Thankyou so much for playing this wonderful piece at the right speed. Widor never played it as though he was anxious to make a quick get away. I get very annoyed when I hear it rushed as though it's some competition to see who can play it fastest.
Brilliant! Too many people spoil this piece by playing it too fast... CMW couldn't have played it fast at St Sulspice, this brings out the beauty of the piece with superb control. Love it!
My only criticism as a sound recordist (and organist!) is the mic placement... though that may well have been dictated by the layout of the building.
I love this piece played at a slower tempo like this....very majestic! I did a research paper on Widor a couple of years ago and found that he often complained of the excessive tempo that organists usually play this at!
Well done! Isn't this Norman Johnston, an organ professor from Sydney, Australia. He's got to be close to 90 years old. I've been watching his videos. Experience in spades. If I remember right quite a number of Australian organists have studies with him.
Finaly, someone who understands it's about accuracey and how the composer wrote it more so than speed and how you want to play it. Great Job for all of your recordings
Great performance! Played with maturity and confidence. I am a 53 y/o hurch organist and have always enjoyed this piece but could not learn it well enough to play publicly. It's difficult for the average organist to coordinate the stuccato with the legato with the hands while the feet play the ominous sounding theme. Hope to hear more from you ...
Yes, Widor did play it slowly. However, he was in a pretty live space for one. Also, this is a simplified version...Widor had a lot more notes to play..
How might I go about finding that? I can't find that recording of the Tocatta and Symphonie "Gothique" anywhere, although I have at least found the fact that it was recorded. I have no clue where to look, to be fair, but still doesn't mean I haven't tried and found nada.
go to Amazon and search for "composers in person" "widor."
This CD contains recordings by Widor, Dupre, Vierne, etc. If you can't get it, PM me your email address and I'll upload the two recordings to a streaming site where you can listen to it and download it.
Obviously a competent organist. I enjoyed this, it is one of those frequently asked for pieces that unfortunately my father can't play (he's an organist at two churches and can be seen playing the piano on my channel).
Actually, Widor frequently complained that his pieces were being performed too fast. I believe it was Virgil Fox who began what's known as the "Rush", playing pieces as fast as possible.
This tempo can also be found performed by Vincent Dubois at St. Sulpice, France. Run a youtube search for "Vincent Dubois". :)
Is it a similar instrument to the Sydney Town Hall organ?
Best wishes, cazzie511
cazzie511 1 month ago
i like this very much! Thank you! cazzie511
cazzie511 1 month ago
i like this very much! Thank you! CMW52
cazzie511 1 month ago
Unbelievable, very nice play. I think he like music :)
It's one of the best versions i ever heard
marxx06 1 year ago
YESS.. this is good.. thumbs up for the correct speed
Riezz73 1 year ago
could you please tell me where I can get a copy of the sheet music played here, would very much appreciate your help. Thanks
fmdtech 1 year ago
Thankyou so much for playing this wonderful piece at the right speed. Widor never played it as though he was anxious to make a quick get away. I get very annoyed when I hear it rushed as though it's some competition to see who can play it fastest.
Well done sir!!
orgmus 1 year ago
Wow...this is one of the few people playing at the proper speed...awesome..thx for sharing
aublutiger 1 year ago
we have a Wicks opus #56 1911 in our Church of St. Rose of Lima Quincy. we just restored it. It is all original with its original blower 1898.
Wicks could not even restore it, I called a Mr. Philip Hoenig of Ft. madison,Iowa. of Hoenig Organ Company.
Geersification 1 year ago
Awesome! I don't know Widor too horrible much but that's really good. I've tried learning the organ but found much harder than the piano. Your good.
edge3220 2 years ago
Weak sound alas...
silverstartrucker 2 years ago
At last a version wherein every note can be clearly heard, played at the tempo style the composer intended..superb and thank you.
gb5uq 2 years ago
That is just Awesome!!!
SmallGrayBox 2 years ago
I think this is the best of the 8 or so I have heard tonight. I have forgotten about this great piece for almost 20 years. How I do not know.
DeltaAlphaDeltaOne 3 years ago
Brilliant! Too many people spoil this piece by playing it too fast... CMW couldn't have played it fast at St Sulspice, this brings out the beauty of the piece with superb control. Love it!
My only criticism as a sound recordist (and organist!) is the mic placement... though that may well have been dictated by the layout of the building.
Owdfolkie 3 years ago
Amazing!
zaogirlo5 3 years ago
this man is amazing
altyd15 3 years ago
I love this piece played at a slower tempo like this....very majestic! I did a research paper on Widor a couple of years ago and found that he often complained of the excessive tempo that organists usually play this at!
tmsenzig 3 years ago
Finally, a superb organist and musician who understands Widor. Bravo sir. PS: Great instrument in a great room.
ahmelmahe 3 years ago
Well done! Isn't this Norman Johnston, an organ professor from Sydney, Australia. He's got to be close to 90 years old. I've been watching his videos. Experience in spades. If I remember right quite a number of Australian organists have studies with him.
organEd 3 years ago
yes and reading from sheets too, now most need practice at this! there were one or two mistakes but hey and wow
mrspenn1611 2 years ago
Comment removed
oakberry61woohalol 3 years ago
This man did awesome. respect
ianno89 3 years ago 2
I'm 12 and can play it and Where did you get the recording of Widor? Please tell me.
Reesman95 4 years ago
Widor's original recording was found on an EMI France compilation of 5CD's and included recordings by Bonnet and Vierne as well.
The title of the collection is
''Orgues et organiste francais du XX siecle'
catalogue number
7243 5 74866 2 0
parison48 4 years ago 2
is that recording the one when Widor was 80, or the one earlier on?
BeFrSc 3 years ago
this is better you can actually hear the organ sing here
vernon361970 4 years ago
Finaly, someone who understands it's about accuracey and how the composer wrote it more so than speed and how you want to play it. Great Job for all of your recordings
Reesman95 4 years ago
It is a great performance of a very difficcut piece. Thanks.
Heli3000 4 years ago
Great performance! Played with maturity and confidence. I am a 53 y/o hurch organist and have always enjoyed this piece but could not learn it well enough to play publicly. It's difficult for the average organist to coordinate the stuccato with the legato with the hands while the feet play the ominous sounding theme. Hope to hear more from you ...
totallyamused 4 years ago
Actually, his tempo marks were about 108- 118 beats per minute... not racing off as most people do.
gooseholla 4 years ago
Yes, Widor did play it slowly. However, he was in a pretty live space for one. Also, this is a simplified version...Widor had a lot more notes to play..
pianoandpipes 4 years ago
How might I go about finding that? I can't find that recording of the Tocatta and Symphonie "Gothique" anywhere, although I have at least found the fact that it was recorded. I have no clue where to look, to be fair, but still doesn't mean I haven't tried and found nada.
colinmb7546 4 years ago
go to Amazon and search for "composers in person" "widor."
This CD contains recordings by Widor, Dupre, Vierne, etc. If you can't get it, PM me your email address and I'll upload the two recordings to a streaming site where you can listen to it and download it.
Thor876 4 years ago
wow, i'd love to hear that. i've sent you my email.
goobleglob 4 years ago
Organ Historical Society will have records of almost anything you want.
octave4 4 years ago
Obviously a competent organist. I enjoyed this, it is one of those frequently asked for pieces that unfortunately my father can't play (he's an organist at two churches and can be seen playing the piano on my channel).
Regards,
Mike
michaeljholme 4 years ago
Yes! I love this piece. I had my organist play it as the recessional at my wedding.
PrincessKimberly 4 years ago
not bad at all;great piece to play, should be in every organist's repertoire if it wasn't so damn hard to play!!
Shogunmiyuchan 4 years ago
Widor Toccata, condensed version! At that tempo, the whole thing would be well over five minutes long.
ccoraxfan 4 years ago
Actually, Widor frequently complained that his pieces were being performed too fast. I believe it was Virgil Fox who began what's known as the "Rush", playing pieces as fast as possible.
This tempo can also be found performed by Vincent Dubois at St. Sulpice, France. Run a youtube search for "Vincent Dubois". :)
NWalterstorf 4 years ago
I have a recording of Widor himself playing this piece, and this is the exact pace at which he plays it!
Thor876 4 years ago
Nice, what is the make/year of the instrument?
Jm4steam 4 years ago
It is a William Hill & Son 1885 3/34 electro-pneumatic Pipe Organ, and we are at St John's Anglican Church, Darlinghurst, Sydney, Australia.
LaurieAlex 4 years ago