Miley Cyrus on Idol Gives Back 2008

[spazzz9]

hey justanoridinarygirl5, whatz this song called?p.s. ♥ the vid-and miley 2!

[1xXxDaniellexXx2]

shes pritty and none of u stupid haters could do better u jealous she amazing so shut up or just dont watch btw whats the name of that ssong?

[helraiser31]

that was just a damn fail

[Mavakk]

She sucks, her singing is horrible.

[emilyremilyr]

she was sick:(

[popcorn10124]

yay the only miley video with no hate comments :)

[amcas97]

the beggining waz funny!

[sarahskeeney94]

She is sooo talented

[oreobabesz]

i have nothinqq aqainst her but i dont thinkk shess all that of a sinqerr because she rushes her sonqqss sometimes i lover her thoughh

[GlamorNinja]

what was the name of this song?

[NiNiCaty]

Good & Broken

[ShouldveSaidNo15]

haahah mily that was funny nice

[fuji463]

uhh wtf

[spykids92]

SHE's not stupid... If she's stupid she wouldn't done anything kind like this,... How many super starrs would want to perform in live just to ask donation....AND SHE"S NOT UGLY she's pretty...

[ShouldveSaidNo15]

yah she is pretty

[NastiaLiukinFreakMmM]

whats this song?

[acidfandude]

no offence to the people that like her, but I hate her!! shes stupid and ugly

[kassidy333]

yup ur jelous

[seriall1337]

Ugly? Shes not ugly...

[acidfandude]

do you mean jealous, what possible reason would I have to be jealous. the only reason why its -5 thumbs down is because this is a miley video other ppl have the same opinion as me.

[burningchances]

.. She's actually quite intelligent & beautiful.

[TobiasTunkler]

@burningchances: beautiful, indeed. She just needs something shoved into her mouth to prevent her from that horrid singing. Any ideas?

[burningchances]

@TobiasTunkler

Nope, but I've got a couple ideas about where you can shove your hate. Would you like to hear them?

[TobiasTunkler]

@burningchances Wow! Hey, now! What hate are you talking about? My inferred interest in her is probably healthier than yours. But... yes, do share your ideas about where my hate can be shoved. I'd love to hear them!

[burningchances]

@TobiasTunkler

You know .. You're probably the coolest hater I've ever come across. Most haters would have replied with quite a few colorful words and paragraph that hardly makes sense. Therefore, I'll save my bitchiness for someone who actually deserves it :)

[burningchances]

@TobiasTunkler

You know .. You're probably the coolest hater I've ever come across. Most haters would have replied with quite a few colorful words and paragraph that hardly makes sense. Therefore, I'll save my bitchiness for someone who actually deserves it :)

[burningchances]

@TobiasTunkler

@TobiasTunkler

You know .. You're probably the coolest hater I've ever come across. Most haters would have replied with quite a few colorful words and paragraph that hardly makes sense. Therefore, I'll save my bitchiness for someone who actually deserves it :)

[helens758]

she was sick then i love u miley u rock..x

[YorkiieLover]

She has i really diffrent voice.

[jessandabby]

i <3 this song... sort of :P:P THE CLIMB IS WAYYY BETTER

[nowaysup]

she really good

[soghiegarretsfan]

miley miley miley i am ur n.o 1 fan go miley

[crazypie101]

she rox! haters dont even comment!

[rachaboom]

i respect people like you.

[MilkinTheBong420]

i take shits on people like you

xD

[OnlyMe8712]

she sounds so bad here. She's bad at preforming

[glamergirl188]

You're right =]

[Natalya1sFit]

whore

[Kamianek]

My whore.

[xLorreeehWHATEVERx]

Whats the song she sing? x

[footygirl991]

its called 'good and broken'

[Zszymishley]

the beggining was so funny!

[Smartiejes100]

i love her funky bejeweled mic stands

[xofooledbyasmilexo13]

what? its a normal stand.

[Smartiejes100]

its not ...its glittery .. she has her own mic stand.. watch her vids and you'll see she has it and then watch other singers and you'll see its just a regular black stand but hers is silver and glittery

[weirdogirl97]

lol

[roxybeachbabe79]

she's such a little cutie

[clemintine702]

shes goos and she looks good to

[bosnianckick7]

no effence i like miley but her voice sounded weird it sucked(not big time tho),didnt it sound like bumpy? or watever u would describe it as.

[luvhannahlots]

ah ma zing

you she might sound a lil weird cuz i dont know she has a throat like infection

[peace594]

i love the begining

[camprockuserMandM1]

kinda blurry

[KaitJane18]

she looks like she doesnt know what she's doing! and y is her arm like that? she looks mental!

[tmgsoccer101]

what the hell is the matter with her left arm?? its like its dead or something i agree with jonasgirl180

[xxkilla59xx]

shes belongs in some sort of rehab...if she thinks she is 2 people she belong there

[bellsaway]

Normally I'd say Miley sucks, but she actually did pretty good, considering how bad she is.

The song fits her voice. Good song choice.

[mmagliaro]

@bellsaway VERY astute observation. I agree with you 100%. She actually has a pretty rotten voice with no range. But they pick her material very carefully - nothing too high, no jumps that are too wide from one note to the next.

[jonasgirl180]

thats a really dumb show fur her to go on cuz if simon was giving his opinion that night she would have ran out crying!

[sourtastecandygrl]

She sucks so bad i mean she is better wen they edit her voice

MILEY ADN HANNAH SUCK idc wat ya'll say she does suck no offense miley/ hannah but u have great fashions style

[nerdyfreak15]

SHE SUCKS! SHE HAS NOT TALENT!

[CearaJennifer]

Shes so amazing

[hthorn123]

o m g everyones well tite to her... shes amazin! none of u cud do any better at all

[njklover]

Haha the beginning

[AnneStudio]

MILEY SUCKS

[datchikk1294]

eekkk she sucked haha she sung worst on good mrning amercia!! i knew they had to edit her voice alot soo she didnt sound lik a rat!!haha=P

[edfrizzle]

she suxxxx

[hasrat91]

she sucks!!

[AshleighPaige4696]

She didn't seem very good that day > :l

[garricam01]

your evil she woz ill that day u bastard

[NikkiTheCritic]

:+(  shes bad

[objmgirl4life]

she always is

[joexjonasxfreakk]

i loveee thiss songg!

shes okayyy hereeee.

[pixie1453]

Wht song did she sing in this vid???

[iloveanimals3131]

she sang good and broken

[garricam01]

shes better on the cd bt shes still my idol

[NikkiTheCritic]

shes better on cd cause they edit that to make her sound "good" but in real live she sings pig calls. lol :P.

[mariom8ts]

Shes practically speaking. she can't sing!

[h3arty]

I don't even know her, not a fan, but from watching her youtube I know she's a great role model for young kids. So, she's cool.

[ishkanashka]

she has a cold. and its the person who recorded the video. i was there and she was fine.

[supergirl4583]

if i had a dime everytime someone said that...

[ashleyv101]

the reality is, Miley Cyrus can't sing/act/perform. Shes only famous because of her dad.

[selenapandemonium]

wow, i thought she would actually sound good, but i guess not. btw, WHAT THE HELL IS WRONG WITH HER VOICE????!!!

[KerryLouiseHowson]

She's Shit.

.Period.

[sarascool12]

she sounds kinda weird but in all she is ok

[lauori]

i dont know what it is, but i dont like her!!!

[pzz123123]

She shouldnt dance because thats why she sounds crummy she does have a good voice she just looses her voice with all the moving around, some people can dance when they sing, some cant. She doesnt sound bad in this video though, she sounds pretty good, and she has a cold because you can here her nose is stuffy.

Miley Cyrus is a great singer though

[LydiaGull1]

I just love her! she rocks on the stage!! Keep going Miley! ;)

[vols8789]

she is sooo hottt in this video

[pakdil786]

yea l wanna fuk her too

[Rebekah12345678]

she did really good with song!

[edgelitafans1]

miley cyrus is very hot. how much?

[pakdil786]

hey yea how muh???

[junitoons12345]

oh my god! the beginning was HILARIOUS. nice song!

[bestvballsetter]

I don't really care for her singing this song, The only song that I really like that she sings is 7 Things.

[jJustHannah]

Miley Cyrus is amazing:]

Andd yeah- i think she had a cold. You can tell by her voice. lol.

[heybevbev]

i think this is pretty good considering she had a cold

[Hsm2Lover188]

cool I was there she rocked the stage and the building

[andreapuselja]

she sounds like she is sick in here :/

[jonasxjanetx3]

she had a cold.

[hollywoodgirl3000]

i love miley cyrus. and i think that it's cool that she showed up there sick. it shows how much she cares about others and loves to sing.

[kiaradabest]

I FEEL THE SAME WAY ABOUT THAT

[Uatricia]

ditto

[ohshnapple12]

u fucking recorded it of the television!!!!

[jonasbrothers6458]

miley!

[earlthebull]

whar a buch of dumb asses. she was there for a charity event to raise money for poor americans in rural area in need of help. instead of giving a few doallrs to these poor people, you selfish morons only know how to critize a precious young unselfish 15 yo girl who's trying to make a difference in poor kids lives. your just trying to piss people off. try helping these poor kids your are out. she sang her heart out and appeared here sick. she always shows up sick or not to her concerts, god bless

[Rockstar3588]

I agree.

[bellsiclepop]

i agree. way for you.

MILEY IS AWESOME.

id like to see asswipes like you get to w here she is. she didnt get famous jsut cos of her dad. there are ppl who try to live off family ppl's names that didnt succeed. miley is awesomeeee

[kiaradabest]

I AGREE

[wowiieexo]

shes gunna end up like both of the spear sisters.

[kiaradabest]

U R TOO FOR BIENG MEAN

[wowiieexo]

haha uhmm no. im pretty sure i wont end up pregent at 16. but this chick is just asking for it now. did you see those magazine photots she took. fricken slut. you guys dont know what good music is, if you listen to this.

[Uatricia]

I think that Miley can sing. If u think she sucks, y do u bother listening to her?Are u talkin' about Miley Cyrus about how she's asking about a baby? If u are u r a loser! I don't think she sucks! I don't care what you haters say! U know what? Those Miley hater suck bananas! That means u guys suck!!!

[wowiieexo]

haha wow dude i suck bananas, nice one. wish you came up with something better... but nahh you listen to this lame stuff i dont except to much outta you.

[Uatricia]

You still hate this stuff, don't you? Why'd you click on this video?

[wowiieexo]

just to make sure that i hate her

[Uatricia]

Again with the hating. Sorry, but I will not let go with this thing. And I have one question, r u a girl or a boy? I have a thing to say to u if u say u r a girl or a boy...

[wowiieexo]

uhmm a girl.

does it matter???

[MileyCyrusHatrsClub9]

miley cyrus fuckin sucks!!

[kiaradabest]

BITCH

[kyliemiley44]

shes not u r a bitch

[kiaradabest]

jus shut the fuck up and leave me alone u no talent whore

[Uatricia]

idk

[kiaradabest]

BITCH SHUT UP

[JustAnOrdinaryGirl5]

LOL!!

[kyliemiley44]

u bitch shut up

[kiaradabest]

watever get a life

[pinkpotato022]

she looks like she's havin a SPAZ attack and i think she's shick cause she sounds awful. o wait she always sounds awful.

[SoDramatical]

LoL...She tried to do a mic stand trick..

This is The Best Of Both Worlds tour all over again. : ]

[TWiNKLEsweetie]

some reason, she sounds sick.

but i like her singing.

[ijustineislikecool]

she has bad alergies... poor miley!!! i hope she gets better! but she sounds really gud!

[joenas83]

she was sick there.

[lovinsoftball]

i love miley cyrus but everytime i hear her sing she sounds like SHIT!!!!!!!no offence to n e 1 but ik think she needs to get her voice checked out!!!

[xofrizzleox]

im so mad i missed it ...

but people are saying she sang see you again.. did she??

[RBCI]

yeah, she did! And she rocked it! lol

The video's on here somewhere.. I didn't even know she sang this song.. I only saw her sing See You Again.

[animalslover7]

Yup she was sick...

[jessicalynne142]

awh, she was sick, wasn't she?

she still sounded great, i love this!

[t1cklemep1nk07]

what song is she singing???

[jessicalynne142]

on this one, she's singing 'good and broken', but she also sang 'see you again', later on in the show.

[kellyxsays]

she looked really pretty, and sang good too. you could definitely tell she was sick, but she still sounded great. awh in her other performance her left earring fell out

[cheerstar92]

what happened 2 the rest of the song

[linleylover14]

thats all she sang. she doesnt have to sing the whole thing if she doesnt want to. hope you know.