They aren't singing in the same key or the same style. The only similarity is the actual song. This doesn't work at all. And it feels like Geoff Tate is just interrupting with the bad sound quality and timing. Basically -_- ...fail.
You had an interesting idea -- I recognize the creative intention behind it -- but Celtic Woman and Geoff Tate are not even singing the song in the same key. That being the case, how can their voices possibly complement each other? They can't, and don't. Anyone with even the slightest musical inclination will be in absolute agony over it; hence the comments about bacon and glass shards. It's a fitting analogy, I'm sorry to say.
Good Try! but the joint are too forceful.. it give out a feeling that I'm opening 2 youtube tab. lols
and u kinda get the "duet" part wrong. it's said the a man & woman each giving each other a "impossible" mission of sort.. so the duet part suppose like "Tell her to make me a cambric shirt, Without no seam nor needlework" & "Tell him to find me an acre of land, Between the salt water and the sea strand" =P
well i like your idea, but the quality of the queensryche video isn't sooo good. I would try to compare her version of the song with the CD-version of queensryche!
@grassmower83 Would have been far better had they actually worked together in the studio on this. Both versions are amazing, but they really don't fit when chopped up like carrots and reassembled together!
aha ha ha wt"bleep"
snake42063 3 weeks ago
Where is the "Celtic Woman Only"-Video????? I cant't find it! It was by far the best video on youtube and it's gone? WAAAAAHHHHH!!!!! :C
BTW: This video is shit.
dMvmubde 1 month ago
you butchered both...Damn you.
shanefire6 2 months ago
He should do the Simon/Garfunkel version
Ihaterudecomments 2 months ago
They aren't singing in the same key or the same style. The only similarity is the actual song. This doesn't work at all. And it feels like Geoff Tate is just interrupting with the bad sound quality and timing. Basically -_- ...fail.
Everwild1 4 months ago
You had an interesting idea -- I recognize the creative intention behind it -- but Celtic Woman and Geoff Tate are not even singing the song in the same key. That being the case, how can their voices possibly complement each other? They can't, and don't. Anyone with even the slightest musical inclination will be in absolute agony over it; hence the comments about bacon and glass shards. It's a fitting analogy, I'm sorry to say.
maxbourne7 5 months ago
wtf?
whitkey 5 months ago
well, they both sing way better than I do, so I'm not gonna talk smack.
ExtravagantNoodle 5 months ago
shit
WhitesAwaken 6 months ago
Good Try! but the joint are too forceful.. it give out a feeling that I'm opening 2 youtube tab. lols
and u kinda get the "duet" part wrong. it's said the a man & woman each giving each other a "impossible" mission of sort.. so the duet part suppose like "Tell her to make me a cambric shirt, Without no seam nor needlework" & "Tell him to find me an acre of land, Between the salt water and the sea strand" =P
J4cJ4c 6 months ago
Too disjointed
Louisehascancer 8 months ago
I feel like the problem is that they aren't singing in the same key. Other than that it wasn't a bad attempt
K121Lightning 10 months ago
@K121Lightning I agree. And kinda choppy...
b6en 7 months ago
this is actually kinda funny....sweet pretty smooth then not so much. nice attempt but i dont think it works so well. lol
SilenceIsMyCanvas723 1 year ago
Also, what awesome182 said about the CD version is true too - the sound quality between the two makes Geoff seem worse than he is!
13ShadowsintheGrave 1 year ago
Are they not signing in different keys?
bonfirejovi 1 year ago
@bonfirejovi
Nope. Get a tuner. Is simply one octave lower.
einarabelc5 1 year ago
it is like eating bacon with broken glass.
ValKorry 1 year ago 16
well i like your idea, but the quality of the queensryche video isn't sooo good. I would try to compare her version of the song with the CD-version of queensryche!
awsome182 1 year ago 2
what year?
TeslaDRay 1 year ago
A hole!!
MrRavenor 1 year ago
@MrRavenor
what a rip off.
TeslaDRay 1 year ago
The comparison shows there's no comparison.
Snicker29 1 year ago
Do they complement? Maybe..
Do they fit together? Not really..
grassmower83 1 year ago
@grassmower83 Would have been far better had they actually worked together in the studio on this. Both versions are amazing, but they really don't fit when chopped up like carrots and reassembled together!
13ShadowsintheGrave 1 year ago