You Make the Call : Safe or Out at Third?

[hosskids20]

He's safe the third basemen had great technice on that play any body who says

Safe needs toe either get glasses or not watch videos like these if there blind (0ut)see yah

[kimv020887]

Is it the minor leagues?

[sfgiantsca]

Got'em

[robmattd10]

OOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOUUUUUUUUU­UUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUTTTTTTTT­TTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTTT­TTTTTTTTTTTTTTT

[CharlesAycock]

He's ooouuuutttttt!!!!!!!!!!

[maxwellsch]

Definitely out, his hand bounced upward as he slid in, so even though he beat the throw speedwise, his hand never touched third until after the tag.

[Mrcrasher09]

pause at 00:28 youll see hes out

[luigiGreenmanic]

Out

[joshjhutton]

Ball beat him there. Sometimes that all it takes. The umpire can't cover every conceivable angle, so if the ball looks like its there, the umps gonna call it just about every time. Not the worse call I've ever seen. Ask Armando Galarraga.

[jmoneyweida]

This call could go either way really.

[jfurm333]

out but barely and when i say barely i meeen it

[garrettstringfellow]

out i paused and the tag is on right before his hand hits the bag

[mrthemasterbeatty]

Safe

[Mike943905]

ouuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu­uuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuttttttttt­tttttttttttttttttt

[Tc7961]

out



[macandcheeseman1]

SAFE!

[dfrez412]

OUT

[ddvbaseball]

he could not beat the throw hes out!

[xXSkrufBearXx]

out throw beat him

[Shmooz09]

out

[AATNO]

@tat22777 no it's u beat the throw or ur out

And he was out

[jasonk1019]

very close, but safe

[MegaCyclone2]

90% out and 10% safe

[carnevaleb1]

out



[AreaIVchamps]

Out, hes fat though so shouldnt have been trying for 3.

[123ItzJustMe]

out



[acdcad328]

out

[tat22777]

tie goes to runner so safe

[shawnlshs]

@tat22777 Tie doesn't go to the runner. You have to beat the throw.

[AceyDucey123]

Out, just pause at 0:28. Great call by the ump.

[dfrez412]

out

[TheMidnightCuber]

Safe



[thegarretthp]

out

[qwertyuiop4332]

Is say sage because as hw tagged his head his arms touched the base but close call

[Diptok]

hes out

[wizardflame101]

out! and ITS JUST OUR FUCKIN OPINION, YOU ALL NEED TO SHUT UP IF YOU SAY WERE IDIOTS FOR SAYING OUT, OR SAFE, ITS JUST A DAMN STUPID GAME!

[nerf915]

@wizardflame101 it is a good sport u r probaly black and like dumb basketball

[wizardflame101]

@nerf915 im white, and i love baseball, i play baseball all the time, but im sick of comments saying were stupid, or dumbasses from our opinions.

[justinblol100]

Out because the ump said so.

[MegaBored4ever]

pause at 0:28 he's out

[Baronwwe]

Out

[yankees1cotton]

safe

[Shayne350]

SAFE BIG TIME U STUPID ASSES IF U PUT OUT!!!!!!!!!!!!

[PianoGod505]

out, nice tag

[Dmo217]

Out



[jmoneyweida]

Me personally, I would have called him safe but that is just me. Whatever call the ump makes is his decision.

[Navalstealth18]

I gotta go with safe. I played it in slow-mo and he barely gets there. But in real time in the umps situation i would have called him out

[thegarretthp]

OUT

[dimentiobleck5]

out

[MrLetsgoblue]

Out.

[bbgoody19]

out no doubt

[ninjamonkeybird]

safe

[0602008555]

im a ump a clearly hes out



[99schwartz]

OUT

[mnw1989]

He was obviously out...His hand never came close to touching the bag...In fact he was at a dead stop

[BRAIESMOM]

out

[mxmaster155]

safe 

[Beholder552]

I say safe but its hard to tell cause theres no slow mo

[catspjs01]

@Beholder552 In the game, do you think the umpires have slo-mo? No. The call must be made in realtime, with your eyes providing the instant replays you need.

[Poseyfan55]

safe



[ARC3093]

safe

[mandonalex]

out!



[RandomManAJS]

because of the crappy camera job i cant say he could be in on a tie he could be out by a little i would not argue either way

[POYAWESOME]

safe

[awesomeboyyoyo]

Safe!

[thehotoneisin]

FAT SLOW you shouldn't ever go for a triple unless you hit it over the fence your OUT!!!

[stryker1228]

safe

[jklm4babies]

safe and if you think its out your RETARDS!!!!!

[dav7722]

SAFE

[MultiRockstar34]

JUST SAFE. his fingertips were on base whe tag was applied

[spataro7]

safe if u stop it at 0:28 u see hes safe

[Umpire323]

out by a mile

[legoman200000]

safe by a long one

[Monsterdavid22x]

out

[Seth35696]

Out

[MarinesSemperFi100]

hardest call to make but i say safe by a hair.

[blueday47]

safe baraly



[TPXhero502]

safe

[prob03]

IF U WERNT CHEAP AND PAID A BIT MORE FOR A BETTER CAMERA, WE COULD TELL WITH NO PROBLEM. THE CALL REALLY COULD HAVE GONE EITHER WAY, BUT LOOKED SAFE BY A HAIR

[callofdutyvids100]

Safe. if u stop at 0:29 then hes safe and there was no tag.

[MultiRockstar34]

Safe. his hand just got in

[gmanbaseball5]

out

[HockeyFan7374]

looked out. he slid and he already had the ball in his glove, so he tagged him before his hand touched 3rd base.

[johncenahbkjblcrymet]

safe

[gmrkyle]

safe.....he tagged him a little to late....you can see him tag him at about his thighs...i say safe



[sk84lifem23]

out

[cooleyotastic]

out

[c0lcr0ss]

out

[henrytod]

its debatable.

[backdown12345]

Out, badboy.  Got it on freezeframe.

[zmoneyandkdawg]

out



[HardyBoys27]

out

[backyardbaseball1024]

safe



[superninjahotdogs]

Safe turds. Gotta apply the tag earlier.

[arsaiah1]

safe



[chickenis6]

out sir

[MrLee38]

out easly

[BabyGirl81097]

Out

[7hl24ll]

out...

[acsuperman3]

he is out

[bui2468]

OUT

[Zacisawesome10]

O....U....T.... not even close

[eflowman1]

outta there!

[xxlaxbeast4lifexx]

out

[ELLISMISTRO]

He was out the ball was there before he even slid in

[LL7768]

out



[cem01388]

O...U...T

[warpig362]

out! Just by a little bit. stop it at 0:29. It shows he is not on the bag yet.

[yahoobuckaroo2]

his arms were strattleing the bag when he slid OUT!!!

[jman12324]

safe

[cem01388]

@jman12324 Nah, he was out. Pause right before he touches. It's an out

[zZBBZz100]

safe tagged him on the shoulder. plus look at his hands they are crammed against the base, that means he clearly got to the base before he was tagged. bad call

[OsidePenguin32]

he was out... i have a good whisper eye

[Poyo279]

that was a good call.

[cccornel7722]

safe

[nowtillforever111407]

safe

[metsfan7797]

out

[rickcjc3]

Good call blue!

[trase67]

see ya yer out!!!

[aa60football]

Out I have perfect eye sight

[Wirld]

Out

[demonsofyoursouls]

out

[kolasa101]

He is safe!

[tatomuck18]

why the fuck is he RUNNING SO SLOW

[tatomuck18]

he is safe. He touched the bag just before the tag was made.

[koichi97186201]

OUT!!!!!

[ivandaedo]

thats play its a out

[TPM75108]

Clearly out he didn't even slide under the tag or have a chance to slide under it.

[Poyo279]

I gotta say out. good call by the umps

[Tibby733]

i have to say out

[gopadres7]

out

[RageAlu]

You have to remember about the umps...they get to watch it ONCE at FULL SPEED. Now if you were watching it once at full speed i would say he is out, but i replay it over and over very slowly at the right point, he is safe by about a hand length.

[gavodonoghue]

out

[phillipjr7]

out 0:28

[action0515]

out

[DXFan1269]

safe

[iluvsk8ting777]

safe but it all happend so fast

[Yankeesfan6542]

out

[thebest545]

Going full speed I would have called him out too but if you slow it down it looks like he barely got in before the tag. Can't blame the ump on that one.

[DJock10]

Out

He got 'em on the wrist/elbow

close... but I he was out

[lightupthehalo]

safe.. he got the right arm in there.. he was tagged high.. but the ump only gets one shot at calling that

[jeterboy12]

out

[videogame888]

out

[stryker0040]

i say out but its so close that the umpire could call either way

[elementrocker69]

out

[ccmunster23]

out

[smdawgy5950]

out

[crakhead93]

DOESNT MATTER? LOL

[kookid1011]

barely out

[mindfreakfan67]

out

[crw2424]

out

[gaers928]

safe

[thunderbball16]

out

[Philadelphia1994]

safe by a very slim margin

[systemdown12]

Very close call

[tcobell]

tie goes to the runner

[rogerfedererrocks]

out

[iTzChase101]

def out

[phillipjr7]

Out look at 0:29

[jeterboy12]

way out not even close

[jmanrox247]

out

[funboxexplodes55]

WHY IS EVERYONE SAYING SAFE IT WAS OUT

[thequackzi]

Just barely out.

[pokedude49]

safe

[preston894]

out!!!

[jackassmovies2009]

safe

[xxxSLUGGERxxx]

safe

[Dahms45]

fuck nig he was out

[atticus126]

definitely safe

[kjcrocks]

safe went under it

[slebrechthausen]

:29 His hand is just in there, just safe!

[142sexyboy]

out

[SteveDude64]

Safe!

[310folife]

safe

[fosnacht22]

safe got his hand in

[MoSK8er1]

OUT

[XBox360Gamerz101]

safe he tsgged him on the back so he had to be safe

[perrydaplatypus9]

S-A-F-E, SAFE