years ago
Everyone is entitled to their opinion. As the saying goes, beauty is in the eye of the beholder...(or, in this case, the ear).
Peace.
SavedandSound 3 years ago 2
poor my little George...! how can you do this to him???????
titutitu92 3 years ago
omg i met her and she is supernice! hope she releases an album sometime soon.
chairOFwonder 3 years ago
luv da song
brooke roxx
american45idol 3 years ago
She has a catchy, great radio voice. The future is bright for her.
n0wandlater 3 years ago 13
i didnt like this when she sung it on american ido but she sounds AMAZING in the studio version
[:
brooke is awesome<33
CheyenneRocks78 3 years ago 3
**gasp**
i never thought i would hear the word "brooke is awesome<33" from you taylor!
lol i like brooke also
xmetrostationgirl 3 years ago 4
This has been flagged as spam show
haha, i know right?
[:
CheyenneRocks78 3 years ago 2
she has a really good voice :]
michaelaawoohh 3 years ago 3
I actually like her stage voice better. It sounds purer and well.... less studio! Not to say this is BAD....
xLOVElikegravity 3 years ago 5
When its raining outside... think about Brooke... and there's the sun.
kvnrox6 3 years ago 5
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I honestly have no idea... I mean she has an AMAZING voice... she is great... but for some reason I don't even know why...
I just didn't like her!
elohel9dalton 3 years ago
I really enjoy this. Better than the live performance. Great Brooke.
crazykid421410 3 years ago 5
all a studio version is is the whole song. thers no diff. just its the full song.
amburr00x 3 years ago
yeah but you don't hear like the audidence screaming and her voice is alot stronger because she isn't like walking or running around the stage even a bit out of energy... so the studio version is kind of better
elohel9dalton 3 years ago 3
i like some of studio versions better, but i also like some of her live versions better. overall, she does a good job of reproducing what she records in studio for a live performance, which bodes well for her future concert performances. when she's live, she does push the range on her voice a lot more. she usually plays it safer in the studio.
ftcfjsk 3 years ago 3
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Brooke sounds much better live. Her recording voice makes me cringe.
poopinisnice 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Brooke's current singing voice is not my style. She had a better voice when she was younger. I like Jewel's version of this song. She has a guitar voice like what one would sing with a guitar at a night club serenading the patrons.
PinkFrostyDonut 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I mean Brooke has a guitar voice made for night clubs.
PinkFrostyDonut 3 years ago
I can't believe she got voted off.
It sucks and I wish she would've made it to the 3rd!
viv181 3 years ago 8
1st!!!
but i guess now ill have to root for david a. hes pretty good. young tho. cute tho. lols.
Dally000PonyboyIsHot 3 years ago
I'm having problems uploading my videos, i don't think they are the right quality. Do u know how to change that? Brooke Rocks by the way!
BrookesBunch 3 years ago
we all no david cook is going to win :)
BlakeLewis108 3 years ago
#1 rule of the Internet!
Please use correct spelling!
It's KNOW!
meleis10 3 years ago
shut up
BlakeLewis108 3 years ago
I agree with meleis10. You should use" Know"
hiblackie 3 years ago
well u guys no want i mean and if u really care so muh u shouldnt be telling me cuz my dead point dc will win _____
BlakeLewis108 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Thanks for agreeting with me...I just now got this..and I'm really happy that David Cook won!
meleis10 3 years ago
...hopefully :D
guitargirlyxx 3 years ago
everyone vote for brooke!!! we want her to remain for atleast one more week!!! even ellen said she liked her on her show..
foreverprettygirl89 3 years ago
Good version,Good arrangement, Good vocals!
jgalias 3 years ago
this reminds me of sheryl crow....
theshore465 3 years ago
I like her better in-studio, when she's less nervous. I'll definitely get her CD now. :)
Jenniferiffic 3 years ago
Go Brooke! She is amazing!
rumwhisp 3 years ago
(aarontse1994) uhmm you are a loser !!! and why are you watching this video many times if you dont like it.. get a life
gamecockgal05 3 years ago
i agree with taylor swift but i think more of kellie pickler with the personality.
IdolSweetHeart 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
thumbs down AFTER i told everyone that no one put one. lame
aarontse1994 3 years ago
OMGGGG
gamecockgal05 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
haha guess no one put a thunmbs down to me =]
aarontse1994 3 years ago
aarontse u are soooo mean! shes amazing so vote brooke white and put the little down thumb to aarontse1994!
Cosmicandy68 3 years ago 2
omg whoever you are 'aarontse1994' you are the meanest person ever! why would you ever hope for that? your not a good person and i dont think you should say that to anyone no matter how much you mean it. obviously you werent thinking when you ssaid that cuz its stupid.
Dperera13 3 years ago 6
This has been flagged as spam show
hahaha loser i hope she dies =]
aarontse1994 3 years ago
loser me? loser you. you shouldnt wish the worse to others you never know when someone you love may die im just saying. what you wish to others may happen to you.
cristianballack 3 years ago 3
That's is a really mean thing to say do unto others as you would have others do unto u so thats very rude and she is an amazing singer
Lindseybrugger411 3 years ago 4
this girl is the best i hope she wins shes so sweet and pretty and makes you smile
cristianballack 3 years ago 13
i love her so much! she is my favorite girl!!
omgxogabby 3 years ago 3
omg! I love brooke white! she is so cute and inspirational!
holber34428 3 years ago 2
I love this studio version, and i also liked it when she sang it on the show.
0Valbella0 3 years ago 2
Love this girl, this was her weekest performance on the show but this studio version is terrific
willy1273 3 years ago
amazinggg <3
breakitoutx 3 years ago 2
i totally agree with u crazyminx1000 i think she is sooooooooooo goooooood i want her to win
haleymonkey05 3 years ago 2
Oh my goodness, this is amazing - I loved it when she performed it, couldn't understand why all the judges hated it! It's so sweet sounding, I love how her voice twangs a bit when she says 'little darling'...Thanks for posting! ♥
crazyminx1000 3 years ago
she reminds me of talylor swift... =D
dazrock89 3 years ago
I think she reminds me of both taylor swift and carrie underwood i think that Brooke will make it big
Lindseybrugger411 3 years ago 2
she looks a lot like taylor swift lol i love this song so much :)
Ryguyg10 3 years ago
Wow, this is such a perfect song. I love it sooo much. Brooke sings it so well, too. :]
heartofsteel 3 years ago
FANTABULOUS!!!!! where can u get this version???
Dally000PonyboyIsHot 3 years ago
luv it !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!
bella5654 3 years ago
you can buy it on itunes :)
Dreamypam 3 years ago
I LOVE this version! i think she didn't sound bad live, but this makes her sound fabulous!! she is my second favorite girl! :)
buchananbecca 3 years ago 3
who is your first?
bella5654 3 years ago
Carly!! :)
buchananbecca 3 years ago
awesome!
bella5654 3 years ago
what about you? do you think she's amazing?
buchananbecca 3 years ago
Yes! shes way better than i am
bella5654 3 years ago
I LOVE this version! Too bad it didn't come out this good on stage. Her voice has a unique quality that sets her apart. I hope she wins.
rumwhisp 3 years ago
oh COME ON u guys! completely drunk?! i think she was only a little bit drunk=) but still love this girl and the yellow dress....a bit overwhelming
beiberfan 3 years ago
i love her in this song...she has such amazing low pitches. it's a shame she screwed it up so much in the real performance! oh well. she's my favorite to win!!!
cherryblossom141 3 years ago 3
did she do a full version of you're so vain and love is a battlefield?
ctf20 3 years ago 5
Unfortunately, no. Only her actual cut live performances are being offered on iTunes. I wish they would let her do full versions of semi-finals performances though.
CarrieFan4Lyfe 3 years ago
i LOOOOVE brooke
dowephill 3 years ago 6
me too!! XD
chrustterine16 3 years ago 4
This is better. She looked completely drunk during the performance
CatgirlRiana 3 years ago
Haha! I liked her performance though. :( It was really endearing IMO.
CarrieFan4Lyfe 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
"COMPLETELY DRUNK"- LOL I couldn't agree more!!!
thet0312 3 years ago
I love this song.
ilovemyman001 3 years ago 5
She has such a lovely voice and she picked a beautiful song to go with it
ilovemyman001 3 years ago 5