Added: 6 years ago
From: Keck
Views: 6,262
Sort by time | Sort by thread (beta)

Link to this comment:

Share to:

All Comments (106)

Sign In or Sign Up now to post a comment!
  • Since humans ARE animals, then I guess whatever we have, other animals have too.

    Just because our brains are very intelligent, doesn't mean we are any better than other animals. Humans are disgusting animals in general. Im quite ashamed to call myself one

  • Comment removed

  • Comment removed

  • Humans are animals we share the same Rights. See: youtube.com/watch?v=tdNYVZQYJq­I

  • its been said that animals are in heaven like lions were playing with little kids and all was good i do believe animals might not have a soul like humans but they do have a purpose for this earth and thats why they were made why would GOD put them here if they didnt have some kind of purpose i do believe they go somewhere yes after life.

  • All animals have souls!

    Many humans do not!

  • @2JAMMY it seems that way true animals are loyal and dont want to hurt anyone only when they are beaten and abused they change like human beings. Alot of humans seem damned on this earth.

  • Funny correlation between beautifulness and intelligence and the answers...

    The healthy ones mostly say yes and the unhealthy ones mostly say no.

    Spread Love. Go Vegan!

  • animals do have souls.

  • oh and we are animals.

  • None of us have souls. It's a made up thing like a measurement of time.

  • who gives a fuck what you think dumbshit! animals have souls because they were created before man dumbass!

  • noobs all living creatures have souls !!!

  • Part 3

    Again, this is from my Catholic point of view, if you disagree with Catholicism, then please don't troll, thank you for reading

  • Part 2

    Now, the with Man, he actually breathed life into him, since the official language of Catholicism is Latin, we use the First Latin Correct Bible (The Vulgate), so we believe that that is the true Bible. Now I said earlier that God breathed life into man, well, the word breath and soul are the same in latin (Anima, -ae F.), so Another way of saying it in English is that God put a soul into man, Not the ANIMALS.

  • im catholic and i believe animals have souls.

  • Could you explain? I would love to hear.

  • actually, no. I dont feel like posting a 2paragraph comment, and i was told not to argue with zealots.

  • Part 1

    I think that the question of whether animals have souls is one of faith. A question of faith deserves an answer of faith. I will be using my Catholic faith.

    Animals do not have souls. I the book of Genesis, God just makes the animals and sets them loose. However, when he made man, he breathed life into him (Gn 1:20-25, Gn 2:6-8).

  • animals have souls insects dont we are animals we comunicate with humans and other animals comunicate with their species not everything that is tought is true if animals didnt have sould you would never see a dog cry i hate the people that are so ignorant that say animals should die they are hear like we are here we are all here for a purpose and they arent just here to get killed and eaten!!!!!

  • Okay. I hate these people who are heavy christians and believe in everything that a priest or a teacher says. Of course animals have souls. Type in Dog saves Dog on Highway and then tell me that they dont have souls. And we kill animals, well animals kill humans too. Animals are just like us. And why would there be a Saint for animals if animals didnt have souls? Saint Francis is the saint for animals. And why would god tell Noah to bring two animals on the arch if he didnt care about animals???

  • WE ARE ANIMALS

  • Great video! =D

  • Comment removed

  • Haha I forgot about this video. Keck made this. He went to my high school. Haha Katie at 2:34.

  • wow what a bunch of freaks you asked that

  • * Humans are animals.

    * There's no evidence that animals have souls (whatever that word even means). Likewise there's no evidence that humans have souls.

    FWIW, I would expect an all or nothing proposition. The idea that only human animals have souls seems more absurd than all animals having souls (which seems even less likely than souls being a self-comforting delusion).

    But if animals lack souls, wouldn't that mean we should treat them even better since they get no reboot or 2nd lives?

  • @Calamity314

    unfortunately for you (and all of us I suppose)... just because we can comprehend such a place doesn't make it exist.

    "Animals are not equal to humans" is a ridiculous statement.

    first, humans are animals.

    second, if what you mean to say is other animals' intelligence is not equal to humans, then that is true.

    Humans are more intelligent than chimps, chimps are more intelligent than dogs, dogs are more intelligent than insects....

    continued...

  • @Calamity314

    continued...

    Just because humans evolved into the most intelligent of all living species doesn't mean they get an additional bonus.

  • your fucking mother is food

  • of course they have souls

  • humans and animals are both in the Animalia kingdom, so yea they have a soul..

  • animals have to go somewhere when they die it could be animal heaven:p and that kid that said to be eaten bye me it can be revurse or man slaughter^^

  • no there's no such thing as " animal heaven" ,

    Animals have soul like us , they are living things and they are in the animalia kingdom just like us

  • The older nerd at 20 seconds-ask him how he'd like to be served up as a meal.Ugh,sorry nobody would want it.

    At 1:05,1;16-1:22-he is obviously a miserable loser.

    The oriental "asian" at 2:12-2:30,doesn't surprise me;completely lost idiot.

    Burned out simple old man @ 2:55.

    3:18-what a freak.

    Sad school here;many needing enlightenment.

  • heck yea they have souls when i look at my animals i think how could they NOt have a soul????

  • Hate that bearded guy at the beginning of the vid, I'd like to barbecue the soulless fucks who said they don't. Fucking hillbillies.

    Non human animals are as likely to have souls as anyone else.

  • There's no real evidence that animals have souls. The same goes for people.

  • asking if animals have souls implies thinking that humans are not animals, which is incorrect. souls are a concept created by humans to make death appear less scary."animals" are not here for us. that thought is narrow minded and conceited. therefore, neither humans nor animals have souls because souls cannot exist.

    you stopped believing in santa when you were 6. after a living being dies, its biological functions cease.

    we just happen to be the most intelligent species of animals on earth.

  • I tend to agree heartily, although i'm not sure we're the most intelligent species on Earth. We have appendages that readily allow us to use our intellects, unlike the elephant or the whale. Likewise i have doubts about SONY.

  • "It is of interest to note that while some dolphins are reported to have learned English -- up to fifty words used in correct context -- no human being has been reported to have learned dolphinese."

    -Carl Sagan

  • First, I would not call that learning english. I call that assimilating a sound to an action. Even birds do that. Second, dolphins communicate with ultra sounds and shrieks which all sound similar to the untrained human ear. finally, the pronunciation of the English language varies greatly from word to word, making each sound quite unique. what WOULD be interesting is finding out whether dolphins can differentiate Chinese words that differ in no way except for the tone in which they are spoken.

  • Your anthropocentrism is showing.

  • intelligent???

  • Souls are energy. Energy cannot be created, nor destroyed. Therefor, souls can exist.

  • No because they are a logical impossibility.

  • how so? you cannot see energy itself but you know it exists. Souls are a form of energy.

  • but there is no evidence for the existence of souls : they are part of belief. Moreover, the definition of a soul makes it a logical impossibility. distinct from the body and survives the death of the body? hello, this isn't wonderland.

  • who said it needed to be wonderland?

  • I don't see how you can consider humans to be the most intelligent species of animal on earth. Maybe at one point in time...yes, but we are the species that is destroying the one and the ONLY home we have (earth) for ourselves and for future generations. How is that intelligent? And look at the retarded things humans do such as taunting a tiger out of their natural habitat and then getting mauled to death. Can we say Darwin award?? Wearing another animals skin? We have our own for gods sake!

  • Animals don't make idiots of themselves on an hourly basis.  Animals sense things. Things that we never would be able to. Such as seizures, violent storms, earthquakes. There has to be a great deal of intelligence there for their brains to be able to sense such things.

  • when an animal runs to the side of an epileptic to warn them they are going to go through a seizure, the animal knows EXACTLY what they are sensing.

    Primates can learn and communicate through sign language, the same as us. They also can learn to read as well as distinguish symbols.

  • lol, funny vid w/ random people

    And yes, I think do think that animals have souls.

  • I'm not religious, but I do believe in life after death.

  • I feel they do. Just look your pet in the eyes. You can NOT tell me they have no soul. They are perfectly capable of showing emotion, feeling pain and happiness, etc.

  • There is 2 options.

    If we have souls so do animals!

    If animals dont have it means we dont have it too!

    Because humans are most terible creatures on this planet and animals especialy dogs and cats for example much more deserves to have a soul then any human!

  • The Torah says that Animals have Living Souls. (Genesis 1:20)

    But that terminology was omitted from most versions of the christian bible.

    Most people don't want to believe that Animals have souls or feelings because they wish to place themselves on a higher plane of existence.

    It is personal greed that fosters the belief that only Humans have souls.

  • Some people say, "We believe that animals have no soul." That is not correct. They believe animals have no soul because they want to eat the animals, but actually animals do have a soul. How do you know that the animal has a soul? You can know also. Here is the scientific proof... the animal is eating, you are eating; the animal is sleeping, you are sleeping; the animal is defending, you are defending; the animals have children, you have children;

  • they have a living place, you have a living place. If the animal's body is cut, there is blood; if your body is cut, there is blood. So, all these similarities are there. Now, why do you deny this one similarity, the presence of the soul? That is not logical. You have studied logic? In logic there is something called analogy. Analogy means drawing a conclusion by finding many points of similarity.

  • That is not logic. That is not science.

  • not scientific.... cuz a soul isnt scientific, but um ok?

  • haha ur really funny

  • If a stupid human has a soul, then so does an animal.

  • sorry could not fit all of it on one comment

    cause when you realy think about it your pet is most likely a much smaller siner then you now this is just a thing a friend of mine bost at lunch but it real makes you think animals do have souls and for you people who think we have souls or do not well you look a kitten or a puppy dead in the and tell me face to face that animals dont have souls

  • yes animals do have souls they have free will they are each diffent in thier own way even cats from the litter are diffent in their own way the soul is what makes the person and the animal one of a kind and think their are good and bad people just like good and bad animals so don't you that the good animals get to go to heaven

  • These people that think it's so funny to eat animals are siickkk.

  • I think that if human animal have souls, than so does the non human animal and every other living nature, from a dog to a fish to a tree.

  • haha the guy at 3:59 :D

  • EXCELLENT video 5/5 star

  • I have to say that Animals DO have souls...Is there any proof? well...let's just say...that You guys that told this guy that animals are here to be eaten by "HUMANS"...for the record..last time i cecked...humans ARE animals...wow, Some people do lack IQ in this world! By the way, Thank you for this very "educational" video...it showed me how much IQ people can have at a school...Final results: Holy shit their low!

    Now those who "thinks" animal have souls are right! In my opinion ^^

  • Creationists, for example, do not think that "We" are animals.

  • No animals dont have souls!! Nor do us humans cos souls arnt real. There is absolulty no evidence for souls to be real. SO no nothing has souls.

    But just so u know i do love animals and a i dont eat them. =)

  • Theology "X" if not false if it can not be proven true.

  • course animals have souls, but they are mortal souls, not immortal

  • Cool video- I'm suprised so many people don't seem to realise that people are animals- I guess they never really thought much of the theory of evalution

  • Animals have souls... its people I'm worried about

  • OMG! My thoughts exactly!

  • I really like the voice of whoever's filming this O_o

  • The question of "souls" is a religious concept,and religion is based on anthprocentricism,which is the justifyer for slaughterhouses,vivisection etc.Though i liked the comedy of the video.

  • noone has souls. there is no evidence for such a nonsensical idea. and no reason to think they have souls.

  • There is no proof that we don't have souls either and yes, there are reasons

  • The proof that we don't have souls is that the brain can be cut up, and then a person's personality will change. That proves there is no soul.

    If a physical change (brain damage) can change a person, then the soul (non-physical personality) does not exist.

  • YEAH, BUT THATS ALTERING.

  • JIN "The proof that we don't have souls is that the brain can be cut up, and then a person's personality will change. That proves there is no soul. If a physical change (brain damage) can change a person, then the soul (non-physical personality) does not exist."

    50N "YEAH, BUT THATS ALTERING."

    Didn't know the soul could be altered by a scalpel! My bad. :)

    Wonder what would happen with a flame thrower? Would the soul die?

    Yes, yes it would.

  • @jinitron

    your mistake was using logic. people rid of their logic when it conflicts with their "faith"

    ..but i agree

  • Excellent vid!

  • haha! josh...seeing desmond explain why animals dont have souls... is priceless... lol

  • If we have souls, they have souls, we're no different from other animals because we are animals ourselves...

    I'm not religious however, so I don't take the "soul" thing seriously.

    PS I am going to mark this as a favorite.

  • Animals do not have souls people!! They steal them when they dance!!!

  • I really did not understand if you are veg-n or even care about animals..? O_o

  • I made this one a favorite. I'll be showing it around.

    And if there are souls to begin with, then ALL living creatures have 'em. I want to see more such little documentaries from Josh.

  • and yes, i have seen a kitten duct-tape a live human baby to a freeway.

  • this appears to be a catholic school. the majority of students surveyed believe that a)humans are not "animals" and b)a "soul" exists in the first place. so when asked if "animals have souls," those who said "no," and believed that humans have souls, did not view humans as "animals." therefore, an answer from one person could mean something different than the same answer from someone else.

  • I love this. I put it on my site. www.myspace.com/seraah.

  • YEA HI MY NAME IS SPARKY...IM A DOG AND YEA I THINK I SPEAK FOR ALL DOGS WHEN I SAY YES WE HAVE A SOUL....WHY WOULD YOU THINK WE DONT HAVE A SOUL OF COURSE WE HAVE SOULS.....ASS....RUFFFFF

  • animals have souls!

  • But.... the interviewer assumes that people believe souls exist. ;)

  • Exactly. Some of the people that said that animals do not have souls might not even believe people  have souls.

    Like me. If he asked me that question I would say:

    "No one has a soul."

  • Secondly, why would it matter if they had souls? They can still be damn tasty.

  • This is brilliant. I love this kid.

    Humans are animals!!! Embrace it! Be it!

Loading...
Alert icon
0 / 00Unsaved Playlist Return to active list
    1. Your queue is empty. Add videos to your queue using this button:
      or sign in to load a different list.
    Loading...Loading...Saving...
    • Clear all videos from this list
    • Learn more