Ma foi ,il ya du matériel! Il faut je pense densifier un peu les harmoniques afin qu'elles ne destructurent pas la voix;il faut agglomérer les résonances plus sur la poitrine que sur la gorge, celà éviterait les aigus qui blanchissent.La voix ne vient pas d'assez loin.J'en dit celà car il y a matière.J'espère une interrogation sur mes propos.Mitia.
Неужели вы не слышите, как много фальши. Голос перегружен! Зачем так орать в зале, в котором акустика, как в сауне! Поэтому и голос неподвижный, если певец больше думает о том, как ошеломить силой звука . Это пример неэффективного пения. А ведь школа пения это эффективность. Чем раньше певец это поймет, тем лучше. Как то в Ералаше один герой возмущался: – «Разве я пою тише Козловского!»
Although difficult to tell from a youtube video this young promising singer has got a very dark voice! Definitely not a baritone, not even a bass-baritone or a cantante. He might have had less "pressure" in his lower register and let the tones float out softer. He is young and needs more routine in handling his voice. This piece is very difficult and dramatic to sing! Lighter..yes! rounder..yes! More bel canto..yes!
@Yitzhakhazak Absolutely agree with you. He might have pushed through it a bit much. Not in tempo though, he added in quite a few fermate. Very nicely done, though I'm sure he'll sing it much better in a few years.
You have an amazing voice. However, you are not a Bass. You are a Baritone, your timbre is not set in tthat range and your tessitura is higher than that. No insult.
A WONDERFUL rendition! @highnote32: I wonder how you can hear what range is comfortable for him? I would advise you not to make such assumptions from a youtube video.
Bravissimo !! Wonderful open-throat low larnyx singing . .a lost art these days to the point where most people recognize it as foreign or dangerous! Stay the course. You definitely are on the right road.
This is exactly what we talked about recently.This is a wonderful instrument- rich and sonorous.Hope he can get from "here" to "there", but this is definately a voice to watch for in the future.Thanks for the alert Rick, and for posting Mastervlad.Best-Ben
I know very little about opera, but as a teenager from a rather culture-gridlocked area, I consider myself lucky to have found appreciation in this art. Thank you for allowing me the opportunity to hear such lovely singing. Best wishes!
fuck! 95% of the worlds top singers can just listen and learn! respect! for 23 yrs- unbeleivable! just take care at your instrument and don't let others ruin it!
Littlebit darker then it should be naturally, but this is the part of the slav singing-culture. I don't think it is a problem - just a "speciality". Powerful, bright voice. I hope we'll meet on stage soon :)
23? wow! Not sure where all the bad comments are coming from. You're a real bass (as am I). Big voice ARE different than light lyrics. Anyone thinking different is wrong. I hear nothing unhealthy. Actually you're amazing. You're on the right track. Better than 99% of basses working now! toi toi toi!
He has a timber indicating his bass voice repertory, he is singing following the right way of singing musicality, velvet power voice. He has a great future remaining with his voice teacher...Good luck... Don't care about negative critics!
This is fabulous singing, for any age. There is a little manufactured darkness, but no more than 99% of professionals. You have a very nice career ahead of you if you keep singing like this. Bravo.
You're absolutely right, and the voice is naturally very black anyway...actually I'd say the majority of professionals sing worst than that. Molodetz eto dectvitelno budet netcho v budushem!
I agree he is putting it on a bit, using the root of the tongue to get false space and bassiness, resulting in some flat notes and over-covering at the top. But what a fabulous talent! Needs to lighten up a bit, send him for a holiday on the Italian Riviera.
This guy does not have as deep a voice as he likes to think, listen carefully to the top and you can hear that if e didnt cover so much he would have a very free and good top.
I agree. His speaking voice at the beginnig is more suggestive of baritone. For 23, the voice is phenomenally sonorous and spacious, but he does cover a bit too much, hoping, I suspect, to sound deeper and more mature.
Are you really 23 years old? If so, wonderful singing and voice (very powerful as well), but do not imitate too much (do you like Nesterenko by any chance?). A bit more focus in your top notes, put some light (a bit over dark) in your voice and it would be perfect.
Seriously, typical ukrainian bass, I stop singing when listen to you. bravo
очень хороший голос! просто он еще очень молодой .
TheNattella 9 months ago
Ma foi ,il ya du matériel! Il faut je pense densifier un peu les harmoniques afin qu'elles ne destructurent pas la voix;il faut agglomérer les résonances plus sur la poitrine que sur la gorge, celà éviterait les aigus qui blanchissent.La voix ne vient pas d'assez loin.J'en dit celà car il y a matière.J'espère une interrogation sur mes propos.Mitia.
abracadabranque 1 year ago
Неужели вы не слышите, как много фальши. Голос перегружен! Зачем так орать в зале, в котором акустика, как в сауне! Поэтому и голос неподвижный, если певец больше думает о том, как ошеломить силой звука . Это пример неэффективного пения. А ведь школа пения это эффективность. Чем раньше певец это поймет, тем лучше. Как то в Ералаше один герой возмущался: – «Разве я пою тише Козловского!»
krespl 1 year ago
Ведь сами говорите, что весь табор спит! Хотите, чтобы все проснулись?
krespl 1 year ago
Absolutely bloody fantastic!!!!
Hasselfelde 1 year ago
Hey, you sound really great. Beautiful singing!
Prickler32 1 year ago
Although difficult to tell from a youtube video this young promising singer has got a very dark voice! Definitely not a baritone, not even a bass-baritone or a cantante. He might have had less "pressure" in his lower register and let the tones float out softer. He is young and needs more routine in handling his voice. This piece is very difficult and dramatic to sing! Lighter..yes! rounder..yes! More bel canto..yes!
Very well done especially at his age!
Yitzhakhazak 2 years ago
@Yitzhakhazak Absolutely agree with you. He might have pushed through it a bit much. Not in tempo though, he added in quite a few fermate. Very nicely done, though I'm sure he'll sing it much better in a few years.
BassoProfundo87 1 year ago
You have an amazing voice. However, you are not a Bass. You are a Baritone, your timbre is not set in tthat range and your tessitura is higher than that. No insult.
highnote32 2 years ago
A WONDERFUL rendition! @highnote32: I wonder how you can hear what range is comfortable for him? I would advise you not to make such assumptions from a youtube video.
BassoProfundo87 2 years ago
MY F%$?>"!ª GOD!!!!
rediscoverySX 2 years ago
Just wonderful ...great voice.
francotenor 2 years ago
Beautiful voice. Thank you.
vstasov 2 years ago
Даже танком не подвинуть такой темп...как не старалась концертмейстер - не вышло. Голос потрясный.
HomerSBaritone 2 years ago
Без ложной лести хочу отметить, что дикция сейчас стала гораздо лучше, чем была в 2007 г.Так держать!
magdapiglet 2 years ago
I do with that more modern singers were basses, I love the tone of them, and I am a bass myself, so i respect anyone who has the lower voice.
AtemiRaven 3 years ago
I love it! Finally a bass that gets it. You remind me so much of Cesare Siepi. Congrats. Don't let any one screw you up.
redsox2213 3 years ago 4
прекрасный!! What a great future you will have! All the best to you, приятель.
cantante189 3 years ago
Bravissimo !! Wonderful open-throat low larnyx singing . .a lost art these days to the point where most people recognize it as foreign or dangerous! Stay the course. You definitely are on the right road.
2ManyHighCs 3 years ago
This is exactly what we talked about recently.This is a wonderful instrument- rich and sonorous.Hope he can get from "here" to "there", but this is definately a voice to watch for in the future.Thanks for the alert Rick, and for posting Mastervlad.Best-Ben
vickersman 3 years ago
Agree!!!!! GOOD Technique!!!!!
francotenor 2 years ago
Very fine musician. I would have enjoyed hearing the "postlude" on the piano. Does anyone know where I can get a translation of this song?
jeanhenley 3 years ago
Suprisingly strong voice for such a young and.. well, normal sized man!
Tyhjis1988 3 years ago
Man... great voice and technique!! In bocca al lupo for all!
aleiv 3 years ago
who's that guy?!?!!??!?!Incredable!!!!!
datzi4ka 3 years ago
I know very little about opera, but as a teenager from a rather culture-gridlocked area, I consider myself lucky to have found appreciation in this art. Thank you for allowing me the opportunity to hear such lovely singing. Best wishes!
ardelle91 3 years ago
fuck! 95% of the worlds top singers can just listen and learn! respect! for 23 yrs- unbeleivable! just take care at your instrument and don't let others ruin it!
baritenor81 3 years ago
what makes slav singing dark?
nero93747 3 years ago
Littlebit darker then it should be naturally, but this is the part of the slav singing-culture. I don't think it is a problem - just a "speciality". Powerful, bright voice. I hope we'll meet on stage soon :)
golaxo 4 years ago
great man! you should be on the world's most famous stages right now!
jccq 4 years ago
Big and beautiful voice. The Young bass. Want to listen such voice on the best scene of the world opera. The Whole best.
STRROM 4 years ago
Bravo! Truly beautiful voice.
battletor4 4 years ago
23? wow! Not sure where all the bad comments are coming from. You're a real bass (as am I). Big voice ARE different than light lyrics. Anyone thinking different is wrong. I hear nothing unhealthy. Actually you're amazing. You're on the right track. Better than 99% of basses working now! toi toi toi!
jdeslauriers 4 years ago
He has a timber indicating his bass voice repertory, he is singing following the right way of singing musicality, velvet power voice. He has a great future remaining with his voice teacher...Good luck... Don't care about negative critics!
mornaymariedomini 4 years ago
You sing really good man, don't listen to those bullshit comments (the tongue, lighter ...blah blah blah) eto vce tshipukha....
dustmondo45 4 years ago
This is fabulous singing, for any age. There is a little manufactured darkness, but no more than 99% of professionals. You have a very nice career ahead of you if you keep singing like this. Bravo.
Blackfish1 4 years ago
You're absolutely right, and the voice is naturally very black anyway...actually I'd say the majority of professionals sing worst than that. Molodetz eto dectvitelno budet netcho v budushem!
dustmondo45 4 years ago
I agree he is putting it on a bit, using the root of the tongue to get false space and bassiness, resulting in some flat notes and over-covering at the top. But what a fabulous talent! Needs to lighten up a bit, send him for a holiday on the Italian Riviera.
sorbino9 4 years ago
Perfect analysis! I wish I had written this.
seancoxen 4 years ago
increible, fabuloso, sobre todo considerando la edad! felicidades y mucha suerte!!!
phalcoboenus 4 years ago
hse ok
pavelkostov 4 years ago
Heartwrenching...
manossg 4 years ago
This guy does not have as deep a voice as he likes to think, listen carefully to the top and you can hear that if e didnt cover so much he would have a very free and good top.
fattenor 4 years ago
I agree. His speaking voice at the beginnig is more suggestive of baritone. For 23, the voice is phenomenally sonorous and spacious, but he does cover a bit too much, hoping, I suspect, to sound deeper and more mature.
seancoxen 4 years ago
Very nice voice, however a little overcovered, especially on the top. Wish you the best of luck in the future.
fattenor 4 years ago
you should never ever sing with the piano lid down... ever...
brendanemig 4 years ago
A beast!!! Awesome!
joshmills04music 4 years ago
A very rich coloured voice fantastic for 23 years old!
stchoukine 4 years ago
Are you really 23 years old? If so, wonderful singing and voice (very powerful as well), but do not imitate too much (do you like Nesterenko by any chance?). A bit more focus in your top notes, put some light (a bit over dark) in your voice and it would be perfect.
Seriously, typical ukrainian bass, I stop singing when listen to you. bravo
ledonciccio 4 years ago