The American Historical Review, among the oldest and most prestigious academic journals in the United States, has condemned Service’s biography of Trotsky, saying that it "fails to meet the basic standards of historical scholarship". The review has explicitly endorsed the critique of Service's book by David North, the chairman of both the Socialist Equality Party in the United States and the international editorial board of the World Socialist Web Site.
You are talking about bolcheviks, but you maybe don't know they were destructing Russia, half of them were German and Austrian spies who wanted do separate Russia in many parts. And if Trotsky have had the power instead of Stalin, it would all be over now, no more Russia as we know. So Trotsky was a treator, spy. BTW, please go an read on wikipedia what nationality was he, and you will understand...
@MrZammmorak That makes no sense what so ever, stalin also wasn't born in part of Russia as we know it today either(born in Georgia). Also Trotsky was born in Ukraine not Austria or Germany. And at the time both countries were part of Russia
@MrZammmorak dude you're such a politically incorrect moron. It angers me that you fucking Stalinists even attempt to link Marxism in any of your ilk, if you would all fuck off then we'd be socialist by now.
@HavidDagstrom Rather no then yes. Sad to say, but Stalin, due to the odiosity of his figure, is quiet popular by internet freaks of all kinds, in post-soviet Russia. IN internet, there are quiet a few of them, now even mcuh more then actual communists, but this is beacuse the Rusisan internet is as much as dead now (not even 10% of the activity back 2005-2007) - when not including social networks, which live and develop.
@acb1511 IRL only one guy on a commun. "funny quotes/; site - red-bash.ru - pretends to have seen 4 such freaks on a demonstraton - a so-called "Russian United Monarchist Stalinist Movement" (thes semm to be all of them), but he didn;t manage to talk to them. But ther spamming scales in the internet can amaze one.
You are talking about bolcheviks, but you maybe don't know they were destructing Russia, half of them were German and Austrian spies who wanted do separate Russia in many parts. And if Trotsky have had the power instead of Stalin, it would all be over now, no more Russia as we know. So Trotsky was a treator, spy. BTW, please go an read on wikipedia from what nationality was he, and you will understand...
Alexander Robinowitschs Book "The Sowjetpower the first year" are now published in German and will present by him in Berlin in the Humboldt University on the 14. of October 2010. More: world socialist web site
Alexander Robinowitschs Book "The Sowjetpower the first year" are now published in German and will present by him in Berlin in the Humboldt University on the 14. of October 2010. More: world socialis web site
Agreement﹝with the Mensheviks﹞? I cannot even speak seriously about that. Trotsky has long ago said that unity is impossible. Trotsky understood this and since then there has been no better Bolshevik. V.I.Lenin (Lenins speech at the session of the Petrograd Committee, 1917, Nov. 1st)
comrades lets get this into the right grove, Comrade Stalin bound the S.U. together for the oncoming fight with fascism/capitalism 22.6.41. Comrade Troksky ,who was a great man , wanted world revolution which was not on the cards at that time. The time is now ripe to carry out Comrade Trotskys polices. Remember it was number one policy to strenghen the S.U. to fight the Nazis in the oncoming war!All that the Ribbentrop / Molotov Pact was just to gain time.
don't worry, Trotsky's world revolution will take place in short time and most unexpectedly it will be generated by the big multinational corporations.
Death to Stalinism! For our communist movement in the 21st century!Extinguish Stalinism! Extinguish Red Fascism! Long live Proretarian Internationalism, Workers of the world unite!
Anti-Stalinism! Anti-Capitalism! Long live Humanism and Democracy! Long live comrade Trotsky!
Trotzki, is Lev Davidovich Bronshtein, who was a Jew, Zionist Jew, who rub Russia after revolution, executet milions of Russians, (not Stalin), he was financed by American Jewish Bank. And Stalin put on end of all his plans. Trotzky (BRONSHTEIN) executet purly Russians, destroy and rub Ortodox Churches.
Brainwashed people here who never read hisory books, SHOULD watch video COPY: Сталин. Разгром пятой колонны. Часть 1/4
It ois difficult to understand following maxime 32's "reasoning" why Trotsky ended up exiled in Mexico, one of the very few places that received him, and not in New York then. There is no picture of Trotsky pacting with Churchill and Roosevelt the division of europe whcih implied preventing revoution from extending West. A great "service2 to capitalism, and the betaryal of revolution.
Stalinists like maxime32 explain why Socialism has got such a bad name. Trotsky always condemned terrorism on political grounds, in several books, and talking about "adventures in Poland" is a typical stalinist slander, on which farces like the Moscow Trials wre based, in which even Stalin's old accomplices were eliminated. Lenin and Trotsky put unity first instead of fighting Stalin's deviations, but Stalin had no problem risking revolution to satisfy his ambitions of power.
Trotsky was banished not by Stalin, but by the Party, for extremism. Any "mistakes" Stalin is accused of by Western bourgeois historians Trotsky favoured with twice the vehemence. He openly defended "terrorism". He launched military adventures in Poland. He was funded by rich foreigners from NYC and tried to return to them when he was kicked out.
In fact, only bourgeois historians and anarchist kids like Trotsky. I lived in Russia for 2 years and never heard the bastard's name mentioned.
@maxime32 Trotsky's name was "forgotten" in the USSR by stalinists so they could carry out their infamous "deed", the destruction of the USSR and the restoration of capitalism, consequences of Stalin's cheap pseudo-theories and his choice to favor personal privileges above those of the working class. His agreements with nazis like Molotov-Ribbentrop pact, and purging the Red Army to silence criticism put the USSR at risk by nazi attack. The stalinist bureaucrats are now millionaires.
maxime32: You should hurry and grab a book on composition and then another book or two on Soviet history, a bit of Marxism might help too. Your words are quasi unintelligible, but understandable enough to reveal you have no clue what you are talking about.
Stalin know how to do world revolution and build New World Comunist Order, but Trotsky, Zinoviev, Kamenev, Buharin was just pawns who do revolution in Russia, they masters Rotsheilds kill them like unnecessary witnesses when they do job. Stalin was real Rotsheilds New World Order leader, he know how to destroy Europe and build one big USSR in whole world.
Jacquinot1982: Well, judging by the results, Stalin preferred just to concoct pseudo-theories like "socialism in one country" and pact with capitalism to stay in power . He trampled on revolutionary moral or scruples with the same ease he physically eliminated opponents. That was his real "virtue", and he thus sacrificed the USSR to his ego.
The "socialism in one country" debate is BS. Trotsky was not massively different in practice.
The Trotskyites were some of the wackos who were looked down on peasants and religious people more than anyone. They wanted to collectivise faster and burn more churches. The NKVD purges of Stalin ended after he purged the NKVD. It would have been worse under Trotsky.
@maxime32 You should first grab a book on composition or something, and then, study some Soviet history as well. A bit of Marxism would maybe help, too. Your words are quasi unintelligible, but understandable enough to reveal you have no clue what you are talking about.
@maxime32 You should hurry and grab a book on composition, and then another book or two on Soviet history, a bit of Marxism might help too. Your words are quasi unintelligible, but understandable enough to reveal you have no clue what you are talking about.
Only one problem with your idiotic idea. Why would world banking capitalists like the Rothschilds finance an anti-capitalist revolution? Think of the logic of what you just said.
I think a lot of right-wingers mistake the foreign funding of the Revolution for the Germans' benefit (to end the Eastern Front) for capitalist endorsement. Anyway, the anti-NWO Right thinking is that tsarist Russia resisted the debt-money system we have with the Fed Reserve and Britain has. So they overthrew it with something they could directly control. Of course, it is wrong because they did not directly control the USSR they tried to attack it in the early years.
And Trotsky would be angy at youtube for giving in to every copyright claim any obscure company makes to remove all worthfull historical and cultural movies from its website.
Ace424,you are an idiot! While Trotsky was a Jew, he was definitely anti-Zionist and far more loyal to Lenin than Stalin who murdered every single of Lenins co-revolutionaries later on. Trotzky even insisted on the violent persecution of capitalist and zionist fellow Jews. And you seem to have forgotten that Lenins testament called for Stalin to be removed from power. Lenins wife also indicated that Lenin would have prefered Trotzki over anyone else as his successor.
Vilarum. Why are you interested in idealizing Trotsky? Isn't it time to take into account historic evidence instead of propaganda materia? His tragic end in the same way as Nicholas II killing made them martyrs. His efforts in USSR till 1925 leave no doubt that if in power he would have sent to death as many millions as Hitler,Stalin,Pol Pott,Mao etc.
Stalin made it a principle of his reign to send at least as many innocents to the Gulags, firing squads,etc. as guilty persons - so that anyone, guilty or not, would be intimidated by his rule. Nicholas II was offered to leave the country, but neither Britain nor any other nation would offer asylum. He was only shot dead about a year after his defrocking, when he was to be freed by approaching White Russians, which would have meant a prolonged civil war with millions additional victims.
Regarding Trotzky, he was advocating international support of communist revolutions, while Stalin was concentrating all ressources on what he called socialism in one country. Trotzky even in 1933 advocated violent opposition against fascism - up to july 1933 when their huge weapons stockpiles were discovered the german communists were ready to counter-coup, but Stalin refused to agree to this. Also, only due to his paranoia, Stalin refused to even acknowledge the Germans had attacked for 7 days
I must still add that Trotzky was at the front when the 1927 revolution happened while Stalin was drinking tea with some friends, telling Georgian jokes. In the Polish campaign of 1920/21 Stalin,when he was a political commisar disobeyed a direct order from Lenin, and instead of reinforcing the main battle line attacked the city of Lemberg, thus spoiling the entire campaign,which ended in defeat and made it impossible for the USSR to support,f.ex. the succesful,but besieged Bavarian revolution
@Reghedable All major communist supporters are/were atheists. ie: Marx, Lenin, Stalin, Trotsky, Mao, etc. Marxism is itself atheistic and strictly anti-religious, as religion was a tool used to subdue and control the working class.
Just because someone is a Jew does not make him a Semitic, just because someone is Christian does not make him white. Arabs are Semites too as well as Assyrians, Ethiopians, etc. That's something most people tend to ignore. Not all Russian Jews were/are Semitic and Trotsky was not a Jew nor was he a Hebrew therefore that does not make him a Semite.
Noooooooooo, Trotsky was not a Semite. Semites come from the Middle East and have darker skin. Trotsky was no more Semitic than Shimon Peres, which means not at all!
Communism only banned religion to have no competition beïng themselves considered as God on earth.
Biblical theory of the "fallen angels" who wanted to put themselves on Gods throne.
BTW. Not only communists do that, every other political fraction does the same thing.
Maybe thats because people miss the presence of God on earth. So every now and then people want to fill in a vacuum that cannot be filled and they hurl themselves into the raveen.
Stalin was a homosexual devil, not only did he kill everyone from the Old Bolsheviks who helped with the Revolution, while Stalin was out doing Mickie Mouse Bank Robberies with his midget ass, He also killed the families of the Old Bolsheviks because he was a paranoid son of a bitch. Stalin was the Devil in disguise.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Real name of Trotsky - Leibo Bronshteyn. He wanted to make the world revolution, and seize global power. Trotsky / Bronstein - is the most hated historical figure in Russia, a U.S. citizen, Jew-Zionist. Only thanks to Stalin managed to keep this monster from the accomplishments of the great evil.
Of course Jewish culture like any other has its weak sides but its a fact the birth of the Soviet Union was mainly organised and promoted by people of Jewish origin.
Ethnicity cannot be chosen and therefore it cannot be used for judgement (although the nazis and orthodox jews as everyone else do).
Culture can be chosen, not without taking difficult obstacles sometimes, but culture is mans creation and therefore its subject to judgement.
Only a Jewish intelectual sensitive genius could create an army in no time out of nothing to be victorious over 14 of the worlds best, experienced, well commanded armies.
The conflict between Trotsky and Stalin was the conflict between ideology and lust of power. Lust of power won, the proletarian revolution lost. Communism became tool for leaders of lust of power in Russia, China, North Korea, Vietnam, Cuba. Leaders of thease countries don't serve working class.
The modern communist are blinded by the views that Trotsky was a great man that wanted to give the workers control when in fact this is blatantly untrue as he helped create the all powerful bureaucracy that only the Bolsheviks had a say in. Furthermore he murdered thousands who opposed him and these aren't merely bourgeois but also thousands of leftist revolutionaries, even though the Bolsheviks claimed to have abolished the death penalty.
The most fearsome example of this kind is Russia where he (Jewry) allowed 39 million humans in truly fanatical wildness to die or starve in inhuman agony, in order to secure the mastery of a great people for a gang of Jewish literati and stock exchange bandits.
The result is not only the end of freedom for the people oppressed by the Jews, but rather also the end of these parasites of the peoples themselves. After the death of the victim, the vampire dies sooner or later.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
I am racist because I know some races are genetically superior than others. Jews are the sickly pigs. Trotsky achieved nothing. Communism was commenced by jew-bolsheviks, but enhanced entirely by Russians. I am supporter of White Army, Soviet Union and Monarchy. Communism in some aspects. You are a faker pro-capitalist rat.
In a December 1, 1952 Politburo session, Stalin announced: "Every Jewish nationalist is a potential agent of the American intelligence. Jewish nationalists think that their nation was saved by the USA."
The night of August 12-13, 1952, in the event known as the Night of the Murdered Poets (Ночь казнённых поэтов), thirteen of the most prominent Yiddish writers of the Soviet Union were executed on the orders of Stalin.
Stalin killed over 1 million jews and efectivly exiles mosto f them from the soviet union... you are a dumb ass, stalin was a georgian orthodox christan, in his early years he was studing to be a priest
Right, and hitler killed over ten million, and stalin didn't really hate jews, he killed anyone who stood in this way, a lot of them happened to be jews.
Trotsky could have saved democracy in the USSr after lenin died. He could have done all that stalin did to modernize the country, but given the workers control of the means of production. I stand against the Stalinist because they give communism a bad name. Trotsky and Marx are in the same league.
1Mehring1 it seems you an imbecil. Comander Chavez follow trosqui but is MUCH mor epwerful. Alll will bow before the iron fist of Bolivarian Comunism!!! Jajajajaja!!!!
Chaves no tiene nada que ver con Trotsky, Marxismo o la revolucion socialista. Es pura nacionalista tan fascista como socialista, a la izquierda hoy, a la derecha manyana. Paquetero que es, usa los pobres para mantener su proprio poder ed el poder de su classe que no es trabajador, en contra de los de su classe que aceptan segundo puesto a los Estados Unidos. Ud no ha aprendido nada de la historia y los mismos errores se repiten hasta que se aprenden.
1Mehring1 traidor estas con Rosales, Bush y la CIA. Has brincado la talanquera. Eres fascista imperialista oligarca de la caurta republica. No sabes nada de historia. El primer comunista fue Jesucristo, leugo viene Bolivar, Marx y Engels, Trosqui, Lenin, Stalin y Mao y el Comandante Chavez. No sabes nada? Ignorante.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Goddamn you ugly Jewish monster fuckers! Long live the Soviet Union, white Russia and and true white people. Fuck the sand monkeys! They are all evil, always got their hands in your poor pockets, take your 20 dollar bills and leave you with pennies! Yeah wake up and fight the Jewish conspiracy take over of the world. Jewish control is out of control, give the power back to the people and the true power rests in them. Fuck the stupid Jewish monkey wanna bes.
This comment has received too many negative votesshow
Trotsky, rest in hell you piece of mother fucking shit. Trotsky was commander of the 666th Lightly Army Peasant Battalion, equiped with stones, sling shots and about 10 guns for 1000 soldiers LOL. Yeah thats right, Trotsky's army was shit, but when Stalin too over, it was glory! Fuck Jewish Trotsky and fuck Israel. You corrupted sand niggers are going to hell. Fuck you too Jew bitches! You eat monkey and hairy Jewish man's assholes. Fuck you again! Trotsky, rest in hell bitch!
I think the wannabe Marxists around here ought to get off the cult of the personality trip and head down to the Marxist Internet Archive and do some serious, sustained STUDY for starters. Ever heard of SCIENTIFIC SOCIALISM? It's not hero worship or idolitory. It's hard theoretical and practical work and for Trotsky's life to have any meaning today, YOU have to do that work.
What's this nonsence clip? It's indulging in a personality cult about someone who had more than his fair share of hair.
You people need to get into the real world. You talk to present day workers about all that stuff and they'll rightly laugh at you. I usually find these people to be wimpish types. When at work they tend to be scared of the bosses and fellow workers, who usually take the piss out of them. It's the kind of crap normal people grow out of when life realities need to be faced.
Remember. In 1917, in Russia, the sentence "Workers of all coutry, unites !" was not writen only in Russian or english. On the flags of the revolutionnary, it was writen in all the languages : "Prolétaires de tous pays, unissez-vous !" - "Proletari di tutti i paesi, unitevi !" etc...
The true is that you merge internationalism and imperialism, dear friend.
Me, I think that the existence of different language on earth is a wealth.
You ask me why you should speak another language. It is true. I can't ask you to speak french. Your and American, you speak english. I respect your culture.
But me, I am French. I speak French. So why I am speaking english here ? Because your language is imperialist now, and because Americans dosen't respect the orther cultures of the world.
What's so disgusting about Trotsky? He's a human being like you and me. And he's a socialist revolutionary. He also was against Stalin and was one of the few communists to urge a united front with other socialist parties against fascism. You're not a Stalinist, are you?
Communists hate Trotky because he was an objective ally of the bourgeoisie during all his life.
For example, in 1940, he said that the people Russian had to destroy USSR, while the Nazis were going to pervade the country... Because of that, in France we say about the trotkist that they are: "hitlero-trotkistes" (objective ally of the nazis...)
Stalinism, which main GOAL in the early USSR was to build socialism in other countries, which would inspire other nations to revolt against the capitalists. While Trotsky argued, like Lenin, that a permanent revolution is the only way.
On the contrary, Trotsky was a committed Marxist and he didn't urge the destruction of the Soviet Union; he urged the overthrow of Stalinism, which, he argued, had betrayed everything Lenin had worked for. Trotsky was both anti-Hitler and anti-Stalin. It was Trotsky who urged a united front against fascism, while most other communists followed Stalin's line.
And after the war, during all the second part of the 20 century, the trotkists was very useful for the capitalism, they was useful for breaking revolutions.
In western countries and in France, they recieved money from the CIA, for breaking the real communist party... And now, former trotkists govern with the capitalist without any problems. (in the french governement today, they are a lot of former trotkists...)
First statement completely irrelevant. Fighting for a legitimate democratic revolution and trying to save it from a Czarist spy, nationalist pigs or the SR's is fighting for the continuity of the revolution not 'breaking' it.
I suppose you think a Marxist-Leninist organization has never been founded or infiltrated by government agencies? Try writing a sentence correctly than maybe you inaccuracies would be believable.
HAHAHAHAH You are suggesting the French weren't/aren't Imperialist? What a joke. I actually am Cajun(French ancestry) and Scottish. My family history has been constantly running from and fighting imperialist movements. But indeed I do speak this imperialist language so well why should I try speak another imperialist language?
Of course in history, french language was imperialist. But today, it is the english language wich is imperialist, not the french...
I think that you can't imagine what it is for a french, a german or an italian to see all the time things written in english. On advertising, on the products that we buy, on movies, on internet...
Trotsky as commander of the 888th peasants battalion, equiped with pitch forks, butcher knives and baseball bats and just ONE gun. Guess who has it? Trotsky of course LOL. Makes for one fucking stupid battalion LOL.
This pigshit got what he deserved for murdering millions as Stalin got his own share - he was assasinnated in 1953
anaspapas 2 weeks ago
Viva Trotsky, saludos desde Chile compañer@s!
hernancillo7 4 months ago
Trotsky was a treu heroe unlike that nazbol facist stalin!!!!
(A) /// (E)
crusty4lyfe 6 months ago
@Bl4ckR0ck a military genius that never served time in the military. His military campaign in Poland ended in a debacle.
Svarog1969 6 months ago
Scum, scum, scum!
Svarog1969 6 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
The American Historical Review, among the oldest and most prestigious academic journals in the United States, has condemned Service’s biography of Trotsky, saying that it "fails to meet the basic standards of historical scholarship". The review has explicitly endorsed the critique of Service's book by David North, the chairman of both the Socialist Equality Party in the United States and the international editorial board of the World Socialist Web Site.
robharris38 8 months ago
Long live Trotsky and Lenin!
HavidDagstrom 8 months ago
Trotsky is killer.
rodoslav10 9 months ago
great song !
envanje 10 months ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Long live hero L.D.B.Trotsky, founder and first commander of the magnificent Red Army,who fall as a victim of Stalinist evil .
nedeljko18 10 months ago
жыдёнок!
BORODA2386 11 months ago
The best organiser wins the war.
envanje 11 months ago
Respect to Lev Trotsky from Peru.
victormanueification 1 year ago
You are talking about bolcheviks, but you maybe don't know they were destructing Russia, half of them were German and Austrian spies who wanted do separate Russia in many parts. And if Trotsky have had the power instead of Stalin, it would all be over now, no more Russia as we know. So Trotsky was a treator, spy. BTW, please go an read on wikipedia what nationality was he, and you will understand...
MrZammmorak 1 year ago
@MrZammmorak Get the fuck outta here you anti-semitic piece of shit. You deserve a death akin to that of Tsar NIcholas II.
macnajee 11 months ago
@MrZammmorak That makes no sense what so ever, stalin also wasn't born in part of Russia as we know it today either(born in Georgia). Also Trotsky was born in Ukraine not Austria or Germany. And at the time both countries were part of Russia
1213141516171819177 10 months ago
@MrZammmorak dude you're such a politically incorrect moron. It angers me that you fucking Stalinists even attempt to link Marxism in any of your ilk, if you would all fuck off then we'd be socialist by now.
HavidDagstrom 8 months ago 2
@HavidDagstrom I think, he is a fascist)))
talk to me.
acb1511 1 week ago
@acb1511 I think he's a troll.
HavidDagstrom 4 days ago
@HavidDagstrom Rather no then yes. Sad to say, but Stalin, due to the odiosity of his figure, is quiet popular by internet freaks of all kinds, in post-soviet Russia. IN internet, there are quiet a few of them, now even mcuh more then actual communists, but this is beacuse the Rusisan internet is as much as dead now (not even 10% of the activity back 2005-2007) - when not including social networks, which live and develop.
acb1511 4 days ago
@acb1511 IRL only one guy on a commun. "funny quotes/; site - red-bash.ru - pretends to have seen 4 such freaks on a demonstraton - a so-called "Russian United Monarchist Stalinist Movement" (thes semm to be all of them), but he didn;t manage to talk to them. But ther spamming scales in the internet can amaze one.
acb1511 4 days ago
You are talking about bolcheviks, but you maybe don't know they were destructing Russia, half of them were German and Austrian spies who wanted do separate Russia in many parts. And if Trotsky have had the power instead of Stalin, it would all be over now, no more Russia as we know. So Trotsky was a treator, spy. BTW, please go an read on wikipedia from what nationality was he, and you will understand...
MrZammmorak 1 year ago
Trotsky abu. Fuck stalin.
celticrossa 1 year ago
Orthodox Marxism :)
nietzscheprime 1 year ago
Where did you get all of the pictures? I'm doing a project on Trotsky, so please?
BigPJC07 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Real name: Lev Bronstein :)
karlkarlkarl1234 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Alexander Robinowitschs Book "The Sowjetpower the first year" are now published in German and will present by him in Berlin in the Humboldt University on the 14. of October 2010. More: world socialist web site
FranzSchobert00 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Alexander Robinowitschs Book "The Sowjetpower the first year" are now published in German and will present by him in Berlin in the Humboldt University on the 14. of October 2010. More: world socialis web site
FranzSchobert00 1 year ago
¡Sigamos el ejemplo de los camaradas Lenin y Trotsky!
CuartaInternacional 1 year ago
Agreement﹝with the Mensheviks﹞? I cannot even speak seriously about that. Trotsky has long ago said that unity is impossible. Trotsky understood this and since then there has been no better Bolshevik. V.I.Lenin (Lenins speech at the session of the Petrograd Committee, 1917, Nov. 1st)
ryota1917 1 year ago
comrades lets get this into the right grove, Comrade Stalin bound the S.U. together for the oncoming fight with fascism/capitalism 22.6.41. Comrade Troksky ,who was a great man , wanted world revolution which was not on the cards at that time. The time is now ripe to carry out Comrade Trotskys polices. Remember it was number one policy to strenghen the S.U. to fight the Nazis in the oncoming war!All that the Ribbentrop / Molotov Pact was just to gain time.
yezhov1 1 year ago
@yezhov1
don't worry, Trotsky's world revolution will take place in short time and most unexpectedly it will be generated by the big multinational corporations.
envanje 1 year ago
Death to Stalinism! For our communist movement in the 21st century!Extinguish Stalinism! Extinguish Red Fascism! Long live Proretarian Internationalism, Workers of the world unite!
Anti-Stalinism! Anti-Capitalism! Long live Humanism and Democracy! Long live comrade Trotsky!
ryota1917 1 year ago 7
Brainwashed people here who never read hisory books, SHOULD watch video COPY: Сталин. Разгром пятой колонны. Часть 1/4
Сталин. Разгром пятой колонны. Часть 2/4
Сталин. Разгром пятой колонны. Часть 3/4
Сталин. Разгром пятой колонны. Часть 4/4
mikeplay007 1 year ago
This has been flagged as spam show
Trotzki, is Lev Davidovich Bronshtein, who was a Jew, Zionist Jew, who rub Russia after revolution, executet milions of Russians, (not Stalin), he was financed by American Jewish Bank. And Stalin put on end of all his plans. Trotzky (BRONSHTEIN) executet purly Russians, destroy and rub Ortodox Churches.
Brainwashed people here who never read hisory books, SHOULD watch video COPY: Сталин. Разгром пятой колонны. Часть 1/4
mikeplay007 1 year ago
Honor and glory for L.D.B.Trotsky first commander and founder of the Rea Army !
nedeljko18 1 year ago
viva trotsky!
moucho34 1 year ago
It ois difficult to understand following maxime 32's "reasoning" why Trotsky ended up exiled in Mexico, one of the very few places that received him, and not in New York then. There is no picture of Trotsky pacting with Churchill and Roosevelt the division of europe whcih implied preventing revoution from extending West. A great "service2 to capitalism, and the betaryal of revolution.
levdbronstein 1 year ago
Stalinists like maxime32 explain why Socialism has got such a bad name. Trotsky always condemned terrorism on political grounds, in several books, and talking about "adventures in Poland" is a typical stalinist slander, on which farces like the Moscow Trials wre based, in which even Stalin's old accomplices were eliminated. Lenin and Trotsky put unity first instead of fighting Stalin's deviations, but Stalin had no problem risking revolution to satisfy his ambitions of power.
levdbronstein 1 year ago 2
Trotsky was banished not by Stalin, but by the Party, for extremism. Any "mistakes" Stalin is accused of by Western bourgeois historians Trotsky favoured with twice the vehemence. He openly defended "terrorism". He launched military adventures in Poland. He was funded by rich foreigners from NYC and tried to return to them when he was kicked out.
In fact, only bourgeois historians and anarchist kids like Trotsky. I lived in Russia for 2 years and never heard the bastard's name mentioned.
maxime32 1 year ago
@maxime32 Trotsky's name was "forgotten" in the USSR by stalinists so they could carry out their infamous "deed", the destruction of the USSR and the restoration of capitalism, consequences of Stalin's cheap pseudo-theories and his choice to favor personal privileges above those of the working class. His agreements with nazis like Molotov-Ribbentrop pact, and purging the Red Army to silence criticism put the USSR at risk by nazi attack. The stalinist bureaucrats are now millionaires.
levdbronstein 1 year ago
maxime32: You should hurry and grab a book on composition and then another book or two on Soviet history, a bit of Marxism might help too. Your words are quasi unintelligible, but understandable enough to reveal you have no clue what you are talking about.
levdbronstein 1 year ago
Great man of great integrity.
TheRightRein 2 years ago
Троцкий был еврейский мудак
BelayaArmiyaForever 2 years ago
Stalin know how to do world revolution and build New World Comunist Order, but Trotsky, Zinoviev, Kamenev, Buharin was just pawns who do revolution in Russia, they masters Rotsheilds kill them like unnecessary witnesses when they do job. Stalin was real Rotsheilds New World Order leader, he know how to destroy Europe and build one big USSR in whole world.
Jacquinot1982 2 years ago
@Jacquinot1982 Learn how to type. Your grammar is atrocious...
DevoutSkeptic 2 years ago
Jacquinot1982: Well, judging by the results, Stalin preferred just to concoct pseudo-theories like "socialism in one country" and pact with capitalism to stay in power . He trampled on revolutionary moral or scruples with the same ease he physically eliminated opponents. That was his real "virtue", and he thus sacrificed the USSR to his ego.
levdbronstein 2 years ago 3
The "socialism in one country" debate is BS. Trotsky was not massively different in practice.
The Trotskyites were some of the wackos who were looked down on peasants and religious people more than anyone. They wanted to collectivise faster and burn more churches. The NKVD purges of Stalin ended after he purged the NKVD. It would have been worse under Trotsky.
maxime32 1 year ago
@maxime32 You should first grab a book on composition or something, and then, study some Soviet history as well. A bit of Marxism would maybe help, too. Your words are quasi unintelligible, but understandable enough to reveal you have no clue what you are talking about.
levdbronstein 1 year ago
@maxime32 You should hurry and grab a book on composition, and then another book or two on Soviet history, a bit of Marxism might help too. Your words are quasi unintelligible, but understandable enough to reveal you have no clue what you are talking about.
levdbronstein 1 year ago
cool story bro.
Only one problem with your idiotic idea. Why would world banking capitalists like the Rothschilds finance an anti-capitalist revolution? Think of the logic of what you just said.
commissarusa 1 year ago
@commissarusa
Because their object its NWO, capitalism its just folding screen
Jacquinot1982 1 year ago
I think a lot of right-wingers mistake the foreign funding of the Revolution for the Germans' benefit (to end the Eastern Front) for capitalist endorsement. Anyway, the anti-NWO Right thinking is that tsarist Russia resisted the debt-money system we have with the Fed Reserve and Britain has. So they overthrew it with something they could directly control. Of course, it is wrong because they did not directly control the USSR they tried to attack it in the early years.
maxime32 1 year ago
And Trotsky would be angy at youtube for giving in to every copyright claim any obscure company makes to remove all worthfull historical and cultural movies from its website.
envanje 2 years ago
Trotsky would be proud on Youtube beïng able to assemble such a big international crowd.
envanje 2 years ago 2
haha
but to his horror significant less than Stalin does
plonsdrums 2 years ago
Ace424,you are an idiot! While Trotsky was a Jew, he was definitely anti-Zionist and far more loyal to Lenin than Stalin who murdered every single of Lenins co-revolutionaries later on. Trotzky even insisted on the violent persecution of capitalist and zionist fellow Jews. And you seem to have forgotten that Lenins testament called for Stalin to be removed from power. Lenins wife also indicated that Lenin would have prefered Trotzki over anyone else as his successor.
Vilarum 2 years ago 3
Vilarum. Why are you interested in idealizing Trotsky? Isn't it time to take into account historic evidence instead of propaganda materia? His tragic end in the same way as Nicholas II killing made them martyrs. His efforts in USSR till 1925 leave no doubt that if in power he would have sent to death as many millions as Hitler,Stalin,Pol Pott,Mao etc.
strauja 2 years ago
Stalin made it a principle of his reign to send at least as many innocents to the Gulags, firing squads,etc. as guilty persons - so that anyone, guilty or not, would be intimidated by his rule. Nicholas II was offered to leave the country, but neither Britain nor any other nation would offer asylum. He was only shot dead about a year after his defrocking, when he was to be freed by approaching White Russians, which would have meant a prolonged civil war with millions additional victims.
Vilarum 2 years ago 2
Regarding Trotzky, he was advocating international support of communist revolutions, while Stalin was concentrating all ressources on what he called socialism in one country. Trotzky even in 1933 advocated violent opposition against fascism - up to july 1933 when their huge weapons stockpiles were discovered the german communists were ready to counter-coup, but Stalin refused to agree to this. Also, only due to his paranoia, Stalin refused to even acknowledge the Germans had attacked for 7 days
Vilarum 2 years ago 2
I must still add that Trotzky was at the front when the 1927 revolution happened while Stalin was drinking tea with some friends, telling Georgian jokes. In the Polish campaign of 1920/21 Stalin,when he was a political commisar disobeyed a direct order from Lenin, and instead of reinforcing the main battle line attacked the city of Lemberg, thus spoiling the entire campaign,which ended in defeat and made it impossible for the USSR to support,f.ex. the succesful,but besieged Bavarian revolution
Vilarum 2 years ago 2
Someone is struggling with history, but it is not Vilarum.
fdoric6 2 years ago
Mate, trotsky was an atheist. An atheist of Jewish descent, but still an atheist.
Good word, though!
Reghedable 2 years ago
@Reghedable All major communist supporters are/were atheists. ie: Marx, Lenin, Stalin, Trotsky, Mao, etc. Marxism is itself atheistic and strictly anti-religious, as religion was a tool used to subdue and control the working class.
DevoutSkeptic 2 years ago
@DevoutSkeptic
Yes, but Semitic is an actual ethnicity, of which Trotsky was a part of.
Agree with you 100% though.
Reghedable 2 years ago
Just because someone is a Jew does not make him a Semitic, just because someone is Christian does not make him white. Arabs are Semites too as well as Assyrians, Ethiopians, etc. That's something most people tend to ignore. Not all Russian Jews were/are Semitic and Trotsky was not a Jew nor was he a Hebrew therefore that does not make him a Semite.
MobHeataEnt 1 year ago
Noooooooooo, Trotsky was not a Semite. Semites come from the Middle East and have darker skin. Trotsky was no more Semitic than Shimon Peres, which means not at all!
maxime32 1 year ago
Communism only banned religion to have no competition beïng themselves considered as God on earth.
Biblical theory of the "fallen angels" who wanted to put themselves on Gods throne.
BTW. Not only communists do that, every other political fraction does the same thing.
Maybe thats because people miss the presence of God on earth. So every now and then people want to fill in a vacuum that cannot be filled and they hurl themselves into the raveen.
envanje 2 years ago
Stalin was a homosexual devil, not only did he kill everyone from the Old Bolsheviks who helped with the Revolution, while Stalin was out doing Mickie Mouse Bank Robberies with his midget ass, He also killed the families of the Old Bolsheviks because he was a paranoid son of a bitch. Stalin was the Devil in disguise.
MobHeataEnt 1 year ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Real name of Trotsky - Leibo Bronshteyn. He wanted to make the world revolution, and seize global power. Trotsky / Bronstein - is the most hated historical figure in Russia, a U.S. citizen, Jew-Zionist. Only thanks to Stalin managed to keep this monster from the accomplishments of the great evil.
Ace424 2 years ago
Stalin was a murdering thug. Trotsky was the true leader of the 1917 revolution.Long Live Comrade Trotsky!
kportjewboy 2 years ago
TRUE
bauerctu4 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
captalism and fascism are two sides of the same barbarian coin...
workers of the world unite against the money grabbing politicians...
wake up, dont be a sheeple, dont allow them to divide and conquer you...
Stalin was the continuation of 1917, Trotsky was the counter-revolution, he was backward, nationalistand he blamed Stalin for all his own failures...
workergirls 2 years ago
Good man. Lenin would have been proud of tavarish Trotsky and his opposition for Stalin"s policies.
Stalin made Molotov-Ribbentrop pact with Hitler. Invited fascist Ribbentrop into Kremlin on August 23 1939.
ss90ss444 2 years ago 21
@ss90ss444
What about Munich pact ?!!! Ha ?
Historican my ass.
Glory to tovarish Stalin !!!
Death to Trotsky !
permyak59 1 year ago
@ss90ss444 LUNGA VTA AL COMPAGNO TROTSKY
zappolete 9 months ago
Trotsky was a great Intelect. Long live Trotsky!
kportjewboy 2 years ago 16
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Trotsky was an idiot revisionist and traitor bastard.
Long live Marxism and Leninism !!!
Glory to Stalin, Mao and Che !!!
Death to fascism and capitalist rats !!!
workergirls 2 years ago
Trotsky was a great organiser
kportjewboy 2 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Trotsky was an idiot revisionist traitor bastard !!!
workergirls 2 years ago
fracasado
MALUNCHI1614 2 years ago
Long Live The Fourth International!
Regards from Argentine
gdvcai 2 years ago
Of course Jewish culture like any other has its weak sides but its a fact the birth of the Soviet Union was mainly organised and promoted by people of Jewish origin.
Ethnicity cannot be chosen and therefore it cannot be used for judgement (although the nazis and orthodox jews as everyone else do).
Culture can be chosen, not without taking difficult obstacles sometimes, but culture is mans creation and therefore its subject to judgement.
Who's the racist now ?
envanje 2 years ago
Comment removed
envanje 2 years ago
Only a Jewish intelectual sensitive genius could create an army in no time out of nothing to be victorious over 14 of the worlds best, experienced, well commanded armies.
envanje 2 years ago
Trotsky, tiny man, great soul, great devotion, great brain, not without faults but of good will.
envanje 2 years ago
The conflict between Trotsky and Stalin was the conflict between ideology and lust of power. Lust of power won, the proletarian revolution lost. Communism became tool for leaders of lust of power in Russia, China, North Korea, Vietnam, Cuba. Leaders of thease countries don't serve working class.
lechinhluan 2 years ago 5
"Leaders of these countries don't serve the working class"
True, they let themselves be served by the working class.
envanje 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Trotsky = Revisionnist
Stalin = Real communist
Long live Mercader !
Selden31 2 years ago
Comment removed
envanje 2 years ago
Trotsky, the real marxist.
Stalin, the real fascist.
ramK08 2 years ago 2
The modern communist are blinded by the views that Trotsky was a great man that wanted to give the workers control when in fact this is blatantly untrue as he helped create the all powerful bureaucracy that only the Bolsheviks had a say in. Furthermore he murdered thousands who opposed him and these aren't merely bourgeois but also thousands of leftist revolutionaries, even though the Bolsheviks claimed to have abolished the death penalty.
SuperSuperfan 2 years ago 4
The most fearsome example of this kind is Russia where he (Jewry) allowed 39 million humans in truly fanatical wildness to die or starve in inhuman agony, in order to secure the mastery of a great people for a gang of Jewish literati and stock exchange bandits.
The result is not only the end of freedom for the people oppressed by the Jews, but rather also the end of these parasites of the peoples themselves. After the death of the victim, the vampire dies sooner or later.
Adolf Hitler
pici44life 2 years ago 2
Oh and viva the 4th international !
Long live the revolution ! death to fascism ,capitalism and poverty !
Coggy69 2 years ago
Trotsky was jew. Fucking Bronstein jew.
MoskvaPeterburg 2 years ago
You are an idiot , he was born a jew , he was athiest for most of his life (not like it matters you racist pighead)
Go die you sick racist oxygen thief !
Coggy69 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
I am racist because I know some races are genetically superior than others. Jews are the sickly pigs. Trotsky achieved nothing. Communism was commenced by jew-bolsheviks, but enhanced entirely by Russians. I am supporter of White Army, Soviet Union and Monarchy. Communism in some aspects. You are a faker pro-capitalist rat.
MoskvaPeterburg 2 years ago
And what scientifichal proofs do you have to demonstrate that whites are better than others?
ramK08 2 years ago
ramK08 what kind of racist remark is that ?
envanje 2 years ago
i'm saying that racist people don't have proffs to demonstrate that, because is a lie.
ramK08 2 years ago
watch?v=KsYe0rhoGng&feature=channel_page
RobertPL91 2 years ago
lol read up on history..
In a December 1, 1952 Politburo session, Stalin announced: "Every Jewish nationalist is a potential agent of the American intelligence. Jewish nationalists think that their nation was saved by the USA."
The night of August 12-13, 1952, in the event known as the Night of the Murdered Poets (Ночь казнённых поэтов), thirteen of the most prominent Yiddish writers of the Soviet Union were executed on the orders of Stalin.
ProtoOmegaXenosaga 2 years ago 4
Trotsky, traitor of the protariaat.
Lycan87 2 years ago
Great video! Glory to Comrade Trotsky!
ComradeLenin1289 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
PIOLET :D
HEIL STALIN
HEIL HITLER
peners 2 years ago
How on Earth can a person praise Hitler and Stalin at the same time?
ComradeLenin1289 2 years ago
yeah he says he´s 100% bolshevik and 100% fascist...wtf. he´s a national-bolshevik i guess?
FIFA07Addicted 2 years ago
I'm wondering the same about Slavic Neo Nazis and Israel Neo Nazis of Russian descent.
DeathlyReaper217 2 years ago 2
Stalin killed over 1 million jews and efectivly exiles mosto f them from the soviet union... you are a dumb ass, stalin was a georgian orthodox christan, in his early years he was studing to be a priest
ProtoOmegaXenosaga 2 years ago
Right, and hitler killed over ten million, and stalin didn't really hate jews, he killed anyone who stood in this way, a lot of them happened to be jews.
bleackorama 2 years ago
Someone made cookies out of Trotsky's ashes.
jortylbro 2 years ago
Trotsky could have saved democracy in the USSr after lenin died. He could have done all that stalin did to modernize the country, but given the workers control of the means of production. I stand against the Stalinist because they give communism a bad name. Trotsky and Marx are in the same league.
ramberghini 2 years ago
Trotsky, Marx, Lenin, and Mao.
bleackorama 2 years ago
Mao¿? Another like Stalin...
Viscalainternacional 2 years ago
dint Mao kill millions? Im not talking about starving
sgsfdgfsdfsdfsddf 2 years ago
Long live comrade LEON DAVIDOVICH BRONSTEIN TROTSKI,legendary first commander and founder of the Red Army, eternal glory!!!
nedeljko18 2 years ago
@nedeljko18
Pusi Kurac Nedeljko!
Svarog1969 9 months ago
a comrade salute from greece! part of CWI ! venceremos!
cospoz 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Counter-revolutionary fascist spy and criminal! Trotskyites are still attempting to sabotage the workers I see! May you all burn in hell.
einsatzdeath 2 years ago
You're nuts.
Stenbjerget 2 years ago 3
Arriba las ideas de Lenin y Trotsky!!
VivalaIV 2 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
FUCK TROTSKY !! Too bad that son of a bitch didnt get an ice pick to the head earlier, like in 1912.
zabotlivaya 2 years ago
Viva la internacional
Viva el marxismo leninismo
Viva Trotsky
Abajo el dictador seudomarxista Stalin
Trotskista90 2 years ago 3
A great video-graphy of the most important revolutionary of the generations-that-are-not-yet here
Epkros 3 years ago 4
Forgot section on icepick.
soyuz27 3 years ago
Leon Trotsky vel Lejb Bronsztajn it provocator and agent of international high finance.
xenia19bd 3 years ago
Trotskyites were the 5th column in the USSR.
RustyChopper 3 years ago
fuck stalinism!
MrXreloded 3 years ago 5
Fuck state socialism!
jackriter 3 years ago
Leon Trotsky? Lejb Bronsztajn!!!!!
xenia19bd 3 years ago
Viva Revolution!
Capitalism must die!
allconrad 3 years ago 2
i love economic freedom...CAPITALISM
ulsterscot 3 years ago
communism is economic democracy
capitalism is economic anarchy
cary123 3 years ago 5
Communism is capitalism controlled by democracy (mob rule)... at best.
HerrSchenkel 3 years ago
i hate imperialistic capitalistic scum in countries where everything including love has its cost.
kgeyst 3 years ago
Well said comrade.
Steeplerot 3 years ago
I Hate Commie Scum
loyallands 3 years ago
Long liove Trosqui!!! Long live Comander Hugo Chavez!! Long live Bolivarian comunism!!
hugocaracas2021 3 years ago 2
You sully the name of Trotsky and communism with petit-bourgeois nationalists who have nothing to do with either.
1Mehring1 3 years ago
1Mehring1 it seems you an imbecil. Comander Chavez follow trosqui but is MUCH mor epwerful. Alll will bow before the iron fist of Bolivarian Comunism!!! Jajajajaja!!!!
hugocaracas2021 3 years ago
Chaves no tiene nada que ver con Trotsky, Marxismo o la revolucion socialista. Es pura nacionalista tan fascista como socialista, a la izquierda hoy, a la derecha manyana. Paquetero que es, usa los pobres para mantener su proprio poder ed el poder de su classe que no es trabajador, en contra de los de su classe que aceptan segundo puesto a los Estados Unidos. Ud no ha aprendido nada de la historia y los mismos errores se repiten hasta que se aprenden.
hugocaracas, parece que el imbecil es Ud.
1Mehring1 3 years ago
1Mehring1 traidor estas con Rosales, Bush y la CIA. Has brincado la talanquera. Eres fascista imperialista oligarca de la caurta republica. No sabes nada de historia. El primer comunista fue Jesucristo, leugo viene Bolivar, Marx y Engels, Trosqui, Lenin, Stalin y Mao y el Comandante Chavez. No sabes nada? Ignorante.
hugocaracas2021 3 years ago 2
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Goddamn you ugly Jewish monster fuckers! Long live the Soviet Union, white Russia and and true white people. Fuck the sand monkeys! They are all evil, always got their hands in your poor pockets, take your 20 dollar bills and leave you with pennies! Yeah wake up and fight the Jewish conspiracy take over of the world. Jewish control is out of control, give the power back to the people and the true power rests in them. Fuck the stupid Jewish monkey wanna bes.
FuckULookinAssNigga 3 years ago
This comment has received too many negative votes show
Trotsky, rest in hell you piece of mother fucking shit. Trotsky was commander of the 666th Lightly Army Peasant Battalion, equiped with stones, sling shots and about 10 guns for 1000 soldiers LOL. Yeah thats right, Trotsky's army was shit, but when Stalin too over, it was glory! Fuck Jewish Trotsky and fuck Israel. You corrupted sand niggers are going to hell. Fuck you too Jew bitches! You eat monkey and hairy Jewish man's assholes. Fuck you again! Trotsky, rest in hell bitch!
FuckULookinAssNigga 3 years ago
I think the wannabe Marxists around here ought to get off the cult of the personality trip and head down to the Marxist Internet Archive and do some serious, sustained STUDY for starters. Ever heard of SCIENTIFIC SOCIALISM? It's not hero worship or idolitory. It's hard theoretical and practical work and for Trotsky's life to have any meaning today, YOU have to do that work.
1Mehring1 3 years ago
I like Trotsky and Stalin.
Kumari58787 3 years ago
the greatest man to ever live
MarylandSocialist 3 years ago
Long live comrade LEON DAVIDOVICH BRONSTEIN TROTSKI,legendary first commander and founder of the Red Army, eternal glory!!!
nedeljko18 3 years ago
Muy buen video camarada.
Thank you. !
camicamipaz 3 years ago
What's this nonsence clip? It's indulging in a personality cult about someone who had more than his fair share of hair.
You people need to get into the real world. You talk to present day workers about all that stuff and they'll rightly laugh at you. I usually find these people to be wimpish types. When at work they tend to be scared of the bosses and fellow workers, who usually take the piss out of them. It's the kind of crap normal people grow out of when life realities need to be faced.
Ianpbx 3 years ago
ITS A NAZI!!!! KILL IT!!!!!
Kumari58787 3 years ago
Remember. In 1917, in Russia, the sentence "Workers of all coutry, unites !" was not writen only in Russian or english. On the flags of the revolutionnary, it was writen in all the languages : "Prolétaires de tous pays, unissez-vous !" - "Proletari di tutti i paesi, unitevi !" etc...
The true is that you merge internationalism and imperialism, dear friend.
EuKra 3 years ago
Me, I think that the existence of different language on earth is a wealth.
You ask me why you should speak another language. It is true. I can't ask you to speak french. Your and American, you speak english. I respect your culture.
But me, I am French. I speak French. So why I am speaking english here ? Because your language is imperialist now, and because Americans dosen't respect the orther cultures of the world.
EuKra 3 years ago
what a disgusting creature
Bibilezoive 3 years ago
What's so disgusting about Trotsky? He's a human being like you and me. And he's a socialist revolutionary. He also was against Stalin and was one of the few communists to urge a united front with other socialist parties against fascism. You're not a Stalinist, are you?
NLS510 3 years ago
Long live hero comrade Leon Davidovich Bronstain Trotski creator and legendary first commander of the red army.Eternal glory!!!
nedeljko18 3 years ago 2
Why is it that the people that admire Stalin hate Trotsky and the people who admire Trotsky hate Stalin?
PDRO4LYFE 3 years ago
History tells you why! Stalin was a brutal dictator whereas Trotsky was a great man whose goal was to obtain a permanent revolution.
politianus 3 years ago
Communists hate Trotky because he was an objective ally of the bourgeoisie during all his life.
For example, in 1940, he said that the people Russian had to destroy USSR, while the Nazis were going to pervade the country... Because of that, in France we say about the trotkist that they are: "hitlero-trotkistes" (objective ally of the nazis...)
EuKra 3 years ago
Stalinism, which main GOAL in the early USSR was to build socialism in other countries, which would inspire other nations to revolt against the capitalists. While Trotsky argued, like Lenin, that a permanent revolution is the only way.
Fiskpure 3 years ago
On the contrary, Trotsky was a committed Marxist and he didn't urge the destruction of the Soviet Union; he urged the overthrow of Stalinism, which, he argued, had betrayed everything Lenin had worked for. Trotsky was both anti-Hitler and anti-Stalin. It was Trotsky who urged a united front against fascism, while most other communists followed Stalin's line.
NLS510 3 years ago 4
And after the war, during all the second part of the 20 century, the trotkists was very useful for the capitalism, they was useful for breaking revolutions.
In western countries and in France, they recieved money from the CIA, for breaking the real communist party... And now, former trotkists govern with the capitalist without any problems. (in the french governement today, they are a lot of former trotkists...)
EuKra 3 years ago
First statement completely irrelevant. Fighting for a legitimate democratic revolution and trying to save it from a Czarist spy, nationalist pigs or the SR's is fighting for the continuity of the revolution not 'breaking' it.
I suppose you think a Marxist-Leninist organization has never been founded or infiltrated by government agencies? Try writing a sentence correctly than maybe you inaccuracies would be believable.
IzRaHFeL4 3 years ago
IzRaHFeL4 :" Try writing a sentence correctly than maybe you inaccuracies would be believable."
But i'm note american ! You think that it's easy and pleasant for me to speak your fucking imperialist english language?
You, can you make a correct sentence in french ? I think no...
EuKra 3 years ago
HAHAHAHAH You are suggesting the French weren't/aren't Imperialist? What a joke. I actually am Cajun(French ancestry) and Scottish. My family history has been constantly running from and fighting imperialist movements. But indeed I do speak this imperialist language so well why should I try speak another imperialist language?
IzRaHFeL4 3 years ago
Of course in history, french language was imperialist. But today, it is the english language wich is imperialist, not the french...
I think that you can't imagine what it is for a french, a german or an italian to see all the time things written in english. On advertising, on the products that we buy, on movies, on internet...
EuKra 3 years ago
yes down with stalinism
12345bybi 3 years ago
Trotsky as commander of the 888th peasants battalion, equiped with pitch forks, butcher knives and baseball bats and just ONE gun. Guess who has it? Trotsky of course LOL. Makes for one fucking stupid battalion LOL.
PaulCoffey7 3 years ago