This comment has received too many negative votesshow
No other cellist equals Mr. Rostropovich (maybe Cunningham?). You will all be jalous: my brother used to play with him at the age of 13 in Paris salle Pleyel. I'm so proud of him!
I foud a video of Wells Cunningham on youtube while googeling my brother (a professional cellist too). I was totaly in awe when I listen to his interpretation of the 24 caprice of Paganini and Handels Passacaglia for cello and violin. I think this guy is just extraordinary. But it is only my opinion. But have a look and enjoy. He also plays the guitar like an Angel. Would be nice if you tell me your opinion on him after you see his video. Sorry for my bad english.
Gotta love the first entrance of the cello solo....Slava plays this piece with such power and musicality. Its almost frightening. Bravo Slava. Bravo.....
What is he doing on the podium period? He's staring at his score the entire time, sets frantic tempos, and his beat occurs SO high it looks incredibly awkward.
Proof that Slava could still play the most difficult cello pieces ridiculously well even when he was getting up there in years.
And this piece is one of his specialties.
I must say, though, I do prefer his earlier recording with Sargent (simply brilliant), and am very fond of a heartwrenching, very exciting reading by Daniil Shafran in the 50s.
I've also come across snippets of the premiere performance of the piece with Sviatoslav Richter conducting, but can't find it in its entirety. Help?
he is actually just 42-43 years old in this video, he seems to be older, but it´s a splendid performance! ( or at least he plays good, not the orchestra!)
wow! theres such a difference between the interpretations of maisky and rostropovich. rostropovich sounds more romantic here and he takes more time on certain passages. it's very interesting.
maisky is notorious for ignoring tempo markings, so you can be sure what differences there are between the interpretations are the difference between what prokofiev intended and, well, not
Prokofiev and Shostakovich both express anger and bitter-sweet melodies in their music. Mainly because of the USSR forcing them to either destroy or change their musical works.
For example did u know that the Romeo and Juliet ballet had to be rewritten b/c it was considered counter-revolutionary to the USSR
@iWyke2 Did you Know this piece was written at Piatigosky request 2 Prokofiev to write something for cello, and then when the 2 movements of the original piece were sent back to Prokofiev with some comments and suggestions to polish the final score, Prokofiev was already back in Russia ant the soviets call that piece the worst work by him due to his foreign influences, and that original piece turned out, rewitten as this sinfonia concertante? (just learn that in Pitigorsky's book "cellist"
This video is a document of an Era , ... 1970 rostropovich still captive of the Soviet , ...a world of myths with its soundtrack! .... great performance.
if it makes you feel better, it's been reasonably well documented that prokofiev on occation would ask people for motifs and small scale ideas and use them in his works, or have other people do some of his orchestration. But I don't really care much. I really like his music. And the truth is, it is a different kind of listening. One the appreciates dissnonance and "less friendly" approachs sounds, harmonies, and rhythms. We can't all be vivaldi, and not all great music has melody clearly defined
To tell you the truth, I think that it is wonderful that Prokofievs music can have such a visceral—albeit somewhat philistine—reaction given that it is considered repertory by most orchestra, soloist and chamber players. Keep listening, friend. Im not saying that you will one day come to like his music—personal aesthetics, are just that personal—but perhaps one day, after giving this kind of music a good listen, youll come up with something intelligent to say about your dislike of it.
It's because your ear is trained to listen to western music. It takes time to appreciate works by Modern compmosers like Prokofiev, Shostakovich, Mahler, Stravinsky, and etc. I wouldn't blame ya tho. If I heard this piece about two years ago I would've hated it XP
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I never liked watching Rostropovich He always looks so serious when he plays, like he's angry with the music and the cello. Mischa Miasky makes it look like fun. Rostropovich makes the most delightful music look like a dreadful pain to play.
I suggest you close your eyes and LISTEN to the music. You might find that it doesn't matter if he glowers or laughs - the music is beautiful and so is his interpretation. Works for me... :)
I can only imagine what may have been on Prokofiev's mind when he wrote this. If there is one good thing that came from Stalin's tyranny it is the music written by Prokofiev, Shostakovich, and Khachaturian.
Or that he's terrified the conductor's going to let it all fall apart....honestly I feel like there are parts where Rostropovich is conducting more than the conductor
Yeah, I agree, the orchestra is pretty pathetic. Sadly, this is th only video I have ever found of the Prokofiev and the added bonus of Slava playing it makes it easier to ignore the orchestra.
@Hopfensperger You can't think of anything wrong with the orchestra? didn't think so, maybe you shouldn't say their pathetic when in fact they play this piece quite good.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
cuz ur an idiot..... ^^; that dvd has shosti concerto no 1 on it and like extra stuff where he's playing with his wife... AWESOME dvd. go out and buy it. totally worth ur money.
hardest song ever written for the cello.
randomprimate 1 week ago
Meh....he's amazing.....not a fan of this piece...my opinion. But ya he plays the crap out of it. This music kinda creeps me out..LOL
noellybobelly 4 weeks ago
I had to dig in to my college fund to buy this sheet music....
Mizzles240 1 month ago 2
increible
Camilesbeiss 3 months ago
Comment removed
MrAjleask 3 months ago
no one will ever play this better than him.....
thefemalecelloplayer 4 months ago
wow, that oppening was so strong
Philboy50 6 months ago
7:47-7:58 that conductor looks like he's directing air traffic. xP
Clarinet4Life1 9 months ago
Comment removed
Philboy50 10 months ago
Comment removed
TheCelloRoots 10 months ago
03:58 the clarinets seem to be zombies -- dead
JC5268 1 year ago
Cool fact: Rostropovich himself wrote the passage from 6:56 - 7:11
aabaker22 1 year ago
thank you so much for uploading this. rostropovich plays with some real cajones >:D i can't stop watching this.... its SOOOO gorgeous!!!
pansyjustinchan 1 year ago
Increible! .....Espero que esto jamas pase de moda.
elmachucho 1 year ago
7:48 is so epic. shostakovich thought this was prokofiev's greatest work
sweatinggrundle 1 year ago
GOD OF CELLO!!!!!!!!!!!
koeloekai 1 year ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
No other cellist equals Mr. Rostropovich (maybe Cunningham?). You will all be jalous: my brother used to play with him at the age of 13 in Paris salle Pleyel. I'm so proud of him!
caisajolie 2 years ago
who is cunningham?
aamish911 2 years ago
Hello aamish911,
I foud a video of Wells Cunningham on youtube while googeling my brother (a professional cellist too). I was totaly in awe when I listen to his interpretation of the 24 caprice of Paganini and Handels Passacaglia for cello and violin. I think this guy is just extraordinary. But it is only my opinion. But have a look and enjoy. He also plays the guitar like an Angel. Would be nice if you tell me your opinion on him after you see his video. Sorry for my bad english.
caisajolie 2 years ago
O yes I know Wells Cunningham. yes he is a very talented person
aamish911 2 years ago
And the conductors name is Okko Kamu, a renown finnish conductor...
kcmusisk 2 years ago
♥♥♥Slava!!♥♥♥
The best cellist of all time. =D
The magic was in his hands, his devotion, his feeling, the way he played.
Besides the Vodka, the second jewel that Russia gave us.
sweetestinyection 2 years ago 28
I just love this video, but it's a pity about the 1st note and last note of the last movement.
diblasic 2 years ago 2
Wow. He co-composed this piece, then played the hell out of it. Gotta love Rostropovich
RandomMuch1337 2 years ago 5
Gotta love the first entrance of the cello solo....Slava plays this piece with such power and musicality. Its almost frightening. Bravo Slava. Bravo.....
makuletboy 2 years ago
What the hell is the conductor doing at 7:53? Some sort of rainbow?
cellobren 2 years ago
That happens to be a third beat.
Ltlevim 2 years ago 4
LOL
You win sir, but I concur with Ltlevim.
chriseok 2 years ago
hahahahahahahahhaha....oh man...agreed.
Seoul2rain 2 years ago
What is he doing on the podium period? He's staring at his score the entire time, sets frantic tempos, and his beat occurs SO high it looks incredibly awkward.
goober8729 2 years ago
Proof that Slava could still play the most difficult cello pieces ridiculously well even when he was getting up there in years.
And this piece is one of his specialties.
I must say, though, I do prefer his earlier recording with Sargent (simply brilliant), and am very fond of a heartwrenching, very exciting reading by Daniil Shafran in the 50s.
I've also come across snippets of the premiere performance of the piece with Sviatoslav Richter conducting, but can't find it in its entirety. Help?
OzzyKingofKings 2 years ago
he is actually just 42-43 years old in this video, he seems to be older, but it´s a splendid performance! ( or at least he plays good, not the orchestra!)
cellogeek95 2 years ago 3
I fell in love with Prokofiev when I heard this piece. He and Shostakovich wrote such beautiful and heart-wrenching music, it's flawless.
petpetfood 2 years ago 6
wow! theres such a difference between the interpretations of maisky and rostropovich. rostropovich sounds more romantic here and he takes more time on certain passages. it's very interesting.
mestisapnoi 3 years ago 3
maisky is notorious for ignoring tempo markings, so you can be sure what differences there are between the interpretations are the difference between what prokofiev intended and, well, not
mynameismaurice 2 years ago 4
A wonderful piece. My first time hearing it too - and I am a cellist! Wow.
CelloNerd314 3 years ago 2
Prokofiev and Shostakovich both express anger and bitter-sweet melodies in their music. Mainly because of the USSR forcing them to either destroy or change their musical works.
For example did u know that the Romeo and Juliet ballet had to be rewritten b/c it was considered counter-revolutionary to the USSR
iWyke2 3 years ago 3
@iWyke2 Did you Know this piece was written at Piatigosky request 2 Prokofiev to write something for cello, and then when the 2 movements of the original piece were sent back to Prokofiev with some comments and suggestions to polish the final score, Prokofiev was already back in Russia ant the soviets call that piece the worst work by him due to his foreign influences, and that original piece turned out, rewitten as this sinfonia concertante? (just learn that in Pitigorsky's book "cellist"
raulishnikov 1 year ago
This video is a document of an Era , ... 1970 rostropovich still captive of the Soviet , ...a world of myths with its soundtrack! .... great performance.
giordaniotto 3 years ago
if it makes you feel better, it's been reasonably well documented that prokofiev on occation would ask people for motifs and small scale ideas and use them in his works, or have other people do some of his orchestration. But I don't really care much. I really like his music. And the truth is, it is a different kind of listening. One the appreciates dissnonance and "less friendly" approachs sounds, harmonies, and rhythms. We can't all be vivaldi, and not all great music has melody clearly defined
fiddlinmatt 3 years ago 3
Yeah, you have to get used to it before you can feel its message. I don't blame you tho, it's just a question of education.
No need to down thumb him to death haha.
gpahdnon 3 years ago
I give all my credits to Rostropovich as well. one of the best ever in my ears
chillisnake 3 years ago
This is great!!!!!!!!!!!!
Pianoloverok 3 years ago 4
I think this is amazing...
pegasus09196 3 years ago
To tell you the truth, I think that it is wonderful that Prokofievs music can have such a visceral—albeit somewhat philistine—reaction given that it is considered repertory by most orchestra, soloist and chamber players. Keep listening, friend. Im not saying that you will one day come to like his music—personal aesthetics, are just that personal—but perhaps one day, after giving this kind of music a good listen, youll come up with something intelligent to say about your dislike of it.
Hachechulo 3 years ago 3
It's because your ear is trained to listen to western music. It takes time to appreciate works by Modern compmosers like Prokofiev, Shostakovich, Mahler, Stravinsky, and etc. I wouldn't blame ya tho. If I heard this piece about two years ago I would've hated it XP
RandomMuch1337 3 years ago 4
I bought the recording with Malcolm Sargent conducting and I didn't appreciate it until 3 months later, although I have liked Prokofiev for years.
RabidCh 3 years ago
Wow, that's a pathetic comment. This music is incredible, you're just retarded.
AbsoluteZ3R0 3 years ago 2
u have no idea wut ur talking about
philly4life36 3 years ago
I just remembered that I have a recording of him conducting the symphonies # 5, and 7 of prokofiev....pretty awesome
vcupiano 3 years ago
what the hell are you talking about I can't look away!
vcupiano 3 years ago
Hardest Cello Concerto.
Kurtyoungblood 3 years ago 3
agreed
philly4life36 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I never liked watching Rostropovich He always looks so serious when he plays, like he's angry with the music and the cello. Mischa Miasky makes it look like fun. Rostropovich makes the most delightful music look like a dreadful pain to play.
xylenz 3 years ago
I suggest you close your eyes and LISTEN to the music. You might find that it doesn't matter if he glowers or laughs - the music is beautiful and so is his interpretation. Works for me... :)
bckm54 3 years ago 12
This comment has received too many negative votes show
true, but the cello is just as much a visual art as it is a performing art
zaclavender 3 years ago
What the hell are you talking about? That is completely untrue.
calderi0 3 years ago 3
Oh, my comment was directed at zaclavender.
calderi0 3 years ago
music is not for watching, it's for listening
junho1202 3 years ago
however, posture while playing any instrument still is important, even while it doesn't affect the sound
uhsayer 3 years ago
I disagree; a good posture while playing the cello will open up the sound, while a bad posture makes it much harder to achieve good tone quality
goober8729 2 years ago
Rostropovich Prokofieva igraet luchshe vseh. A orkestr adovii)
bzyakalka 3 years ago
I can only imagine what may have been on Prokofiev's mind when he wrote this. If there is one good thing that came from Stalin's tyranny it is the music written by Prokofiev, Shostakovich, and Khachaturian.
AbsoluteZ3R0 3 years ago
wow they so don't deserve him. What a Great Cellist- What a moronic Orchestra.
Mark91Gilenson 3 years ago 4
yeah they really don't. He just owns them
fiddlinmatt 3 years ago 2
His playing is beyond criticism
vegettogohan 3 years ago
everyone notices the orchestra haha. They're totally dead. Sometimes you can see that Rostropovich's not liking it haha
LyeraNY 3 years ago
Or that he's terrified the conductor's going to let it all fall apart....honestly I feel like there are parts where Rostropovich is conducting more than the conductor
goober8729 2 years ago 2
Man, the orchestra is terrible! And yet, to see Rostropovich performing this is a real treat. A superb rarity.
Hopfensperger 3 years ago 7
Yeah, I agree, the orchestra is pretty pathetic. Sadly, this is th only video I have ever found of the Prokofiev and the added bonus of Slava playing it makes it easier to ignore the orchestra.
rasputin1357 3 years ago
Maybe Rostropovich is friends with the manager or something
goober8729 2 years ago
The Orchestra of the Living Dead!
rasputin1357 1 year ago 2
@rasputin1357
2nd chair cellist ! left 4 dead :(
xXTiberiusXx 1 year ago
What orchestra is this, by the way?
cellocarrot 1 year ago
@cellocarrot The orchestra of the Living Dead from the Underworld.... XD
xbasket12x 1 year ago
@Hopfensperger What's wrong with the orchestra? they sound fine to me.
MrAjleask 3 months ago
@MrAjleask rofl
Hopfensperger 3 months ago
@Hopfensperger You can't think of anything wrong with the orchestra? didn't think so, maybe you shouldn't say their pathetic when in fact they play this piece quite good.
MrAjleask 3 months ago
@MrAjleask Listen to their tone on the first note.
Hopfensperger 3 months ago
@Hopfensperger So 1 note in the whole piece is bad? okay, they must be crap lol
MrAjleask 3 months ago
@MrAjleask You're a real genius.
Hopfensperger 3 months ago
Why have I never heard this performance before?!
Hopfensperger 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
cuz ur an idiot..... ^^; that dvd has shosti concerto no 1 on it and like extra stuff where he's playing with his wife... AWESOME dvd. go out and buy it. totally worth ur money.
joylee123 3 years ago