Added: 3 years ago
From: WhitneyStan
Views: 25,959
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (125)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • i love aaliyah but theres no way in hell she could ever sing better than THE VIOCE

  • Crack is wack and so is this crackhead beeeotch!!!!!! She hasn't had a hit since she smoked her last rock. AAliyah is way too classy to be compared to a crackhead.

  • u should of pick some better performances of whitney too prove this point

  • Comment removed

  • ok Whitney use to be a good singer her voice is GONE NOW! wall Mariah Carey (the best voice of all time) when off and sold 200,000,000 albums she was sniffing crack out of Bobby Browns ass sorry but its true. And Aaliyah (the Queen) could sing wayyyy better then Whitney 2day come on people whitneys voice is gone. forever Mariah and Aaliyah thouse to are my bitchs. One was a killer Dancer and Performer and one has a killer voice today Forever Aaliyah and Mariah!!!!

  • Hahahahhaha!!!!!

  • Crack head or not, Whitney is one of the MOST talented singers on the planet. I loved Aaliyah, but I can't imagine them in the same category. Aaliyah was an extraordinary dancer. Let's not compare them...it's apples and oranges.

  • Comment removed

  • Aaliyah's more beautiful & young but whiney's voice was better.

  • Aaliyah was a cute talented girl, but who for a moment thought she was on the same singing or performing level as Whitney? When Whitney was in her prime, there was no performer that could sing and command the state like she could. Whiteny was the the top. Not to take nothing away from talented but she was not even remotely close to being on the same level as Whitney. Mariah Carey comes close but can't half way command the stage like Whitney. She comes close with her chops but no dice!

  • you stupid fuck. they represent 2 different styles in music so how can you say one is better than the other? thats why whitneys career is gone. her old saggy ass. ppl still love aaliyah even though shes gone. shes a hoe? bitch she was so classy that whitney couldve even touch her. fucking cunt

  • Whitney was once an amazing singer but lets face it she is nothing now!

    Mary J Blige is still going strong and is a great singer.

    If Aaliyah was still alive i imagine she would be doing really well maybe even reach a higher fame than Mary or Whitney we will never know there us no point arguing about who is better because you will never find out!

  • why they let whit get out there lookin like that

  • Whtintey Houston... #1 Till the end of Time!!!

  • Whitney is the best. Hands down. You're comparing a living legend to an ordinary singer. Don't get me wrong, I like Aaliyah and I think it was a terrible tragedy what happened to her. There are tons of other singers like Aaliyah but there is only one Whitney Houston.

  • was she Whitney fucking high when she did that performance? Ew!!

  • Bitch you need to delete this fucking video real talk. We all know Whitney is a better singer than Aaliyah so why post this? I love Aaliyah more though. & I am also a fan of Whitney. But bitch are you scared of the Manry j Blige fans or something? Because you stay letting that wrinkled ugly bitches stans walk all over Whitney! Have you seen the fucking videos of Manry J Blige clowning Whitney! You are not a TRUE Whitney fan! If you were you would not be letting Mary fans walk all over Whitney.

  • OMG look how skinny Whitney was in the first performance....it's kinda sick!

  • uhm

    whitney.

    whitney.

    whitney.

    period.

    whitney HANDS DOWN.

  • When Whitney was Aaliyah's age she was prettier than Aaliyah. Whitney will always be more talented. She could actually sing. That girl broke records and she is alive and wasn't a slut.

  • you made whitney look like a stupid drunk crackhead lmfaooo

  • oh my god...she looks so ill...so stick thing :x it's hard to concentrate on her amazing voice when i am afraid of her legs snapping :S

  • Aaliyah is more classy and beautiful then crackhead whitney Houston. Aaliyah will always be the best.

  • RIP Aaliyah

    Even if Whitney wasn't on Crack, she still ain't no Mariah. Evidence: When You Believe and compare Whitney and Mariah's careers right now.

  • whitney huston can sing she just cnt hold a note dnt blame her 4the drug abuse she was put through she was in a very abusive relationship with a controlling husband you dnt say stupid things lik that because you dnt know how you may end up. As for aaliyah yea she could sing but even though that is my favorite singer all her songs were slow and about her heart being broken. She was also a bad performer!Whitney is a great performer so just stop comparing one is in rehab and the other is in heaven

  • whitney is a diva, cant really compare even if you talk about styles. lol

  • "whitney destroys aaliyahh" pleaseee more like "aaliyah destroy whitneyy" come on man u must be on druggss aaliyah was number one and if god aint take her when he did she would be better then all them femaless teehee im sorry but im still a fan of hers and shes my idol to this dayy now i really like ciara;) but this video was pointless.

  • aaliyah had style and a sweet sweet personality, she was beautiful never ever acted like a diva, so she gets my vote, whitney is rude and a diva.....

  • OUT OF BREATH WHITNEY!!!

  • BABY GIRL

  • Whitneystan and jacada dont know what there talkin about. AALIYAH is the QUEEN B of R&B music

  • Aaliyah is number 1

  • Aaliyah could blow whittey away with her voice as skinny as whitteny is in this video.

  • Aaliyah is someone who can set expamples for young people, and whitteny is nothing but a crack head who cant try of the pipe.

  • Nobody can destroy Aaliyah. She is untouchable.

  • ha ha ha that video was so hilarious all those crack head moments of whitney looking and sounding a mess than the video says finish her at the end and whitney choked up what a joke the person who posted this video is either a comedian or a crack head themself aaliyah alive and standing still singing a slow song is unmatched by anybody ANYBODY

  • Mariah Carey destroys them both.

    Shes still around, still raking in the cash and still in the limelight.

    Whitneys ruined her voice and Aaliyah is dead.

  • Umm Mariah Carey can barely sing anymore. Listen to her when she manages to sing live. She sounds pitchy and she can't hold a note properly. Listen to her on GMA on Idol on...EVERYWHERE lately.

    Whitney has done some damage to her voice but as that concert in Morocco proved homegirl can still sing amazingly.

  • i KNOW RIGHT.

  • lmao..lmao...u funny!

  • whitney's voice is the shit and no matter if she is on Herioin and everything else she'll never have to worry Mariah's vocals....cuz Mariah's voice is just as bad she a crackhead and a loon

  • yes hail mariah

  • So what's Mariah's excuse? Honey, are you SERIOUS?!? Did you not catch Mariah's dismal performance @ the inaugural ball? She could barely get through the song--and bear in mind that "Hero" is NOT a difficult song to sing at all. **Rolls eyes** Chile, she's all but finished! I get so tired of you queens ALWAYS pulling Mariah's name outta your ass when the topic of vocal ability is put on the table. When in reality a new jack like Leona Lewis will sit Mariah the fuck down--with EASE.

  • So what's Mariah's excuse? Honey, are you serious? Did you not catch Mariah's inaugural performance? She could barely get through the song--and bear in mind that "Hero" in NOT a difficult song to sing at all. **rolls eyes** Chile, Mariah is all but finished! I get so tired of you queens ALWAYS pulling Mariah's name outta your ass when vocal ability is put on the table. When in reality a new jack like Leona Lewis will sit Mariah the fuck down--with EASE!!

  • what is the point of this video im really confused? why are they comparing someone who lost the her singin career due to drug use, and one who lost hers in death? what is the point? show some respect! look at how Whitney destroyed her whole career and look at what Aaliyah accomplished and would have accomplished if she were still alive.

  • ...ok, 1st of all Whitney didn't destroy anything. She hasn't released anything in the past few years yet people are still aching to hear her new CD. Does that sound destroyed to u??

    2nd, who knows what Aaliyah (RIP, bless her soul) would've done in her career. So there's no point in tryin to bringing that up

  • Well obviously you haven't heard her recent concerts lol I suggest looking them up on youtube because her voice is GONE

  • whittneys a crack head. aaliyah was gorgeous, and could sing better too.

  • Too bad everybody else on the planet don't agree with you.

  • hey I'm a die hard aaliyah fan as anyone else is, but aaliyah better singer than whitney I have to disagree.

  • No where in Aaliyah's life has she ever been able to sing better than WHITNEY HOUSTON!!! Are you on crack yourself? LMAO @ Aaliyah singing better than Whitney...

  • They represent 2 totally different musical styles, so you can't compare her. Aaliyah had her own style that didn't resemble anything else, while Whitney is just another soul snger. But I love her too. I don't see the point in these videos, you stupid assholes.

  • just another soul singer? LOL whitney has sung EVERY kind of music execept maybe for Metal maybe. what music will remain in memories? aaliyah's or whitney's?

  • fuck up¡¡¡¡

    you are stupid right???????yes you are.

  • Aaliyah is number 1 for all you hatters.

  • yes she beat her in that because you picked the worst that you could find but think about it she could not beat her in the raw and i love aaliyah but it's no match long live whitney thank god she's back and STILL THE SHIT!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!­!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • bitch fuck you!!!!...dnt ever fuckin try to diss my mutha fuckin favorite singer...you hatin ass bitch juss mad ckuz u ckant do wat she ckould.....yo ass prolly ugly too...bald headed ass bitch!!!!!

  • Wat a Crack Whore...she is such a bad influance>:(

  • Whitney Houston use to be able to sing like that. Not anymore dude. And as for Aaliyah, she is totally different from Whitney Houston, so you can't compare the two.

  • BTW I LOVE HOW U LOWERED THE VOLUME WHEN AALIYAH SANG...piece of shit. i cant believe u called Aaliyah a hoe! WHITNEY THE ONE WITH BOBBY BROWN, THE F*ING FLOOR HUMP MAN, DOING CRACK AND THEN F*ING RAY-J. WTF IS WRONG WITH YOU?!?!?

  • whitney completely left the black community behind... its not our fault aaliyah/brandy/monica filled that gap. i agree whitney is a great artist..but to speak about the dead the way described in the video's title is both rude and IGNORANT because aaliyah is a better performer... even if crackhead has a stronger voice

  • whitney left the black community behing? LMFAO those girls you just mentioned are black and the name WHITNEY as their main influence, so what is your point?

  • Whitney Houston had extra crack on this video, the only thing she destroyin is her self.

  • bitch please

    she just wasn't high this night

  • haha. shes been around longer than Aaliyah, whitneys had like 60 years to become what she is. Aaliyah had 21

  • she had 22

  • this is sad.

  • Whitney, is the voice!!

    This video makes no sense!!

  • yea.. the voice of crack feines

  • fuck u aaliyah aint no yo u fuckin dumb

  • whitney fucking wins

  • AALiYAH iS NEVER DESTOYED OR EVEN CLOSE TO BEiNG DESTROYED!!! AALiYAH HAD HER OWN VOiCE VERY DiFFERENT FROM WHiTNEY

  • You're right about one thing. It was different from Whitney's. See Whitney could actually sing!!!! Aaliyah was talented but she wasn't much of a singer. Whitney is a singer!

  • who is Alliyahh? I know Aleluyah! But Aaaliyahh?????? hmmm....

  • maybe you should've done some research before leaving such an ignorant comment. what country and planet are you from?

  • uhmm.. this make no sence

    you can NOT compare Aaliyah with Whitney

    Aaliyah.. had a Whole deferent type of voice for you to compare to Whitney!

    I don't what you to get mad or anything.. but

    Whitney is Whitney and Aaliah is Aaliah

    they can't be compare !!

  • lol why would somebody compare whitney to aaliyah? thats like comparin britney spears to celine dion

  • aye bitch you betta check yurself....dont get it where you dont want it, dont you eva come out ya mouth about Aaliyah like that...who the hell you think you are...Whitney is a crackhead...so get it right.

  • Nothing against Aaliyah but your statement about Whitney if you gonna call her a crackhead say Miss Crackhead with your broke ass!

  • First off, you got this anorexic crackhead bitch singing "wanna be starting something" like you Whitney fans are some bad mothafuckas or something. BITCH please!!! Believe me, you don't want none of this Aaliyah fanhood ya digg? The best thing you can do for Whitney is take her to a rehab center. At least Aaliyah didn't have a drug problem. Talking about you dare us to respond to this shit. BITCH!! I dare you to respond to my shit BITCH!!!! You got us Aaliyah fans FUCKED UP!!!

  • LOL firstly whitney is no crakhead! secondly this video is a response to one of you Aaliyah fan who made a video to show the girl could sing better than Whitney Houston.and lastly even at her worst Whitney still sounds better than Aaliyah at her best

  • Get off of whitney's pussy bitch!!! aaliyah couln't sing better than whitney.. But she could cover almost all of the notes whitney can.. She go lower than whitney.. And she can go higher in head voice than whitney.. And THATS A FACT.. DO YA RESEARCH!! Whitney is a better singer cuz she had years and years to mature here voice.. But aaliyah died and didn't get a chance too. At least mary is here to put whitney to shame!!

  • This is kind of unfair because Aalyiah was still very young in comparison to a woman who has decades of training

  • Whitney's voice is stronger than Aaliyah's was, but that's like comparing apples to oranges. They have different styles, and are two different people...when it came to making music they both were very successful and both met very sad ends (one in death and one in self-destruction)...I respect both of them though.

    Honestly, not many can sing as smooth as old school greats such as Ella Fitzgerald, Sara Vahaughn, Natalie Cole, and Billie Holiday (all live performers)...but I respect all musicians

  • y'all actually comparing Whitney and aaliyah? some of y'all stans need to get a life

  • lol lol. NOW I THOUGHT ASHANTI VS CIARA WAS FUNNY THIS IS JUST a day in laughing heaven  hahaha

  • This is a joke. how the fuck are you gonna compare Whitney Houston to Aaliyah. Aaliyah couldn't outsing Whitney at her worst...which is why I'm guessing that you "tried" to pick out Whitney's worst moments to go against Aaliyah's best and vocally she still lost--point blank. Aaliyah was cute and all and I really liked her but even if she had lived she would never be on Whiteny's level. Peace and blessings and shit

  • how the hell can you say where aaliyah would be andcouldnt be whitney loved aaliyah admired aaliyahs talent of course aaliyah isnt a better singer then whitney but still EVERYBODY havea unique tone

  • -whitney is known around the world as the graetest

    -aaliyah is known in the united states, she was not world-wide superstar

    -i can name at least 20 singers that could sing cirlces around aaliyah and there are probably millions and talking about

    -one young girl(11) by the name of charice who was on oprah could blow aaliyah out of the water

    -aaliyah is good but far from the greatest,the little girl closer to being the greatest then aaliyah was

  • bitch hush! Crackney can't sing shit no more can she???? Aaliyah can sing.. and if she was alive, she might not be good as whitney, but she'd be close.. She was already close, almost every note whitney could hit, aaliyah could hit.. Aaliyah's falsetto is better than whitneys. ANd BEYONCE WILL BLOW WHITNEY OUT THE CRACK HOUSE!!

  • -it's about putting her little dumb teenage fans in their place

    -i agree with this comment but i am a 16 years old and i know whitney is better and is the best.

    -aaliyah + R. kelly = no class at all

    -i believe teenagers to day are fully brainwashed by this crap they call music today

    -we as women are not hoes,sluts,or bitches

    we are women who have names given to us by our mothers and fathers

  • aaliyahs not a slut.

  • That first performance by whitney was weak, Sure the crack head can sing but Aaliyah as a performer was better. And for the record Jennifer Holiday can sing circles around whitney housten. Aaliyah was the best. so when you make videos like this u do it right and use both of the artists best moments then it can be classified as a competition.

  • you are really hoeso silly why do you say that Aaliyah fans make videos dissing other artist we dont do it we show the world what Aaliyah was and still the best for me the best singer ever nobody is better that Aaliyah this is my Opinion.

    I dont say i dont like beyonce rihanna brandy mya no I like them also they are good singer. so think befor you do somethink like that silly shit

  • Whitney may have slightly better pipes than Aaliyah, but Whitney is not young, like Aaliyah, Aaliyah was still maturing musically, so if she we're still with us now, she would have been better than her, and besides, Whitney is tweeked out crack queen.

  • Aaliyah coudlnt sing

  • Now everybody already know...Whitney is da best ever.

  • wow whats with the hate with aaliyah its like a new trend beside her being and artist she was a human being why disrespect her name and death an who doesnt love whitney shes the queen why are you comparing them u can like more then one artist without having to disrespect the other especially considering u dont know her personally to show this much hate towards her shes dead have some respect if not for music then for the fact that she is not here any more RIP

  • Shut the fuck up, bitch i'm doing this for a reason, it's not about disrespecting the dead bitch, it's about putting her little dumb teenage fans in their place when they make videos dissing other artist who are bigger than that hoe. So stop catching feelings and build and bridge and get over it.

  • i love aaliyah to death but...vocally aaliyah is not even on a level with whitney perieod i mean you actually had to take it easy on aaliyah i know because you coulda threw whitneys real great moments out and man but aaliyah is great to

  • usher lookin kinda fruity

  • Aaliyahs age aint nothin but a number peformance was so smooth

    aaliyahs an amazing artist

    i will never get tired of her music

    and well whitney...... what can i say... not impressed all the different wigs and drugs are clearly affecting her brain

  • wow...love this video, even whitney after prime was/is unbeatable:))

  • YOU FUCKING IDIOT!!!! Whats the point in this video?? Your so sad i know a singer who can beat Whitneys arse maybe il post a video like that then you'l see!!!

  • You dont know nobody that can fuck with Whitney bitch.

  • whitneystan thank you fo rthis video n what i loved was that u used her newer perf after her prime i wouldve loved if u used the 2004 world music awards but still love the vid should show those aaliyah fans

  • People just mad cuz Aaliyah is still the shit dead or alive and yall need to get the fuck over it. Whitney is still here and what is she doing with her life Exactly!!!!

  • Why is everyone fighting for? This is ridiculous. Whitney, Mary and Aaliyah are 3 beautiful women with careers and fanbases. Whitney wanted Aaliyah to play the lead role in her movie sparkle, her death effected both Mary and Whitney. But thats not whats important here. The important thing is we stop these stupid videos and realize not everyone agrees with us in life. Cant we just all get along. Where did this AALIYAH VS EVERYONE shit start in the first place.

  • its funny how the two artists WhitneyStan loves are both crackheads...goes to show what WhitneyStan is like.

  • And they both shitting on Aaliyah wack ass. Aaliyah did crack too, Mary & Whitney said they NEVER did crack, so I believe them over you bitch.

  • she does sound better dan aaliyah in dis performance

  • Fuck that crackhead hoe, Aaliyah rules.

  • WHAT THE FUCK! How the hell are you going to compare Aaliyah to Crack head Whitney. That is fucking messed up and very inappropriate!

    They all can sing, I don't have a problem with Whitney or Mary. You know everyone is going to have different opinions.

  • AAliyah always sounded a mess...RIP..

  • I know, Aaliyah was one of the worse singers I ever heard, she would sound like a man in her live performances and her stage presences was horrible. The only reason why people are praising her now is because she dead, but I remember when she was alive, nobody liked her, thats why she won no Grammys and was never praised for her voice like all the other divas like Whitney, Mariah, Celine, Mary and the list goes on.

  • THANKYOU!! And Aaliyah should be compared to someone like Hanna Montanna!! Or Hilary Duff or some shit...not a great diva like Miss Houston...because anyone wit two ears knows whose the real deal..no need for further elaboration!!

  • o andlets remember the age difference in age aint nothin but a number she was 15 and how old was whitney...... and the one i gave ma heart to she was wat 17/18 bitch get rite

  • Mary is NEVER praised for her voice 'cause she ain't got much of one

  • Stupid faggot Whitney herself has praised Mary plenty of times and performed with her LIVE on stage countless times, your opinion doesn't matter, Mary is established as one of the GREATEST SINGERS and there is NOTHING you can do about it.

  • c'mon bra..i love aaliyah so much but are we talking bout whitney..i mean shes the greatest singer in the world and god know i love aaliyah god rest her sole but she can't do absolutley nothing with whitney houston i see you did'nt even have to use any of whtineys strogest stuff

  • wow you just need to relax there bud.

  • and what the fuck u sound like not better than aaliyah and thats fa damn show and if she always sounded a mess than look up aaliyah the one i gave my heart to live bitch or journey to the past live on the rossie o donell show of aaliyah performing journey to the past live at the oscars yea the oscars were she broke records for being the youngest african american singer invited to perform at the oscars bitch so dont even say aaliyah sounded a mess because aaliyah had tremendous talent get over it

  • All she was was a teen star. Like Britney Spears, Lil Mama and Ciara. Mary J and Whitney are queens and legends. They have done things that this woman could of never dreamed of doing.

    No comparison. Glad to use the Whitney power to help MJB a bit. Not that MJB needs it, but sometimes a team can bring down the wrong. :)

  • "They have done things that this woman could of never dreamed of doing"

    Bitch, Aaliyah only been in the game 4 only 7 YEARS. she didnt even have a chance to do all that shit. But she did make some accomplishements. know that.

  • Either way, i'm sorry, I feel her death was a tragedy but she was in the game for 7 years. When Whitney hit her 7 year mark, she already had 10 number one singles, 3 multi platinum albums, the biggest selling soundtrack of all time and was the first woman to debut at number one.

    Thats no excuse that she was only in it for 7 years.

  • I agree, they always making up excuses and say what she could have and would have, when she didn't even sell until AFTER she died. Monica & Brandy were kicking her ass in the 90's.

  • LIESSS! I WILL NOT ARGUE COKEney WAS A MORE SUCCESSFUL ARTISt IN HER 30+ YEAR CAREER.. BUT FIRST AND FOREMOST SHE RELEASED HER FIRST lp WHEN SHE WAS 22! B4 tHAT SHE WAS STILL TRYING TO GET PUT ON SINGING BACK-uP! WHERRE WERE THE #1 SINGLES B4 THAT??! THE TOP 10's??! **PUTS IDEAS FOR /.\ vs. COKEney & COKE J. ON STAGing dock**

  • Whitney holds the biggest selling first lp of all time by any female which also gave her seven consecutive #1's. Whitney has been successful throughout her whole career, can you say the same for your girl Aaliyah? NO! Dont get it twisted motherfucker. Whitney is a better singer than Aaliyah could've only dreamed of being. You better off comparing her to Ciara and them, because you will loose comparing her to a grand diva like Nippy.

  • "All she was was a teen star. Like Britney Spears, Lil Mama and Ciara."

    BUT SIS, LI STARTED THE WHOLE "teen star" CRAZE! SHE IS THE REASON THESE TEENS HAVE DEALS! WHO WAS B4 HER??!

  • Mary, Brandy, Monica and a string of others. Aaliyah didn't start any trends, sorry to break your heart.

  • but are any of these actually talented ..NOPE

  • Yes sis, drag that bitch. Whitney>>>>>>>>>>>DEADliyah, you aint lying. LMAOOOOOOOOOOOO!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more