The Battle of Helm's Deep by Josh Farrar

[foeaelwood]

Interesting animation project, but total music matching failure.

[NewBetrayal]

i tot this was runescape. But great animation man!

[Perrybcfc3]

mate you destroyed the whole wall

[GFSuperTrooper]

one word can not describe how amazing this vid is this is a masterpiece i congragulate you

[sandalwood10]

n i c e but classical music really

[THEgorillaman13]

could the music be any gayer

[Zgredzik112]

@THEgorillaman13 Well actualy yes if you replace it with a Justin Beiber song........

[Musketeer17Century]

cool

[templarknight3127]

i love it....

but classical music lol?

[Tezcatlipocaable]

OMG!!! What a pure shit!!! Are you serious to make this fucking video! Really man fuck off!

[cmg1228]

nice vid but one quick thing WHY PUT BRITISH MUSIC IN A BLOODY GOREY MOVIE (hey that rhymes) LIKE LORD OF THE RINGS

[Troublesome2008]

Good, but i think the "special thanks to" should be shown after the movie, not during it.

[kathen111]

its hard to see with all the dark effect!

[MrLegoman53]

it'd be better if you could see something

[memberofthejabs]

ok good vid but u dident show the hole thing and when the wall got blown up u blow up the hole thing not just a small part of it XD but nice vid

[Fyuryun]

haha muhahaha the great army of uruk-hai will march on helms deep

[darth1anyan]

Good job at making this.

Although you blew a bit more of that wall...

[XxIMRICKJAMESxX]

are you a complete fagget or somthing?

[Bushwacked487]

@XxIMRICKJAMESxX Are you such an idiot that you dont know how to even spell your insults properly?

[puregold120]

lol amazing

[jastheskater]

this must have took u a while and u put effort onto it ill give u that but u left alot of parts out from that happen at the real battle

[SanOlanCan]

song´s name?

[Max123Mann]

rubbish music

[thendlessonline]

i like this song

[bodczar]

well done!

[gonnaflynow707]

nice work with 3ds studio max,but the worst music i have ever heard

[tegapomdq]

all done on 3d max? what the helll!! great job, u could update in another video host, and show us how is it ur real finall work, cause the music reaaaaaaalllly suxxxxx

pd: the uruks army should be closer and less colums that lines (12 colums/60 lines aprox)

[killCrsiller45]

the video is really good. you think its bad because you couldn't do any better. the movie is animated and you can't make animation can you.

[yeerk22]

At 0:45 if u put mgs 3 main theme there it'll sync perfectly to your animation.

[MrGreenPancake]

I think the music could be better, but good job!

[Zuity]

a happy saruman :D

[theparster6266]

HOW DID YOU MAKE THIS

[farrarjr727109]

i had the proper music and even talking but youtube made me take it off for copyright issues errrrggg......

[connorjms]

@farrarjr727109 Just take your original version and upload it somewhere else, then put the link at the end of the vid here on youtube. And how come they took copyrighted music off of your and not other videos with copyrights I've seen?

[ytmarmalade]

I think this is cool. My friend is currently going threw the animation program at Otis so I know how hard this stuff it. Fun to watch and good job. Keep at it.

[AirborneSoviet]

Whats otis?

[Fall3IA]

@ytmarmalade Going through*

[tc0w]

Soooooo borrriiinnnggg.

[Friedtunafish77]

This is awesome!!! You have done an amazing job!! ( May I ask, what program did you use??)

[farrarjr727109]

3dsMax

[84HASNOVIDEOS]

wtf is this shit?

1 star

[farrarjr727109]

Yes I fully understand that there were no elves at the battle for the Hornburg in the book but seeing as this animation (that I made) is obviously based on the movies and not the books, I feel that it would make sense to have elves! duh. I mean just look at Helm's Deep. I copied its look from the movies. Get a life ohyewildwhatever your name is. There are cooler things to do in life then leave stupid text comments trying to prove youtube vids wrong!

[Ohyewildthong]

Pray tell, why base an animation on something which has been made as a visual and why not do the books instead, believe me, they are far superior

[farrarjr727109]

you know what dude, I made this animation for fun in a summer school class that i had to take for occupational education credit because I take band and couldn't fit the class in my schedule. I love lotr and I have read the books once yearly forever. i fully understand that the books are better yet I did what I did and I based my animation on what i wanted to. How about you get a life, stop dissing on it, and if you don't like it make one of your own.

[farrarjr727109]

plus, I think that Peter jackson did a great job on the Helm's Deep sequence and I feel that it is the only battle that is better in the movies than in the books.

[Ohyewildthong]

Jesus, I am not 'dissing' it and have said it is a good animation, I simply asked a critical question.

[farrarjr727109]

haha dude. I'm just kidding with you man. You obviously love Lord of the Rings too and right there makes me respect you. I was just enjoying arguing with a knowledgable person. Sorry i took it alittle too far. Thanks for watching and thanks for putiing so much thought into your responses!

[Ohyewildthong]

No its cool, you obviously put a lot of effort into this and it is a job well done.

[farrarjr727109]

Thanks dude

[dikkealex1]

There were Elves. they were come to help the men and the leader of them is Haldir, which died in the movie.

[godffery]

our right NO elves were in this part of the story ..Peter Jacksons team added it ..

[Ohyewildthong]

No, elves in the battle for the Hornburg

[Ohyewildthong]

To everyone thumbs downing my last comment, I suggest you go out and read.

[airsoftcrazy456]

Hey josh! Its tiki sweet vid!

[farrarjr727109]

This isn't a game. I made it with animation equipment in a summer class. It is the same animation equipment used in PIXAR films like Finding Nemo and Toy Story. It was just a introductory class and I tried my best. The music sucks but Youtube made me take out all of my Lord of the Rings music and voiceovers due to copyright infringement.

[33juden33]

what is the game?

[musiclverrxo]

this is made me laugh.......but good job

[hrhas5]

wich program is it??? it is NICE i wanna make somethink too

[FunnyFingerFriends]

how did u make rhis?

[NlGHTEYES]

"I've got too much, time on my hands" comes to mind.

[farrarjr727109]

lollollollollol

[catanddog4me]

dude this is sweet lol

[brutal360]

dude! get a 360 and buy that version its much better and the graphics rock!