Answer to the question: Lets say if there was one family of chimpanzees to begin with, then half of them move to a different area, with different species and they adapt to this new environment while the other half stays in the same spot. Will all the chimpanzee's be adapted to this new environment, or just the group who migrated? If I moved to France and left my family behind. If learned how to speak French over there, would my family be able to speak French then. Also,look at 71.14 in the quran
omg i actually had to take historical geologynlast semester and thought us about this homosabiense or whatever.... loool thats funny how shaikh Estes talked about it!!! thank u and may Allah bless all
Bilal needs to eat arse. He will be fine. The real problem with Muslims is that , when they bend over to pray is mosque, there are so many men whoj eat spicy kebab and hummus and fart...it has been proven that this arse hole sniffing and fart inhaling damages the Muslim brain. I recommend lobotomy and vasectomy to Yusuf motha
So, this is what happens when you combine a southerner with Islam?? No, we did not come from monkeys, he is right. We came from a common ancestor to chimpanzees, gorillas and other apes...not monkeys. Humans evolved along one path, while other animals evolved along another. There have been other humanoids that have died out as well over the course of evolution. Sadly, this humanoid like creature was not one of them.
Oh my goodness. This was probably the most pathetic speech on evolution I've ever seen. how can somebody possibly be that stupid?! so wrong. So so wrong, if you're going to talk, give speeches on a topic, at least know the bloody fundamentals. It upsets me that a brother makes himself look like an idiot.
Argh . . . we don't come from monkey, we share a common ancestor with monkeys. That's the first thing. Secondly . . . screw it, there is really no point.
Let's all understand one thing: the theory of evolution or Darwinism is still a THEORY. Science is now discovering that there's something else which travels faster than the speed of light. If you told this to someone in the 90's they would laugh at you.
@ShamsherKhan82 In the scientific world, a theory that has been around for a long time basically means it is a fact. In science you can never prove anything true, you can only provide evidence supporting a hypothesis or falsifying a hypothesis. This is to further limit incidence of type 1 error (rejecting the null and accepting an alternate) which creationists are so horribly guilty of.
@hopesuress "WHY ARE THERE ARE STILL MONKEYS?...i wonder what's their reply to that!"
RE
The same reason there are still donkeys & horses, foxes and wolves, tigers and lions, camels and llamas. The same reasons there are several species of monkeys and apes living in close proximity. Humans don't even live in the same area as those other primates living side by side. A species specializes to survive in new environments. If it moves into a new environment, there's no competition.
evolution does not claim that "humans evolved from monkeys" as this guy in the video says. evolution states "humans and monkeys share a common ancestor". That being said. there is diversity in every species. many kinds of cat. lions are much stronger and bigger than the household cat. they do come from a common ancestor. As primates, Humans are much smarter than monkeys,. But lets not forget they are stronger. These differences accounted for our adaption to different environments.
@aak492 How is that knowledge and information (whether evolution is true/false) going to help you and I in the hereafter once we leave this earth and enter the next world through our graves?
@ShamsherKhan82 Very good question! And the answer is certainly not in the theory of evolution, as it describes our past history. However science is growing exponentially, and hopefully future discoveries will elucidate such questions of WHY we are here or WHERE we are going after we die? In any case, I would not follow the teachings of a leader who is less educated in the subject and preaches false ideas. Move with the time. After all, this religion was founded when the world was flat
As a fellow creation and brethren, I highly recommend you to dedicate a few minutes of your life and watch this beautiful lecture by Dr. Bilal Philips on life and its purpose. Watch it with an open mind and I guarantee you it will not be time wasted:
devil and hitler are angels compared to bible god. see he orders women raped infront of families, has animals and babies smashed on rocks, orders mums cut open to kill ther unborn. even devil never did this evil. and christians dare say other gods are evil. they never did such evil acts theres so much more in the bible. about god, you know satan inspired bible look at these things it says god did
Alhamdulillah he makes a good point , even if we did evolve where did these so called "common ancestors " come from, what did they just happen to come into existence ?
@05alis Exactly where did this god come from?? and whats the evidence that is a creation....An almighty god violates all logical questions in existence and yet because you "believe" in him its true...that is stupid
But hold on, The Almighty (al praise to Him) says in holy quran that some jews at a time commit sin in holy day while they knew they werent supposed to so He convert them (group) into monkeys... Allahu akbar
Actually what evolution says is that we evolved from a common ancestor of monkeys, but not actually monkeys. But I still understand Estes' argument as evolution does not still rule out the existence of a creator (God).
@abishan10 In fact Darwinism states that humans evolved from apes, but today's modren science says that humans and apes share the same origin,and that debunked the dusty Darwinism.
@PointBlanc7 I don't know your point here. "If we were wrong about islam", you mean if islam is wrong or islam is right? Even if it's either, we can never know until we die, and then if it's real we couldn't prove it to the living lol.
If we were wrong about islam being the truth. Clearly; since we're muslims!
But I understand your point. But if it is real, then surely there would be a way for us to understand that before we die? What's the point in it being right, if you can never find that out?
If you assume it's wrong, then you also assume there is no possible way to find the meaning of life, because there isn't one.
@PointBlanc7 Yeah there's no possible way to find out until you die. So just believe in it until you die and even if you were wrong, you won't know that because you would be dead, and your life would of been a happy one with delusions of eternal life and moral goodness so at least you kept yourself happy and hopeful while you were alive, nothing really matters when you're dead.
You're talking with the point of view of someone who hopes. Almost like they aren't sure, so they just guess?
We aren't guessing.
And you're using deductive logic. Everything you said relies on the first statement being correct. You're the one hoping. Hoping that that first sentence is correct.
I am a Muslim/Agnostic and this guy makes absolutely no sense. He has no idea how rigorously a hypothesis is tested before it gets the status of a theory and how theories are the best possible answers available. Until someone can come up to me and disprove all the scientific evidence that supports Evolution with an alternative theory that makes more sense. I prefer to believe in Evolution.
I have nothing against religions and the morals often lead to good but keep religion out of science please.
@tmanntalalash23 There is a story in the Quran that says one of the generations of humans were turned into monkeys as a punishment. I would say that's an interesting myth. But other than that, keep the religious stories whether Quranic or Biblical out of science and let it do it's wonders. Science has done more good to humanity than anything else in the last few centuries.
Technically he didnt prove anything by saying "why are there still monkeys". Because evolution state we all start from a one species and eventually evolve and branc out. Look at cladograms.
@StopSpamming1 But the cars were 'created' by humans and so were trucks and buses they didn't just automatically go from one thing to another...so according to your analogy monkey were created and so were humans..........:)
The problem with the concept of evolution is that it's misunderstood. A proper definition of evolution is that it's a very slow change that takes place with every living thing based on the environment. This does not imply that every living thing will progressively evolve.
Lets please note: Evolution does not say we evolved from monkeys. Evolution states, monkeys and humans have a recent common ancestor.
And according to the pictures in the books, by which he means peer reviewed literature... yes evolution does believe life started as a single cell only to become our world now over the course of roughly 3.5 billion years. It is creepy.
@MKPAK93 Nakalipithecus species that live aprox 10 mya in africa near what we call kenya..as time goes on species die... as evident from the fossil records. some flourish and continue to branch. just as we see today. the evolution of finches on the galapagos islands are the best and most known amongst the public on this. Im not here to fight the argument. Believe what ever makes you happy. just dont take someones word for it. do your OWN research.
@Hairysteed Because Americans aren't the next stage of Europeans,they are just Europeans who crossed an Ocean.Unless you think Americans and Europeans are two diffrent species!!!
@orandxb Because they became extinct. Once again, evolution is NOT a ladder! It's a TREE! Some branches continue growing and produce other branches while some die out. Why do you think speciation requires that the parent species dies out?
@orandxb That's not in the field of Evolution. Evolution only explains how life diversified, not how it started. How life began is in the subject of Abiogenesis.
@orandxb The "Why are there still apes" is listed in "Arguments we think creationists should not use" in Creation Ministeries International website. Even creationists think it's a poor argument!
Then they'll just come up with another theory to cover that question up like 'natural selection' or something like that. I've chatted with some of these people and they come up with so many different theories.
where is darwin come out and answer u monkey ??
homes696 3 days ago
Answer to the question: Lets say if there was one family of chimpanzees to begin with, then half of them move to a different area, with different species and they adapt to this new environment while the other half stays in the same spot. Will all the chimpanzee's be adapted to this new environment, or just the group who migrated? If I moved to France and left my family behind. If learned how to speak French over there, would my family be able to speak French then. Also,look at 71.14 in the quran
bountyhunter552 5 days ago
omg i actually had to take historical geologynlast semester and thought us about this homosabiense or whatever.... loool thats funny how shaikh Estes talked about it!!! thank u and may Allah bless all
ml900 1 week ago
looool he is really funny
may allah bless you ^^
KkidaK 1 week ago
Bilal needs to eat arse. He will be fine. The real problem with Muslims is that , when they bend over to pray is mosque, there are so many men whoj eat spicy kebab and hummus and fart...it has been proven that this arse hole sniffing and fart inhaling damages the Muslim brain. I recommend lobotomy and vasectomy to Yusuf motha
maroczyvariation 2 weeks ago
@chearn73 why can't we see humans with tails or wings? NO! because evolution is a hoax created to deceive us!
NarutoRasengan89 2 weeks ago
So, this is what happens when you combine a southerner with Islam?? No, we did not come from monkeys, he is right. We came from a common ancestor to chimpanzees, gorillas and other apes...not monkeys. Humans evolved along one path, while other animals evolved along another. There have been other humanoids that have died out as well over the course of evolution. Sadly, this humanoid like creature was not one of them.
chearn73 3 weeks ago
@chearn73 wtf are you babbling about LOL!
NarutoRasengan89 3 weeks ago
Evolution.
chearn73 3 weeks ago
I would actually pay to see this guys answers on his high school biology exam.
safieboi 3 weeks ago
"bring me any kind of evidence.."
"well, a human being looks like a monkey"
Wow. Im afraid this speaker is an utter twat. Though, I do find his stupidity rather entertaining.
safieboi 3 weeks ago
Oh my goodness. This was probably the most pathetic speech on evolution I've ever seen. how can somebody possibly be that stupid?! so wrong. So so wrong, if you're going to talk, give speeches on a topic, at least know the bloody fundamentals. It upsets me that a brother makes himself look like an idiot.
safieboi 3 weeks ago 2
a modern monkey said: we don't come from monkey
tranngocthuyvietnam 3 weeks ago
LoL he looks like a monkey himself (no pun intended)
sharmaldh 4 weeks ago
subhanallah... 11 people still think we came from a monkey o_O
Nightwalking12 1 month ago 15
@Nightwalking12
Or, 1 person with 11 account's still thinks we came from Monkeys...
zimmerinhere 4 weeks ago 7
@zimmerinhere true lol .....
Nightwalking12 4 weeks ago
@zimmerinhere Or they are real monkey with computer & internet access.
zumedusa 4 weeks ago
@Nightwalking12 or 17 people are monkey´s.. astaghfirullah astaghfirullah astaghfirullah
dzeniusz 1 week ago 2
@dzeniusz lol...subhan allah
Nightwalking12 1 week ago
Argh . . . we don't come from monkey, we share a common ancestor with monkeys. That's the first thing. Secondly . . . screw it, there is really no point.
bfoaliali 1 month ago 2
Allah gives knowledge for people for whom he likes.
altafnalim123 1 month ago
Let's all understand one thing: the theory of evolution or Darwinism is still a THEORY. Science is now discovering that there's something else which travels faster than the speed of light. If you told this to someone in the 90's they would laugh at you.
ShamsherKhan82 1 month ago
@ShamsherKhan82 In the scientific world, a theory that has been around for a long time basically means it is a fact. In science you can never prove anything true, you can only provide evidence supporting a hypothesis or falsifying a hypothesis. This is to further limit incidence of type 1 error (rejecting the null and accepting an alternate) which creationists are so horribly guilty of.
ehandkz 1 month ago
WHY ARE THERE ARE STILL MONKEYS?
hahahahaha!!!! well said mate!! right on the spot!
i wonder what's their reply to that! lol
hopesuress 1 month ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@hopesuress "WHY ARE THERE ARE STILL MONKEYS?...i wonder what's their reply to that!"
RE
The same reason there are still donkeys & horses, foxes and wolves, tigers and lions, camels and llamas. The same reasons there are several species of monkeys and apes living in close proximity. Humans don't even live in the same area as those other primates living side by side. A species specializes to survive in new environments. If it moves into a new environment, there's no competition.
OptimisticCynic715 1 month ago
evolution does not claim that "humans evolved from monkeys" as this guy in the video says. evolution states "humans and monkeys share a common ancestor". That being said. there is diversity in every species. many kinds of cat. lions are much stronger and bigger than the household cat. they do come from a common ancestor. As primates, Humans are much smarter than monkeys,. But lets not forget they are stronger. These differences accounted for our adaption to different environments.
aak492 1 month ago
@aak492 I totally agree with you. My calculator and my iPhone also have a common ancestor but stupid people don't believe me. :(
Asemahdi3 1 month ago
@Asemahdi3 they also have a creator :D thank you Steve!
Snbkr 1 month ago
@Snbkr Actually it's Jonathan Ive who designed iPhone. Steve is CEO. :)
Asemahdi3 1 month ago
@aak492 How is that knowledge and information (whether evolution is true/false) going to help you and I in the hereafter once we leave this earth and enter the next world through our graves?
ShamsherKhan82 1 month ago
@ShamsherKhan82 Very good question! And the answer is certainly not in the theory of evolution, as it describes our past history. However science is growing exponentially, and hopefully future discoveries will elucidate such questions of WHY we are here or WHERE we are going after we die? In any case, I would not follow the teachings of a leader who is less educated in the subject and preaches false ideas. Move with the time. After all, this religion was founded when the world was flat
aak492 1 month ago
@aak492 Hey, thanks for the reply.
As a fellow creation and brethren, I highly recommend you to dedicate a few minutes of your life and watch this beautiful lecture by Dr. Bilal Philips on life and its purpose. Watch it with an open mind and I guarantee you it will not be time wasted:
watch?v=7OKJ4Wu8VHI
ShamsherKhan82 3 weeks ago
devil and hitler are angels compared to bible god. see he orders women raped infront of families, has animals and babies smashed on rocks, orders mums cut open to kill ther unborn. even devil never did this evil. and christians dare say other gods are evil. they never did such evil acts theres so much more in the bible. about god, you know satan inspired bible look at these things it says god did
mrlogicalman1 1 month ago
masha allah sh. yusuf made a good point , we all humanbing
dararac 2 months ago
Alhamdulillah he makes a good point , even if we did evolve where did these so called "common ancestors " come from, what did they just happen to come into existence ?
05alis 2 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
@05alis "even if we did evolve where did these so called "common ancestors " come from, what did they just happen to come into existence ?"
RE
The Origin of Life - Abiogenesis... watch?v=U6QYDdgP9eg
OptimisticCynic715 1 month ago
@05alis Exactly where did this god come from?? and whats the evidence that is a creation....An almighty god violates all logical questions in existence and yet because you "believe" in him its true...that is stupid
geodude3000 1 month ago
But hold on, The Almighty (al praise to Him) says in holy quran that some jews at a time commit sin in holy day while they knew they werent supposed to so He convert them (group) into monkeys... Allahu akbar
alphys 2 months ago
For y'all monkeys out there: Why you still a monkey? Nice question... :))
gudangsuratimotman 2 months ago
Actually what evolution says is that we evolved from a common ancestor of monkeys, but not actually monkeys. But I still understand Estes' argument as evolution does not still rule out the existence of a creator (God).
abishan10 2 months ago
@abishan10 In fact Darwinism states that humans evolved from apes, but today's modren science says that humans and apes share the same origin,and that debunked the dusty Darwinism.
TheBenghazison 2 months ago
We are a species of ape, all the evidence you need is the preacher's face.
ShaxAMV 2 months ago
@ShaxAMV your a loser compensating for something lacking in your life you know that and o know that and that makes me laugh
lilblitz 2 months ago
@lilblitz That's you. You need Islam to compensate the emptiness and pointlessness of your life.
ShaxAMV 2 months ago
@ShaxAMV
Even if we were wrong about islam, your life would still appear to be 'pointless and empty'
PointBlanc7 1 month ago
@PointBlanc7 I don't know your point here. "If we were wrong about islam", you mean if islam is wrong or islam is right? Even if it's either, we can never know until we die, and then if it's real we couldn't prove it to the living lol.
ShaxAMV 1 month ago
@ShaxAMV
If we were wrong about islam being the truth. Clearly; since we're muslims!
But I understand your point. But if it is real, then surely there would be a way for us to understand that before we die? What's the point in it being right, if you can never find that out?
If you assume it's wrong, then you also assume there is no possible way to find the meaning of life, because there isn't one.
PointBlanc7 1 month ago
@PointBlanc7 Yeah there's no possible way to find out until you die. So just believe in it until you die and even if you were wrong, you won't know that because you would be dead, and your life would of been a happy one with delusions of eternal life and moral goodness so at least you kept yourself happy and hopeful while you were alive, nothing really matters when you're dead.
ShaxAMV 1 month ago
@ShaxAMV
You're talking with the point of view of someone who hopes. Almost like they aren't sure, so they just guess?
We aren't guessing.
And you're using deductive logic. Everything you said relies on the first statement being correct. You're the one hoping. Hoping that that first sentence is correct.
PointBlanc7 1 month ago
I am a Muslim/Agnostic and this guy makes absolutely no sense. He has no idea how rigorously a hypothesis is tested before it gets the status of a theory and how theories are the best possible answers available. Until someone can come up to me and disprove all the scientific evidence that supports Evolution with an alternative theory that makes more sense. I prefer to believe in Evolution.
I have nothing against religions and the morals often lead to good but keep religion out of science please.
tmanntalalash23 2 months ago
@tmanntalalash23 There is a story in the Quran that says one of the generations of humans were turned into monkeys as a punishment. I would say that's an interesting myth. But other than that, keep the religious stories whether Quranic or Biblical out of science and let it do it's wonders. Science has done more good to humanity than anything else in the last few centuries.
tmanntalalash23 2 months ago
This is the dumbest man I'v ever seen. Poor guy has no clue about Science or Evolution, I bet he didn't get through High school science.
forgottenmemories63 2 months ago
@forgottenmemories63
he's not stupid. hes a con man. this man makes a ton of money off these suckers. he's found a good hustle.
Bigpussycat5 2 months ago
Comment removed
eby61ahb 2 months ago
monkey magic:)
isgbful 2 months ago
hahaha
ineedhack2 2 months ago
Technically he didnt prove anything by saying "why are there still monkeys". Because evolution state we all start from a one species and eventually evolve and branc out. Look at cladograms.
purebloodfreedom1 3 months ago
Darwin came out of monkey asre LOL
MegaRajasinga 3 months ago
No, evolution is not monkey --> human.
I made a video, showing how an engine made possible cars and then motorbikes. Does this mean bikes replaced cars? No.
Cars made possible trucks and buses. Do we still have cars?
StopSpamming1 3 months ago
@StopSpamming1 But the cars were 'created' by humans and so were trucks and buses they didn't just automatically go from one thing to another...so according to your analogy monkey were created and so were humans..........:)
eby61ahb 2 months ago
@eby61ahb
You don't want to understand, so why don't you believe what you want?
StopSpamming1 2 months ago
Be muslim and then relax :-)
sasa1010ism 3 months ago
@sasa1010ism haha yeah broo!! :DDD
Finsoul145 3 months ago
The problem with the concept of evolution is that it's misunderstood. A proper definition of evolution is that it's a very slow change that takes place with every living thing based on the environment. This does not imply that every living thing will progressively evolve.
elazteca21 3 months ago
Lets please note: Evolution does not say we evolved from monkeys. Evolution states, monkeys and humans have a recent common ancestor.
And according to the pictures in the books, by which he means peer reviewed literature... yes evolution does believe life started as a single cell only to become our world now over the course of roughly 3.5 billion years. It is creepy.
aak492 3 months ago
@aak492 wait. u said they have a common ancestor can u please tell me what that is?
MKPAK93 3 months ago
@MKPAK93 Nakalipithecus species that live aprox 10 mya in africa near what we call kenya..as time goes on species die... as evident from the fossil records. some flourish and continue to branch. just as we see today. the evolution of finches on the galapagos islands are the best and most known amongst the public on this. Im not here to fight the argument. Believe what ever makes you happy. just dont take someones word for it. do your OWN research.
aak492 3 months ago
If Americans are descended from Europeans why are there still Europeans?
Hairysteed 4 months ago
@Hairysteed Because Americans aren't the next stage of Europeans,they are just Europeans who crossed an Ocean.Unless you think Americans and Europeans are two diffrent species!!!
orandxb 4 months ago 2
@orandxb Let me refrase: Why wouldn't there be monkeys? Yusuf Estes thinks Evolution is a latter when it's actually a tree.
Hairysteed 4 months ago
@Hairysteed If it's the case why aren't there homo habilis and homo erectus anymore???
orandxb 4 months ago
@orandxb Because they became extinct. Once again, evolution is NOT a ladder! It's a TREE! Some branches continue growing and produce other branches while some die out. Why do you think speciation requires that the parent species dies out?
watch?v=wh0F4FBLJRE
Hairysteed 4 months ago
@Hairysteed If it's a tree who did plant the seed?? what was the origin of the initial species??
orandxb 4 months ago
@orandxb That's not in the field of Evolution. Evolution only explains how life diversified, not how it started. How life began is in the subject of Abiogenesis.
Hairysteed 4 months ago
@orandxb The "Why are there still apes" is listed in "Arguments we think creationists should not use" in Creation Ministeries International website. Even creationists think it's a poor argument!
Hairysteed 4 months ago
Then they'll just come up with another theory to cover that question up like 'natural selection' or something like that. I've chatted with some of these people and they come up with so many different theories.
triadsaint48 4 months ago
@triadsaint48 most of their theories can easily be proven false Islam will always prove to be the truth.
Those whose hearts are dead. May Allah revive them.
Those whose hearts are sick. May Allah guide them.
Those whose hearts are healthy. May Allah reward them.
May Allah make us of those whose hearts are Healthy.
Remember bro Fast these 10 well 9 now days of Zuhr Hijjah. Great rewards insha'Allah
UnderstandingAll 4 months ago
@UnderstandingAll Ameen. Thanks for the reminder, akhee.
freghorn 4 months ago
@freghorn JazaakAllah Khair all day any day aki befriend me InshAllah
UnderstandingAll 4 months ago
mashallah sheikh put them on check
MuslimAllDay1 4 months ago
Comment removed
MuslimAllDay1 4 months ago
Good work man keep them comming
omg13omg13 4 months ago
lmao
thewizardofdark1 4 months ago