Added: 3 years ago
From: EmoPrinny
Views: 16,788
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (188)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • This part still bums me out. Isara was so lovable.

  • Goddamm campers!

  • Damn... That didn't make my cry but I felt like I was at the funeral, and I closed my eyes with the rest of the characters without even realising it.

  • In the description when you say that you did not expect that, are you referring to Isara's death or Rosie's singing?

  • DAMNIT WHY DO ANIME'S AND ANIME GAMES ALWAYS KILL OFF MY FAVORITE CHARACTERS!?!

    In Gundam 00, it was Lockon Stratos. In Gundam SEED Destiny, Stella lousier. WHY!?!

  • @EmoPrinny How did you get this high level (of your soldiers) so fast??

  • change welkin to Zaka

  • did you notice that the scout shoots the invulnerable Welkin and Largo and didnt shoot at vulnerable Rosie?

  • dang, just when they start getting good with one another

  • she's stuff shit, i'd be crying my ass off if i was shot!

  • Heh...I sorta knew that was coming.

    Damn...Isara...WHY GOD WHY!?

  • Comment removed

  • Steven Spielberg (I think) said, "I will accept video games as an art form when someone can honestly say, 'I cried at level 26.'"

    Start accepting, Steven.

  • @razormusik Yep... I'd say this was sadder than Sniper Wolf's death. And Metal Gear Solid is a real piece of art.

  • @razormusik Amen to that.

  • Second i've watched it and it still gets to me :,( first time playing it I bawed like a baby :,(

  • @SakagamiNL I feel sad for you, that you don't know when to TAKE A HINT AND SHUT UP.

    This convo has gone on longer than it is worth, let it go. I have already said that neither of us will change our stance on this topic, so there's no point in continuing.

    If you knew anything about writing a story, you would have seen the signs of what was coming in FFX. And since MGS3 is actually a prequel, then you already know what events transpire.

    My point made, your point made, take the hint and stop now.

  • CHILL. OUT.

    Everyone feels differently, whether MGS3 or FFX (gag me) are sadder or not is up to someone to decide, just cause some people feel more for this scene than those 2 doesn't mean you should come out like a self righteous prick and call other people morons for having different thoughts

    Go enjoy those moments, but stay the fuck out of how they might feel for Isara and trying to tell us what's sad and what's not

  • @SakagamiNL In each of those games, you know what's coming. That's the difference, in Valkyria Chronicles Isara's death is just out of the blue. There was no inevitable possibility, no time to prepare.

    Granted these are two different types of grief, MGS and FFX are like watching a loved one die from cancer, you accept the inevitable but are still saddened when it happens. VC is like losing someone in a car accident, sudden and unexpected.

    Neither of us will budge, so let's agree to disagree.

  • @SakagamiNL Dude take it easy. It's just a game. Save your tears for real life. The last time I teared up was during the finale of LOTR's Return of the King, and the last time I cried was at my grandmother's funeral.

    Stop acting so tryhard about sadness of games when it all depends on the person. Each person has their own preference, though as my teacher says, there ARE aspects that are universally accepted. Just accept that not everyone will think like you and you won't have so much grief.

  • @SakagamiNL I know the ending won't have an effect without the rest of the game, I watched the whole thing before posting that. I had to shorten my comment due to time restraints on my side.

    One reason I think this is sadder is because it happens in the middle of the game. It's not just "oh no, they're dead, it's so sad. But the games over and now I'll go chat about it with my friends." (that sounds drier than I mean it to) In this you have to continue and see the characters through their grief.

  • i absolutely love it when a game makes me cry for a character. it shows that they did a good job.

    yet at the same time, it pisses me off...

  • @SakagamiNL Ok, I've looked at MGS3 ending and I still say this is the saddest. I'm not saying it wasn't sad, I'm saying this is better.

  • still a beautiful game, hope there will be a ps3 release soon. please let it be.

  • @91supernova91 if ur talking about this game not the 2nd game the 1st game is only avaliable to ps3

  • @eliwood5837 whoops, sorry that was'nt quite clear, what i typed there. i meant, they released Valkyria Cronicles 2 on psp only and the 3rd is already coming. i hope that one will be once again on ps3, (i do own Valkyria cronicles for ps3)

  • Alright, this just demoted the Imperials back to bastards again.

  • man i actually cried a very sad part T.T

  • ffs shocked me sad part :(

  • i realy should have seen that comeing but it caught me by supire.

  • Well, it's to be expected. It IS war after all. Even the enemies feel like this when you shoot their buddy in the trench.

    After all, no matter what side you are on, you are still human. They all had a home, loved their families, fucked their wives, and yet they still die. Why should any of us experience any different put in the same situation?

  • God, that shot as they're about to shake hands, it hits me every time too

    As far as what i predicted, i honestly was expecting Largo to be the one, considering that he blushed at her a few times i thought he was going to take a bullet for her at some point, sure it was just a little embarassing and not a relationship or anything

    Still, for the scene with Fritz to hit me hard, this was heartstopping

  • I always get a tear in my eye at this part. Doesn't matter how many times i've seen it already, I always get a tear in my eye.

  • Who played Vuvuzelas during the emotional scene? :D

  • oh yeah one more thing, the next imp scout that cross my path can expect to die VERY violently and painfully, lots of bullets to the crutch YEAH!*ahem*, back to grieving...

  • ive heard she was gonna die before i got the game, i even saw her get sniped in the lung in the anime' version (very sad episode, and yet i was surprised, oh well at least she finaly became friends with rosie and made her sing, RIP isara, we salute you

  • NOOO!!!! ISARA!!!!!! What the FUCK was the medic doing picking her nose!? Why do the best ones always die?

  • I don't know how or why, but for some reason when i first saw Isara, i knew that she was going to die. I don't know where that feeling came from, i just... knew.

    Sometimes whenever you're playing a game, the very first time you see a particular charater, you almost immediately know that later on in the game, that they're going to die.

    But even so, when i did see her die i just... dropped the controller. I knew it was coming, but i was still surprised.

  • damn it

  • I don't know if this happened to anyone else as I don't know the exact criteria for the Aged Gentleman to teach you a new order, whether it's class levels or story progression or something else entirely, but when I went to the war cemetery after her death, he offered to teach me "Heal All". Damn kick in the stomach if there ever was one :'(

    I ever have a daughter, I'm naming her Isara.

  • I SHED MANLY TEARS

  • Here here! Manly tears! :'C

  • Saddest part of any video game, from any system, of all time.

  • Isara noooooooooooo....dam this was sooo sad...I like rosie's song tho..she sings very well

  • Reaction to this scene:

    FFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFFUUU-KIL­L EVERYTHING.

  • I don't grieve like most people, but after seeing Isara die the next mission was just too easy.

    I killed everything in my path!

  • During Isara's death scene, my thoughts were "where's the &*^%ing medic?!". Video games don't usually affect me, but Isara's death and the graveyard scene after it left me with tear's running down my face.

  • I meant tears...>_>

  • *Cries nonstop*

    One of the saddest scenes I have ever seen.

    Just a question, but, if the sniper had the drop on all of them, why did he aim for Isara, who has no military high rank or importance other than being a mechanic, rather than someone else, like Welkin, who was sitting on top of a tank and is the (infamous to the Empire) commander of Squad 7?

    Maybe being a Darcsen has something to do with it...

    Excuse me, I've got to go back to crying.

    *Sobs*

  • cuz she it their enemy as well..... she opperates the tank so you know

    they will shoot her....

  • Isara's death was a lot more realistic and dramatic in the anime.

    But that doesn't mean the game version isn't sadder.

  • Isara is the new Aeris.

    May their memories live on forever.

  • This story is really close to Final Fantasy VII epicness.

  • Yeah, they should make a couple of movies on this.

  • Comment removed

  • This was the first time Ive teared up for the death of a fictional character.

    And im not ashamed of it.

  • Rosie was next to Isara... why the hell didnt she call for the medic .___.

  • What Rosie thought when Isara got shot

    "Wow this protection charm works!"

  • ok i was expecting someone to die but not isara jesus

  • ...shoot.... and Isara's my favorite character too.

  • Why do they always kill the awesome characters and leave the bad ones :(

  • I shed a tear during Isara's death.

    In the anime, there was no emotion at all.

    I Prefere the game better.

  • I thought there was a lot of it. Especially for Welkin. The drama lasted for a lot of episodes.

  • Isara, nooooo. No. NO. (im crying right now.)

  • me: yeeaAAAAA........... NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!

  • Wow the singing ruined the sadness for me

  • in japanese, it was much better, probably wont ruin the sadness for you lol.

  • the anime was way better

  • HOLY SHIT! I definitely wasn't expecting that either! Scared the fuck outta me.

  • ;( sawd face

  • This game never made me feel all that much emotional to any of the characters.

  • Yeah same here. I think it may be the script for some of the characters.

  • i have 1 thing to say to this dam the empire to hell

  • this was very depressing, but hey thats war for ya : /

  • tragedy Oo comparable to the death of aerith in ffVII =(

  • oh my god NOOO~ damn you Imperials...T_T R.I.P. Isara...

  • Rosie's VA actually has a really beautiful voice. (and she doesn't completely change tone like the japanese one xD)

    But still... ;_;

  • ISARA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! NOOOOOOOOOOOOO! Imperial scum. I hope the anime takes nothing away from this moment.

  • She's my dearest in this game...

    My tears jerked out like crazy when she died...

  • snipers i hated them then, I HATE THEM EVEN MORE NOW. when rosie sang all the tears i kept back just washed out

  • Wow...I havent even played this game but this scene is a truly tearjerking moment, also very well directed! My tears of joy go out to the creators of this game! I salute thee!

  • WAAAAAAA!!! Why must the good die young!? However, while I was playing my first time through the game, I did have some sort of feeling that she was going to die sooner or later. Its always that type of character that ends up with a tragic death like that. BUT WHY DID IT HAVE TO BE SOMEONE AS CUTE, KIND, AND ETHNICALLY OPPRESSED AS ISARA!? SHE DIDN'T DESERVE THAT!!!

  • I almost cried.....

  • Killing the cutest female member of an enemy squad is the surest way of killing their morale. Some would say Rosie is cuter, but she was safe because she had the charm doll.

  • @darthfrodo7 OH GOD SPOILER ALERT!!! I DIDN'T KNOW!!!! I JUST WANTED A TRICK TO BEAT THIS LEVEL!!! WHY DID I READ THE COMMENTS!!?!?!?!?! NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO­OOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • @darthfrodo7 because the game has to have the anime story line as much as posible

  • It woulda been cool if the "protective charm" actually did it's job and took the bullet for Isara o-o

  • the protective charm did protect rosie

  • DAM y does isara has to die....i like her shes so nice and kind....dam the empire again...

  • maybe the sniper missed and instead of rosie hit isara.

    (sniper)-hold still

    (sniper)-fires>

    (sniper)- dam I missed oh well hit someone at least

    (scout after retreating to sniper) you fucktard why you kill the girl she was to cute to die!

    (sniper to scout)- my bad

    in the end the scout shoots the sniper and Isaras killer is killed.

    Hey would have been an ironic way of getting rvenge on your killer.

  • Either the shooter has a very sorry ass aim, or the "Protective Charm" that Isara gave to Rosie works!

  • where is the medic when you actually need her

  • lunchbreak. union rules

  • Comment removed

  • @supermmzfan Held back by a Plot device

  • that was a F'd up twist in the storyline

    i'd expected someone to die but Isara?!?!!?!?

    especially when her and rosie finally acceted their differencees?!?!?!!''

    like i said before that was F'd up

  • Whose gonna drive the tank now!!!???

  • In the end, it doesn't even matter who's winning or losing.........

  • 3 questions:

    1. Where the f is Fina (the medic) when you need her?

    2. Out of all the heavily armed, dangerous looking people there, why did the sniper take the target that was the least of a threat? Tactical discrepancies.

    3. When Rosie sings, where is the orchestra hiding? That was a little much.

  • was that necesary

  • 1. Don't know how to answer that....

    2. Actually, Isara is the tank driver of squad 7 command vehicle. And she's the only family for Welkin. So, there are some temporary gains in terms of tactical and morale for the Imps.

    3. Maybe it's a glitch......

  • 2. maybe, but does she look like it? she looks like a kid in a tan shawl to me, I'd probly take Rosie out instead. But, I digress, the real reason is HAX!!

  • I was surprised by how good the singing scene was... i liked how she starts sounding a bit awkward but then it ramps up and she puts everything into it ;( sad momentz

  • I held in my tears until Welkin said,

    "We'll go flying real soon Is, I promise."

    Then Isara leaves with a peacefull smile.

    ;_;

  • Jeez this is almost as sad as the ending to metal gear solid 3

  • 2:54 QUICK MEDIC!!!!!!!!!

  • i wonder what actually happened to the tanks that are nearby the camp did they destroy those tanks?

  • And they didn't even get the guy who shot her

  • Gah, writers and their forced drama through a death of a great character...grrr

  • I think this would have to be my favorite mission. The tactical use of the smoke grenades, the flanking manuever near the end, and the fact that this is Isara's final mission. :'(

  • haha... though It's ok now

    Since watched this scene, I had been heavy depression for a week.

    and, I didn't feel like doing anything

    plus, one of my friend had been awful depression for months

    and, he even felt like killing himself

    HOW SAD!!?

  • Next time, when you make a scene, do it behind the tank!

  • Most pointless death ever...

    Even Sephiroth coming outta nowhere and stabbing her through the back would've had more meaning than a random Imp.........

    OK, I gotta be honest...I laughed at the idea.

    I MUST REPENT!!! *jumps off random cliff, but lives*

    Damn....agonizing...pain..

  • It's a war... all death is pointless.

  • I know...I'm just sad she ended up being one of my favorite characters. T_T

  • I will not cry...I will not cry...

    *BAWLS*

    Grtz Sega u have achieved the impossible

  • Isara shouldn't die! Another one should!Like a completly useless charecter, like, Kreis in an explosion at the R&D!!

    Damn the IMPs!!

    *becomes a IMP hater*

  • They should blame it on their infantry on watch, where the hell are they anyway?

  • They admiring the new friendship of Rosie and Isara

    So sad...

  • At the same time as the shooting: The two Infantry assigned to watch:

    Guard 1: Hey look. Isara and Rosie are friends.

    Guard 2: Oh, how swee-

    (Isara is shot)

    Guard 1: If they ask, we were knocked out...

  • i cried when Isara died and Rosie can sing damn good!

  • That's sad too.

  • *sniff* isara and MAria, DAMN THE IMPERIALS AND LOCUSTS!!!!!!!!

    well at least rosie didn't have to Isara outta her misery

  • OMG........ISAAAARAAAAAAAAAAAA­AA.....NOOOOOOO

    Stupid Imperials......... T_T

    I think I'll be in shock for a month......

  • i second this!! DX ISAARAAAA!!!! T_T

  • MEDIC!!!

  • SPOILERS!!!!!

    This hella reminds me of Fullmetal Alchemist for some reason (prob. cause of the WW2 style weaponry, no real air support, super powered soldiers aka Alchemist of FMA and Valkyria of VC).

    For some reason I didn't cry ( I was dry eyed in Hughes death and Passion of the Christ) but i felt sad. Sorta wish I was there to take the blow or something (wouldn't we all T_T) but then they'll be crying over my death.

  • This is my favorite part in the game because it's dramatic and tragic ( i love tragedys in movies and games).

    And also because Rosie REALLY sing awsome.

  • Yeah she sings awsome in both english and japanese :)

  • I wanted hearing the japanese version since i listened to this one, someone knows if there is a link here on youtube to this one?

  • well now the imp really have too die now don't they

  • 'O' now thats a gooooood story...

    you finnaly think their friends.... BUM!

    Isara dead.... just some love talk and RIP!

    i almost cried....

    and I must say, Rosie is a kinda good singer

    still sort of strange, she picked the ideal song...

  • HOW DEPRESSING!

  • these are my manly tears TT-TT

  • EEEEEFFFFFF!!!!!! SHE DIED????? THIS ISNT RIGHT MAN!! NOT AT ALL!!!!!!!!she was my favorite char! i'm ganna cry!!!!! T.T

  • Should I be ashamed that I actually cried a little during Isara's death? I'm not one to be emotional during a game, but this game really did it for me.

    And just when she finally got Rosie's trust...

  • wait so she just DIED JUST LIKE THAT !?

    what the hell is this Gantz !?

  • Why does it remind me of Fullmetal Alchemist?

    P.S. Unfortunately one of the comments in one of the previous clips spoiled whats going to happen.

  • Do you remember which one?  I'll go and remove it.

  • Well, it was in the beach event clip, though the person just wrote that something bad happens to Is. I figured out the rest on my own (I've seen too many anime, so its sort of my own fault).

  • Comment removed

  • sad

  • man, these writers really know their stuff. i mean i wuz thinking "oh, they're gunna be friends, great" and then BAM! outta friggin nowhere. This'll be in the back of my head for at least a month =P

    RIP Isara.

  • stupid Imps why did they have to kill Isara. I wish i was there to save her. She was one of my favorites in this game. My number 1 favorite in this game. She was a very cute girl and i loved her(kinda weird ya know).

  • I kinda saw this coming

    the youngest member of the squad usually has to die

    its like Carmine from GOW2 except this was dramatic on an epic scale

  • The writers did a really good job in this story, yet it is a shame that such a great character like Isara died. She still had plenty to do in her life. Great work sega for connecting us so deeply in the story.

  • hand shake THEN BAM AT 2:42 ................

  • When Isara got shot it shocked the hell out of me, and the fact that she and Welkin will never be able to see the sky together makes me furious and extremely sad at the same time.

  • this was so sad

    but it was a good ending

    she actually sounded really sad

  • (Takes Masashi Kishimoto & Mitsuo Fukuda - authors of Naruto and Gundam Seed Destiny - sits them down in front of his PC, bitchslaps the both of them, and forces them to watch Isara's death.)

    JudauAshita: YOU FOOLS! *THIS* is how you do a character death! You make the audience bawl their eyes out, you don't make them say "Oh, well, he's dead.". *KAPEESH?*

    Amazing video. I'll be sure to watch your entire Valkyria Chronicles playthrough!

  • eh. Somewhat well done death.

  • WAHAHAH nice

  • dammit! NOOOO

  • WHAT??? Jesus Christ, who's next?

  • stupidest thing about this is how when in gameplay u get shot about 12 times, blown by anti tank and still be alive or be wounded and get revived by the medic and in the cutscenes she got shot once by a stinkin low damage giving scout and die permanantly

  • yeah, they shoulda gotten the medic out there

  • lol

    bring out the oscar!

  • Yay for Japanese videogames. They've got a medic that goes charging into enemy fire with no regard for her safety, and she lies there bleeding to death.

  • Wha!? she died!? holy shit! this series is deeper than I thought.

  • Damn imperials...Whos the bastard responsible for that sneak attack? She wasn't even armed and they already lost to Welkin already!! Why the hell did they do that?!?

  • It pisses me off that I actually killed every single Imp in that mission.

  • It pisses me off that i never let anybody die and now she dies because of a fucking sequence !!! arghh.... ISARA !!!!!

  • ...I can't believe I'm crying.

    Who are the writers? They deserve awards...

    They did a marvelous job making us connect with characters.

  • She didn't have a weapon for god sake!!!! That was mean.

  • Don't take me wrong, I felt sorry for Isara too.

    However, although she was unarmed at the time, Isara was still a combatant. Therefor the Imperial troops didn't really violated any wartime laws of ethics by killing her.

    War is not nice...