Drugstore Liner That Won't Smudge :)

[lee80500]

haha i love that liner too!! its my favorite liner...(and one that works) ever!

[foxxyk96]

You're vietnamese aren't you? Woohooo

[MszJackieChu]

@foxxyk96 lol no full chinese

[ColorMePretty010]

Do you use it on the bottom too, or just the top?

[ThePrettiBrownEyes]

Hi Jackie! have you ever used your own eyeliner brush to apply MAC liquidlast? I use liquidlast too and had the same problem with the eyeliner sticking to my lashes, but if you use your own brush you get a better control of the amount of product you pick up and I never had that problem again :D

[candycanesluv9030221]

I also have very oily lids and tried the urban decay waterproof liquid eyeliner and found that it didnt smudge but that it tended to have a "cracked" look and wasnt a smooth line does this happen with either the milani or mac eyeliner????

[emmiielii5]

what lip gloss & or lipstick are you wearing?

[MyLinh1997]

Wait! Wat R The ScarS From??

[rosemite123]

hey are you asian and luv the video

[MsMzPa]

Awesome :) Thx for the review!

Btw, what do you use for your eyebrows?/can you recommend some products you liked best+color? It looks so natural!

[EMRichards90]

Try PRESTIGE liquid liner. Fairly priced at cvs, very dark, and a thin felt tip.

[mrsbeautylover]

i bought my first MAC eyeliner. Usually i always used drugstore.. But it smear a lot. The Milani is right stand on eyes but it's not that black . Thanks to you i finally can wear really waterproof eyeliner without worry.. Thanks Jacky!

[MidnightInspiration]

Does the Mallani make up test on animals?

[1234Mixedchick]

Lovee your vids Jackie. How tall are you/how much do you weigh? You're gorgeous! :)

[jjen0812]

loreal telescopic liquid liner is rly good i think u wud like it. its long lasting and dark:)

[keepcalmandluvmakeup]

Omg I have the same exact problem with my eyes because I have really oily eyelids and I have monolids as well. The only liquid I've been using is the Mac Liquid Last Eyeliner and I love it but since you've mentioned this one, I think I will try it:) great video!!!

[thatsprettiiamazingx]

Hi jackie! I'm wondering whether you went swimming with the milani eyeliner on because I want to know if milani eyeliner has some sort of waterproof staying power to it like the mac one. Thanks!

[fanntarded]

I was wondering could you make a video on how you 'clean' your eye liner? Such as, if you messed up (as you mentioned in the video, the wing), how do you come about to fixing it and cleaning it?

[aat10Kyoko]

Thanks for this video! I am a monolid, (with that thick layer of skin over my eyes), so my eyes are tiny, so yes I totally agree, for decades I've stayed away from "Drugstore" makeup, because nothing would stay on my eyes, and only bought department store brands. I will head out and look for this "Milani" brand. <;0) Cool, this will save me $.

[EntreprenistaTV]

have you tried L'Oreal Linuer Intense in Carbon black?

[alexxomgg]

Finally someones giving my 4 year crush some credit!!! Unfortunately i got sick of having to buy a new one every 1-2 months. It would dry up and get really gloppy and catch on my eyelashes and make me look like i had two eyelashes.. And it obviously doesnt come off so.... Not pretty! I tried the maybelline ultra liner after and its been PERFECT. It stays all day like the milani, ( i touch my eyes, ive cried, its been fine!) and its not thick and gloopy like the milani crap :/

[zinggibagoy]

you should try the physician's formula 2 in 1 eye booster..or something like that..?

i have really oily eyelids too and it worked for me

[flyfire5]

@Princesshellokitty...Dang she showed the brush tips lol...have you ever heard of being OBSERVANT

[flyfire5]

Hey your so pretty hun and I were eyeliner everyday so thanx for your input :) just wondering if anyone has checked out AUDFACED here on you tube...she's so unique and fun to watch!

[AnaAydee]

I had a bad experience with the Millani eye liner. I bought one, used it once and it dryed out right away!!! I'm glad it worked out for you though

[tma415]

heyy I love your videos, even though I'm a guy. What kind of cologne do you recommend for guys?

[MszJackieChu]

@tma415 this is horribly generic, but i LOVEEEEE aqua di gio :) by giorgio armani hahaha 

[Slovesnyx]

@tma415 Anything AXE! :) It's hot! <3

[MszJackieChu]

@PRINCESSHELL0KiTTY Actually I did, but you missed it because you were fast forwarding :)

[13suju4evr]

@PRINCESSHELL0KiTTY 3:20

[BurntSunshine96]

What lip gloss are you wearing? It looks soooo shiny!

[khnsanda]

@annsleyw u can use baby oil for removing eyemakeup

[annsleyw]

@khnsanda That's very interesting. Thanks! I'm looking forward to using my MAC Liquidlast thanks to all the suggestions I've gotten from here. :)

[khnsanda]

@annsleyw u can use any babu oil..xDD more info the comment below this comment

[khnsanda]

@annsleyv u cam also use baby oil frm any drugstores they have more product and it is also good for moisturizing and it erases all of the eyemakeup..

[ayeitsjuli]

for me the milani did last all day when i first started using it but after a while idono if its my skin or something it began to smudge a bit since i connect my bottom liner to my wing and same with the mac liquid blast D: *sigh

[BrittanyGoeddert]

Jackie i just started using stila's liquid felt tip liner. ITS AMAZING i have oily lids and its completely waterproof and super black.

[shortyyy22]

have you tried revlon colorstay one? its amazing and so much better than maybelline's lineur intense

[magatha]

i don't know if you have a shoppers drug mart - but GOSH liquid eyeliner never smudges! it's about $16 i think

[shortyyy22]

@magatha its only in canada

[Oinkoinkmeow1]

I don't know about you, but I find the Mac hard to use. I love the product, I have the same oily eyes, but I do have a really small double eyelid so if I ever forget to wait for the mac liner to dry before I blink, it gets all over my top lid and it's hard to fix -.- maybe I'll give the Milani a try. And plus, Mac liquidlast is discontinued :(

[coloryourlife123]

I think u should try the wet and wild h2o proof its amamzing for people with our eye lids! I wish u would try this. And I hope u read this. Ohmy god its also only 1.99$ also

[msanimeluver0926]

Can you do a tutorial using the Milani Liner? I always seem to get product on my lashes when I'm lining my lid.. -___- And I can't really do a wing using it either, pretty difficult.

[beautyru5h]

milani is very good

[piinkneko]

try wet n' wild h20 proof one its about 4 dollars and i at first didnt think id like it but it does NOT smugde!!!! its really worth trying

[lovelovelove4326]

my friend has mac liquid last andshe uses my Maybelline Line Stiletto...its amazing and works crazy good..i have oily eyelids too

[only4girlz25]

stila waterproof mmascaraa is magical

[NormalBadGood]

Lol sadly I don't think we get milani over here in the U.K , wish i could come to america one day lol :)

[fashionedbyfate]

i had the milani infinite liner before and i really liked it, but it started like getting clumpy and it became a really rubbery formula! it's hard to explain, but i wasn't too pleased after that. now i use milani liner tec (i think that's what its called....i have no idea but its a tiny golden pen) and its SUPER easy to use and once you set it with a black eye shadow on top, it doesn't budge whatsoever and i have the oiliest eyelids ever! coming from a fellow monolid, that is.

[twilite798]

I love the maybelline line stiletto and i have oily mono lids too. My trick is to use primer and powder or eyeshadow underneath

[KiL0VE22]

i'm monolid and my trick is setting my eyeliner and whole lid with translucent powder :) it makes my eyeliner not smudge onto my lid

[mrslizz387]

which are you wearing now?

[biancalovesfashion]

What are you wearing on your lips?(:

[heilkitler]

You used to work with ... parrots?

[raininghard]

Have you tried the K-Palette 24hr tattoo eye liner from Japan? It's a very interesting liquid eyeliner because it will never smudge due to the ingredients. Love your reviews! So nice of you to share your thorough thoughts of every aspect after experience!

[frazadoodl]

How can you work out for an hour and a half? I've recently started track and cross-country running again after I saw your video but I find I just can't run for more than 20/30 minutes max... how often do you go to the gym? Thank you!

[MszJackieChu]

@frazadoodl I do weights too :) and if im just steady jogging and not doing interval training I can go for an hour or so haha

[donnaearl3]

My favorite liquid liner is Lancôme art liner ....after trying it I decided to stick with it forever! It's the best! It's pricey but it's worth it...

[MszJackieChu]

@donnaearl3 Ive used it, I agree its a great liner :) But its not smudge proof on me

[OMGitsRachelBabay]

Jackie, I love how smart you are when you review things like this. You go at it in a businesslike way, and it's very cool because you hit every thing that people may ask and you go about it in a non-biased way. You're awesome :) lol and now I wanna try both those eyeliners.

[MszJackieChu]

@OMGitsRachelBabay Aww thank you ^_^ I really appreciate it

[annsleyw]

How do you remove the MAC liquidlast eyeliner? I have one but I stopped using it after using once because I tried removing it with makeup remover, makeup remover wipes, eyemakeup remover and washing my face with cleanser, removing it with toner and moisturizer but I can't get it off completely. My eyes get so sore from all the cleansing that I stopped using it which is a waste. :(

[MszJackieChu]

@annsleyw haha a good eye makeup remover! A bilevel one, neutrogena and lancome make great ones ^^ So does shiseido :D andd....sonia kashuk? I heard that one's good as well. Or you can always use olive oil haha :)

[annsleyw]

@MszJackieChu Olive oil sounds interesting. I'll give it a go. Thanks! :)

[aznpridebuhhd]

@annsleyw Try an oil-base makeup remover like the Lancome Bi-Facil Double Action Eye Makeup Remover. If that's too expensive, you can always try the Sonia Kashuk's Eye Makeup Remover instead. I heard they're both pretty similar, and I personally use the Sonia Kashuk one.

[annsleyw]

@aznpridebuhhd One of the removers I used was the Clinique Eye makeup remover which is oil-based. It helped remove some of the liner but didn't remove it completely. Thanks for the suggestion! I'm looking forward to using my MAC Liquidlast!

[summerbayy]

i dont use eyeliner but im watching this! xx

[darguel]

Try Canmake's Perfect black liquid liner. It's from Japan so not sure if you can get it in the US but I swear by it. No smudging once dry and stays on the whole day. My eyes are uber oily, I can't even wear eyeshadows.

[Chococopie174749]

Omg I needed someone to make a video about this lol! Thanks Jackie!

[angelajdesimone]

Hey Jackie! Your lips look so pretty! What are you wearing on them?

[tynotika]

i use the liquidlast religiously and the last time i went to my mac store, they said they were discontinuing it!

[carmz916]

omg yeah... my liquid last is sooooo tacky right now, kinda annoying because it's pricey and there's still a lot of product in there.

[carmz916]

what's your suggestion on preventing eyeliner from smudging on the lower lash line?

I find that mine just smudges almost immediately , even if I set it with a powder...

I might try liquid last on my lower lashline but that'll probably be quite a harsh look

[massyvang]

got to give this a try, i guess i'll go buy my friend one too since she has super oily eyelid love your review

[OMGitsRachelBabay]

@massyvang Maybe if you used liquid liner on the bottom lashes, you could kindof set it with a dark brown or black and then smudge it a little to make it fade into your inner corner. Maybe that way you can use liquid liner and hopefully it wouldn't smudge :)

[WEAREANIMALS]

hmm, I might try to grab some milani liquid liner now! I hope I can find it here in Canada.

I usually just use ELF liner, so I need an upgrade!!

[EssiaBailey]

Yay! You are my go to girl for in depth reviews on makeup products!

[0231dd]

love ur makeup<3

[enticx]

can i ask how long did you have the milani one, although it's 5ml (double than mac's), i wonder if would dry up after maybe 40 - 60 uses?

[prettyblissful]

MAC liquidlast is also the only liner that will stay on my oily lids. I will always use that one. But agree it gets tacky after a while which is when I buy a new one.

[GaMeOuTtAcOnTrOl]

Your beautiful!

[Arwaabdulla]

you're so pretty!

[missjones873]

If you have oily eyelids, what do you do to make your eyeshadow stay? Primer isn't enough for me :(

[mylinh1995]

WHAT?! it is 17.50? Over here it is like $35...

[luvsmiling513]

ohh this is something i should try lol i've been searching for a liquid liner that doesn't smudge on me here. the best one that i've ever owned was the liquid liner from palangtong, but i could only find it overseas xP it's the best since it comes off really easily when you want it to come off, otherwise it doesn't budge at all ^.^

[ViralVideosMusic]

you have nice hair : )

[rebeckyyyful]

How do you get it off though? I've tried it, and I can't get it off my eyelid without rubbing at it with Vaseline :/

[MszJackieChu]

@rebeckyyyful A bilevel makeup remover :) Neutrogena and Lancome make great ones

[ohBOYjoyBOY]

Omg thank u! I have the same problem where my eyelids are too oily. Ive been using gosh, which has the same formula as Mac but a tad but cheaper. Glad to know there's an even cheaper alternative!

[ericahaj]

what lip gloss areyou wearing??

[Kukolka42]

It's weird bc in both the swatches & the shots of the brushes, the Milani one seemed darker to me O.o am I colorblind? haha

[MszJackieChu]

@Kukolka42 haha its not I assure you :) its because those close ups I did at night, the milani brush is bigger and picks up more product so the camera makes it look darker. Nothing is darker than the MAC one haha

[jordanluver17]

i think u shuld try the milani tech liquid eye liner! its it in a gold tube nd u shake it!! its SUPER black

[liveyourlife365jess]

Does the Physicians Formula felt tip liner smudge for you? I want to try it but I'm not sure if its good for oily lids

[MszJackieChu]

@liveyourlife365jess never tried it, and havent heard anything about it

[beautyxjenn3710]

@liveyourlife365jess dude i love it.

[MsGEOLOVER]

For the sharp and clean wings, you can have your own liner brush instead of the one come with Malani, so you don't need to struggle at all ^^

[bluebear143]

i have tried that miliani liquif. its pretty good & thick formula & it stays on well . my cousin really liked it :)

[AppleAina]

kat von d has been GREAT for me. it doesn't last as long though :/ also do NOT get the physicians formula eye booster eye liner, it does have a lot of product in it.

[Cutie83ify]

I also have oily lid, paladio liquid eyeliner is works great on me, u should try. :)

[Kx1942O2212]

What about both high-end and drugstore gel liners that don't budge? (:

[MszJackieChu]

@Kx1942O2212 I dont find gel liners to never budge :) haha but my favorite would be Etude houses

[Kx1942O2212]

@MszJackieChu Thank you (: xx

[xoxkaye]

Do you have a tutorial on how you do your eyeliner? Also, have you tried the Dolly Wink eyeliner?

[MszJackieChu]

@xoxkaye yes I do and no I havent haha but it doesnt SEEM waterproof to me? Mainly because most of the pen/fountain style liners i've ever tried are awful :x im not super impressed by most dollywink products. But i've never tried the liner, only their awful lash glue haha

[xoxkaye]

@MszJackieChu Thanks! Just watched the video :) I am a bit hesitant in trying the eyeliner only because it doesn't seem waterproof to me either and also is quite expensive in my opinion here in Australia, but thanks nonetheless!

[HellooJackie]

Did you use your Milani or Mac liner on your waterline & to tight line your eyes?

[MszJackieChu]

@HellooJackie you can use either :) btw tight lining with liquid liner (or putting it on your water line) isnt recommended, but I still put it on my waterline. I tightline with pencil liner

[xxcheeto]

Try Kat Von D's tattoo liner! I found it works best on oily lids! I've never seen those with smaller lids try it, but I have huge eyes and I've been using it for about 2 years now. My favorite eyeliner!

[sunnylanes]

You should try tarte's Amazonian clay liners! I once slept with it on and it does not budge!

[xmselaine]

I love wet and wild h20 liwuid liner. I find it the best for drugstore liquid liners

[outofordinaryabbey78]

Good tutorial :))

[classiccouture21]

This is a great video and was very helpful!

[BeautySavvy]

I just bought the Milani one after EmilyNoel83 said it was the best non-smudging liquid liner at the drugstore! I'm glad you have good feedback on it too, I'm excited to try it! <3

[mindyyyyy]

I have the Milani Eye Tech Liquid Liner and I think it's darker!

[onexlov3]

Have you tried the hard candy "walk the line - Liquid eyeliners"? I recently brought it and it's awesome. It stays on my eyes and I have oily eyelids too. The only thing negative I'd have to say is the brush, but it's not that bad.

[glamourittaohhme]

in my country, our drugstore didn't sell Milani, not even wetnwild and sonia kashuk as well. And some other brands like L.A Girls :( i'm a sad woman now

[flingstars13]

Pretty ^_^

[Sukhime]

Aww wished u showed us the brush size comparison. I used to use wet n wild H20 before since it was cheap and it was the only eyeliner that would stay on for EVER but I really hated how thick the brush was. Now I use Urban decay 24/7 liquid eyeliner and i LOVE IT! it is really expensive compared to the cheap wet n wild one, but oh my the brush is perfect, its so thin...and the eyeliner stays on all day long, doesnt smudge at all. Only bad this is that is $18 for 1.7ml :/ might try mac one next

[mindyyyyy]

@Sukhime she did show the brush size comparison at 3:15

[Sukhime]

@mindyyyyy

Wah thank you! lmao its so funny that i skip a few seconds trying to find the brush size comparison, and I skipped it too! xDD

[khiaraleigh]

@Sukhime she does show a brush size comparison at 3:14 :)

[Electropop3545]

I'm so sad :( this still didn't work for me

[2Tkellly]

have you used the wet n wild megaliner, not the H20 one?

[redloveballoon]

You used to work with parrots? That's so cool, I'd love to hear more about that

[Asian69Delight]

You're so helpful! ^^ <3

[itssandy]

Thanks Jackie :). I also have a problem with eyeliner smudging even with primer :(..oily lids ...now after watching this video, I have a new eyeliner I can test out! : )

[lintsanchez]

what do you use on your lower waterline? pencil, gel? and what brand because your eyeliner looks really good

[MszJackieChu]

@lintsanchez I use the liquid liners :x its not recommended but I do it anyway x.X haha

[simplyxpliicitful]

hmm the MAC liquid last liner...I have the black track & I have oily lids too and it tends to imprint on my higher lid after 5 hours. I have to try the liquid last liner one!

[MszJackieChu]

@simplyxpliicitful yea, blacktrack is the color of their potted black gel liner. Gel liner will never ever have the staying power of liquid liner

[LxXxR052111]

@simplyxpliicitful its the best!!! no matter how many that i have gone through lol the last liner is always the best and will last up to the next day lol! get it!!

[livingwater2009]

Have you tried the Japanese brand, Majolica Majorca liquid eyeliner? I have very oily eyelid too, this doesn't smudge on me as well as on many people. Maybe you would like to try out :)

[BlairBearxoxo]

Jackie, do you know of any mascaras that won't smudge? :) I'll be sure to check out the Milani liner! :D

[MszJackieChu]

@BlairBearxoxo haha any waterproof mascara doesnt smudge on me, right now im using imju's fiberwig (curl after w/ a heated lash curler) you take it off with warm water...but that gets a bit annoying I wish it'd just come off with makeup remover! haha

[tseqnj]

@BlairBearxoxo Urban Decay's Cannonball doesn't go anywhere!!!

[jessicalee422]

@BlairBearxoxo you should check enkoremakeup's newest video about setting mascara :) so helpful!

[Kookiez72]

love your vids jackie! i think i might try this one out, i have sensitive eyes and they get bloodshot easily when i use eyeliner.. hopefully will get diff results with this one!

[rachellikescookies]

yesss this milani liner is AMAZING. very very waterproof. doesn't smudge. it's seriously hard to remove, so use a good quality remover and be gentle!

GET THIS LINER EVERYONE. IT'S AMAZING.

the brush is kind of irritating so i use a liner brush sometimes.

[GurlPlease2127]

ugh you are so pretty!!!!!!

[heyimsamie]

I use Loreal linear intense and I love it :)

[JustineYeaa]

0:06 hahaha cutest "they make" ever :P

[hchizzle]

Jackie.

[poohbear0805]

try the eye tech liquid eye liner by milani instead!! it's my absolute favorite, my HG! it never smudges!

[TheAnahi2009]

Gorgeous!

[msanimeluver0926]

Hehe, this was my first ever liquid eyeliner! On me, its okay, the line I make with the eyeliner does start to fade and crack tho.. :\

[WhoaItsKathleen]

Yay I was 3rd to comment :) but can you do an updated everyday makeup tutorial? You're gorgeous btw!

[pinkdevilishgal]

have you tried the wet n wild H2o proof?

[MszJackieChu]

@pinkdevilishgal yes i think its awful lol

[killdaking17]

i love that eyeliner!

[opalstar567]

i love that eyeliner! :D i hv monolids nd it works good for me.

[LeiLei465]

Have you ever used the Lancome Artliner? It's the one that works the best for me.

[MszJackieChu]

@LeiLei465 yup, it was my favorite in high school but its not smudge proof on me

[freesoul2278]

oh dang! my comment can actually get into first 10 :O

[MsLibragurl]

your so pretty, i love staring at your hair...im weird, sorry LOL

[dollyfacegirl]

Miss you Jackie~~

[WhoaItsKathleen]

I get soo excited every time I see that you upload a new video haha. I love you and your videos!♥

[preenallday]

thanks! i am trying this