Tristania - "Beyond the Veil" live in Kyiv

[myster1234]

Now I know why she isn't singing these parts in the newer videos online. Because she can't and butchered it. So they are just like "Yo, when we play Beyond the Veil", just around playing air guitar, and only sing the very last easy part--well, easy for you--when the big dude sings so the male vocals mask your vocals. Sound good?"

[HellDragon66]

ke asco de cancion

tanto ke me gusta obviamente con vibeke

pero esta tipa solo se pone a gritar y canta horrible

suena mejor cuando no canta ella



[MusicaCool23]

O.o creo que estaba mejor cuando no cantaba esas partes u.u

[dogg8701]

OMG she cant sing anything....Tristania leave her go^^

[maxleouf01]

tres belle musique mais l'ambiance du public pas terrible

[johnzevanz]

This girl is so... =\ I want the gothic woman back :B

[Retytania]

eu gosto MUITO do contraste entre gruturais e a voz melódica de Vibeke, porém o que vejo nesse vídeo não é mais esse contraste, que dava tanta particularidade ao Tristânia, o que vejo (e ouço), dá impressão de uma cantora amadora, tentando reproduzir o estilo de Vibeke e resultando num vocal gritado e desafinado".

[yayosanz]

That sadness ... Definitely should not continue playing the old songs live .. Nothing like the old days with Vibeke Stene .. Mary D. You do not have the vocal to interpret this song .. We are accustomed to the essence of Vibeke ...

[eanatum]

I can't find words for this performance, Tristania was once a great and respected band, this is so sad. I miss the old days...

[hellcetchup]

on 3:16 her "together! wo-wo-wo-wo!" made me laugh... but her howling on 5:15 plunged me in awe, it's not even funny anymore... i think that was unexpected "surprise" even for the band. so deplorable.

[Lightbringer1234]

lol

its like the tarja/annette thing, except with tristania its actually... iffy

[darkis1201]

@hellcetchup Agreed.

[athelionravi]

Looks like the chipmunk choir!! Dun get me wrong, but Vibeke owes her place more than Tarja in Tristania. There is something mystical in Vibeke that Traja seems to be lacking. Both are good, get that point, but FOR Tristania, Vibeke rocks!

[truskawka92]

tarja is not in tristania, but mary :P

[Epica90]

How can you mistake Mary for Tarja???? OMG this takes the price

[athelionravi]

Oh man sorry!!! This is a big mistake I confess!

But the voice is like Tarja!

[Epica90]

OMG are you kidding me!!!! I was wrong THIS takes the price!!! Mary does NOT sound anything like Tarja!!!

[athelionravi]

Sorry take no offence! I happened to have a cold when i heard this live version I was kinda bit of deaf at that time!

Peace!

[sauber18]

mmmmm

[xEternalxDarlness]

tristania still awesome i love u vibby u r nor forgtten

[kotopoulo13]

seems like the beginning choir part is too high for her pitch...they should re-recorded on lower pitched choir to fit her voice...i like her a lot but i still miss the godess :'(

[Epica90]

HAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHA­HA

This is just SO FUNNY and PAINFUL in the same time!

[vnom0301]

Sorry, but when she sings "Welcome..." that sounds really bad...

[SakumaRyuichiNG]

I just wanna say, I know she can´t sing as Vibeke, but if she sang that day, why the fuck she doesn´t sing anymore!? she just act like a doll in the stage and you just listen the beaufitul voice of Vibeke in chorus ¬¬

[Legume666]

I like'd :)

[Blitzballgott]

Yahooo here she sings the chorus and it's not too bad :)

[pilytratra]

No le llega ni a los talones a vibeke... vuelve porfa... de verdad te extrañamos vibeke

[sinamore81]

katastrophe

[AlexiLaihoIsTheBest]

Mary killed the song vocally

[mytouniquet]

Agreed:)

[vnom0301]

So true!!! When she starts the chorus my heart just... kinda broked

[Epica90]

I Never said she dident have any right to sing them...What i mean it is for her own good to do a new album and leave the other songs because it will only dissapoint fans that liked Vibike more... The same as Anette sings the songs Tarja use to for what I know 99.99 procent of everyone prefere the original

[vhazheo]

hola pues aki algo decepcionado nadamas de saber k la porkeria de k tienen komo cantante se ve k andaban necesitados no pido k regrese vibeke pero k por lo menos se tomen la molestia de elegir a alguien k si cante bien y no haga el dirriculo como ella probrecita pero en fn para mi dejo de ser tristania

[1malakian]

i dont know if i like what i hear or not....

[WitchOvAgnesi]

I dunno, she's a bit wobbly, but it sounds like she's nailing everything and even adding a bit of inflection that's unique. Thanks for posting this!

[anamad05]

The opera is over in gothic metal... it seems like that...

[jonath689]

Nena eres divina!! pero no das la talla!!!

[Dokyriak]

Pero que porqueria es eso? Que asco de cantante, estaba a punto de ir al concierto de buenos aires que estoy de paso pero me lo estoy pensando mucho, Que vuelva Vibeke!!!!

[EndlessCompassion]

God, no one can please you guys. There was such a great fuss when Anette joined Nightwish (and she's absolutely fabulous, in my opinion), and I can see the same thing is going on with Tristania, and Mary truly has one of the greatest voices in metal out there. She really does, and got me hooked with her skills.

[mytouniquet]

Yeah she is pretty good but I don't like her version of q2orld of glass at all.

[Epica90]

Well they are her songs to since she was with them and recorded them!...

[sinsofchrist]

They are NOT her songs.Did she compose them?NO!Yes,she was with them at that time.But does that mean Mary has no right singing them?SHE HAS A RIGHT AS A SINGER OF TRISTANIA!

[Epica90]

Oh no she is destroying the best song of Tristania...do a new album and leave vibekes songs alone

[sinsofchrist]

shut your stupid mouth!These are NOT Vibeke's songs because she didn't make them.Morten did.

[HECHICERA7]

yes you are right morten did them but he did them to fit vibeke's voice 'cause she was with them at that time

[vinsilfon]

If Vibeke left Tristania because she wanted to become a singing teacher, maybe should teach Mary how to sing well.

[SakumaRyuichiNG]

XD You said it better than myself XD! Yeah, Vibeke would be a pretty good teacher

[booooyah12345]

How about recording a new album with here instead of ruinning the old and amazing songs of Tristania? \:

[Rafathatha]

PQP! Enfia essa porra no c.u.

Essa mina é uma aberração!!

[xxxthoughtlessxxx]

How about you Soon-To-Be-Throat-Slit-Mary-Ba­shers go see her IN CONCERT!?! These vids of Mary live are lowest quality!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Ahileen]

What a garbage!que liiiixo velho...Vib, get back!I miss U...

[xxxthoughtlessxxx]

At least Mary can SING.

[mytouniquet]

and Vibeke can't?

[xxxthoughtlessxxx]

Huh?

[sinsofchrist]

Ur precious little vibeke stene aint comin` back!

[Einrabe]

That stupid whore ruined the song!!!

What the hell happened to these guys' brains?

She doesn't sing: she shouts as if an elephant was fucking her!!!

[xxxthoughtlessxxx]

HOW DARE YOU. Mary a whore!?! Slit your throat, bitch, before I do it FOR you.

[Einrabe]

At first, don't you call me bitch, you do not have any fucked idea about what I am.

At seconds, that's is exactly what she is. A whore, a bitch, a slut who is just looking for money and fame.

She should sing on a dirty-rock band that makes soundtracks for porno movies, or, at least, act in those movies

[sinsofchrist]

who?You?

O,we all know you're a porn star.

[xxxthoughtlessxxx]

You have no idea who Mary is, you goddamn son of a bitch. I guess if you can call Mary a bitch, then I can call you one. I guess Nell Sigland is a bitch doing it for money/fame? FLoor Jansen? Tarja Turunen? I can call you whatever the FUCK I please.

[sinsofchrist]

I bet u an elephant would rather fuck her than your stupid ass.

[sinsofchrist]

I bet u an elephant would rather fuck her than your stupid ass.

[pandorabrx]

meu deus mandem ela parar de gritarrr!!!!!!!!

[nocturnocultoinfame]

thanks for this video men! from Chile

[xXBeyondthesilenceXx]

Mary's such a fantastic vocalist! I'm totally poisoned of her voice and this song.

I hope Tristania will release something soon with her.

By the way, does anyone know who makes the growls on this?

[arhat82]

I like Mary on Ashes and Illumination songs.

:°°°(

[arhat82]

I hope the audio of the video is bad. I dearly hope. :°°°°°°°(

[kerosenee]

vibeke i miss u!!

Mary is trying to do her best, but jesus! the 5:10 minute... WTF

[black0enchantress]

holy mother of god , she shouldnt even attempt that, she destroys the song

[SakumaRyuichiNG]

;O; I will miss you forever and ever Vibeke >O>!!!

[meElysia]

WTF is she doin`? :(

[DarkerMary]

u.u Omigosh.. I'm definitely crying

I never really liked her but.. I thought she could improve.. u.u

I'll check tristania in a couple of years to see if it happens ='(

[xXBeyondthesilenceXx]

This is simply brillant!!!

[SakumaRyuichiNG]

Pardon?????????? O_o

[xXBeyondthesilenceXx]

If you don't like it, don't get on my nerves leaving comments with insults to the part of Mary or people who love Tristania and her voice.

[SakumaRyuichiNG]

Don't care. Bye.

[sinsofchrist]

Get the fuck out of here!!!!

[SakumaRyuichiNG]

LOL mature

[MaryYamiINC]

:s I just can't like her, I'm really trying but :s it's quite impossible

[xXBeyondthesilenceXx]

Mary sings really good here! So bad that Tristania don't do stuff like Widow's Weeds or Beyond the Veil anymore.

[mittti]

omg omg my poor ears :(

[zeirlee]

uuuu q mal

[pandorabrx]

jesuis cristu!!! essa mulher mia igual um gato com raiva ueaheuahe saudades da vibeke..=/

[pandorabrx]

jesuis cristu!!! essa mulher mia igual um gato com raiva ueaheuahe saudades da vibeke..=/

[andyc225]

Does anyone have a recent version of Angina? I want to see what she's like with it. So far, I'm very disappointed.

[JDarkMoon]

Omg, in the beginning she sounds ridiculous in her poppy/country phrazing, then tries to sing classical and ruins it. Please keep the playback louder than her! ROFL

[ladymacbethx]

I dunno...but

the beginning of this MASTERPIECE (not for

Mary's voice) my ears where like

being tortured...I really want to cry...

[rudolphlomax]

Tá loco meu manda a Vibeke pra mim, e manda a Mary cantar Axé com a Ivete Sangalo hauahua

[JDarkMoon]

hahahahahah concordo!!!

[Mrjansen]

Angina? I want to hear that

[thegranny2006]

she didnt sound that bad, really. and for those up there ^^ you stil have the rest of the original band plus Osten's voice which sounds as fresh & clear as ever!

[mariazona4JUL]

What was the setlist of that concert?

[squall3492]

the sound is bad so I it's hard to judge Mary's performance, but I think she starts well! Good job, she's great ^^

[cursedness]

É Mary, vai descendo na bokinha da garrafa!!!

[Deadlands09]

Mary rulez \m/

[petersonmanagement]

They need a singer who knows how to sing classical music. Mary does not have a clue! She butchers their music. It's horrible. I cannot stand her stage antics at all either. What on earth were they thinking?

[DarkerMary]

Agreed.. They cannot attempt to sing the songs with mary as they did with vibeke. They're two totally different styles and voices and.. everything =S

Maybe they should try giving themselves a break to write songs mary can perform and not forcing her into a soprano's shoes =S

[SakumaRyuichiNG]

...Vibeke is mezzosoprano ^^U but she was trained isn't she? mhm u.u Well Mary sung this in a decent way... World of glass was T____T... horrible.

[DarkerMary]

Uhm, all biographies I've read so far say she's a full soprano though she can reach very high notes and, yes, she's trained but that ain't bad at all.. Floor's trained too and I love her ^^

Yaa.. WoG was definitely not their best album but this is just horrible. As I said before, Mary's voice is a rock voice. Like trying to put aaron lewis in him, lol!!

But tell me.. isn't it just suicidal around 5:10 when she starts the "AAAAAAAA... AAAAAAAAAAAA.."?

My god!! Vibeke come back for God's sake!!

[SakumaRyuichiNG]

Nou, Vibeke said -in the forum- she was a mezzosoprano, but she is light mezzo mhm, she can reach soprano's notes ^^ well almost all mezzos can.. O.Ou... ah, she can do it very well ^^U I love the WoG +0+, beyond the veil is wonderful though ^^

Min, 5.10?... -watching.- ...WTF?! o_O

...XD After listen Mary I said to myself that nobody could sing World of glass worst than her XD That's why I am doing a cover ^o^ -it mustn't be as terrible as Mary's XD

Ps. Sorry for english mistakes XD

[DarkerMary]

Hahahahahahaha, no importa, yo te entiendo. Hahahahahaha, pues si.. yo siempre sospeche de eso del soprano de vibby, me parecio muy fina su voz a pesar de tener un rango y color alto como los sopranos..

Yo ya me puse a practicar a ver si subo algo tambien ^^

[SakumaRyuichiNG]

Haberlo dicho antes XD! El español se oye mas bonito que el inglés digo yo o.ó enserio

Fuera de eso XD ¡dale! +0+ yo subi sanguine pero la edicion fue pésima porque lo hice en movie maker! -no preguntes -__-U- ahorita hice world of glass, luego date una vuelta por mi cuenta ^^ pero para serte sincera yo amo más a Nigthwish +0+...

Por otra parte ¬¬U creo que mi world of glass se oye más decente que el de Mary; XD en fin, mejor me callo porque ya me estoy viendo payasada @__@

[fabi0iag]

No dear, Vibeke isn't a mezzosoprano, she is a full soprano, a dramatic soprano !!! It says one that it has a fansite for the tristania, and that is not a day that I follow Vibeke, sorry but you'r mistaking !! Greetings.

Fabio

[fabi0iag]

for SakumaRyuichiNG !

Sorry ^^

[SakumaRyuichiNG]

Nou =D You can read in the "ILLUMINATED" (the official forum) a question that was made my a fan to vibeke, and vibeke aswered her: I am a mezzosoprano -well, her words was something like "musical theory says I am a mezzosoprano" <- =D really, used to think she was a soprano, but a friend of mine show me that comment and vibekes aswered and she was right, The own vibeke said it, so look for it in the illuminated if you don't belive me =D

[kotopoulo13]

no a dramatic (and lyrics) soprano is tarja turunen vibeke is a light lyric soprano

[CountessEva]

Oh my good god..... :( Going to dig deep grave for Tristania!

[Anomell]

It's terrible -_-

[WorldOfGlass]

She's no Vibeke...

[sneerbite]

I no idea what to expect from Mary on the older songs and I'm very impressed :)