A more intensely personal version than some others, more a sense of desperation in a man who, even as he slips away, keeps being brought back by his need for the absolution he can never find. "...but they cursed me...I'm bound to wander..I'm bound away..."
As a 22-year old university student, I had a 70-man crew in a park in Saskatchewan. I was faced with directing these men against a forest fire that threatened our park when the "Super" was away.
Young, and scared shitless, I mustered the crew and equipment and took it on. As a team, with the help of locals, we stopped the fire before it took the park.
Never had the sad outcome of this song, but I often reflect.
I first heard this this past summer at my guard school, basic wildland firefight training. One of the guys on my crew played this song with us all just listening. It was the quietest I've heard heard any group of people. God bless Wag Dodge and those who fell.
I first heard this song on the Via train going from Toronto to Vancouver. We were going through Sioux Lookout (North-western Ontario). The man beside me gave me his iPod and told me that I had to listen to the song. I ended up listening to it several times and I've been in love with it ever since. This version is just beautiful.
Wow! This is one of my all time favorite songs. Keelaghan is incredible, and I love the Cry, Cry, Cry version, but this is equally breathtaking. What a voice. Thanks!
This is a very good job of doing the song. I heard the Richard Shindell version and fell in love and I almost always hate to hear my fav songs done by other people but you did the song justice.
VRAIMENT EXCELLENT.......VRAIMENT
jmpaustralie 11 months ago
john garza rules this cover....
i would love to hear a better quality recording of this
great voice
perfect guitar
i guess crycrycry is the holy grail for this song, but i'm not so sure
john lays it out to an afternoon empty house..... as though he were headlining SoundStage....
did i say great voice
and he conveys all the emotion, all the sadness of that tragic loss
crycrycry has that wonderful backup, that so ties in w/ the images
like to see/hear john garza w/ that edit
bofustjohnson 1 year ago
Terrrific version. Goose bumps.
themuse64 1 year ago
A more intensely personal version than some others, more a sense of desperation in a man who, even as he slips away, keeps being brought back by his need for the absolution he can never find. "...but they cursed me...I'm bound to wander..I'm bound away..."
EDMCD22 3 years ago
Nicely done.
-jcr
NSResponder 3 years ago
Love this song, by Canadian James Keelahgan.
As a 22-year old university student, I had a 70-man crew in a park in Saskatchewan. I was faced with directing these men against a forest fire that threatened our park when the "Super" was away.
Young, and scared shitless, I mustered the crew and equipment and took it on. As a team, with the help of locals, we stopped the fire before it took the park.
Never had the sad outcome of this song, but I often reflect.
This song has always "teared me up".
lgcrooks 3 years ago 4
I first heard this this past summer at my guard school, basic wildland firefight training. One of the guys on my crew played this song with us all just listening. It was the quietest I've heard heard any group of people. God bless Wag Dodge and those who fell.
kissellt 4 years ago
he does a great version
UbiDuboi 3 years ago
happened in the 40s? august 49?
UbiDuboi 4 years ago
amazing,thnx for sharing this record with us!
sebius1980 4 years ago
August of, what was it?--1949?
UbiDuboi 4 years ago 2
i love john garza
no one who is there is listening, but the professional plays, and does his best--for the likes of me i guess
UbiDuboi 4 years ago 4
Amen to that
OldStump 4 years ago 2
this a good song
and a better story
UbiDuboi 4 years ago 2
I first heard this song on the Via train going from Toronto to Vancouver. We were going through Sioux Lookout (North-western Ontario). The man beside me gave me his iPod and told me that I had to listen to the song. I ended up listening to it several times and I've been in love with it ever since. This version is just beautiful.
metalgod2347 4 years ago 3
Great, great performance, of the gigs I,ve been to this would be the performance we all would be taking about on the way home Well done
robindavies24 4 years ago
this is the most beautiful song, and he does the best version after the composer's.
UbiDubi1A 4 years ago
Wow! This is one of my all time favorite songs. Keelaghan is incredible, and I love the Cry, Cry, Cry version, but this is equally breathtaking. What a voice. Thanks!
jamaithan 4 years ago
This is a very good job of doing the song. I heard the Richard Shindell version and fell in love and I almost always hate to hear my fav songs done by other people but you did the song justice.
carsonsheir 4 years ago
I played first and people were just starting to show up. The plight of the Solo Musician at big concerts.
johnnygnote 4 years ago
John - very nicely done. Forget the audience. I could see that you were totally in the zone...Great ending!
adeefeinstein 4 years ago
why was there no audiance?
clwacdc 4 years ago
Great voice, and excellent performance of this song.
kkwycoff 4 years ago
Nice rendition. Not as good as the Cry,Cry,Cry version, but that's to be expected. Good performer.
rlpniew 4 years ago